Shane (2009) has suggested that encouraging more people to become entrepreneurs is bad public policy because it is existing firms that bring jobs and productivity growth and not new firms. To test this view this article shifts the perspective onto existing firms and away from start-up by examining firm survivability in the regions and countries of the UK and its relationship with employment and productivity growth. The article provides some evidence to support Shane’s (2009) view that it is existing firms that are important for economic development.
AthertonA (2006) Should government be stimulating start-ups? An assessment of the scope for public intervention in new venture formation. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24(1): 21–36.
2.
Bureau of Labor Statistics (2008) Overview of Bureau of Labor Statistics Data, Washington, DC: US Bureau of Labor Statistics.
3.
Cambridge Econometrics (2012) Homepage. Available at: www.camecon.com (accessed 27 August 2012).
DavisSJHaltiwangerJ (1992) Gross job creation, gross job destruction, and employment reallocation. Quarterly Journal of Economics107(3): 819–862.
6.
DerbyshireJHaywoodG (2009) Uncovering creative destruction brought about by new firm formation: A new method and data source. Local Economy24(4): 310–322.
7.
DerbyshireJHaywoodG (2010) Labour, the enterprise gap and the Red Queen. Local Economy25(5/6): 446–461.
8.
DTI (Department for Trade and Industry) (2003) A Government Action Plan for Small Businesses, London: The Stationery Office.
9.
HaltiwangerJLaneJSpeltzerJ (1999) Productivity differences across employers: The roles of employer size, age, and human capital. American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings89(2): 94–98.
10.
HMTreasury (2006) Meeting the Productivity Challenge, London: HM Treasury.
11.
HugginsRWilliamsN (2009) Enterprise and public policy: A review of Labour Government intervention in the United Kingdom. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy27(1): 19–41.
12.
JohnsonPS (2005) Targeting firm births and economic regeneration in a lagging region. Small Business Economics24(5): 451–464.
13.
ShaneS (2009) Why encouraging more people to become entrepreneurs is bad public policy. Small Business Economics33(2): 141–149.
14.
StoreyD (2011) Optimism and chance: The elephants in the entrepreneurship room. International Small Business Journal29(4): 303–321.
