The Use of Animals in National High School Student Science Fair Projects in the United States

Abstract

Science fair projects can provide a sound opportunity to teach students the value of scientific methodology without relying on the routine and unnecessary use of animals. Unfortunately, students are often encouraged to use animals in an expendable manner that both duplicates previous experiments and neglects the opportunity to “think outside the box” in order to generate new hypotheses/theories about human health, physiological processes or basic biological concepts. Although at least one national science fair sponsor has changed its policy regarding students’ utilisation of vertebrate animals, others continue to encourage the more traditional in vivo experimental projects. This paper will review the guidelines of two major national science fairs in the USA; types of projects conducted that involve animals; numbers of animals involved; interview responses by some student finalists who used vertebrates in their projects; successful initiatives by animal advocates in the USA to eliminate the use of animals in science fairs; and potential areas of outreach to science educators, science fair sponsors, high schools and students.

Keywords

humane education science fair student

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Association for the Advancement of Science (1993). Benchmarks for Scientific Literacy. Web site http://www.project2061.org.benchol/bolinto.htm. Washington, DC, USA: AAAS (accessed 30.06.02).

Balas

A.K.

(1998). Science Fairs in Elementary School. Columbus, OH, USA: ERIC Clearinghouse for Science, Mathematics, and Environmental Education (ERIC Document No. ED432444).

Orlans

F.B.

(1995). Investigator competency and animal experiments: guidelines for elementary and secondary education. Lab Animal 24, 29–34.

Orlans

F.B.

(1993). In the Name of Science: Issues in Responsible Animal Experimentation. New York, NY, USA: Oxford University Press.

Science Service (2002). 75 Years in the Service of Science. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/history.asp. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 08.08.02).

Science Service (2002). About Intel ISEF: Background. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/isef.background.asp. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 08.08.02).

Science Service (2002). About Intel STS: Background. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/sts/about/background.asp. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 08.08.02).

Science Service (2002). STS Rules and Regulations. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/sts/students/rules.asp. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 08.08.02).

Science Service (2002). Non-Human Vertebrate Animals, 2003 Intel ISEF: The Science Service and ISEF Position Statement on the Use of Animals in Pre-College Science Research; Rules; and Instructions for the Research Plan Attachment. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/isef/rules/rules10.asp. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 03.05.02).

10.

Science Service (2002). Intel ISEF 2002 Finalist Directory. Web site http://www.sciserv.org/isef/document/finaldir.pdf. Washington, DC, USA: Science Service (accessed 11.05.02).

11.

National Anti-Vivisection Society (2002). NAVS Awards Humane Science Prize to Intel ISEF Student. Web site http://www.navs.org/news/story_display.cfm?SectionID=News&NewsID=26. Chicago, IL, USA: NAVS (accessed 29.10.02).