A Methodology for the Evaluation of IT for Strategic Implementation

Abstract

The integration of business strategic planning and IT has been raised as one of the most important issues facing management in the 1990s. At the same time, there have been spectacular failures when business ventures have sought to exploit information technology. So how does business management go about applying information technology in order to maximize the possibility of gaining success, while minimizing the possibility of failure? Most literature concerned with information technology and evaluation focuses on the evaluation of benefits from the use of a technology. The limited amount of literature which considers the ‘front end’ of the process of selection, as well as implementation of information technology, is more concerned with identifying the business problem areas, the actions of competitors or how to set priorities between projects, than looking at the potential utility of a new or emergent technology. This paper presents a practical methodology which can be used by management to evaluate an information technology and to determine its apparent suitability for their business at this particular time. Its strength lies in the capability of IS management and line managers to quickly and cost-effectively identify the major opportunities for the application of technology to business problems.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Benjamin

R.I.

, and Scott Morton

M.S.

(1988). Information technology, integration, and organisational change. Interfaces 18(3), 86–98.

Buss

M.D.J.

(1983). How to rank computer projects. Harvard Business Review January-February, 118–25.

Clemons

E.K.

, and Weber

B.W.

(1990). Strategic information technology investments: guidelines for decision making. Journal of Management Information Systems 7(2), 9–28.

Davis

G.B.

, and Olsen

M.H.

(1985). Management Information Systems; Conceptual Foundations Structure and Development, 2nd edn (McGraw-Hill).

Dictionary of Computing 3rd ed (1990). (Oxford University Press, Oxford).

Earl

M.J.

(1989). Management Strategies for Information Technology (Prentice-Hall International (UK) Ltd, Hemel Hempstead).

Earl

M.J.

(1992). Putting IT in its place: a polemic for the nineties. Journal of Information Technology 7, 100–8.

Earl

M.J.

(1993). Experiences in strategic information systems planning. MIS Quarterly March, 1–24.

Feeny

D.F.

, and Ives

(1990). In search of sustainability: reaping long-term advantage from investments in information technology. Journal of Management Information Systems 7(1), 27–46.

10.

Galliers

R.D.

(1991). Strategic information systems planning: myths, reality and guidelines for successful implementation. European Journal of Information Systems 1(1), 55–64.

11.

Galliers

R.D.

(1992). Information technology: management's boon or bane? Journal of Strategic Information Systems 2, 50–6.

12.

Galliers

R.D.

, and Sutherland

A.R.

(1991). Information systems management and strategy formulation: the ‘stages of growth’ model revisited. Journal of Information Systems 1, 89–114.

13.

Huff

S.L.

, and Munro

M.C.

(1985). Information technology assessment and adoption: a field study. MIS Quarterly December, 32740.

14.

IBM (1981). Business Systems Planning – Information Systems Planning Guide. Application Manual. IBM.

15.

Keen

P.G.W.

(1988). Competing in Time (Ballinger Publishing Company).

16.

Ives

, and Learmonth

G.P.

(1984). The information system as a competitive weapon. Communications of the ACM 27(12), 1193–201.

17.

Lederer

A.L.

, and Sethi

(1988). The implementation of strategic information systems planning methodologies. MIS Quarterly September, 445–61.

18.

MacDonald

K.H.

(1991a). The value process model, in The Corporation of the 1990's: Information Technology and Organisational Transformation, Scott Morton

M.S.

(ed.) (Oxford University Press, New York) pp. 299–309.

19.

MacDonald

K.H.

(1991b). The strategic alignment process, in The Corporation of the 1990's: Information Technology and Organisational Transformation, Scott Morton

M.S.

(ed.) (Oxford University Press, New York) pp. 310–22.

20.

Martin

(1989). Information Engineering – Planning and Analysis (Prentice-Hall International Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ).

21.

Niederman

, Brancheau

J.C.

, and Wetherbe

J.C.

(1991). Information systems management issues for the 1990s. MIS Quarterly December, 474–500.

22.

Parker

M.M.

, Benson

R.J.

, and Trainor

H.E.

(1988). Information Economics: Linking Business Performance to Information Technology (Prentice-Hall International Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ).

23.

Porter

M.E.

, and Millar

V.E.

(1985). How information gives you competitive advantage. Harvard Business Review July-August, 149–60.

24.

Premkumar

, and King

W.R.

(1991). Assessing strategic information systems planning. Long Range Planning 24(5), 41–58.

25.

Rockart

J.F.

(1979). Chief executives define their own data needs. Harvard Business Review March–April, 215–29.

26.

Rockart

J.F.

, and Scott Morton

M.S.

(1984). Implications of changes in information technology for corporate strategy. Interfaces 14(1) 84–95.

27.

Sabherwal

, and King

W.R.

(1991). Towards a theory of strategic use of information resources. Information & Management 20, 191–212.

28.

Scott Morton

M.S.

(1991). The Corporation of the 1990's: Information Technology and Organisational Transformation (Oxford University Press, New York).

29.

Singh

S.K.

(1993). Using information technology effectively: organizational preparedness models. Information & Management 24, 133–46.

30.

Tomlin

(1991). Developing a management culture in which information technology will flourish: how the UK can benefit. Journal of Information Technology 6, 45–55.

31.

Watson

R.T.

, and Brancheau

J.C.

(1991). Key issues in information systems management: an international perspective. Information & Management 20, 213–23.