Inclusion of Physicochemical Data in Quantitative Comparisons of In Vitro and In Vivo Toxic Potencies

Abstract

In order to evaluate the relevance of in vitro test systems for acute toxicity assessment, quantitative comparisons of in vitro and in vivo potency data have to be performed. The potency of chemicals to cells in vitro is usually characterised by nominal effective concentrations (e.g. EC50 values). Often, the only available in vivo data are acute lethal body doses (e.g. LD50 values). To enable a reasonable quantitative in vitro–in vivo comparison to be made, a formula has been developed to permit the conversion of EC50 values into “effective model body doses, ED50 values”. This formula takes into account the lipophilicity of the compounds and the very different relationships between the volumes of the lipid and water compartments in vitro and in vivo. The suitability of this approach is evaluated with results obtained for the first 30 MEIC chemicals.

Keywords

acute toxicity MEIC chemicals lipid/water distribution in vitro–in vivo comparison in vitro test

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bondesson

, Ekwall

, Hellberg

, Romert

, Stenberg

, & Walum

(1989). MEIC: a new international multicentre project to evaluate the relevance to human toxicity of in vitro cytotoxicity tests. Cell Biology and Toxicology 5, 331–346.

Ekwall

, Bondesson

, Castell

J.V.

, Gómez-Lechón

M.J.

, Hellberg

, Högberg

, Jover

, Ponsoda

, Romert

, Stenberg

, & Walum

(1989). Cytotoxicity evaluation of the first ten MEIC chemicals: acute lethal toxicity in man predicted by cytotoxicity in five cellular assays and by oral LD50 tests in rodents. ATLA 17, 83–100.

Barile

F.A.

, Arjun

, & Hopkinson

(1993). In vitro cytotoxicity testing: biological and statistical significance. Toxicology In Vitro 7, 111–116.

Seibert

, Gulden

, Kolossa

, & Schepers

(1992). Evaluation of the relevance of selected in vitro toxicity test systems for acute systemic toxicity. ATLA 20, 240–245.

Seibert

, Gulden

, & Voss

J-U.

(1994). An in vitro testing strategy for the classification and labelling of chemicals according to their potential acute lethal potency. Toxicology In Vitro (in press).

Gülden

(1993). In vitro toxicity screening using cultured rat skeletal muscle cells. I. Surfactants and mitochondrial poisons. Toxicology In Vitro 7, 25–34.

Gulden

, Seibert

, & Voss

J-U.

(1994). In vitro toxicity screening using cultured rat skeletal muscle cells. II. Agents affecting excitable membranes. Toxicology In Vitro (in press).

Gulden

, & Finger

(1992). Effects of the first twenty MEIC reference chemicals on viability, glucose consumption and spontaneous contractility of primary cultured rat skeletal muscle cells. ATLA 20, 222–225.

Gulden

, Seibert

, & Voss

J-U.

(1994). The use of cultured skeletal muscle cells in testing for acute systemic toxicity. Toxicology In Vitro, (in press).

10.

Hansch

, & Leo

(1979). Substituent constants for correlation analysis in chemistry and biology. 330 pp. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

11.

Glaser

, & Kriegelstein

(1970). Die Eiweißbindung einiger Psychopharmaka mit tricyclischem Ringsystem in Abhängigkeit von ihrer chemischen Konstitution. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacology 265, 321–334.

12.

Cohnen

, Flasch

, Heinz

, & Hempelmann

F.W.

(1978). Verteilungskoeffizienten und R_m-Werte von Cardenoliden. Arzneimittel Forschung/Drug Research 28, 2179–2182.

13.

Leo

, Hansch

, & Elkins

(1971). Partition coefficients and their uses. Chemical Reviews 71, 525–616.

14.

Anon. (1987). Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances, 1985–86 edn, 87–114. US Department of Health and Human Services Publication. Cincinnatti, OH, USA: NIOSH.

15.

Purchase

I.F.H.

, Furrar

D.G.

, & Whitaker

T.A.

(1985). The toxicity of 2,4–D. Toxicology Summary No. 21. Macclesfield, UK: ICI.