Alternative Approaches and Tests in Ecotoxicology: A Review of the Present Position and the Prospects for Change,Taking into Account ECVAM's Duties,Topic Selection and Test Criteria
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 1998
Alternative Approaches and Tests in Ecotoxicology: A Review of the Present Position and the Prospects for Change,Taking into Account ECVAM's Duties,Topic Selection and Test Criteria
The objectives of this review are to summarise the present position concerning the use of vertebrates in ecotoxicity testing, giving particular attention to tests that cause suffering, and to discuss in some detail, alternatives to them, and the prospects for change. The report has been written with the objectives of the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) in mind, and some recommendations for action have been made at the end of the discussion section. The first section of the review describes the present requirements within the European Union for the ecotoxicity testing of industrial chemicals in general, and for pesticides in particular, and the very limited documentation of the tests that are actually carried out. The next four sections describe the many different assays and systems used to evaluate the harmful effects of chemicals on free-living organisms and natural populations, and the extent to which they might be suitable alternatives to vertebrate toxicity tests that cause suffering. Attention is drawn to certain assays and strategies that can already be used as satisfactory alternatives, and thus provide the basis for short-term change. Included here are nondestructive assays on vertebrates which are available for certain types of chemicals, and which provide a direct and relatively uncomplicated approach to the problem. Other approaches are described which still require development, but hold considerable promise in the longer term. The growth of knowledge in the broad field of biochemical toxicology and the development of related technologies should lead to the development of better and more-sophisticated alternatives in the future. In vitro assays employing vertebrate cell systems are of particular interest here. The last section of the review deals with conclusions and recommendations. The recommendations are made with a view to the activities and responsibilities of ECVAM.
BallsM., and FentemJ.H. (1997). Progress toward the validation of alternative tests.ATLA25, 33–43.
2.
WalkerC.H., Greig-SmithP.W., CrosslandN.O., and BrownR. (1991). Ecotoxicology. In Animals and Alternatives in Toxicology (ed. BallsM., BridgesJ., SoutheeJ.), pp. 223–252. Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan.
3.
BallsM., BridgesJ., and SoutheeJ. eds (1991). Animals and Alternatives in Toxicology, 390 pp. Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan.
4.
van ZutphenL.F.M., and BallsM. eds (1997). Animal Alternatives, Welfare and Ethics, 1262 pp. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
5.
PeakallD.B., and WalkerC.H. (1994). The role of biomarkers in environmental risk assessment. III. Vertebrates.Ecotoxicology3, 173–179.
6.
WalkerC.H., HopkinS.P., SiblyR.M., and PeakallD.B. eds (1996). Principles of Ecotoxicology, 321 pp. London: Taylor & Francis
7.
BottrillK. (1998). The use of biomarkers as alternatives to current animal tests on food chemicals.ATLA26, 421–480.
8.
WalkerC.H. (1996). Biomarkers and risk assessment.Pesticide Outlook1, 7–12.
9.
PeakallD.B. (1992). Animal Biomarkers as Pollution Indicators, 291 pp. London: Chapman & Hall.
10.
PeakallD.B., and ShugartL.R. eds (1993). Biomarker Research and Application in the Assessment of Environmental Health, 119 pp. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
11.
HuggettR.J., KimerleR.A., MehrleP.M.Jr., & BergmanH.L. eds (1992). Biomarkers: Biochemical, Physiological and Histological Markers of Anthropogenic Stress, 347 pp. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
12.
NelsonD.R., KoymanL., KamatakiT., StegemannJ.J., FeyereisenR., WaxmanD.J., WatermanN.R., GotohO., CoonM.J., EstabrookR.W., GunsalusI.C., and HerbertD.W. (1996). P450 superfamily: update on new sequences, gene mapping, accession numbers and nomenclature.Pharmacogenetics6, 1–42.
13.
LivingstoneD.R., and StegemanJ.J. (1998). Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology — C Pharmacology, Toxicology and Endocrinology, Special Issue: Forms and Functions of Cytochrome P450, in press.
14.
FossiM., and LeonzioC. eds (1994). Non-destructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates, 345 pp. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
LewisD. (1997). Sex and drugs and P450.Chemistry and Industry20, 831–834.
17.
WalkerC.H. (1998). Avian forms of cytochrome P450. In Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology — C Pharmacology, Toxicology and Endocrinology, Special Issue: Forms and Functions of Cytochrome P450, in press.
18.
RattnerB.A., MelanconM.J., CusterT.W., HothanR.L., KingK.A., Le CaptainL.J., SpannJ.W., WoodinB.R., and StegemanJ.J. (1993). Biomonitoring environmental contamination with pipping black-crowned night heron: induction of cytochrome P450.Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry12, 1719–1732.
19.
HayesJ.D., PickettC.D., and MantleT.J. eds (1990). Glutathione S-Transferases and Drug Resistance, 452 pp. London: Taylor & Francis.
20.
FitzpatrickP.J., O'HalloranJ., SheehanD., and WalshA.R. (1997). Assessment of a glutathione S-transferase, and related proteins in the gill and digestive gland of Mytilus edulis as potential organic pollution biomarkers.Biomarkers2, 51–56.
21.
HalliwellB., and GutteridgeJ.M.C. (1986). Oxygen free-radicals and iron in relation to biology and medicine: some problems and concepts.Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics295, 223–229.
22.
WalkerC.H. (1998). Biomarker strategies to evaluate the environmental effects of chemicals.Environmental Health Perspectives106, 613–620.
23.
MineauP. ed. (1991). Cholinesterase-inhibiting Insecticides: Their Impact on Wildlife and the Environment, 348 pp. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
24.
FossiM-C., Sanchez-HernandezJ.C., and GaggiC. (1995). The lizard (Gallotia galloti) as a biomarker of organophosphorus contamination in the Canary Islands.Environmental Pollution87, 289–294.
25.
JohnstonG.O. (1995). The study of interactive effects of pesticides in birds: a biomarker approach.Aspects of Applied Biology41, 25–31.
26.
ShugartL.R. (1994). Genotoxic responses in blood. In Non-destructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates (ed. FossiM.C., LeonzioC.), pp. 131–146. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
27.
ShugartL.R. (1994). Hemoglobin adducts. In Non-destructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates (ed. FossiM.C., LeonzioC.), pp. 159–168. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
28.
SawaD. (1996). DNA fingerprinting as a biomarker assay in ecotoxicology.Toxicology and Ecotoxicology News3, 110–114.
29.
GrueC.E., HartA.D.M., and MineauP. (1991). Biological consequences of depressed brain cholinesterase activity in wildlife. In Cholinesterase-inhibiting Insecticides: Their Impact on Wildlife and the Environment (ed. MineauP.), pp. 151–210. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
30.
BrouwerA. (1996). Biomarkers for exposure (and effect) assessment of dioxins and PCBs. In The Use of Biomarkers in Exposure Assessment, Report R5 (ed. GompertzD., ShukerD., TonioloP., ShukerL., BinghamS., CalowP., CoggonD., KingN., McMichaelA., WalkerE.H.), pp. 51–58. Leicester, UK: MRC.
31.
BrouwerA., MurkA.J., and KoemanJ.H. (1990). Biochemical and physiological approaches in ecotoxicology.Functional Ecology4, 275–281.
32.
BrouwerA., RejindersP.J.H., and KoemanJ.H. (1989). PCB-contaminated fish induce vitamin A and thyroid deficiency in the common seal (Phoca vitulina).Aquatic Toxicology15, 99–105.
33.
HamulyàkK., ThijssenH.H.W., and VermeerC. (1994). Effects of coumarin derivatives on coagulation proteins.Human and Experimental Toxicology13, 631.
34.
GrosnikB.E., & GoksøyrA. (1996). Biomarker protein expression in primary cultures of salmon hepatocytes exposed to environmental pollutants.Biomarkers1, 45–54.
35.
CalowP. ed. (1993). Handbook of Ecotoxicology, Vol. 1, 478 pp. Oxford: Blackwells.
36.
De MatteisF., and LimC.K. (1994). Porphyrins as non-destructive indicators of exposure to environmental pollutants. In Non-destructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates (ed. FossiM.C., LeonzioC.), pp. 93–128. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
37.
NicholsonJ.K. (1994). NMR spectroscopy and pattern recognition approaches to the detection of novel molecular markers of toxicity.Human and Experimental Toxicology13, 630.
38.
AnthonyM.L., SweatmanB.C., BeddellC.R., LindonJ.C., and NicholsonJ.K. (1994). Pattern recognition classification of the site of nephrotoxicity based on metabolic data derived from proton NMR spectroscopy of urine.Molecular Pharmacology46, 119–121.
39.
ZacharewskiT. (1998). Identification and assessment of endocrine disrupters: limitations of in vivo and in vitro assays.Environmental Health Perspective106, 577–582.
40.
Institute of Environmental Health (1995). Environmental Oestrogens: Consequences to Human Health and Wildlife, 107 pp. Leicester, UK: IEH.
41.
Institute of Environmental Health (1998). Assessment of the Ecological Significance of Sex Hormone Disruption, in press.
42.
SumpterJ.P., and JoblingS. (1995). Vitellogenesis as a biomarker for estrogenic contamination of the aquatic environment.Environmental Health Perspectives103, Suppl. 7, 173–178.
43.
GuilletteL.J., GrossT.S., MassonG.R., MatterJ.M., PercivalH.F., and WoodwardA.R. (1994). Developmental abnormalities of the gonad and abnormal sex hormone concentrations in juvenile alligators from contaminated and control lakes in Florida.Environmental Health Perspectives102, 680–688.
44.
OECD (1993). OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals: Effects on Biotic Systems.Paris: OECD.
45.
McCarthyJ.F., and ShugartL.R. eds (1990). Biomarkers of Environmental Contamination, 457 pp. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
46.
MooreM.N., LivingstoneD.R., WiddowsJ., LoweD.M., and PipeR.K. (1987). Molecular, cellular and physiological effects of oil-derived hydrocarbons in molluscs and their use in impact assessment.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B Biological Sciences, 603–623.
47.
Schulte-HermannR., BurschW., Kraupp-GraslB., OberhammerF., and WagnerA. (1992). Programmed cell death and its protective role with particular reference to apoptosis.Toxicology Letters64/65, 569–574.
48.
SalgameP., VaradhachaayA.S., PrimianoL.L., FinckeJ.E., MullerS., and MonestierM. (1997). An ELISA for detection of apoptosis.Nuclear Acids Research25, 680–681.
49.
WiddowsJ., and DonkinP. (1991). Role of physiological energetics in ecotoxicology.Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology100C, 69–75.
50.
WarnerR.E., PetersonK.K., and BorgmanL. (1966). Behavioural pathology in fish: a quantitative study of sublethal pesticide intoxication.Journal of Applied Ecology3, Suppl., 223–247.
51.
WalkerC.H., FossiM.C., DepledgeM.H., SparaganoO., SawaD., MatteiN., BamberS., LariL., SheehanD., and ChipmanJ.K. (1998). Biomarker responses to aromatic hydrocarbons, metals and PCBs in crabs (Carcinus maenas and Carcinus aestuarii). In Proceedings of the SETAC meeting, Copenhagen, Denmark, June 1995, in press.
52.
AguilarA., and BorrellA. (1994). Assessment of organochlorine pollutants in cetaceans by means of skin and hypodermic biopsies. In Non-destructive Biomarkers in Vertebrates (ed. FossiM.C., LeonziaC.), pp. 245–268. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis.
53.
SchulteC., and NagelR. (1994). Testing acute toxicity in the embryo of zebra fish (Brachydanio rerio) as an alternative to the acute fish test: preliminary results.ATLA22, 12–19.
54.
FricciusT., SchulteC., EnsenbachV., SeelP., and HagelR. (1995). Der Embryotest mit dem Zebra bärbling: eine neue Möglichkeit zur Prüning und Bewertung der Toxizität von Abwasserproben.Vom Wasser84, 407–418.
55.
Van LeeuwenC.J., GrootelaarE.M.M., and NiebeekG. (1990). Fish embryos as teratogenicity screens: a comparison of embryotoxicity between fish and birds.Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety20, 42–48.
56.
HoffmanP.J., and AlbensP.H. (1984). Evaluation of potential embryotoxicity and teratogenicity of 42 compounds to mallard eggs.Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology13, 15–30.
57.
GarrisonP.M., TullisK., AartsJ.M.M.J.G., BrouwerA., GiesyJ.P., and DennisonM.S. (1996). Species-specific cell lines as bioassay systems for the detection of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo dioxinlike chemicals.Fundamental and Applied Toxicology30, 194–203.
58.
VaillantC., MonodG., VolataireY., & RiviereJ-L. (1989). Measurement and induction of cytochrome P450 and monooxygenase activities in a primary culture of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) hepatocytes.Comptes Redus de L'Academie des Sciences308, 83–88.
59.
MasfaraudJ-F., DevauxA., Pfhol-LeszkowiczA., MalaveilleC., and MonodG. (1992). DNA adduct formation and 7-ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase induction in primary culture of rainbow trout hepatocytes exposed to benzo[a]pyrene.Toxicology in Vitro6, 523–531.
60.
PesonenM., GoksøyrA., and AnderssonT. (1992). Expression of P4501A1 in a primary culture of rainbow trout hepatocytes exposed to β-naphthoflavone or 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin.Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics292, 228–233.
61.
SmeetsJ., RothB., EveraartsJ., & van den BergM. (1997). In vitro CYPIA induction by 3,3’,4,4’ PCB (PCB126) and TCDD in flounder hepatocytes (Platychthis flesus). In Organohalogen Compounds, Vol. 29, Ecotoxicology, Toxicology, Metabolism and Kinetics, pp. 122–315. Amsterdam: University of Amsterdam.
62.
GlattH., EngstW., HagenM., HermersdörferH., LandsiedlR., and PabelM. (1997). The use of cell lines genetically engineered for human xenobiotic-metabolizing enzymes. In Animal Alternatives, Welfare and Ethics (ed. van ZutphenL.F.M., & BallsM.), pp. 81–94. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
63.
WalkerC.H., KaiserK., KleinW., LagadicL., PeakallD.R., SheffieldS., and SoldanT. (1998). Alternative testing methodologies for ecotoxicity.Environmental Health Perspectives106, 441–451.
64.
MaronD.M., and AmesB.N. (1983). Revised methods for the Salmonella mutagenicity test.Mutation Research113, 173–215.
65.
BarrattM.D., CastellJ.V., ChamberlainM., CombesR.D., DeardenJ.C., FentemJ.H., GerenerI., GiulianiA., GrayT.J.B., LivingstoneD.J., ProvanW.M., RuttenF.A.J.J.L., VerhaarH.J.M., and ZbindenP. (1995). The integrated use of alternative approaches for predicting toxic hazard. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 8.ATLA23, 410–429.
66.
DeardenJ.C., BarrattM.D., BenigniR., BristolR.D., CombesR.D., CroninM.T.D., JudsonP.N., PayneM.P., RichardA.M., TichyM., WorthA.P., and YourickJ.J. (1997). The development of expert systems for predicting toxicity. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 24.ATLA25, 223–252.
67.
Institute of Environmental Health (1996). The Use of Biomarkers in Environmental Exposure Assessment, 115 pp. Leicester, UK: IEH.
68.
CrosslandN.O. (1994). Extrapolating from meso-cosms to the real world.Toxicology and Ecotoxicology News1, 15–22.
69.
WrightJ.F. (1995). Development and use of a system for predicting the macroinvertebrate fauna found in flowing waters.Australian Journal of Ecology20, 181–197.
70.
KarrJ.R. (1981). Assessment of biotic integrity using fish communities.Fisheries6, 21–27.
71.
SomervilleL., and WalkerC.H. (1990). Pesticide Effects on Terrestrial Wildlife, 404 pp. London: Taylor & Francis.
72.
Greig-SmithP.W., FramptonG., and HardyA.R. (1992). Pesticides, Cereal Farming and the Environment: The Boxworth Project, 288 pp. London: HMSO.
73.
HMSO (1996). Statistics of Scientific Procedures on Living Animals: Great Britain 1995, Cm. 3516, 95 pp. London: HMSO.
74.
HMSO (1997). Statistics of Scientific Procedures on Living Animals: Great Britain 1996, Cm. 3722, 95 pp. London: HMSO.
75.
HSMO (1998). Statistics of Scientific Procedures on Living Animals: Great Britain 1997, Cm 4025, 95 pp. London: HMSO.
76.
European Commission (1997). Classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances in the European Union. II. Testing Methods.Luxembourg: Official Publication of the European Communities.
