This study investigates the effects of live and non-live reporting on recall and
appreciation of political television news. A sample of 161 randomly selected adults
participated in an experiment testing the effects of format difference (a live
cross-talk between reporters vs a canned field report). Using an authentic
experimental news bulletin produced in cooperation with the national Dutch public
broadcaster, NOS, the findings did not support the hypothesis that the live
cross-talk format enhances recall or appreciation. In fact, the results showed that
the non-live field report format resulted in greater recall. These findings
challenge the common newsroom assumption about the attractiveness of live reporting
and have practical policy implications for both news practitioners and actors in the
political arena.
Brosius, Hans-Bernd
(1991)
`Format Effects on Comprehension of Television News'
, Journalism Quarterly68: 396-401.
2.
Brosius, Hans-Bernd
,
Wolfgang Donsbach
and
Matthias Birk
(1996)
`How do Text-Picture Relations Affect the Informational Effectiveness of
Television Newscasts?'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media40: 180-95.
3.
Burris, Larry L.
(1987)
'How Anchors, Reporters and Newsmakers Affect Recall and Evaluation of
Stories'
, Journalism Quarterly64: 514-19.
4.
Crigler, Ann
,
Marion Just
and
Russell W. Neuman
(1994)
`Interpreting Visual Versus Audio Messages in Television News'
, Journal of Communication44: 132-49.
5.
De Vreese, Claes H.
(2001)
` "Europe" in the News: A Cross-National Comparative Study of the News
Coverage of Key EU Events'
, European Union Politics2(3):
283-307.
6.
Drew, Dan G.
and
Thomas Grimes
(1987)
`Audio-Visual Redundancy and TV News Recall'
, Communication Research14: 452-61.
7.
Edwardson, Mickie
,
Donald Grooms
and
Susanne Proudlove
(1981)
`Television News Information Gain from Interesting Video vs. Talking
Heads'
, Journal of Broadcasting25: 15-24.
8.
Edwardson, Mickie
,
Kurt Kent
,
Erika Engstrom
and
Richard Hofmann
(1992)
`Audio Recall Immediately Following Video Change in Television News'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media36: 395-410.
9.
Findahl, Olle
and
Birgitta Höijer
(1976) Fragments of Reality: An Experiment with News and TV
Visuals. Stockholm: Swedish
Broadcasting Corporation, Audience and Program Research
Department .
10.
Findahl, Olle
and
Birgitta Höijer
(1985)
`Some Characteristics of News Memory and Comprehension'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media29: 379-96.
11.
Galtung, Johan
and
Marie H. Ruge
(1965)
`The Structure of Foreign News: The Presentation of the Congo, Cuban and
Cyprus Crises in Four Foreign Newspapers'
, Journal of Peace Research2: 64-91.
12.
Graber, Doris A.
(1988) Processing the News. How People Tame the Information
Tide (2nd edn). New York:
Longman.
13.
Graber, Doris A.
(1990)
`Seeing is Remembering: How Visuals Contribute to Learning from Television
News'
, Journal of Communication40: 134-55.
14.
Graber, Doris A.
(2001) Processing Politics: Learning from Television in the
Internet Age. Studies in Communication, Media and Public Opinion.
Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
15.
Gunter, Barrie
(1987) Poor Reception: Misunderstanding and Forgetting
Broadcast News. Hillsdale, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum.
16.
Heuvelman, Aad
,
Allerd Peeters
and
Chris Krüs
(1995) Presentation Format Features of The Journaal: Story
Structure and Role of Reporters. An Experiment, R 95-082.
Hilversum: NOS Audience Research
Department.
17.
Katz, Elihu
,
Hanna Adoni
and
Pnina Parness
(1977)
`Remembering the News: What the Picture Adds to Recall'
, Journalism Quarterly54: 231-9.
18.
Ksobiech, Kenneth
,
James Tiedge
and
Aaron Mark Bor
(1980)
`Visualization Mode, Perceived Immediacy and Audience Evaluation of TV
News'
, Journalism Quarterly57: 55-60.
19.
McQuail, Denis
(1992) Media Performance.
London:
Sage.
20.
Neuman, Russell W.
(1976)
`Patterns of Recall among Television News Viewers'
, Public Opinion Quarterly40: 115-23.
21.
Reese, Stephen D.
(1984)
`Visual-Verbal Redundancy Effects on Television News Learning'
, Journal of Broadcasting28: 79-87.
22.
Reeves, Byron
and
Seth Geiger
(1994) `Designing Experiments that Assess Psychological
Responses to Media Messages', pp. 165-80 in
Annie Lang
(ed.) Measuring Psychological Responses to Media.
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum.
23.
Robinson, John P.
and
Mark R. Levy
(1986) The Main Source. Learning from Television News.
Beverly Hills, CA:
Sage.
24.
Saris, Willem E.
(1997)
`The Public Opinion about the EU Can Easily Be Swayed in Different
Directions'
, Acta Politica: International Journal of Political Science32: 406-35.
25.
Semetko, Holli A.
,
Claes H. de Vreese
and
Jochen Peter
(2000)
`Europeanised Politics - Europeanised Media? European Integration and
Political Communication'
, West European Politics23(4):
121-41.
26.
Son, Jinok
,
Stephen D. Reese
and
William R. Davie
(1987)
`Effects of Visual-Verbal Redundancy and Recaps on Television News
Learning'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media31: 207-16.
27.
Tuggle, Chris A.
and
Susanne Huffman
(1999)
`Live News Reporting: Professional Judgement or Technological Pressure? A
National Survey of Television News Directors and Senior Reporters'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media43: 492-505.
28.
Tulving, Endel
(1974)
`Recall and Recognition on Semantically Encoded Words'
, Journal of Experimental Psychology102: 778-87.
29.
Tulving, Endel
and
Mark J. Watkins
(1975)
`Structure of Memory Traces'
, Psychological Review82: 261-75.
30.
Van der Molen, Juliette H.
and
Tom H.A. van der Voort
(2000)
`The Impact of Television, Print and Audio on Children's Recall of the
News'
, Human Communication Research26: 3-26.
31.
Woodall, W. Gill
,
Dennis K. Davis
and
Halul Sahin
(1983)
`From the Boob Tube to the Black Box: Television News Comprehension from an
Information Processing Approach'
, Journal of Broadcasting27: 1-23.
32.
Zillmann, Dolf
,
Rhonda Gibson
,
Virginia L. Ordman
and
Charles F. Aust
(1994)
`Effect of Upbeat Stories in Broadcast News'
, Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media38: 65-78.
