Fetal citizens? Birthright citizenship,reproductive futurism,and the “panic” over Chinese birth tourism in southern California

Abstract

In September 2012, residents of Chino Hills, California—a wealthy suburb of Los Angeles—exposed a maternity hotel in their city. Subsequently, controversy erupted as protesting residents argued that Chinese birth tourism is an immigration loophole, where foreigners took advantage of jus soli birthright citizenship guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. This paper uses this controversy as a springboard to explore how temporalities—both the past and the future—come to shape politics in the present. Considering reproductive futurism in the contexts of citizenship and migrations, this paper argues that the figure of the fetal citizen emerges as the defining site of struggle between preserving, or exposing, the fantasy of a national future. Reports of panic over Chinese birth tourism, then, show how “backwards” racialized citizenship is continually brought to this present struggle, especially vis-a-vis discourses of the “worthy immigrant” and “anchor babies”, to determine who may give birth to citizens in the U.S.

Keywords

Birthright citizenship reproductive futurism birth tourism immigration temporality critical media studies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aber

Small

(2013) Citizen or subordinate: Permutations of belonging in the United States and the Dominican Republic. Journal on Migration and Human Security 1(3): 76–96.

Aleinikoff

Klusmeyer

(2002) Citizenship Policies for an Age of Migration, Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Amin

(2010) The remainders of race. Theory, Culture & Society 27(1): 1–23.

Amin

(2013) Surviving the turbulent future. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 31(1): 140–156.

Baldwin

(2012) Whiteness and futurity. Progress in Human Geography 36(2): 172–187.

Balta

Altan-Olcay

(2016) Strategic citizens of America: Transnational inequalities and transformation of citizenship. Ethnic and Racial Studies 39(6): 939–957.

Barnett

Low

(2004) Geography and democracy: An introduction. In: Barnett

Low

(eds) Spaces of Democracy: Geographical Perspectives on Citizenship, Participation and Representation, London: Sage, pp. 1–22.

Bauder

(2014) Domicile citizenship, human mobility and territoriality. Progress in Human Geography 38(1): 91–106.

Beech

(2013) I want an American baby! Chinese women flock to the U.S. to give birth. Time Magazine. 27 November. Available at: http://world.time.com/2013/11/27/chinese-women-are-flocking-to-the-u-s-to-have-babies/.

10.

Berlant

(1993) The theory of infantile citizenship. Public Culture 5: 395–410.

11.

Berlant

(1994) America, ‘fat,’ the fetus. Boundary 2 21(3): 145–195.

12.

Berlant

(1997) The Queen of America Goes to Washington City, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

13.

Bhabha

(2009) The ‘mere fortuity of birth’? Children, mothers, borders, and the meaning of citizenship. In: Benhabib

Resnik

(eds) Migrations and Mobilities: Citizenship, Borders, and Gender, New York, NY: New York University Press, pp. 187–227.

14.

Bloemraad

(2013) Being American/becoming American: Birthright citizenship and immigrants’ membership in the United States. Studies in Law, Politics and Society 60: 55–84.

15.

Bloemraad

Korteweg

Yurdakul

(2008) Citizenship and immigration: Multiculturalism, assimilation, and challenges to the nation-state. Annual Review of Sociology 34: 153–179.

16.

Buscher

Urry

(2009) Mobile methods and the empirical. European Journal of Social Theory 12(1): 99–116.

17.

CAACH (2012) Chino Hills Chinese American Association Endorses Not in Chino Hills! Chinese American Association of Chino Hills. 17 December. Available at: www.notinchinohills.org/chino_hills_chinese_american_association_endorses_not_in_chino_hills.

18.

Chang

(2012a) Chino Hills maternity hotel controversy heats up. Los Angeles Times. 11 December. Available at: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2012/12/chino-hills-maternity-hotel-controversy-heats-up.html.

19.

Chang

(2012b) Chino Hills seeks to close home used by pregnant Chinese women. Los Angeles Times. 4 December. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/dec/04/local/la-me-birthing-center-20121204.

20.

Chang

(2013a) Complaints against maternity hotels surge. Los Angeles Times. 27 January. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2013/jan/27/local/la-me-birthing-centers-20130126.

21.

Chang

(2013b) L.A. County cites 16 ‘maternity hotel’ owners. Los Angeles Times. 11 April. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2013/apr/11/local/la-me-ff-maternity-hotels-20130412.

22.

Chang

(2013c) Maternity hotel ordinance not necessary, planning department says. Los Angeles Times. 28 October. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2013/oct/28/local/la-me-ln-maternity-hotel-ordinance-20131028.

23.

Chávez

(2013) Queer Migration Politics: Activist Rhetoric and Coalitional Possibilities, Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.

24.

Cheng

(2013) The Changs Next Door to the Díazes: Remapping Race in Suburban California, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

25.

Cisneros

(2008) Contaminated communities: The metaphor of ‘immigrant as pollutant’ in media representations of immigration. Rhetoric & Public Affairs 11(4): 569–601.

26.

Cisneros

(2013) ‘Alien’ sexuality: Race, maternity, and citizenship. Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy 28(2): 290–306.

27.

Clinton

(2011) America’s Pacific century. Foreign Policy. 11 October. Available at: www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/10/11/americas_pacific_century.

28.

Conlon

(2010) Ties that bind: Governmentality, the state, and asylum in contemporary Ireland. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 28(1): 95–111.

29.

Connell

(2013) Contemporary medical tourism: Conceptualization, culture and commodification. Tourism Management 34: 1–13.

30.

Constable

(2014) Born Out of Place: Migrant Mothers and the Politics of International Labor, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

31.

Cresswell

(2006) On the Move: Mobility in the Modern Western World, London: Routledge.

32.

de Beauvoir

(1989) The Second Sex, New York: Vintage.

33.

Edelman

(2004) No Future: Queer Theory and the Death Drive, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

34.

Ellis

(2006) Unsettling immigrant geographies: US immigration and the politics of scale. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 97(1): 49–58.

35.

Ellis

Wright

Townley

(2014) The Great Recession and the allure of new immigrant destinations in the United States. International Migration Review 48(1): 3–33.

36.

Eng

(2010) The Feeling of Kinship: Queer Liberalism and the Racialization of Intimacy, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

37.

Enloe

(1990) Women and children: Making feminist sense of the Persian Gulf Crisis. The Village Voice. 25 September.

38.

Glenn

(2000) Citizenship and inequality: Historical and global perspectives. Social Problems 47(1): 1–20.

39.

Hannerz

(2003) Being there … and there … and there! Reflections on multi-site ethnography. Ethnography 4(2): 201–216.

40.

Hartry

(2012) Birthright justice: The attack on birthright citizenship and immigrant women of color. NYU Review of Law & Social Change 36(1): 57–101.

41.

Hoeffel

Rastogi

Kim

et al. (2012) The Asian population: 2010. 2010 Census Briefs, Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.

42.

Huffington Post (2012) ‘Maternity hotel’ in Chino Hills, Calif. sparks outrage, reports of other maternity tourism businesses, 12 December. Available at: www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/12/maternity-hotel-chino-hills-calif-asian-mothers-video_n_2286372.html.

43.

Ignatow

Williams

(2011) New media and the ‘anchor baby’ boom. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication 17(1): 60–76.

44.

Isin

(2012) Citizens without nations. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 30(3): 450–467.

45.

Jacobson

(2010) Fact-checking the claims about ‘anchor babies’ and whether illegal immigrants ‘drop and leave’. PolitiFact.com. 6 August. Available at: www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2010/aug/06/lindsey-graham/illegal-immigrants-anchor-babies-birthright/.

46.

Jones

(2008) The ambiguous roles of suburbanization and immigration in ethnic segregation: The case of San Antonio. Urban Geography 29(3): 196–223.

47.

Katz

(2008) Childhood as spectacle: Relays of anxiety and the reconfiguration of the child. Cultural Geographies 15(1): 5–17.

48.

Katz

(2011) Accumulation, excess, childhood: Toward a countertopography of risk and waste. Documents d’Anàlisi Geogràfica 57(1): 47–60.

49.

Kerber

(2009) The stateless as the citizen’s other: A view from the United States. In: Benhabib

Resnik

(eds) Migrations and Mobilities: Citizenship, Borders, and Gender, New York, NY: New York University Press, pp. 76–123.

50.

Koch

(2013) Technologising the opinion: Focus groups, performance and free speech. Area 45: 411–418.

51.

Koch

(2016) Is nationalism just for nationals? Civic nationalism for noncitizens and celebrating National Day in Qatar and the UAE. Political Geography 54: 43–53.

52.

Lederer

(2013) ‘Anchor baby’: A conceptual explanation for pejoration. Journal of Pragmatics 57: 248–266.

53.

Lee

(2015) Family reunification and the limits of immigration reform: Impact and legacy of the 1965 Immigration Act. Sociological Forum 30: 528–548.

54.

Lee E (2002) The Chinese exclusion example: Race, immigration, and American gatekeeping, 1882–1924. Journal of American Ethnic History 21(3): 36–62.

55.

Levitt

Jaworsky

(2007) Transnational migration studies: Past developments and future trends. Annual Review of Sociology 33: 129–156.

56.

(1998) Anatomy of a new ethnic settlement: The Chinese ethnoburb in Los Angeles. Urban Studies 35(3): 479–501.

57.

(1999) Building ethnoburbia: The emergence and manifestation of the Chinese ethnoburb in Los Angeles’ San Gabriel Valley. Journal of Asian American Studies 2(1): 1–28.

58.

(2009) Ethnoburb: The New Ethnic Community in Urban America, Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai’i Press.

59.

Lin

(2012) Beyond flexible citizenship: Towards a study of many Chinese transnationalisms. Geoforum 43: 137–146.

60.

Lin

Robinson

(2005) Spatial disparities in the expansion of the Chinese ethnoburb of Los Angeles. GeoJournal 64(1): 51–61.

61.

Liu

(2000) The place of immigration in studies of geography and race. Social & Cultural Geography 1(2): 169–182.

62.

(2014) Look who’s walking: Chinese birth tourism goes stateside. Foreign Policy. 25 April. Available at: www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2014/04/25/chinese_birth_tourism_on_rise_in_usa.

63.

Luibhéid

(2013) Pregnant on Arrival: Making the Illegal Immigrant, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

64.

MacDonald

(2016) Calls for educating girls in the Third World: Futurity, girls and the ‘Third World Woman’. Gender, Place & Culture 23(1): 1–17.

65.

Mancini

Finlay

(2008) ‘Citizenship matters’: Lessons from the Irish citizenship referendum. American Quarterly 60(3): 575–599.

66.

Mas

(2014) Canadian citizenship rules face broad reform in 2014. CBC News. 24 January. Available at: www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadian-citizenship-rules-face-broad-reform-in-2014-1.2508758.

67.

Massey

(1992) Politics and space/time. New Left Review, 196: 65–84.

68.

Massey

(2008) New Faces in New Places: The Changing Geography of American Immigration, New York, NY: Russell Sage.

69.

May

Thrift

(2001) Timespace: Geographies of Temporality, London: Routledge.

70.

Medina

(2011) Arriving as pregnant tourists, leaving with American babies. New York Times. 28 March. Available at: www.nytimes.com/2011/03/29/us/29babies.html.

71.

Menzel

(2013) Birthright citizenship and the racial contract: The United States’ jus soli rule against the global regime of citizenship. Du Bois Review 10(1): 29–58.

72.

Mitchell

(1998) Reworking democracy: Contemporary immigration and community politics in Vancouver’s Chinatown. Political Geography 17(6): 729–750.

73.

Mitchell

(2010) Pre-black futures. Antipode 41: 239–261.

74.

Molina

(2014) How Race is Made in America: Immigration, Citizenship, and the Historical Power of Racial Scripts, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

75.

Nair

(2011) How to make prisons disappear: Queer immigrants, the shackles of love, and the invisibility of the prison industrial complex. In: Stanley

Smith

(eds) Captive Genders: Trans Embodiment and the Prison Industrial Complex, Oakland, CA: AK Press, pp. 123–139.

76.

Ngai

(1999) The architecture of race in American immigration law: A reexamination of the Immigration Act of 1924. The Journal of American History 86(1): 67–92.

77.

Ngai

(2005) Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

78.

Ngai

(2007) Birthright citizenship and the alien citizen. Fordham Law Review 75(5): 2521–2530.

79.

Ochoa

(2004) Becoming Neighbors in a Mexican American Community: Power, Conflict, and Solidarity, Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.

80.

Oliviero

(2013) The immigration state of emergency: Racializing and gendering national vulnerability in twenty-first century citizenship and deportation regimes. Feminist Formations 25(2): 1–29.

81.

Ong

(1999) Flexible Citizenship: The Cultural Logics of Transnationality, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

82.

Pandit

Holloway

(2005) New immigrant geographies of United States metropolitan areas. Geographical Review 95(2): iii–vi.

83.

PBS (2013) New Americans. Public Broadcasting Company, 17 May. Available at: http://video.pbs.org/video/2365013663/.

84.

Price

(2012) Race and ethnicity: Latino/a immigrants and emerging geographies of race and place in the USA. Progress in Human Geography 36(6): 800–809.

85.

Pulido

Barraclough

Cheng

(2012) A People’s Guide to Los Angeles, Oakland, CA: University of California Press.

86.

Roberts

(1998) Who may give birth to citizens? Reproduction, eugenics, and immigration. Rutgers Race and the Law Review 1: 129–136.

87.

Roberts

EFS

Scheper-Hughes

(2011) Introduction: Medical migrations. Body & Society 17(2&3): 1–30.

88.

Rojas

(2013) Asian-Americans become a more prominent voice in immigration debate. Southern California Public Radio. 2 August. Available at: www.scpr.org/blogs/multiamerican/2013/08/02/14422/asian-americans-become-a-more-prominent-voice-in-i/.

89.

Sadiq

(2008) Paper Citizens: How Illegal Immigrants Acquire Citizenship in Developing Countries, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

90.

Saito

(1998) Race and Politics: Asian Americans, Latinos, and Whites in a Los Angeles Suburb, Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.

91.

Schuck

Smith

(1985) Citizenship Without Consent: The Illegal Alien in the American Polity, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

92.

Sewell

(2013) L.A. supervisors approve task force to examine ‘maternity hotels’. Los Angeles Times. 5 February. Available at: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2013/02/maternity-hotels.html.

93.

Shachar

(2009) The Birthright Lottery: Citizenship and Global Inequality, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

94.

Singer

Hardwick

Brettell

(2008) Twenty-First Century Gateways: Immigrant Incorporation in Suburban America, Washington, DC: Brookings.

95.

Smith

(2005) Power in place/places of power: Contextualizing transnational research. City & Society 17(1): 5–34.

96.

Smith

Winders

(2008) ‘We’re here to stay’: Economic restructuring, Latino migration and place-making in the US South. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 33(1): 60–72.

97.

Somerville

(2005) Notes toward a queer history of naturalization. American Quarterly 57(3): 659–675.

98.

South El Monte Arts Posse. (2014) A brief history (and geography) of the San Gabriel Valley. Tropics of Meta, 3 February. Available http://tropicsofmeta.wordpress.com/2014/02/03/a-brief-history-and-geography-of-the-san-gabriel-valley/.

99.

Stevens

(2009) States without Nations: Citizenship for Mortals, New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

100.

Tchen

JKW

Yeats

(2014) Yellow Peril! An Archive of Anti-Asian Fear, London: Verso.

101.

Templeton

(2010) Baby baiting. The Nation. 29 July. Available at: www.thenation.com/article/38035/baby-baiting.

102.

Tobar

(2011) ‘Anchor baby’ myth is pure fear-mongering. Los Angeles Times. 4 February. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/feb/04/local/la-me-0204-tobar-20110204.

103.

Tormey

(2007) ‘Everyone with eyes can see the problem’: Moral citizens and the space of Irish nationhood. International Migration 45(3): 69–100.

104.

Tseng

(1994) Chinese ethnic economy: San Gabriel Valley, Los Angeles County. Journal of Urban Affairs 16(2): 169–189.

105.

Tyler

(2010) Designed to fail: A biopolitics of British citizenship. Citizenship Studies 14(1): 61–74.

106.

Wessler

(2013) Advocates to Obama: Stop deporting future citizens. Colorlines. 13 May. Available at: http://colorlines.com/archives/2013/05/advocates_to_obama_stop_deporting_future_citizens.html.

107.

Wong

(2014) Canada’s birthright citizenship policy makes us a nation of suckers. Toronto Life. 20 May. Available at: www.torontolife.com/informer/columns/2014/05/20/jan-wong-canada-birthright-citizenship-nation-of-suckers/.

108.

Yam

(2016) Affective economies and alienizing discourse: Citizenship and maternity tourism in Hong Kong. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 46(5): 410–433.

109.

Zhou

Tseng

Kim

(2008) Rethinking residential assimilation: The case of a Chinese ethnoburb in the San Gabriel Valley, California. Amerasia Journal 34(3): 53–83.