Examining participatory governance in a devolving UK: Insights from national parks policy development in Northern Ireland

Abstract

This paper provides a contemporary examination of policy making and participatory practice in the context of devolving governance in the UK. The paper takes Northern Ireland as its focus and is particularly timely considering the context of devolved governance, the ongoing transition from conflict to relative peace and the potential for rejuvenating democracy through participatory governance. The paper concentrates on one particular policy process, namely the attempted designation of a national park in the Mournes Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. A thematic analysis of qualitative data is drawn upon to analyse the structural factors that framed the policy-making process, in particular the role of power in determining how consultation processes were initiated, designed and undertaken. Using Lukes’ model as an analytical framework, power is shown to manifest at multiple levels within the policy-making process to influence policy outcomes. The paper reveals how the persistence of a top-down approach to policy development combined with a highly parochial political outlook undermined attempts to designate a Mourne National Park. The paper concludes that, given the immaturity of recently devolved government in Northern Ireland, in this instance, the democratising intentions of devolved governance have not been met. This has implications for Northern Ireland’s recent reform of public administration which devolves certain planning powers to local authority level and the management of the internationally significant Mournes landscape.

Keywords

National parks governance power public consultation partnerships

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Robinson

(2002) Devolution in Practice: Public Policy Differences within the UK, London: Institute for Public Policy Research.

Arnstein

(1969) A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners 35(4): 215–224.

Annet J and Scott P (2006) National Park: Potential Impacts of National Park Designation in Northern Ireland, Belfast: JACC&PSPS.

Bachrach

Baratz

(1962) The two faces of power. American Political Science Review 56(4): 941–952.

Barnes

(1988) The Nature of Power, Cambridge: Polity Press.

BBC (2002) National park plan moves closer. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/2282701.stm (accessed 6 January 2011).

BBC (2014) Environment Minister Mark H Durkan Shelves National Parks Plan. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-24903525 (accessed 10 September 2014).

Bell

Stockdale

(2009) Towards a multi-purpose model for the proposed Mourne National Park. Irish Geography 42(3): 293–321.

Bell

Stockdale

(2015a) Comparing the political imperative to designate new national parks in a devolved Scotland and Northern Ireland. In: Murray

(ed.) A Sense of Place: Multidisciplinary Essays in Honour of Malachy McEldowney, Belfast: Institute of Spatial and Environmental Planning, Queen’s University Belfast.

10.

Bell

Stockdale

(2015b) Evolving national park models: The emergence of an economic imperative and its effect on the contested nature of the ‘national’ park concept in Northern Ireland. Land Use Policy 49: 213–226.

11.

Birrell

(2008) The final outcome of the review of public administration in Northern Ireland. Tensions and compatibility with devolution, parity and modernization. Public Administration 86(3): 779–793.

12.

Bishop

Davis

(2002) Mapping public participation in policy choices. Australian Journal of Public Administration 61(1): 14–29.

13.

Braun

Clarke

(2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2): 77–101.

14.

Buchanan Partners Ltd (2006) Tourism in Mourne: Current and Potential Economic Impact, Belfast: Buchanan Partners Ltd.

15.

CAAN (2007) Mourne Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty Access Study, Belfast: Countryside Access and Activities Network.

16.

Cave

(2012) Local Government Reform - Past and Present, Belfast: Northern Ireland Assembly Research and Information Service.

17.

Clegg

(1989) Frameworks of Power, London: SAGE Publications.

18.

Colhoun

(2007) Review of Public Administration: Research Briefing, Belfast: Northern Ireland Assembly Research and Library Services.

19.

Cornwall

(2002) Making Spaces, Changing Places: Situating Participation in Development. Working Paper 170. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies (IDS).

20.

Cornwall

(2004) Introduction: New Democratic Spaces? The Politics and Dynamics of Institutionalised Participation, Brighton: Institute of Development Studies (IDS).

21.

Dahl RA (1957) The concept of power. Behavioural Science 2(3): 211–215.

22.

Davies

(2011) Challenging Governance Theory: From Networks to Hegemony, Bristol: The Policy Press.

23.

Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht (2015) National Landscape Strategy for Ireland, Dublin: The Stationary Office.

24.

Derkzen

Bock

(2009) Partnership and role perception, three case studies on the meaning of being a representative in rural partnerships. Environment and Planning C 27(1): 75–89.

25.

Derkzen

Franklin

Bock

(2008) Examining power struggles as a signifier of successful partnership working: A case study of partnership dynamics. Journal of Rural Studies 24(4): 458–466.

26.

DoE (2007) Foster pledges half a million pounds for mournes access management. Available at: http://www.northernireland.gov.uk/news/news-doe/news-doe-september-2007/news-doe-280907-foster-pledges-half.htm (accessed 3 June 2013).

27.

Donnon

Wilson

(1994) Border Approaches: Anthropological Perspectives on Frontiers, Lanham, MD: University Press of America.

28.

Eagles

Romagosa

Buteau-Duitschaever

(2013) Good governance in protected areas: An evaluation of stakeholder perspectives in British Columbia and Ontario Provincial Parks. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 21(1): 60–79.

29.

Edwards

Goodwin

Pemberton

(2001) Partnerships, power and scale in rural governance. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 19(2): 289–310.

30.

Ferguson

Forster

(2005) Establishing the Cairngorms National Park: Lessons learned and challenges ahead. In: Thompson

DBA

Price

Galbraith

(eds) Mountains of Northern Europe: Conservation, Management, People and Nature, Edinburgh: TSO Scotland, pp. 275.

31.

Gaventa

(2006) Finding the spaces for change: A power analysis. Institute of Development Studies 37(6): 23–33.

32.

Goodwin

(2008) Rural governance, devolution and policy delivery. In: Woods

(ed.) New Labour's Countryside – Rural policy in Britain Since 1997, Bristol: Policy Press, pp. 45.

33.

Griffin

(2012) Where is power in governance? Why geography matters in the theory of governance. Political Studies Review 10(2): 208–220.

34.

Hall

(2011) Policy learning and policy failure in sustainable tourism governance: From first- and second-order to third-order change. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 19(4–5): 649–671.

35.

Hamin

(2001) The US National Park Service’s partnership parks: Collaborative responses to middle landscapes. Land Use Policy 18(2): 123–135.

36.

Hayward

(1998) De-facing power. Polity 31(1): 1–22.

37.

Healey

(2003) Collaborative planning in perspective. Planning Theory 2(2): 101–123.

38.

Healey

(2006) Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies, 2nd ed. Hampshire: Palgrave MacMillan.

39.

Illsley

Richardson

(2004) New national parks for Scotland: Coalitions in conflict over the allocation of planning powers in the Cairngorms. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 47(2): 219–242.

40.

Inform Communications (2007) Report to the Mourne National Park Working Party on the outcome of their public consultation: ‘Your opportunity to have your say’. Belfast: Inform Communications Ltd.

41.

Innes

(2004) Consensus building: Clarifications for the critics. Planning Theory 3(1): 5–20.

42.

Isaac

(1987) Beyond the three faces of power: A realist critique. Polity 20(1): 4–31.

43.

Jessop

(1997) Capitalism and its future: Remarks on regulation, government and governance. Review of International Political Economy 4(3): 561–581.

44.

Knox

(2006) Improving Public Services: Public Administration Reform in Northern Ireland, Jordanstown: School of Policy Studies, University of Ulster.

45.

Knox C (2008) Policy making in Northern Ireland: Ignoring the evidence. The Policy Press 36(3): 343–359.

46.

Knox

(2012) The reform of public administration in Northern Ireland: A squandered opportunity? Administration 60(1): 117–138.

47.

Lockwood

(2010) Good governance for terrestrial protected areas: A framework, principles and performance outcomes. Journal of Environmental Management 91(3): 754–766.

48.

Lukes

(1974) Power: A Radical View, 1st ed. London: MacMillan Press Ltd.

49.

Lukes

(2005) Power: A Radical View, 2nd ed. Hampshire: Palgrave MacMillan.

50.

McAlister

(2010) Putting the ‘community’ into community planning: Assessing community inclusion in Northern Ireland. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34(3): 533–547.

51.

McAreavey

(2006) Getting close to the action: The micro-politics of rural development. Sociologia Ruralis 46(2): 85–103.

52.

McAreavey

(2008) Rural Development Theory and Practice: A Critical Analysis of Rural Development Theory and Practice, London and New York: Routledge.

53.

Mack

Loughry

McDonald

(2006) A Socio-economic Profile of the Proposed Mournes National Park, Belfast: Rural Development Council Policy and Innovation Research Unit.

54.

Margerum

(2002) Collaborative planning: Building consensus and building a distinct model for practice. Journal of Planning Education and Research 21(3): 237–253.

55.

Marsh

Richards

Smith

(2003) Unequal plurality: Towards an asymmetric power model of British politics. Government and Opposition 38(3): 306–332.

56.

May

(2001) Social Research – Issues, Methods and Process, 3rd ed. London: Open University Press.

57.

MHT (2007) An Introduction to the Mourne Biodiversity Action Plan – A Reflection of Mourne’s Rich Natural Heritage, Newcastle, NI: Mourne Heritage Trust.

58.

MHT (2011) Wildfires in the Mourne Mountains. Available at: http://www.mournelive.com/francais/news/news/viewdetails.asp?newsID=515 (accessed 16 July 2012).

59.

Mitchell

(2000) New parliament, new politics in Scotland. Parliamentary Affairs 53(3): 605.

60.

MNPWP (2007) Report to the Minister, Belfast: Environment and Heritage Service.

61.

Mourne Observer (2011, 5 October) MP urges local people to think ‘long and hard’ about national park issue. Newcastle (NI): The Mourne Observer.

62.

Mourne Trustees (2010) Report on the outcome of the Mourne national park consultation exercise by nominees of the Mourne Trustees, Newcastle, NI: Mourne Trustees.

63.

Murray

(2010) Participatory Rural Planning: Exploring Evidence from Ireland, 1st ed. Surrey: Ashgate.

64.

NIA (2010) Engagement Strategy for the Northern Ireland Assembly, Belfast: The Northern Ireland Assembly.

65.

O’Hara

(2010, 24 June) Boundary Dispute Village at Heart of a £9m Disaster, Belfast: Independent News and Media.

66.

Parker G (2008) Countryside access, the ‘right to roam’ under New Labour: Nothing to CRoW about? In: Woods M (ed.) New Labour's countryside: Rural policy in Britain since 1997. Bristol: The Policy Press, p. 135.

67.

Peters

(2000) Governance and comparative politics. In: Pierre

(ed.) Debating Governance: Authority, Steering and Democracy, London: Oxford University Press, pp. 36.

68.

Pierre

(2000) Introduction: Understanding governance. In: Pierre

(ed.) Debating Governance: Authority, Steering and Democracy, London: Oxford University Press, pp. 1–12.

69.

Ramsden L (2012, 12 September) Mood at packed meeting is one of implacable opposition. Newcastle: The Mourne Observer Ltd.

70.

Rettie

(2010) Place, politics and power in the Cairngorms National Park. In: Stewart

Strathern

(eds) Farming Issues in the European Union, Carolina: Carolina Academic Press, pp. 107–139.

71.

Rettie

(2001) The report on the proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms. An independent assessment of the consultation on the proposed National Park for the Cairngorms, Edinburgh: Scottish Natural Heritage.

72.

Rhodes

RAW

(1996) The new governance: Governing without government. Political Studies 44(6): 652–667.

73.

Rhodes

RAW

(1997) Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability, Buckingham: Open University Press.

74.

Rhodes

RAW

(2000) Governance and public administration. In: Pierre

(ed.) Debating Governance: Authority, Steering and Democracy, London: Oxford University Press, pp. 54–90.

75.

Richards

(1996) Elite interviewing: Approaches and pitfalls. Politics 16(3): 199–204.

76.

Sable

(1996) Ireland: Local Partnerships and Social Innovation, Paris: OECD.

77.

Scottish Government (2011) Getting the Best from Our Land: A Land Use Strategy for Scotland, Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

78.

Shand

Arnberg

(1996) Background Paper in Responsive Government: Service Quality Initiatives, Paris: OECD.

79.

Shoard

(1987) No space for parks; Marion Shoard explains why Scotland lacks national parks. Geographical magazine, Surrey: Circle Publishing.

80.

Shortall

(2004) Social or economic goals, civic inclusion or exclusion? An analysis of rural development theory and practice. Sociologia Ruralis 44(1): 109–123.

81.

Sidaway

(1998) Good Practice in Rural Development: Consensus Building, Edinburgh: Crown Copyright.

82.

Skelcher

(2000) Changing images of the state: Overloaded, hollowed out, congested. Public Policy and Administration 15(3): 3–19.

83.

SNH (1999) National Parks for Scotland – Scottish Natural Heritage’s Advice to Government, Perth: SNH.

84.

SNH (2001) Report 1. The report on the proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms, Perth: Scottish Natural Heritage.

85.

Stockdale

Barker

(2009) Sustainability and the multifunctional landscape: An assessment of approaches to planning and management in the Cairngorms National Park. Land Use Policy 26(2): 479–492.

86.

Stoker

(1998) Governance as theory: Five propositions. International Social Science Journal 50(155): 17–28.

87.

Stoker

(2011) Was local governance such a good idea? A global comparative perspective. Public Administration 89(1): 15–31.

88.

Sturzaker

(2010) The exercise of power to limit the development of new housing in the English countryside. Environment and Planning A 42(4): 1001–1016.

89.

Sturzaker

Shucksmith

(2011) Planning for housing in England: Discursive power and spatial exclusion. Town Planning Review 82(2): 169–193.

90.

Swyngedouw

(2005) Governance innovation and the citizen: The Janus face of governance-beyond-the-state. Urban Studies 42(11): 1991–2006.

91.

Tansey

(2009) Process tracing and elite interviewing: A case for non-probability sampling. Political Science and Politics 40(4): 481–496.

92.

Taylor

(2000) Communities in the lead: Power, organisational capacity and social capital. Urban Studies 37(5–6): 1019–1035.

93.

Taylor

(2003) Public Policy in the Community, 1st ed. Hampshire: Palgrave MacMillan.

94.

Taylor

(2007) Community participation in the real world: Opportunities and pitfalls in new governance spaces. Urban Studies 44(2): 297–317.

95.

The Scottish Office (1997) Scotland’s Parliament, Edinburgh: The Scottish Office.

96.

Thompson

(2006) The practice of government in a devolved Scotland: The case of the designation of the Cairngorms National Park. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 24(3): 459–472.

97.

Thompson NJ (2003) Governing national parks in a devolving UK. PhD Thesis, University of Leeds.

98.

UKANPA (2010) Working with partner organisations. Available at: http://www.nationalparks.gov.uk/lookingafter/partners.htm (accessed 9 November 2010).

99.

Warner

(1997) ‘Consensus’ participation: An example for protected areas planning. Public Administration and Development 17(4): 413–432.

100.

Warren

(2009) The ‘natural’: Conservation management. In: Warren

(ed.) Managing Scotland’s Environment, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 214.

101.

Wilford

MacGinty

Dowds

(2003) Northern Ireland’s devolved institutions: A triumph of hope over experience. Regional and Federal Studies 13(1): 31–54.

102.

Wilford

Wilson

(2001) A Democratic Design? The Political Style of the Northern Ireland Assembly, London: UCL, Constitution Unit.

103.

Woods

(1997) Discourses of power and rurality: Local politics in Somerset in the 20th century. Political Geography 16(6): 453–478.

104.

Woods

(2005a) Contesting Rurality: Politics in the British Countryside, 1st ed. Hampshire: Ashgate.

105.

Woods

(2005b) Rural Geography, London: Sage.

106.

Woods

(2010) Reporting an unsettled countryside: The news media and rural protests in Britain. Culture Unbound 2(13): 215–239.