Social Integration and Loneliness: A Comparative Study among Older Adults in the Netherlands and Tuscany,Italy

Abstract

On the average, older adults in Italy are lonelier than those in the Netherlands. The results of a study by Jylha & Jokela (1990) showed that loneliness was more prevalent in regions of Europe where living alone was rarest and where community bonds were strongest. This inverse macro-level association, an increasing proportion of lonely older people and a decreasing proportion of older people who live alone from northern to southern Europe, could not be explained by differences in individual social integration. The aim of the present study was to reinvestigate this association. The data were from surveys conducted in the Netherlands (N = 3750) and northwestern Tuscany, Italy (N = 1543). Fewer older adults lived alone in Tuscany than in the Netherlands, which indicates that the Dutch were less integrated. As regards their participation in social organizations and personal networks, the Tuscan older adults were less integrated. To a large extent, loneliness among the Dutch and Tuscans based on differences in social integration could be similarly explained, and regional loneliness differences could be attributed to individual situations and characteristics:

Keywords

aged cross-cultural differences loneliness social integration social networks

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beckman, L.J. (1981) `Effects of Social Interaction and Children's Relative Inputs on Older Women's Psychological Well-being', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 41: 1075-1086.

Berg, S. , Mellstrom, D. , Persson, G. & Svanborg, A. (1981) `Loneliness in the Swedish Aged', Journal of Gerontology 36: 342-349.

Bottai, M. (1995) The OLIVARR Survey. Department of Economic Statistics and Mathematics, University of Pisa, Italy.

Broese van Groenou, M.I. , van Tilburg, T.G. , de Leeuw, E.D. & Liefbroer, A.C. (1995) `Data Collection', in C.P.M. Knipscheer et al. (eds) Living Arrangements and Social Networks of Older Adults, pp. 185-197. Amsterdam: VU University Press.

Brown, G.W. & Harris, T.O. (1978) Social Origins of Depression. London: Tavistock.

Cantor, M.H. (1989) `Social Care: Family and Community Support Systems', in M.W. Riley & J.W. Riley (eds) The Quality of Aging: Strategies for Interventions, pp. 99-112. Sage.

de Jong Gierveld, J. & Dykstra, P.A. (1993) `Life Transitions and the Network of Personal Relationships: Theoretical and Methodological Issues', in D. Perlman & W.H. Jones (eds) Advances in Personal Relationships. Vol. 4: A Research Manual, pp. 195-227. London: Jessica Kingsley.

de Jong Gierveld, J. & Kamphuis, F.H. (1985) `The Development of a Rasch-type Loneliness Scale', Applied Psychological Measurement 9: 289-299.

de Jong Gierveld, J. , Kamphuis, F.H. & Dykstra, P.A. (1987) `Old and Lonely?', Comprehensive Gerontology 1: 13-17.

10.

Dykstra, P.A. (1993) `The Differential Availability of Relationships and the Provision and Effectiveness of Support to Older Adults', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 10: 355-370.

11.

Dykstra, P.A. (1995a) `Loneliness among the Never and Formerly Married: The Importance of Supportive Friendships and a Desire for Independence', Journal of Gerontology 50b.

12.

Dykstra, P.A. (1995b) `Network Composition', in C.P.M. Knipscheer , J. de Jong Gierveld , T.G. van Tilburg & P.A. Dykstra (eds) Living Arrangements and Social Networks of Older Adults, pp. 97-114. Amsterdam: VU University Press.

13.

Gove, W.R. & Hughes, M. (1980) `Reexamining the Ecological Fallacy: A Study in Which Aggregate Data Are Critical in Investigating the Pathological Effects of Living Alone', Social Forces 57: 1157-1177.

14.

Hollinger, F. & Haller, M. (1990) `Kinship and Social Networks in Modern Societies: A Crosscultural Comparison among Seven Nations', European Sociological Review 6: 103-124.

15.

Hox, J.J. & Kreft, I.G.G. (1994) `Multilevel Analysis Methods', Sociological Methods & Research 22: 283-299.

16.

Imamoglu, E.O. , Kuller, R. , Imamoglu, V. & Kuller, M. (1993) `The Social Psychological Worlds of Swedes and Turks in and around Retirement', Journal of Cross-cultural Psychology 24: 26-41.

17.

Johnson, D.P. & Mullins, L.C. (1987) `Growing Old and Lonely in Different Societies: Toward a Comparative Perspective', Journal of Cross-cultural Gerontology 2: 257-275.

18.

Jylha, M. & Jokela, J. (1990) `Individual Experiences as Cultural: A Cross-cultural Study on Loneliness among the Elderly', Ageing and Society 10: 295-315.

19.

Knipscheer, C.P.M. (1992) `Aging, Social Environment and Social Support', European Journal of Gerontology 1: 421-435.

20.

Larson, R. , Zuzanek, J. & Mannell, R. (1985) `Being Alone versus Being with People: Disengagement in the Daily Experience of Older Adults', Journal of Gerontology 40: 375-381.

21.

Mullins, L.C. , Johnson, D.P. & Andersson, L. (1987) `Loneliness of the Elderly: The Impact of Family and Friends', Journal of Social Behavior and Personality 2: 225-238.

22.

Peplau, L.A. (1985) `Loneliness Research: Basic Concepts and Findings', in I.G. Sarason & B.R. Sarason (eds) Social Support: Theory, Research and Applications, pp. 269-286. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Nijhoff.

23.

Peplau, L.A. , Bikson, T.K. , Rook, K.S. & Goodchilds, J.D. (1982) `Being Old and Living Alone', in L.A. Peplau & D. Perlman (eds) Loneliness: A Sourcebook of Current Theory, Research and Therapy, pp. 327-347. New York: Wiley.

24.

Perlman, D. & Peplau, L.A. (1981) `Towards a Social Psychology of Loneliness', in S.W. Duck & R. Gilmour (eds) Personal Relationships in Disorder, pp. 31-56. London: Academic.

25.

Rasbash, J. & Woodhouse, G. (1995) MLn Command Reference, Version 1.0. University of London, Institute of Education, Multilevels project.

26.

Rook, K.S. (1987) `Social Support versus Companionship: Effects of Life Stress, Loneliness, and Evaluations by Others', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 52: 1132-1147.

27.

Russell, D. , Peplau, L.A. & Cutrona, C.E. (1980) `The Revised UCLA Loneliness Scale', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 39: 471-480.

28.

Snijders, T.A.B. & Bosker, R.J. (1994) `Modeled Variance in Two-level Models', Sociological Methods and Research 22: 342-363.

29.

van Tilburg, T.G. (1995) `Delineation of the Social Network and Differences in Network Size', in C.P.M. Knipscheer , J. de Jong Gierveld , T.G. van Tilburg & P.A. Dykstra (eds) Living Arrangements and Social Networks of Older Adults, pp. 83-96. Amsterdam: VU University Press.

30.

van Tilburg, T.G. & de Leeuw, E.D. (1991) `Stability of Scale Quality under Different Data Collection Procedures: A Mode Comparison on the "De Jong-Gierveld Loneliness Scale"', International Journal of Public Opinion Research 3: 69-85.

31.

Walker, A. (1993) `Age and Attitudes: Main Results from a Eurobarometer Survey', Commission of the European Communities.