Inequality,the New Right and mental health care delivery in the United States in the Reagan era

Abstract

This essay draws upon research on mental health treatment and provision in the San Francisco Bay Area in 1988, and is part ofa wider US-UK com parative study. The main concern is to examine the linkages between pub lic policy and inequalities in mental health care delivery in one local area. In opposition to the concept of the welfare state, a primary stance of the New Right and of the Reagan administration has been the belief in the necessity ofsocial hierarchies based on wealth. The consequences of poli cies predicated on these beliefs were studied at a local mental health sys tem, where it was found that economic factors strongly influence access to and experience in the system. Principally through drawing upon data from 42 in-depth focussed interviews with mental health professionals in the San Francisco Bay Area, I examine how the poor are excluded from treat ment, how patients are dumped from the private sector, and how a com plex triage system in both public and private treatment settings has come into being.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson, M. , (1978) Welfare, Stanford, CA: Hoover Institute.

Brady, J. , et al (1986) 'Trends in Private Insurance Coverage for Mental Illness', American Journal of Psychiatry vol 143, pp 1276-1279.

Brown, E.R. , et al (1987) Californians Without Health Insurance, Los Angeles: California Policy Seminar.

Brown, P. (1985) The Transfer of Care, Boston : RKP.

Brown, P. and Cooksey, E. (1989) 'Mental Health Monopoly: Corporate Trends in Mental Health Services', Social Science and Medicine vol 28 no 11, pp 1129-1138.

Burt, M. and Pittman, K. (1985) Testing the Social Safety Net, Washington DC: Urban Institute.

California Department of Commerce (1986) The Californias, Sacramento: State of California.

Department of Health (1989) Caring for People: Community Care in the Next Decade and Beyond (CM 849) London: HMSO.

Elpers, J. (1989) 'Public Mental Health Funding in California, 1959 to 1989,' Hospital and Community Psychiatry, vol 40, no 8, pp 799-804.

10.

Frank, R. and Kamlet, M. (1986) 'Nonmarket Resource Allocation in Mental Health Care, American Behavioral Scientist, vol 30 no 2 pp 201-230.

11.

Franz, J. (1984) 'Hospitals Turn from Acquiring to Building New Psychiatric Units', Modern Healthcare, May 15, pp 124-127.

12.

Gilder, G. (1981) Wealth and Poverty, New York : Basic.

13.

Gray, Bradford (ed), (1986) For-Profit Enterprise in Health Care, Washington DC: National Academy Press.

14.

Hollingshead, A. and Redlich, F. (1959) Social Class and Mental Illness, New York: Wiley.

15.

Hope, M. and Young, J. (1986) The Faces of Homelessness, Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

16.

Light, D. (1986) 'Corporate Medicine for Profit', Scientific American, vol 255 no 6, pp 38-45.

17.

Martinsons, J. Newald (1988) 'Still Plenty of Room for More Psych Hospitals' , Hospitals, March 5, p 52.

18.

Maynard, A. (1982) 'The Regulation of Public and Private Health Care Markets', in G. McLachlan and A. Maynard , (eds), The Public/Private Mix for Health, Oxford: Nuffeld Trust , pp 473-511.

19.

McGuire, T. (1986) 'Economics of Mental Health', in G. Klerman et al (eds), Psychiatry: Social, Epidemiologic and legal Psychiatry, New York: Basic, pp 31-43.

20.

Reagan, R. (1984) 'Remarks of the President to the 11th Annual Conservative Political Action Conference Dinner', March 2nd, Washington DC: Office of the Press Secretary.

21.

Roberts, S. (1088) 'Reagan on Homelessness: Some Choose Life Out There', New York Times, December 23, p 1. Schiff, R. et al (1986) 'Transfers to a Public Hospital: A Prospective Study of 467 Patients', New England Journal of Medicine, vol 314 no 9, pp 552-557.

22.

Schlessinger, M. et al (1987) 'The Privatization of Health Care and Physicians' Perceptions of Access to Hospital Services', Milbank Quarterly , vol 65 no 1, pp 25-58.

23.

Starr, P. (1983) The Social Transformation of American Medicine , New York: Basic Books.

24.

Surber, R. et al (1986) 'Effects of Fiscal Retrenchment on Public Mental Health Services for the Chronic Mentally Ill', Community Mental Health Journal, vol 22 no 3, pp 215-228.

25.

Thorpe, K. et al (1989) 'Including the Poor: The Fiscal Impacts of Medicaid Expansion', Journal of the American Medical Association , vol 261 no 7, pp 1003-1007.

26.

Tolchin, M. (1989a) 'Judges Who Decide Social Security Claims Say Agency Goads Them to Deny Benefits', New York Times, January 8, p 12.

27.

Tolchin, M. (1989b) 'Richest Got Richer and Poorest Poorer from 1979 to 1987', New York Times, March 24, p 1.

28.

United States Bureau of the Census (1988) Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1988, 108th Edition, Washington DC: Government Printing Office.

29.

Wallace, C. (1987) 'Psychiatric Hospital Industry Still Growing, But Rate of Expansion Slower than Last Year', Modern Healthcare , June 5, pp 92-98.

30.

Warner, R. (1985) Recovery from Schizophrenia, London: RKP.