This article examines the impact of the 2018 announcement of changes to the public charge rules on the benefits use of noncitizen immigrant households. Using data from the American Community Survey and difference-in-difference models, as well as an event-study approach, we document a decrease in Medicaid use in 2019 by members of low-income households with noncitizens compared to low-income households with only citizens, with larger effects for children. We find a similar decline in SNAP use but are unable to rule out differential pretrends before the announcement. Our findings suggest that the fear of being considered a public charge susceptible to deportation under the new rules likely explains the decrease in noncitizens’ public benefits in the postannouncement period.
AsadAsad L.2020. “On the Radar: System Embeddedness and Latin American Immigrants’ Perceived Risk of Deportation.” Law & Society Review54 (1): 133–67.
2.
BarofskyJeremyVargasAriadnaRodriguezDinardoBarrowsAnthony. 2020. “Spreading Fear: The Announcement of the Public Charge Rule Reduced Enrollment in Child Safety-Net Programs.” Health Affairs39 (10): 1752–61.
3.
BernsteinHamutalGonzalezDulceKarpmanMichaelZuckermanStephen. 2020. “Amid Confusion over the Public Charge Rule, Immigrant Families Continued Avoiding Public Benefits in 2019.” Urban Institute.
4.
BertrandMarianneDufloEstherMullainathanSendhil. 2004. “How Much Should We Trust Differences-in-Differences Estimates?” The Quarterly Journal of Economics119 (1): 249–75.
5.
BloemraadIrene. 2006. Becoming a Citizen: Incorporating Immigrants and Refugees in the United States and Canada. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
BorjasGeorge J.2002. “Welfare Reform and Immigrant Participation in Welfare Programs.” International Migration Review36 (4): 1093–123.
8.
Bovell-AmmonAllisonEttinger de CubaStephanieColemanSharonAhmadNayabBlackMaureen M.FrankDeborah A.OchoaEduardoJr.CuttsDiana B.. 2019. “Trends in Food Insecurity and SNAP Participation among Immigrant Families of U.S.-Born Young Children.” Children6 (4): 55.
9.
CappsRandyGelattJuliaGreenbergMark. 2020. “The Public-Charge Rule: Broad Impacts but Few Will Be Denied Green Cards Based on Actual Benefits Use.” Commentaries, Migration Policy Institute.
10.
CelhayPablo A.MeyerBruce D.MittagNikolas. 2022. “What Leads to Measurement Errors? Evidence from Reports of Program Participation in Three Surveys.” NBER Working Paper #29652. Accessed July 30, 2023, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4010501
11.
CitrinJackGreenDonald P.MusteChristopherWongCara. 1997. “Public Opinion Toward Immigration Reform: The Role of Economic Motivations.” The Journal of Politics59 (3): 858–81.
FixMichael E.CappsRandyKaushalNeeraj. 2009. “Immigrants and Welfare: Overview.” In Immigrants and Welfare: The Impact of Welfare on America’s Newcomers, edited by FixMichael E., 1-36. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
———, and PasselJeffrey. 1999. “Trends in Noncitizens’ and Citizens’ Use of Public Benefits Following Welfare Reform: 1994-1997.” The Urban Institute, Washington, D.C.
15.
FlemingPaul J.LopezWilliam D.MesaHannahRionRaymondRabinowitzEllenBryceRichardDoshiMonika. 2019. “A Qualitative Study on the Impact of the 2016 US Election on the Health of Immigrant Families in Southeast Michigan.” BMC Public Health19: 947.
16.
FlippenChenoa A.Farrell-BryanDylan. 2021. “New Destinations and the Changing Geography of Immigrant Incorporation.” Annual Review of Sociology47 (1): 479–500.
17.
FoxLiana EHeggenessMisty L.PacasJoséStevensKathryn. 2017. “Precision in Measurement: Using SNAP Administrative Records to Evaluate Poverty Measurement.” U.S. Census Bureau SEHSD Working Paper #2017-49, 2017.
18.
FussellElizabeth.2014. “Warmth of the Welcome: Attitudes Toward Immigrants and Immigration Policy in the United States.” Annual Review of Sociology40 (1): 479–98.
19.
HaiderSteven J.SchoeniRobert F.BaoYuhuaDanielsonCaroline. 2004. “Immigrants, Welfare Reform, and the Economy.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management23 (4): 745–64.
20.
HaqCynthiaHostetterIsaureZavalaLauraMayorgaJose. 2020. “Immigrant Health and Changes to the Public-Charge Rule: Family Physicians’ Response.” The Annals of Family Medicine18 (5): 458–60. https://doi.org/10.1370/afm.2572.
21.
KaestnerRobertKaushalNeeraj. 2005. “Immigrant and Native Responses to Welfare Reform.” Journal of Population Economics18 (1): 69–92.
22.
KandulaNamratha R.GroganColleen M.RathouzPaul J.LauderdaleDiane S.. 2004. “The Unintended Impact of Welfare Reform on the Medicaid Enrollment of Eligible Immigrants.” Health Services Research39 (5): 1509–26.
23.
KaushalNeerajKaestnerRobert. 2005. “Welfare Reform and Health Insurance of Immigrants.” Health Services Research40 (3): 697–722.
24.
LowreyKendalVan HookJennifer. 2022. “Standing on Their Own Two Feet: How the New Public Charge Rules Could Impact Non-European LPR Applicants.” Population Research and Policy Review41 (2): 559–82.
25.
LuthraReneeSoehlThomasWaldingerRoger. 2017. “Reconceptualizing Context: A Multilevel Model of the Context of Reception and Second-Generation Education Attainment.” International Migration Review52 (3): 898–928.
26.
MeyerBruce D.MittagNikolas. 2019. “Misreporting of Government Transfers: How Important Are Survey Design and Geography?” Southern Economic Journal86 (1): 230–53.
27.
———, MokWallace K.C.SullivanJames X.. 2009. “The Under-Reporting of Transfers in Household Surveys: Its Nature and Consequences.” NBER Working Paper No. 15181.
28.
NamYunju.2012. “Welfare Reform and Older Immigrant Adults’ Medicaid and Health Insurance Coverage: Changes Caused by Chilling Effects of Welfare Reform, Protective Citizenship, or Distinct Effects of Labor Market Condition by Citizenship?” Journal of Aging and Health24 (4): 616–40.
29.
PatlerCaitlinGonzalezGabriela. 2021. “Compounded Vulnerability: The Consequences of Immigration Detention for Institutional Attachment and System Avoidance in Mixed-Immigration-Status Families.” Social Problems68 (4): 886–902.
30.
PeltoDebra J.OcampoAlexGarduño-OrtegaOlgaBarraza LópezClaudia TeresaMacalusoFrancescaRamirezJuliaGonzálezJavierGanyFrancesca. 2019. “The Nutrition Benefits Participation Gap: Barriers to Uptake of SNAP and WIC Among Latinx American Immigrant Families.” Journal of Community Health45 (3): 488–91.
31.
PerreiraKrista M.PedrozaJuan M.. 2019. “Policies of Exclusion: Implications for the Health of Immigrants and Their Children.” Annual Review of Public Health40 (1): 147–66.
32.
PortesAlejandroRumbautRuben. 1996. Immigrant America: A Portrait. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
33.
RamakrishnanS. KarthickBloemraadIrene. 2008. Civic Hopes and Political Realities: Immigrants, Community Organizations, and Political Engagement. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
34.
RothJonathanSant’AnnaPedro H. C.BilinskiAlyssaPoeJohn. 2023. “What’s Trending in Difference-in-Differences? A Synthesis of the Recent Econometrics Literature.” Journal of Econometrics235 (2): 2218–44.
ShantzKathrynFoxLiana E.. 2018. “Precision in Measurement: Using State-Level Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Administrative Records and the Transfer Income Model (TRIM3) to Evaluate Poverty Measurement.” U.S. Census Bureau SEHSD Working Paper #2018-30, 2018.
39.
ShinHyon B.2021. “An Assessment of the COVID-19 Pandemic’s Impact on the 2020 ACS 1-Year Data.” ACS Research and Evaluation Report Memorandum Series # ACS21-RER-04.
TouwSharonMcCormackGraceHimmelsteinDavid U.WoolhandlerSteffieZallmanLeah. 2021. “Immigrant Essential Workers Likely Avoided Medicaid and SNAP Because of a Change to the Public Charge Rule.” Health Affairs40 (7): 1090–8.
42.
TwerskySylvia E.2019. “Restrictive State Laws Aimed at Immigrants: Effects on Enrollment in the Food Stamp Program by U.S. Citizen Children in Immigrant Families.” PLoS One14 (5): e0215327. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215327.
Van HookJennifer. 2003. “Welfare Reform’s Chilling Effects on Noncitizens: Changes in Noncitizen Welfare Recipiency or Shifts in Citizenship Status?” Social Science Quarterly84 (3): 613–31.
47.
Van HookJenniferBrownSusan K.BeanFrank D.. 2006. “For Love or Money? Welfare Reform and Immigrant Naturalization.” Social Forces85 (2): 643–66.
48.
WangScarlett SijiaGliedSherryBabcockClaudiaChaudryAjay. 2022. “Changes in the Public Charge Rule and Health of Mothers and Infants Enrolled in New York State’s Medicaid Program, 2014-2019.” American Journal of Public Health112 (12): 1747–56.
