Play-based interventions improve physical function for people with adult-acquired brain injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials

Abstract

Objective:

To undertake a systematic review and meta-analysis of the effectiveness of play-based interventions compared to traditional therapy in rehabilitation of adults with adult-acquired brain injury.

Data sources:

The search was performed using Medline; Cinahl Plus; Health Source (Nursing/Academic Edition); Psychology and behavioural sciences collection; Biomedical reference collection (basic).

Review methods:

Studies included were randomised controlled trials that investigated the effect of play-based interventions on physical function of adults with adult acquired brain injury. Two independent reviewers identified eligible studies and assessed methodological quality using a modified Downs and Black. Meta-analysis compared standardised differences in means, to determine effect sizes for grouped functional outcome measures. The GRADE scoring system was used to determine the level of clinical evidence.

Results:

Thirty studies met the inclusion criteria, 13 were considered high quality and 17 moderate quality. Studies predominantly involved post-stroke participants, with only three studies including participants with traumatic brain injury. When compared to traditional therapy, dose-matched studies of play-based interventions showed a significant effect on independence (Effect size (ES) = 0.6) and physical performance (ES = 0.43), as measured using the Fugl –Meyer. For non-dose matched studies, play-based interventions showed a significant improvement for balance (ES = 0.76) compared with traditional therapy. In all studies that measured participant enjoyment, play-based therapy was rated as more enjoyable than traditional therapy.

Conclusion:

Play-based interventions for people with adult acquired brain injury are more effective in improving balance and independence, which may be due to them being more enjoyable than traditional therapy.

Keywords

Brain injury rehabilitation interventions systematic review

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kleim

Jones

. Principles of experience-dependent neural plasticity: implications for rehabilitation after brain damage. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 2008;51(1):S225–S39.

Nudo

Wise

SiFuentes

Milliken

. Neural substrates for the effects of rehabilitative training on motor recovery after ischemic infarct. Science. 1996;272(5269):1791–1794.

Carey

Kimberley

Lewis

Auerbach

Dorsey

Rundquist

. Analysis of fMRI and finger tracking training in subjects with chronic stroke. Brain. 2002;125(4):773–788.

Bryanton

Bosse

Brien

Mclean

McCormick

Sveistrup

. Feasibility, motivation, and selective motor control: virtual reality compared to conventional home exercise in children with cerebral palsy. CyberPsychology & Behavior. 2006;9(2):123–128.

Lewis

Rosie

. Virtual reality games for movement rehabilitation in neurological conditions: how do we meet the needs and expectations of the users? Disability and Rehabilitation. 2012;34(22):1880–1886.

Burke

McNeill

Charles

Morrow

Crosbie

McDonough

. Optimising engagement for stroke rehabilitation using serious games. The Visual Computer. 2009;25(12):1085–1099.

Lohse

Hilderman

CGE

Cheung

Tatla

Van Der Loos

HFM

. Virtual reality therapy for adults post-stroke: A systematic review and meta-analysis exploring virtual environments and commercial games in therapy. PLoS ONE. 2014;9(3).

Laver

George

Thomas

Deutsch

Crotty

. Virtual reality for stroke rehabilitation. The Cochrane Database Of Systematic Reviews. 2015;2:CD008349.

Singh

DKA

Mohd Nordin

Abd Aziz

Lim

Soh

. Effects of substituting a portion of standard physiotherapy time with virtual reality games among community-dwelling stroke survivors. BMC Neurology. 2013;13:199–205.

10.

Borenstein

Hedges

Higgins

Rothstein

. Introduction to Meta-Analysis. Chichester: Wiley, 2009.

11.

Downs

Black

. The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 1998;52(6):377–384.

12.

Mani

Milosavljevic

Sullivan

. The effect of occupational whole-body vibration on standing balance: A systematic review. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics. 2010 Nov;40(6):698–709.

13.

Hopp

. Risk of bias reporting in Cochrane systematic reviews. International Journal Of Nursing Practice. 2014. PubMed PMID: 24621329.

14.

Hedges

. Distribution theory for Glass’s estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of educational and behavioural statistics. 1981;6(2):107–128.

15.

Cohen

. A power primer. Psychological Bulletin. 1992;112(1):155–159.

16.

Higgins

JPT

Thompson

Deeks

Altman

. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ (Clinical Research Ed). 2003;327(7414):557–560.

17.

Deeks

Higgins

Altman

. Analysing Data and Undertaking Meta-Analyses. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions: Cochrane Book Series 2008. pp. 243–296.

18.

BMJ clinical evidence. What is Grade? Available at: http://clinicalevidence.bmj.com/x/set/static/ebm/learn/665072.html (accessed 4 November 2015).

19.

Meader

King

Llewellyn

Norman

Brown

Rodgers

. A checklist designed to aid consistency and reproducibility of GRADE assessments: development and pilot validation. Systematic Reviews. 2014;3:82–90.

20.

Nelson

Konosky

Fleharty

Webb

Newer

Hazboun

. The effects of an occupationally embedded exercise on bilaterally assisted supination in persons with hemiplegia. The American journal of occupational therapy: official publication of the American Occupational Therapy Association. 1996 Sep;50(8):639–646.

21.

Popović

Kostić

Rodić

Konstantinović

. Feedback-mediated upper extremities exercise: Increasing patient motivation in poststroke rehabilitation. BioMed Research International. 2014;2014.

22.

Rand

Givon

Weingarden

Nota

Zeilig

. Eliciting upper extremity purposeful movements using video games: A comparison with traditional therapy for stroke rehabilitation. Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair. 2014;28(8):733–739.

23.

Bower

Clark

McGinley

Martin

Miller

. Clinical feasibility of the Nintendo Wii™ for balance training post-stroke: a phase II randomized controlled trial in an inpatient setting. Clinical Rehabilitation. 2014;28(9):912–923.

24.

Logan

Goldman

Zola

Mackey

. A study of interventions and related outcomes in a randomized controlled trial of occupational therapy and leisure therapy for community stroke patients. Clinical Rehabilitation. 2003;17(3):249–55.

25.

Friedman

Chan

Reinkensmeyer

Beroukhim

Zambrano

Bachman

. Retraining and assessing hand movement after stroke using the MusicGlove: Comparison with conventional hand therapy and isometric grip training. Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation. 2014;11(1):76.

26.

Broeren

Claesson

Goude

Rydmark

Sunnerhagen

. Virtual rehabilitation in an activity centre for community-dwelling persons with stroke. The possibilities of 3-dimensional computer games. Cerebrovascular diseases. 2008;26(3):289–296.

27.

Cho

Lee

Song

. Virtual-reality balance training with a video-game system improves dynamic balance in chronic stroke patients. Tohoku journal of experimental medicine. 2012;228(1):69–74.

28.

Crosbie

Lennon

McGoldrick

McNeill

McDonough

. Virtual reality in the rehabilitation of the arm after hemiplegic stroke: a randomized controlled pilot study. Clinical Rehabilitation. 2012;26(9):798–806.

29.

da Silva Cameirao

Bermudez

IBS

Duarte

Verschure

. Virtual reality based rehabilitation speeds up functional recovery of the upper extremities after stroke: a randomized controlled pilot study in the acute phase of stroke using the rehabilitation gaming system. Restorative neurology and neuroscience. 2011 Jan;29(5):287–298.

30.

Fan

Chen

Hou

Sun

Chen

. Improved intrinsic motivation and muscle activation patterns in reaching task using virtual reality training for stroke rehabilitation: A pilot randomized control trial. Journal of Medical and Biological Engineering. 2014;34(4):399–407.

31.

Fritz

Peters

Merlo

Donley

. Active video-gaming effects on balance and mobility in individuals with chronic stroke: A randomized controlled trial. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation. 2013;20(3):218–25.

32.

Housman

Scott

Reinkensmeyer

. A randomized controlled trial of gravity-supported, computer-enhanced arm exercise for individuals with severe hemiparesis. Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair. 2009;23(5):505–514.

33.

Hung

Chou

Hsieh

Chen

. Randomized comparison trial of balance training by using exergaming and conventional weight-shift therapy in patients with chronic stroke. Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation. 2014;95(9):1629–1637.

34.

Jang

You

Hallett

Cho

Park

C-M

Cho

S-H

. Cortical reorganization and associated functional motor recovery after virtual reality in patients with chronic stroke: an experimenter-blind preliminary study. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 2005;86(11):2218–2223.

35.

Jung

. Effects of virtual reality-based rehabilitation on upper extremity function and visual perception in stroke patients: A randomized control trial. Journal of Physical Therapy Science. 2012 Dec;24(11):1205–1208.

36.

Kim

Kang

Park

Jung

. Clinical feasibility of interactive commercial Nintendo gaming for chronic stroke rehabilitation. Journal of Physical Therapy Science. 2012;24:901–903.

37.

Kim

. Effects of an Enjoyable Nurse-Led Intervention to Promote Movement in Poststroke Inpatients. Clinical Nursing Research. 2012;21(4):390–405.

38.

Kim

Jang

Kim

Jung

You

. Use of virtual reality to enhance balance and ambulation in chronic stroke: a double-blind, randomized controlled study. American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation. 2009;88(9):693–701.

39.

Kwon

J-S

Park

M-J

Yoon

I-J

Park

S-H

. Effects of virtual reality on upper extremity function and activities of daily living performance in acute stroke: a double-blind randomized clinical trial. NeuroRehabilitation. 2012;31(4):379–385.

40.

Lee

. Effects of training using video games on the muscle strength, muscle tone, and activities of daily living of chronic stroke patients. Journal of Physical Therapy Science. 2013 May;25(5):595–597.

41.

McEwen

Taillon-Hobson

Bilodeau

Sveistrup

Finestone

. Virtual reality exercise improves mobility after stroke: An inpatient randomized controlled trial. Stroke. 2014;45(6):1853–1855.

42.

Mirelman

Bonato

Deutsch

. Effects of training with a robot-virtual reality system compared with a robot alone on the gait of individuals after stroke. Stroke. 2009 Jan;40(1):169–174.

43.

Morone

Tramontano

Iosa

Shofany

Iemma

Musicco

. The efficacy of balance training with video game-based therapy in subacute stroke patients: A randomized controlled trial. BioMed Research International. 2014;2014:1–6.

44.

Prange

Kottink

AIR

Buurke

Eckhardt

MMEM

Van Keulen-Rouweler

Ribbers

. The effect of Arm Support combined with rehabilitation games on upper-extremity function in subacute stroke: A randomized controlled trial. Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair. 2015;29(2):174–182.

45.

Rajaratnam

KaiEn

JiaLin

SweeSin

FenRu

Enting

. Does the Inclusion of Virtual Reality Games within Conventional Rehabilitation Enhance Balance Retraining after a Recent Episode of Stroke? Rehabilitation Research & Practice. 2013:1–6.

46.

Sin

Lee

. Additional virtual reality training using Xbox kinect in stroke survivors with hemiplegia. American Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 2013;92(10):871–880.

47.

Singh

. Effect of play therapy on functional reach in stroke cases. Indian Journal of Physiotherapy & Occupational Therapy. 2011;5(4):181–184.

48.

Yavuzer

Senel

Atay

Stam

. “Playstation eyetoy games” improve upper extremity-related motor functioning in subacute stroke: A randomized controlled clinical trial. European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine. 2008;44(3):237–244.

49.

Yin

Sien

Ying

Chung

SF-CM

Tan May Leng

. Virtual reality for upper extremity rehabilitation in early stroke: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Clinical Rehabilitation. 2014;28(11):1107–1114.

50.

You

Jang

Kim

Y-H

Hallett

Ahn

Kwon

Y-H

. Virtual reality-induced cortical reorganization and associated locomotor recovery in chronic stroke: an experimenter-blind randomized study. Stroke: A Journal Of Cerebral Circulation. 2005;36(6):1166–1171.

51.

Gil-Gómez

J-A

Lloréns

Alcañiz

Colomer

. Effectiveness of a Wii balance board-based system (eBaViR) for balance rehabilitation: a pilot randomized clinical trial in patients with acquired brain injury. Journal of NeuroEngineering & Rehabilitation (JNER). 2011;8:30.

52.

Cox

Davis

Singh

Barbour

Don Nidiffer

Trudel

. Driving rehabilitation for military personnel recovering from traumatic brain injury using virtual reality driving simulation: A feasibility study. Military medicine. 2010;175(6):411–416.

53.

Cuthbert

Staniszewski

Hays

Gerber

Natale

O’Dell

. Virtual reality-based therapy for the treatment of balance deficits in patients receiving inpatient rehabilitation for traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury. 2014;28(2):181–188.

54.

Cox

Davis

Singh

Barbour

Nidiffer

Trudel

. Driving rehabilitation for military personnel recovering from traumatic brain injury using virtual reality driving simulation: A feasibility study. Military Medicine. 2010;175(6):411–416.

55.

Cho

Jung

56.

You

Jang

Kim

Y-H

Hallett

Ahn

Kwon

Y-H

. Virtual reality–induced cortical reorganization and associated locomotor recovery in chronic stroke an experimenter-blind randomized study. Stroke. 2005;36(6):1166–1171.

57.

Gowland

Stratford

Ward

Moreland

Torresin

Van Hullenaar

. Measuring physical impairment and disability with the Chedoke-McMaster Stroke Assessment. Stroke: A Journal Of Cerebral Circulation. 1993;24(1):58–63.

58.

Caron

Wightman

. “To learn, you must pay attention.” Molecular insights into teachers’ wisdom. Proceedings Of The National Academy Of Sciences Of The United States Of America. 2009;106(18):7267–7268.

59.

Vearrier

Langan

Shumway-Cook

Woollacott

. An intensive massed practice approach to retraining balance post-stroke. Gait & Posture. 2005;22(2):154–163.

60.

Jurkiewicz

Marzolini

. Adherence to a home-based exercise program for individuals after stroke. Topics In Stroke Rehabilitation. 2011;18(3):277–284.

61.

Wiles

Demain

Robison

Kileff

Ellis-Hill

McPherson

. Exercise on prescription schemes for stroke patients post-discharge from physiotherapy. Disability And Rehabilitation. 2008;30(26):1966–1975.

62.

Stroke Foundation of New Zealand and New Zealand Guidelines Group. Clinical Guidelines for Stroke Management. Wellington, New Zealand: Stroke Foundation of New Zealand, 2010.

63.

Danzl

Etter

Andreatta

Kitzman

. Facilitating neurorehabilitation through principles of engagement. Journal Of Allied Health. 2012;41(1):35–41.

64.

Poltawski

Boddy

Forster

Goodwin

Pavey

Dean

. Motivators for uptake and maintenance of exercise: perceptions of long-term stroke survivors and implications for design of exercise programmes. Disability And Rehabilitation. 2015;37(9):795–801.

65.

Lewis

Woods

Rosie

McPherson

. Virtual reality games for rehabilitation of people with stroke: Perspectives from the users. Disability and Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology. 2011;6(5):453–463.

66.

Umeda

Marino

Lee

Hilliard

. The association between exercise enjoyment and physical activity in women with fibromyalgia. International Journal Of Sports Medicine. 2014;35(12):1044–1050.

67.

Shaughnessy

Resnick

Macko

. Testing a model of post-stroke exercise behavior. Rehabilitation Nursing: The Official Journal Of The Association Of Rehabilitation Nurses. 2006;31(1):15–21.

68.

Mohd Nordin

Aziz

NAA

Abdul Aziz

Ajit Singh

Omar Othman

Sulong

. Exploring views on long term rehabilitation for people with stroke in a developing country: findings from focus group discussions. BMC Health Services Research. 2014;14:118.

69.

Puckree

Naidoo

. Balance and stability-focused exercise program improves stability and balance in patients after acute stroke in a resource-poor setting. PM & R: The Journal Of Injury, Function, And Rehabilitation. 2014;6(12):1081–1087.

70.

Turner

Bird

Higgins

JPT

. The impact of study size on meta-analyses: examination of underpowered studies in Cochrane reviews. Plos One. 2013;8(3):e59202–e.