The EYTEX™ System and the Neutral Red Uptake Inhibition Assay in Cultured Hep G2 Cells as Alternative Methods for In Vivo Eye Irritation Following the EEC Protocol

Abstract

The neutral red uptake inhibition assay and the EYTEX™ system were investigated as alternative methods for the assessment of eye irritation, determined according to the EEC protocol. The 17 test chemicals used were mainly organic solvents. The xenobiotics were applied to Hep G2 cells for 24 hours at different concentrations. Neutral red uptake inhibition was then measured. The results are expressed as the NI50 value, which is the concentration of test compound required to induce a 50% reduction in neutral red uptake. The same chemicals were also tested as coded samples by the EYTEX™ test according to the manufacturer's directions. A nearly identical quantitative correlation was found for both in vitro methods with corneal opacity scores: r = 0.84 for EYTEX™ scores and r = 0.83 for log NI50, expressed in μg/ml. Whilst these correlations are certainly not perfect, it is clear that both in vitro methods can be used as valuable prescreening methods.

Keywords

EYTEX™ system neutral red uptake inhibition Hep G2 cells eye irritation alternative methods cytotoxicity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Nardone

J.M.

(1980). The interference of toxicology and tissue culture and reflections on the carnation test. Toxicology 17, 105–111.

Shopsis

, and Sathe

(1984). Uridine uptake inhibition as a cytotoxicity test: correlation with the Draize test. Toxicology 29, 195–206.

Dierickx

P.J.

, and Martens

(1986). Validation of the uridine uptake inhibition assay in cultured human hepatoma cells. Belgisch Archief voor Sociale Geneeskunde, Hygiëne, Arbeidsgeneeskunde en Geriatrische Geneeskunde 44, 470–477.

Jacobs

G.A.

, Dierickx

P.J.

, and Martens

M.A.

(1988). Evaluation of the in vitro uridine uptake inhibition assay in comparison with the in vivo irritation test as prescribed by the EEC. ATLA 15, 290–296.

EEC (1984). Council Directive 84/449/EEC, 19 September 1984. Adaptation of Council Directive 79/831/EEC concerning the methods for the determination of toxicity. Annex V. Part B. Official Journal of the European Community (L251), 109–112.

Draize

J.H.

, Woodward

, and Calvery

O.H.

(1944). Methods for the study of irritation and toxicity of substances applied topically to the skin and mucous membranes. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 82, 377–390.

Dierickx

P.J.

(1989). Glutamic acid uptake inhibition assay in cultured Hep G2 cells as an alternative method for evaluating potential in vivo eye irritation. ATLA 16, 344–352.

Borenfreund

, and Shopsis

(1985). Toxicity monitored with a correlated set of cell culture assays. Xenobiotica 15, 705–711.

Gordon

V.C.

, and Bergman

H.C.

(1987). EYTEX™, an in vitro method for evaluation of ocular irritancy. In Alternative Methods in Toxicology, Vol. 5, Approaches to Validation (ed. Goldberg

), pp. 87–90. New York: Mary Ann Liebert.

10.

Gordon

V.C.

, and Bergman

H.C.

(1988). External evaluation of the EYTEX™ system in twelve labs to determine the correlation of results with in vivo results. In Progress in In Vitro Toxicology (ed. Goldberg

A.M.

). New York: Mary Ann Liebert.

11.

Gordon

V.C.

, Kelly

, and Bergman

H.C.

(1990). Applications of the EYTEX™ method. In Practical In Vitro Toxicology Conference, in press.

12.

Booman

K.A.

, Cascieri

T.M.

, Demetrulias

, Driedger

, Griffith

J.F.

, Grochoski

G.T.

, Kong

, McCormick

W.C.

3rd , North-Root

, Rozen

, and Sedlak

R.I.

(1988). In vitro methods for estimating eye irritancy of cleaning products. Phase I: preliminary assessment. Journal of Toxicology — Cutaneous and Ocular Toxicology 7, 173–185.

13.

National Testing Corporation (1986). The EYTEX™ System: Directions for Use. Palm Springs, CA, USA.

14.

Morgan

R.L.

, Sorenson

S.S.

, and Castles

T.L.

(1987). Prediction of ocular irritation by corneal pachymetry. Food and Chemical Toxicology 25, 609–613.

15.

Weil

C.S.

, and Scala

(1971). Study of intra- and interlaboratory variability in the results of rabbit eye and skin irritation tests. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology 19, 276–360.