Migration scholars have frequently emphasized the tremendous increase in international migration in recent years. But several advanced industrial countries — Japan in particular — have relatively small numbers of foreign workers. Most of the literature on labor migration relates only to “positive cases,” i.e., countries that have actually experienced significant inflows of foreign workers. This article proposes considering Japan as a “negative case” of labor migration in the post-World War II period. There has been much recent interest in the growing numbers of foreign workers in Japan, but what is most interesting about Japan is the fact that the numbers are relatively small (as a percentage of the labor force) and that they began to increase so late, in comparison to other countries. The main goal of the paper is to advocate consideration of negative cases in migration research; a proper theory of labor migration would distinguish between positive and negative cases.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AMPO1988“Will the Japanese government open the legal door?”Japan-Asia Quarterly Review, 19:12–21.
2.
BöhningW. R.1984Studies in International Labor Migration.London: Macmillan.
3.
BolthoA.1975Japan: An Economic Survey, 1953–1973. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
BrubakerW. R.1994“Are Immigration Control Efforts Really Failing?” In Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective. Eds. CorneliusW., MartinP., and HollifieldJ.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
5.
CalderK. E.1988Crisis and Compensation: Public Policy and Political Stability in Japan, 1949–1986.Princeton: Princeton University Press.
6.
CookA.1978The Working Mother: A Survey of Problems and Programs in Nine Countries, 2nd ed. Ithaca: New York State School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Cornell University.
7.
CorneliusW.1994“Japan: The Illusion of Immigration Control.” In Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective. Eds. CorneliusW., MartinP., and HollifieldJ.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
8.
DescloitresR.1967The foreign worker: adaptation to industrial work and urban life. Paris: OECD.
9.
DoreR.1986Flexible Rigidities: Industrial Policy and Structural Adjustment in the Japanese Economy 1970–80.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
10.
EmighR. J.1997“The Power of Negative Thinking: The Use of Negative Case Methodology in the Development of Sociological Theory,”Theory and Society, 26:649–84.
11.
EvansP. B.1995Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
EvansR.Jr., 1971The Labor Economies of Japan and the United States.New York: Praeger Publishers.
13.
FooteD. H.1993“Japan's ‘Foreign Workers’ Policy: A View from the US,”Georgetown Immigration Law Journal, 7(4), 707–46.
14.
FreemanG. P.1995“Modes of Immigration Politics in Liberal Democratic States,”International Migration Review, 29(4): 881–902.
15.
FreemanG. P.1994“Can Liberal States Control Unwanted Migration?”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Scientists, 534:17–30.
16.
FreemanG. P.1992“Migration Policy and Politics in the Receiving States,”International Migration Review, 26(4): 1144–1167.
17.
FreemanG. P. and MoJ.1996“Japan and the Asian NICs as New Countries of Destination.” In International Trade and Migration in the APEC Region. Ed. LloydP. J. and WilliamsL. S.New York: Oxford University Press.
18.
FukuiH.1972“Economic Planning in Postwar Japan: A Case Study in Policy Making,”Asian Survey, 12(4): 327–48.
19.
GalensonW., with OdakaK.1976“The Japanese Labor Market.” In Asia's New Giant: How the Japanese Economy Works. Eds. PatrickH. and RosovskyH.Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
20.
HallP. A.1986Governing the Economy: The Politics of State Intervention in Britain and France.New York: Oxford University Press.
21.
HammarT. and TamasK.1997“Why do people go or stay?” In International Migration, Immobility, and Development. Ed. HammarT., New York: Berg.
22.
HerbertU.1990A History of Foreign Labor in Germany 1880–1980: Seasonal Workers, Forced Laborers, Guest Workers. Trans. W. Templer, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
23.
HicksG.1997Japan's Hidden Apartheid: The Korean Minority and the Japanese.Aldershot: Ashgate.
24.
HigashiC., and LauterG. P.1990The Internationalization of the Japanese Economy. Second Edition. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
25.
HollifieldJ. F.1992Immigrants, Markets, and States: The Political Economy of Postwar Europe.Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
26.
HollingsworthJ. R., SchmitterP. C. and StreeckW.1994Governing Capitalist Economies: Performance and Control of Economic Sectors.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
27.
IguchiY.1998“What We Can Learn from the German Experiences with Foreign Labor.” In Temporary Workers or Foreign Citizens? Japanese and U.S. Migration Policies. Eds. WeinerM. and HanamiT.New York: New York University Press.
28.
Japan: Ministry of Justice, Study Group on Immigration Statistics1990Japan and the development of international migration (Wagakuni wo meguru kokusai jinryu no hensen). Tokyo: Ministry of Justice.
29.
JohnsonC.1989“MITI, MPT, and the Telecom Wars: How Japan Makes Policy for High Technology.” In Politics and Productivity: The Real Story of Why Japan Works. Eds. JohnsonC., D'Andrea-TysonL., ZysmanJ.New York: Ballinger.
30.
JohnsonC.1982MITI and the Japanese Miracle: The Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925–1975.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
31.
KamermanS.1979“Work and Family in Industrialized Societies.”Signs, (4):632–50.
32.
KnokeD., 1996Comparing Policy Networks: Labor Politics in the U.S., Germany, and Japan.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
33.
KojimaK.1983“Japanese Direct Foreign Investment in Asian Developing Countries.” In Japans Economy in a Comparative Perspective. Ed. FodellaG.Tenterden Kent, Paul Norbury Publications Limited.
34.
KomaiH.1998“Migrants in Japan.”Paper presented to the Technical Symposium on International Migration and Development, The Hague, July.
35.
KomaiH.1995Migrant Workers in Japan. Trans. J. Wilkinson. New York: Kegan Paul.
36.
KuptschC., and OishiN.1995German and Japanese Schemes for Workers from Transition Economies or Developing Countries, International Migration Papers, Geneva, International Labor Office.
37.
LieJ.1997“The ‘Problem’ of Foreign Workers in Contemporary Japan.” In The Other Japan: Conflict, Compromise, and Resistance Since 1945. Ed. MooreJ.London: M. E. Sharpe.
38.
LimL. L.1990“International Labour Movements: a Perspective on Economic Exchanges and Flows.” In Immigration Reconsidered: History, Sociology, and Politics. Ed. Yans-McLaughlinV.New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
MahmoodR. A.1996“Labor Crunch, Foreign Workers and Policy Responses: The Experience of Japan,”International Migration, 34(1): 97–116.
40.
MartinP. L.1993“European and Asian Perspectives on Immigration Policy.” In In Defense of the Alien, Vol. 15. Ed. TomasiL.New York: Center for Migration Studies.
MillerM. J.1997“International Migration and Security: Towards Transatlantic Convergence?” In Immigration Into Western Societies: Problems and Policies. Eds. UçarerE. M. and PuchalaD. J.London: Pinter.
43.
MillerM. J.1994“Towards Understanding State Capacity to Prevent Unwanted Migration: Employer Sanctions Enforcement in France, 1975–1990.” In The Politics of Immigration in Western Europe. Eds. Baldwin-EdwardsM. and SchainM. A.Ilford: Frank Cass.
44.
MillerM. J.1986“Policy Ad-Hocracy: The Paucity of Coordinated Perspectives and Policies,”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, No. 485, May.
45.
MiyazakiI.1970“Economic Planning in Postwar Japan,”The Developing Economies, 8 (4):369–85.
46.
MooreB.Jr., 1966The Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy: Lord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World.Boston: Beacon Press.
47.
MoriH.1997Immigration Policy and Foreign Workers in Japan.New York: St. Martins Press.
48.
MurumatsuM., and KraussE. S.1987“The Conservative Policy Line and the Development of Patterned Pluralism.” In The Political Economy of Japan, Vol. 1: The Domestic Transformation. Eds. YamamuraK. and YasubaY.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
49.
NagayamaT.1996“Foreign Workers Recruiting Policies in Japan,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 5(2–3):241–264.
50.
NagayamaT.1992“Clandestine Migrant Workers in Japan,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 1(3–4):623–36.
51.
NakamuraT.1995The Postwar Japanese Economy: Its Development and Structure, 1937–1994.Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.
52.
NakamuraT.1991“Labor Market and Manpower Policy, 1945–1985.” In Employment Security and Labor Market Flexibility: An International Perspective. Ed. KoshiroK.Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
53.
OchiaiE.1974Ajiajin Rodoryoko Yunyu (The Importation of Asian Labor Power).Tokyo: Gendai Hyoronsha.
54.
OkaT.1994Prying Open the Door: Foreign Workers in Japan. Contemporary Issues Paper #2. Washington: Carnegie Endowment.
55.
OkunishiY.1996“Labor Contracting in International Migration: The Japanese Case and Implications for Asia,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 5(2–3):219–240.
56.
OECD1995SOPEMI Trends in International Migration. Paris: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
57.
PempelT. J.1990Uncommon Democracies: The One-Party Dominant Regimes.Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
58.
PempelT. J.1982Politics and Polity in Japan: Creative Conservatism.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
59.
PempelT. J.1978“Japanese Foreign Economic Policy: The Domestic Bases for International Behavior.” In Between Power and Plenty: Foreign Economic Policies of Advanced Industrial States. Ed. KatzensteinP.Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
60.
PioreM. J.1979Birds of Passage: Migrant Labor and Industrial Societies.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
61.
PortesA.1997“Immigration Theory for a New Century: Some Problems and Opportunities,”International Migration Review, 31(4): 799–825.
62.
ReubensE. P.1981“Low-Level Work in Japan Without Foreign Workers,”International Migration Review, 15(4): 749–757.
63.
RichardsonB. M.1997Japanese Democracy: Power, Coordination, and Performance.New Haven: Yale University Press.
64.
SamuelsR. J.1987The Business of the Japanese State: Energy Markets in Comparative and Historical Perspective.Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
65.
SassenS.1993“Economic Internationalization: The New Migration in Japan and the United States,”International Migration, 31(1): 73–99.
66.
SassenS.1988The Mobility of Labor & Capital: A Study in International Investment and Labor Flow.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
67.
SekiguchiS.1979Japanese Direct Foreign Investment.Allanheld, Osmun & Co. Publishers. Montclair: NJ.
68.
SellekY.1997“Nikkeijin: The Phenomenon of Return Migration.” In Japan's Minorities: The Illusion of Homogeneity. Ed. WeinerM.New York: Routledge.
69.
SellekY.1994“Illegal Foreign Migrant Workers in Japan: Change and Challenge in Japanese Society.” In Migration: The Asian Experience. Eds. BrownJ. M. and FootR.New York: St. Martin's Press.
70.
SellekY. and WeinerM. A.1992“Migrant Workers: The Japanese Case in International Perspective.” In The Internationalization of Japan. Eds. HookG. D. and WeinerM. A.New York: Routledge.
71.
ShimadaH.1994Japan's “Guest Workers”: Issues and Public Policies. Trans. R. Northridge. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.
72.
SteinmoS., ThelenK. A. and LongstrethF.1992Structuring Politics: Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
73.
TairaK.1970Economic Development and the Labor Market in Japan.New York: Columbia University Press.
74.
WadeR.1990Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization.Princeton: Princeton University Press.
75.
WeinerM.1995The Global Migration Crisis: Challenges to States and to Human Rights.New York: Harper Collins College Publishers.
76.
WeinerM.1993International Migration and Security.Boulder: Westview Press.
77.
WeinerM.1985“On International Migration and International Relations,”Population and Development Review, 11(3): 441–445.
78.
YamanakaK.1994“Theory versus Reality in Japanese Immigration Policy.” In Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective. Eds. CorneliusW., MartinP., and HollifieldJ.Stanford: Stanford University Press.
79.
YamanakaK.1993“New Immigration Policy and Unskilled Foreign Workers in Japan,”Pacific Affairs, 66(1): 72–90.
80.
ZolbergA. R.1992“Labour Migration and International Economic Regimes: Bretton Woods and After.” In International Migration Systems: A Global Approach. Eds. KritzM. M., LimL. L., and ZlotnikH.Oxford: Clarendon Press.
81.
ZolbergA. R.1991“Bounded States in a Global Market: The Uses of International Labor Migration.” In Social Theory for a Changing Society. Eds. BourdieuP. and ColemanJ. S.Boulder, CO: Westview Press/Russell Sage Foundation.
82.
ZolbergA. R.1987“Wanted But Not Welcome: Alien Labor in Western Development.” In Population in an Interacting World. Ed. AlonsoW.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
83.
ZolbergA. R.1981“International Migrations in Political Perspective.” In Global Trends in Migration: Theory and Research on International Population Movements. Eds. KritzM., KeelyC., and TomasiS.New York: Center for Migration Studies.
