Evolution and revolution: Anarchist geographies,modernity and poststructuralism

Abstract

This paper addresses the recent rediscovery of anarchist geographies and its implications in current debates on the ‘foundations’ of science and knowledge. By interrogating both recent works and original texts by early anarchist geographers who have greater influence on present-day literature such as Elisée Reclus (1830–1905) and Pyotr Kropotkin (1842–1921), I discuss the possible uses of a poststructuralist critique for this line of research by first challenging ‘postanarchist’ claims that so-called ‘classical anarchism’, allegedly biased by essentialist naturalism, should be entirely dismissed by contemporary scholarship. My main argument is that early anarchist geographers used the intellectual tools available in their day to build a completely different ‘discourse’, criticising the ways in which science and knowledge were constructed. As they openly contested ideas of linear progress, racism and European supremacy, as well as anthropocentrism and dichotomised definitions of ‘man’ and ‘nature’, it is hard to make them fit simplistic definitions. The body of work I address stresses their possible contributions to critical, anarchist and radical scholarship through their idea of knowledge, not limited to what is now called ‘discourse analysis’, but engaging with social movements in order to transform society.

Keywords

Anarchist geographies more-than-human geographies evolutionism mutual aid postanarchism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackelsberg

(1991) Free Women of Spain: Anarchism and the Struggle for the Emancipation of Women, Indianapolis: Indiana University press.

Adams

(2015) Kropotkin, Read and the Intellectual History of British anarchism, London: Palgrave.

Angault

et al. (2014) Le Maitron des Anarchistes, Paris: Les Éditions Ouvrières.

Antliff A (2010) Anarchy, power, and poststructuralism, Anarchist Library. Available at: http://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/allan-antliff-anarchy-power-and-poststructuralism (accessed 3 February 2017).

Antonioli

et al. (2003–2004) Dizionario Biografico degli Anarchici Italiani, Pisa: BFS.

Barclay

(1996) People Without Government, an Anthropology of Anarchy, London: Kahn and Averill.

Bourdieu

(1975) The specificity of the scientific field and the social conditions of the progress of reason. Social Science Information 14: 19–47.

Breitbart M (1978) The Theory & Practice of Anarchist Decentralism in Spain, 1936–1939. PhD dissertation, Clark University, Worcester.

Brun C (2015) Elisée Reclus, une chronologie familiale. Raforum. Available at: http://raforum.info/reclus/spip.php?article474&lang=fr (accessed 3 February 2017).

10.

Call

(2002) Postmodern Anarchism, Lanham: Lexingdon Books.

11.

Castree

(1995) The nature of produced nature. Antipode 27(1): 12–48.

12.

Cho

Crenshaw

McCall

(2013) Toward a field of intersectionality studies: Theory, applications, and praxis. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 38(4): 785–810.

13.

Demeritt

(2002) What is the ‘social construction of nature’? A typology and sympathetic critique. Progress in Human Geography 26(6): 767–790.

14.

Clark

(2013) The Impossible Community, London: Bloomsbury.

15.

Clark

Martin (2013) Anarchy, Geography, Modernity: Selected Writings of Élisée Reclus, Oakland: PM Press.

16.

CNT (1936) Resolution over the Confederal Concept of Libertarian Communism. The Anarchist Library. Available at: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/the-confederal-concept-of-libertarian-communism (accessed 3 February 2017).

17.

Cresswell

(2013) Geographic Thought: A Critical Introduction, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.

18.

Day

(2005) Gramsci is Dead, Anarchist Currents in the Newest Social Movements, London: Pluto Press.

19.

Dugatkin

(2011) The Prince of Evolution: Peter Kropotkin's Adventures in Science and Politics, Charleston: Createspace.

20.

Dunbar

(1978) Élisée Reclus: Historian of Nature, Hamden: Archon Books.

21.

Eribon

(1993) Michel Foucault, London: Faber.

22.

Faye

(2006) Nazi foundations in Heidegger’s work. South Central Review 23(1): 55–56.

23.

Featherstone

Griffin

(2016) Spatial relations, histories from below and the makings of agency: Reflections on The Making of the English Working Class. Progress in Human Geography 40(3): 375–393.

24.

Ferretti

(2011) The correspondence between Élisée Reclus and Pëtr Kropotkin as a source for the history of geography. Journal of Historical Geography 37: 216–222.

25.

Ferretti

(2014) Pioneers in the history of cartography: The Geneva map collection of Élisée Reclus and Charles Perron. Journal of Historical Geography 43: 85–95.

26.

Ferretti F (2016) “The murderous civilization”: Anarchist geographies, ethnography and cultural differences in the works of Elie Reclus. Cultural Geographies [early view]. Available at: http://cgj.sagepub.com/content/early/2016/08/09/1474474016662293.full (accessed 3 February 2017).

27.

Foucault

(1991) Discipline and Punish, New York: Vintage Books.

28.

Gibson-Graham

(2006) A Postcapitalist Politics, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

29.

Girón Sierra

(2003) Kropotkin between Lamarck and Darwin: The impossible synthesis. Asclepio 40(1): 189–213.

30.

Girón Sierra

(2005) En la Mesa con Darwin. Evolución y Revolución en el Movimiento Libertario en España (1864–1914), Madrid: CSIC.

31.

Goldman

(1970) Living My Life, New York: Dover.

32.

Gould

(1997) Kropotkin was no crackpot. Natural History 106: 12–21.

33.

Graeber

(2004) Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology, Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press.

34.

Gramsci

(1975) Quaderni dal Carcere 12–29, Torino: Einaudi.

35.

Haraway

(1988) Situated knowledges: The science question in feminism and the privilege of partial perspective. Feminist Studies 14(3): 575–599.

36.

Haraway

(2008) When Species Meet, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

37.

Hobsbawm

(1959) Primitive Rebels: Studies in Archaic Forms of Social Movement, Manchester: Manchester University Press.

38.

Ince

Barrera de la Torre

(2016) For post-statist geographies. Political Geography 55: 10–19.

39.

Jun

(2012) Anarchism and Political Modernity, New York: Continuum.

40.

Kinna

(2016) Kropotkin: Reviewing the Classical Anarchist Tradition, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

41.

Kropotkin

(1899) Memoirs of a Revolutionist, Vol. II, London: Smith, Elder & Co.

42.

Kropotkin

(1902) Mutual Aid, a Factor in Evolution, London: Heinemann.

43.

Kropotkin

(1903) Modern Science and Anarchism, Philadelphia: The Social Science Club.

44.

Kropotkin

(1924) Ethics, Origins and Development, London: Harrap.

45.

Kuhn G (2009) Anarchism, postmodernity and poststructuralism. In: Amster R, DeLeon A, Fernandez LA, et al. (eds) Contemporary Anarchist Studies: An Introductory Anthology of Anarchy in the Academy. London: Routledge, pp. 18–25.

46.

Latour

(2004) Politics of Nature: How to Bring the Sciences into Democracy, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

47.

La Vergata

(2009) Colpa di Darwin? Razzismo, Eugenetica e Altri Mali, Turin: UTET.

48.

Levy

(2007) Sovversivismo: The radical political culture of otherness in Liberal Italy. Journal of Political Ideologies 12(2): 147–161.

49.

Livingstone

(2003) Putting Science in its Place, Geographies of Scientific Knowledge, Chicago: Chicago University Press.

50.

Livingstone

(2014) Dealing with Darwin, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

51.

Lorimer

(2006) Herding memories of humans and animals. Environment and Planning D 24(4): 497–518.

52.

Lorimer

(2012) Multinatural geographies for the Anthropocene. Progress in Human Geography 36(5): 593–612.

53.

MacLaughlin

(2016) Kropotkin and the Anarchist Intellectual Tradition, London: Pluto.

54.

Malatesta

(2014) The Method of Freedom: An Errico Malatesta Reader, London: AK Press.

55.

May

(1994) The Political Philosophy of Poststructuralist Anarchism, University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.

56.

Metchnikoff

(1886) Revolution and evolution. Contemporary Review 50: 412–437.

57.

Metchnikoff

(1889) La Civilisation et les Grands Fleuves Historiques, Paris: Hachette.

58.

Mitchell

(2000) Cultural Geography, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

59.

Morris

(2014) A Brian Morris reader, Oakland: PM Press.

60.

Nash

(1975) Mujeres Libres, Barcelona: Tusquets.

61.

Nettlau

(1930) Eliseo Reclus: Vida de un Sabio Justo y Rebelde, Vol. II, Barcelona: Edicciones de la Revista Blanca.

62.

Newman

(2001) From Bakunin to Lacan: Anti-authoritarianism and the Dislocation of Power, Lanham: Lexington books.

63.

Newman

(2010) The Politics of Postanarchism, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

64.

Newman

(2011) Post-anarchism: A politics of anti-politics. Journal of Political Ideologies 16(3): 313–327.

65.

Newman

(2016) Postanarchism, Cambridge: Polity Press.

66.

Olsson

(1987) Abysmal, a Critique of Cartographic Reason, Chicago: Chicago University Press.

67.

Pelletier

(2013) Géographie et Anarchie, Reclus, Kropotkine, Metchnikoff, Paris: Éditions du Monde Libertaire.

68.

Pelletier

(2015) Anarchisme et Cause Animale, Paris: Éditions du Monde Libertaire.

69.

Philo

Wilbert

(2000) Animal Spaces, Beastly Places: New Geographies of Human-Animal Relations, London: Routledge.

70.

Puente Amestoy

(2013) Libertarian Communism, Hastings: Christiebooks.

71.

Ramnath

(2011) Decolonizing Anarchism: An Antiauthoritarian History of India’s Liberation Struggle, London: AK Press.

72.

Reclus

(1888) Nouvelle Géographie Universelle, Vol. XIII, Paris: Hachette.

73.

Reclus

(1901) On vegetarianism. The Humane Review 1(4): 316–324.

74.

Reclus

(1905) L’Homme et la Terre, Vol. I, Paris: Librairie universelle.

75.

Reclus

(1908) L’Homme et la Terre, Vol. VI, Paris: Librairie universelle.

76.

Reclus

(2012) Écrits Sociaux, Geneva: Héros-limite.

77.

Rousselle

(2013) Postanarchism and its critics: A conversation with Saul Newman. Anarchist studies 21(2): 74–96.

78.

Scott

(2009) The Art of not Being Governed, an Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia, New Haven: Yale University Press.

79.

Secord

(2014) Visions of Science, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

80.

Springer

(2014) Human geography without hierarchy. Progress in Human Geography 38(3): 402–419.

81.

Springer

(2016) The Anarchist Roots of Geography: Toward Spatial Emancipation, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

82.

Springer

Barker

Brown

et al. (2012) Reanimating anarchist geographies: A new burst of colour. Antipode 44(5): 1591–1604.

83.

Springer S, White R, Lopes de Souza M (eds) (2016) The Radicalisation of Pedagogy. Anarchism, Geography and the Spirit of Revolt. New York: Rowman & Littlefield.

84.

Swyngedouw

(2006) Circulations and metabolisms: (Hybrid) natures and (cyborg) cities. Science as Culture 15(2): 105–121.

85.

Tang

(2008) The Geographic Imagination of Modernity, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

86.

Turcato

(2015) Making Sense of Anarchism, London: AK Press.

87.

Vuilleumier

(2012) Histoire et Combats, Geneva: Éditions d’en bas.

88.

White

(2015) Following in the footsteps of Elisée Reclus: Disturbing places of inter-species violence that are hidden in plain sight. In: Nocella

II White

Cudworth

(eds) Anarchism and Animal Liberation. Essays on Complementary Elements of Total Liberation, Jefferson: Mc Farland & Company, pp. 212–230.

89.

Wills

(2008) Mapping class and its political possibilities. Antipode 40(1): 25–30.

90.

Withers

CWJ

(2010) Geography and Science in Britain, 1831–1939: A Study of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, Manchester: Manchester University Press.