Is there any difference between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection during cardiac surgery? A meta-analysis of 5576 patients from 36 randomized trials
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online November, 2012
Is there any difference between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection during cardiac surgery? A meta-analysis of 5576 patients from 36 randomized trials
To compare the efficacy of blood versus crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection in patients undergoing cardiac surgery.
Methods:
MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL/CCTR, SciELO, LILACS, Google Scholar and reference lists of relevant articles were searched for clinical studies that reported in-hospital outcomes after blood or crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection during cardiac surgery procedures from 1966 to 2011. The principal summary measures were risk ratio (RR) for blood compared to crystalloid cardioplegia with 95% Confidence Interval (CI) and P values (considered statistically significant when <0.05). The RRs were combined across studies using the DerSimonian-Laird random effects model and fixed effects model using the Mantel-Haenszel model - both models were weighted. The meta-analysis was completed using the software Comprehensive Meta-Analysis version 2 (Biostat Inc., Englewood, New Jersey).
Results:
Thirty-six studies (randomized trials) were identified and included a total of 5576 patients (2834 for blood and 2742 for crystalloid). There was no significant difference between the blood and crystalloid groups in the risk for death (risk ratio [RR] 0.951, 95% CI 0.598 to 1.514, P=0.828, for both effect models) or myocardial infarction (RR 0.795, 95% CI 0.547 to 1.118, P=0.164, for both effect models) or low cardiac output syndrome (RR 0.765, 95% CI 0.580 to 1.142, P=0.094, for the fixed effect model; RR 0.690, 95% CI 0.480 to 1.042, P=0.072, for the random effect model). It was observed that there was no publication bias or heterogeneity of effects about any outcome.
Conclusion:
We found evidence that argues against any superiority in terms of hard outcomes between blood or crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection during cardiac surgery.
BarnerHB. Blood cardioplegia: a review and comparison with crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1991; 52: 1354–1367.
2.
GuruVOmuraJAlghamdiAAWeiselRFremesSE. Is blood superior to crystalloid cardioplegia?A meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Circulation2006; 114 (Suppl. I): I-331–338.
3.
JacobSKallikourdisASellkeFDunningJ. Is blood cardioplegia superior to crystalloid cardioplegia?Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg2008; 7: 491–499.
4.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJAltmanDG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta- analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med2009; 151: 264–269.
5.
HigginsJPThompsonSGDeeksJJAltmanDG. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ2003; 327: 557–560.
6.
DerSimonianRKackerR. Random-effects model for meta-analysis of clinical trials: an update. Contemp Clin Trials2007; 28: 105–114.
7.
LauJIoannidisJPSchmidCH. Quantitative synthesis in systematic reviews. Ann Intern Med1997; 127: 820–826.
8.
BeggCBMazumdarM. Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics1994; 50: 1088–1101.
9.
EggerMDavey SmithGSchneiderMMinderC. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ1997; 315: 629–634.
10.
PonceletAJSteenbergheMMoniotteS. Cardiac and neurological assessment of normothermia/warm blood cardioplegia vs hypothermia/cold crystalloid cardioplegia in pediatric cardiac surgery: insight from a prospective randomized trial. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2011; 40: 1384–1391.
11.
LucianiGBForniARigatelliG.
. Myocardial protection in heart transplantation using blood cardioplegia: 12-year outcome of a prospective randomized trial. J Heart Lung Transplant2011; 30: 29–36.
12.
OvrumETangenGTollofsrudSOysteseRRingdalMLIstadR. Cold blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia: a prospective randomised study of 345 aortic valve patients. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2010; 38: 745–749.
13.
BraathenBTonnessenT. Cold blood cardioplegia reduces the increase in cardiac enzyme levels compared with cold crystalloid cardioplegia in patients undergoing aortic valve replacement for isolated aortic stenosis. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2010; 139: 874–880.
14.
BovenWPGerritsenWBDriessenAH. Myocardial oxidative stress, and cell injury comparing three different techniques for coronary artery bypass grafting. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2008; 34: 969–975.
15.
KaracaPYurtsevenNEnçY. Effects of different cardioplegic solutions on nitric oxide release from coronary vasculature in diabetic patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery. Anadolu Kardiyol Derg2006; 6: 347–351.
16.
AmarkKBerggrenHBjörkK. Blood cardioplegia provides superior protection in infant cardiac surgery. Ann Thorac Surg2005; 80: 989–994.
17.
ModiPSuleimanMSReevesB. Myocardial metabolic changes during pediatric cardiac surgery: a randomized study of 3 cardioplegic techniques. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2004; 128: 67–75.
18.
OvrumETangenGTollofsrudSOysteseRRingdalMAIstadR. Cold blood cardioplegia versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia: a prospective randomized study of 1440 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2004; 128: 860–865.
19.
SirlakMEryilmazSYaziciogluL. Conduction disturbances in coronary artery bypass surgery. Int J Cardiol2003; 92: 43–48.
20.
TokmakogluHKandemirOCatavZYorganciogluCZorlutunaY. A comparison of crystalloid and blood induction cardioplegia in low-risk patients undergoing coronary artery byass grafting. Marmara Med J2002; 15: 39–43.
21.
BratRTosovskyJJanuskaJ. Comparison between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia in patients with left ventricular dysfunction undergoing coronary surgery. Acta Medica2000; 43: 107–110.
22.
GasiorZKrejcaMSzmagalaPBochenekA. Long term left ventricular systolic function assessment following CABG. A prospective, randomized study. Blood versus cristalloid cardioplegia. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino)2000; 41: 695–702.
23.
ElwatidyAMFadalahMABukhariEA. Antegrade crystalloid cardioplegia vs antegrade/retrograde cold and tepid blood cardioplegia in CABG. Ann Thorac Surg1999; 68: 447–453.
24.
IbrahimMFVennGEYoungCPChambersDJ. A clinical comparative study between crystalloid and blood-based St Thomas’ hospital cardioplegic solution. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg1999; 15: 75–83.
25.
JacquetLMNoirhommePHVan DyckMJ. Randomized trial of intermittent antegrade warm blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1999; 67: 471–477.
26.
YuanSM. A generalized consideration of myocardial preservation with cold crystalloid versus warm blood cardioplegia in heart valve replacement. Kaohsiung J Med Sci1998; 14: 266–273.
ChocronSAlwanKYanY. Warm reperfusion and myocardial protection. Ann Thorac Surg1998; 66: 2003–2007.
29.
YoungJNChoyIOSilvaNKObayashiDABarkanHE. Antegrade cold blood cardioplegia is not demonstrably advantageous over cold crystalloid cardioplegia in surgery for congenital heart disease. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1997; 114: 1002–1009.
30.
PichonHChocronSAlwanK. Crystalloid versus cold blood cardioplegia and cardiac troponin I release. Circulation1997; 96: 316–320.
31.
CaputoMDihmisWBirdiI. Cardiac troponin T and troponin I release during coronary artery surgery using cold crystalloid and cold blood cardioplegia. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg1997; 12: 254–260.
32.
JinXYGibsonDGPepperJR. Early changes in regional and global left ventricular function after aortic valve replacement. Comparison of crystalloid, cold blood, and warm blood cardioplegias. Circulation1995; 92 (9 Suppl): II155–II162.
WandschneiderWWinterSThalmannMHowanietzNDeutschM. Crystalloid versus blood cardioplegia in coronary by-pass surgery. A prospective, randomized, controlled study in 100 consecutive adults. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino)1994; 35 (6 Suppl 1): 85–89.
35.
MartinTDCraverJMGottJP. Prospective, randomized trial of retrograde warm blood cardioplegia: myocardial benefit and neurologic threat. Ann Thorac Surg1994; 57: 298–302; discussion 304.
36.
LajosTZEspersenCCLajosPSFiedlerRCBergslandJJoyceLT. Comparison of cold versus warm cardioplegia. Crystalloid antegrade or retrograde blood?Circulation1993; 88(5 Pt 2): II344–II349.
37.
BiagioliBGiomarelliPGnudiG. Myocardial function in early hours after coronary artery bypass grafting: comparison of two cardioplegic methods. Ann Thorac Surg1993; 56: 1315–1323.
38.
RinneTPehkonenEKaukinenSTarkkaM. Comparison of cardioprotection with crystalloid and blood cardioplegia in CABG patients. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth1993; 7: 679–683.
39.
BeyersdorfFKrauseESaraiK. Clinical evaluation of hypothermic ventricular fibrillation, multi-dose blood cardioplegia, and single-dose Bretschneider cardioplegia in coronary surgery. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1990; 38: 20–29.
40.
MullenJCFremesSEWeiselRD. Right ventricular function: a comparison between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg1987; 43: 17–24.
41.
ChristakisGTFremesSEWeiselRD. Reducing the risk of urgent revascularization for unstable angina: a randomized clinical trial. J Vasc Surg1986; 3: 764–772.
42.
IversonLIYoungJNEnnixCL. Myocardial protection: a comparison of cold blood and cold crystalloid cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1984; 87: 509–516.
43.
FremesSEChristakisGTWeiselRD. A clinical trial of blood and crystalloid cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1984; 88(5 Pt 1): 726–741.
44.
SinghAKFarrugiaRTeplitzCKarlsonE. Electrolyte versus blood cardioplegia: randomized clinical and myocardial ultrastructural study. Ann Thorac Surg1982; 33: 218–227.
45.
ShapiraNKirshMJochimKBehrendtDM. Comparison of the effect of blood cardioplegia to crystalloid cardioplegia on myocardial contractility in man. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1980; 80: 647–655.
