Comparison of reading performance between visually impaired and normally sighted students in Malaysia

Abstract

The aim of this study is to compare reading performance between visually impaired and normally sighted school children. Participants (n = 299) were divided into three groups: normal vision (NV, n = 193), visually impaired print reader (PR, n = 52), and Braille reader (BR, n = 54). Reading performance was determined by measuring reading rate and comprehension. ANOVA was used to compare the results. A statistically significant difference was found in reading rate between the three groups (p < 0.0001). The BR had the lowest reading rate compared to other groups. Only a small percentage of the visually impaired children were able to achieve a reading rate within the normal values of normally sighted children. Results of the comprehension test showed no significant difference in the scores of the three groups (p = 0.232). The findings of this study suggests that visually impaired students required a longer time to read and understand a text and this has implications on the time given to them, especially during examinations.

Keywords

Braille reader comprehension print reader reading rate visually impaired

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahn, S.J. & Legge, G.E. ( 1995) ‘Psychophysics of Reading, XIII: Predictors of Magnifier-Aided Reading Speed in Low Vision’, Vision Research 35: 1931-8.

Bailey, I.L. & Lovie, J.E. ( 1976) ‘New Design Principles for Visual Acuity Letter Charts’, American Journal of Optometry and Physiological Optics 53: 740-5.

Bailey, I.L. , Lueck, A.H. , Greer, R.B. , Tuan, K.M. , Bailey, V.M. & Dornbusch, H.G. ( 2003) ‘Understanding the Relationships Between Print Size and Reading in Low Vision’, Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 97(6): 325-34.

Bullimore, M.A. & Bailey, I.L. ( 1995) ‘Reading and Eye Movement in Age-related Maculopathy’ , Optometry and Vision Science 72: 125-38.

Carver, R.P. ( 1990) Reading Rate: A Review of Research and Theory. Sand Diego: Academic Press.

Douglas, G. , Grimley, M. , Hill, E. , Long, R. & Tobin, M. ( 2002) ‘The Use of the NARA for Assessing the Reading Ability of Children with Low Vision’, British Journal of Visual Impairment 20: 68-75.

Gompel, M. , Van Bon, W.H.J. & Schreuder, R. ( 2004) ‘Reading by Children with Low Vision’ , Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 98(2): 77-89.

Gompel, M. , Van Bon, W.H.J. , Schreuder, R. & Adriaansen, J.J.M. ( 2002) ‘Reading and Spelling Competence of Dutch Children with Low Vision’, Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 96: 435-47.

Gonzalez Garcia, L. ( 2004) ‘Assessment of Text Reading Comprehension by Spanish-speaking Blind Persons’, British Journal of Visual Impairment 22: 4-12.

10.

Leat, S.J. & Woodhouse, J.M. ( 1993) ‘Reading Performance with Low Vision Aids’ , Ophthalmic Physiological Optics 13: 9-16.

11.

Legge, G.E. , Madison, C.M. , & Mansfield, J.S. (1999) ‘Measuring Braille Reading Speed with the MNREAD Test’, Visual Impairment Research 1(3): 131-45.

12.

Mansfield, J.S. , Legge, G.E. & Bane, M.C. ( 1996) ‘Psychophysics of Reading. XV. Font Effects in Normal and Low Vision’, Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 37: 1492-1501.

13.

Nation, K. & Snowling, M.J. ( 1998) ‘Individual Differences in Contextual Facilitation: Evidence from Dyslexia and Poor Reading Comprehension’, Child Development 69: 996-1011.

14.

Nolan, C.Y. & Kederis, A.J.C. ( 1969) Perceptual Factors in Braille Word Recognition . New York, NY: American Foundation for the Blind.

15.

Omar, R. , Knight, V.F. & Mohammed, Z. ( 2009) ‘Effectiveness of Low Vision Devices in a Special Education School’, Sains Malaysiana 38(5): 799-804.

16.

Stanovich, K.E. , West, R.F. & Freeman, D.J. ( 1981) ‘A Longitudinal Study of Sentence Context Effects in Second-grade Children: Tests of an Interactive-compensatory Model’ , Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 32: 185-91.

17.

Steinman, B.A. , Lejeune, B.J. & Kimbrough, B.T. ( 2006) ‘Developmental Stages of Reading Processes in Children Who Are Blind and Sighted’, Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 100(1): 36-46.

18.

Wetzel, R. & Knowlton, M. ( 2000) ‘A Comparison of Print and Braille Reading Rates on Three Reading Tasks’, Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness 94(3): 146-54.