Background: A literature review of educational interventions in palliative care (PC) for primary care physicians (PCP) was performed, to evaluate its impact in changing professional practice.
Methods: Studies undertaking any educational intervention in PC by PCP, published between 1966 and February 2005, identified through Medline, EMBASE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews and Clinical Trials, Educational Resources Information Centre, Research and Development Resource Base in Continuing Medical Education, Spanish Medical Index, using a combined text word and MESH heading search strategy.
Results: Eighteen articles were included with 1653 physicians. Educative methods were: role model training, small group discussions, and distribution of guidelines. Quality of the studies was low. Opioids prescription improved in two studies. Discrepancies were shown between the perception of PCP in symptom management, determined through questionnaires, and the data concerning opioids prescription. Knowledge improved in all studies. Some benefit of multifaceted approach was stated. Carers were satisfied, in general, with the PCP care, but dissatisfied with patients' pain control.
Conclusion: PC education for PCP is poorly studied. Adequate research designs are necessary in future studies with objective outcomes and patient opinion.
World Health Organization . Palliative care: the solid facts. WHO, 2004.
2.
Recommendation Rec (2003) 24 of the Committee of Ministers to member states on the organization of palliative care . Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 12 November 2003, at the 860th meeting of the Ministers' Deputies, Council of Europe, 2003.
3.
Gore JM , Brophy CJ , Greenstone MA.How well do we care for patients with end stage chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)? A comparison of palliative care and quality of life in COPD and lung cancer . Thorax2000; 55: 1000-1006 .
4.
Hanratty B , Hibbert D , Mair F , et al. Doctors' perceptions of palliative care for heart failure: focus group study . BMJ2002; 325: 581-585 .
5.
Murray SA , Kendall M , Boyd K , Sheikh A.Illness trajectories and palliative care . BMJ2005; 330: 1007-1011 .
6.
Barclay S , Wyatt P , Shore S , Finlay LL , Grande G , Todd Ch.Caring for the dying: how well prepared are the general practitioners? A questionnaire study in Wales . Palliat Med2003; 17: 27-39 .
7.
Salinas AM , Asensio AF , Armas J , Benítez del Rosario MA . Palliative care in primary care: professionals' opinion . Aten Primaria1999; 23: 187-191 .
8.
Brown JB , Sangster M , Swift J.Factors influencing palliative care. Qualitative study of family physician practices . Can Fam Physician1998; 44: 1028-1034 .
9.
Bruera E , Neumann CM , Gagnon B , et al. Edmonton Regional Palliative Care Programme: impact on patterns of terminal cancer care . CMAJ1999; 161: 290-293 .
10.
Jones W , Avant R , Davis N , Saultz J , Lyons P.Task Force Report 3. Report of the Task Force on continuous personal, professional, and practice development in family medicine . Ann Fam Med2004; 2: 565-574 .
11.
Lloyd-Williams M , Carter YH.General practice vocational training in the UK: what teaching is given in palliative care?Palliat Med2003; 17: 616-620 .
12.
Mitchell GK.How well do general practitioners deliver palliative care? A systematic review . Palliat Med2002; 16: 457-464 .
13.
Davis DA , Thomson MA , Oxman AD , Haynes B.Changing physician performance. A systematic review of the effect of continuing medical education strategies . JAMA1995; 274: 700-705 .
14.
Lanier D , Roland M , Burstin H , Knottnerus J.Doctor performance and public accountability . Lancet2003; 362: 1404-1408 .
15.
Davis D , Thomson MA , Freemantle N , Wolf FM , Mazmanian P , Taylor-Vaisey A.Impact of formal continuing medical education. Do conferences, workshops, rounds, and other traditional continuing education activities change physician behavior or health care outcomes?JAMA1999; 282: 867-874 .
16.
Grimshaw JM , Shirran L , Thomas R , et al. Changing provider behavior: an overview of systematic reviews of interventions . Med Care2001; 39: II2-II45 .
17.
Vanselow NA , Donaldson MS , Yordy KD.From the Institute of Medicine. A new definition of primary care . JAMA1995; 273: 192-192 .
18.
Moher D , Schulz F , Altman G ; for the Consort Group . The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials . Ann Intern Med2001; 134: 657-662 .
19.
Allard P , Maunsell E , Labbe J , Dorval M.Educational interventions to improve cancer pain control: a systematic review . J Palliat Med2001; 4: 191-203 .
20.
Weissman DE , Dahl JL , Beasley JW.The Cancer Pain Role Model Programme of the Wisconsin Cancer Pain Initiative . J Pain Symptom Manage1993; 8: 29-35 .
21.
Weissman DE , Dahl JL.Update on the cancer pain role model education programme . J Pain Symptom Manage1995; 10: 292-297 .
22.
Janjan NA , Martin CG , Payne R , Dahl JL , Weissman DE , Hill CS.Teaching cancer pain management: durability of educational effects of a role model programme . Cancer1996; 77: 996-1001 .
23.
Hines C , Bingham J , Muirden N , Beavis M.Cancer pain management. Improving knowledge and patient care . Aust Fam Phys1998; 27: S66-S69 .
24.
Elliot TE , Murray DM , Oken MM , et al. Improving cancer pain management in communities: main results from a randomized controlled trial . J Pain Symptom Manage1997; 13: 191-203 .
25.
Clark D , Ingleton C , Hughes P , Yap T , Noble B.Evaluation of a scheme to enhance palliative cancer care in rural Wales . Support Care Cancer2004; 12: 683-691 .
26.
Ingleton C , Morgan J , Hughes P , Noble B , Evans A , Clark D.Carer satisfaction with end-of-life care in Powys, Wales: a cross-sectional survey . Health Soc Care Commun2004; 12: 43-52 .
27.
Ingleton C , Hughes P , Noble B , Gray M , Clark D.An evaluation of a Macmillan GP clinical facilitator project: the post-holders' perspective . Primary Health Care Res Dev2003; 4: 177-186 .
28.
Noble B , Hughes P , Ingleton C , Berg J , Clark D.Impact of the Powys Macmillan GP clinical facilitator project: views of health-care professionals . Int J Palliat Nurs2003; 9: 528-533 .
29.
Schuit W , Bender W , Meijler J , Otter R , Meyboom-Dejong B , Sleijfer T.Learning effects of a workshop in palliative cancer care for general practitioners . J Cancer Educ1999; 14: 18-22 .
30.
Schuit W , Otter R , Stewart R , Sleijfer T , Meijler J , Meyboom-Dejong B.The effects of a postgraduate course on opioid-prescribing patterns of general practitioners . J Cancer Educ2000; 15: 214-217 .
31.
Boakes J , Gardner D , Yuen K , Doyle S.General practitioner training in palliative care: an experiential approach . J Palliat Care2000; 16: 11-19 .
32.
Hall P , Hupe D , Scott J.Palliative care education for community-based family physicians: the development of a programme, the evaluation, and its consequences . J Palliat Care1998; 14: 69-74 .
33.
Hinkka H , Kosunen E , Metsanoja R , Lammi U , Kellokumpu-Lehtinen P.General practitioners' attitudes and ethical decisions in end-of-life care after a year of interactive Internet-based training . J Cancer Educ2002; 17: 12-18 .
34.
Keogh K , Jeffrey D , Flanagan S.The Palliative Care Education Group for Gloucestershire (PEGG): an integrated model of multidisciplinary education in palliative care . Eur J Cancer Care1999; 8: 44-47 .
35.
Kristjanson L , Dusgeon D , Nelson F , Henteleff P , Balneaves L.Evaluation of an interdisciplinary training programme in palliative care: addressing the needs of rural and northern communities . J Palliat Care1997; 13: 5-12 .
36.
Eastaugh A , Higginson I , Webb D.Palliative care communication workshops for general practitioners and district nurses . Educ Gen Pract1998; 9: 331-336 .
37.
Macleod R , Nash U , Charny M.Evaluating palliative care education . Eur J Cancer Care1994; 3: 163-168 .
38.
Mitchell G.Assessment of GP management of symptoms of dying patients in an Australian community hospice by chart audit . Fam Pract1998; 15: 420-425 .
39.
Oxenham D , Duncan R , Fischbacher M.Cancer pain management in Lanarkshire: a community-based audit . Palliat Med2005; 17: 708-713 .
40.
Nash A , Hoy A.Terminal care in the community-an evaluation of residential workshops for general practitioner/district nurse teams . Palliat Med1993; 7: 5-17 .
41.
Shipman C , Addington-Hall J , Thompson M , et al. Building bridges in palliative care: evaluating a GP Facilitator programme . Palliat Med2003; 17: 621-627 .
42.
Higginson I.Palliative care services in the community: what do family doctors want?J Palliat Care1999; 15: 21-25 .
43.
Hanson LC , Tulsky JA , Danis M.Can clinical interventions change care at the end of life?Ann Intern Med1997; 126: 381-388 .
44.
Grol R , Grimshaw J.From best evidence to best practice: effective implementation of change in patients' care . Lancet2003; 362: 1225-1230 .
45.
Bero LA , Grilli R , Grimshaw JM , Harvey E , Oxman AD , Tompson MA.Closing the gap between research and practice: an overview of systematic reviews of interventions to promote the implementation of research findings . BMJ1998; 317: 465-468 .
46.
Pereira J , Bruera E , Quan H.Palliative care on the net: an online survey of health care professionals . J Palliat Care2001; 17: 41-45 .
47.
Klueber KK , Bruera E.Interactive collaborative consultation model in end-of-life care . J Pain Symptom Manage2000; 20: 202-209 .
48.
Thompson AR , Savidge MA , Fulper-Smith M , Strode SW.Testing a multimedia module in cancer pain management . J Cancer Educ1999; 14: 161-163 .
49.
Peterson MW , Galvin JR , Dayton Ch , D'Alessandro MP.Delivering pulmonary continuing medical education over the Internet . Chest1999; 115: 1429-1436 .
50.
Grande GE , Barclay SIG , Todd CJ.Difficulty of symptom control and general practitioners' knowledge of patients' symptoms . Palliat Med1997; 11: 399-406 .
51.
Phillips LS , Branch WT , Cook CB , et al. Clinical inertia . Ann Intern Med2001; 135: 825-834 .
52.
Klein JG.Five pitfalls in decisions about diagnosis and prescribing . BMJ2005; 330: 781-784 .
53.
O'Brien MA , Freemantle N , Oxman AD , Wolf F , Davis DA , Herrin J.Continuing education meetings and workshops: effects on professional practice and health care outcomes. The Cochrane Library, Issue 3. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. , 2004.
54.
Barclay S , Todd Ch , Grande G , Lipscombe J.Controlling cancer pain in primary care: the prescribing habits and knowledge base of general practitioners . J Pain Symptom Manage2002; 23: 383-392 .
55.
Griffin JP , Nelson JE , Koch KA , et al. End-of-life care in patients with lung cancer . Chest2003; 123: 312S-331S .
56.
Kirk P , Kirk I , Kristjanson J.What do patients receiving palliative care for cancer and their families want to be told? A Canadian and Australian qualitative study . BMJ2004; 328: 1343-1349 .
57.
Curtis JR , Patrick DL , Caldwell ES , Collier AC.Why don't patients and physicians talk about end-of-life care? Barriers to communication for patients with Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome and their primary care clinicians . Arch Intern Med2000; 160: 1690-1696 .
58.
Maguire P , Pitceathly C.Key communication skills and how to acquire them . BMJ2002; 325: 697-700 .
59.
Goldschmidt D , Groenvold M , Johnsen AT , Strömgren AS , Krasnik A , Schmidt L.Cooperating with a palliative home-care team: expectations and evaluations of GPs and district nurses . Palliat Med2005; 19: 241-250 .
60.
Shipman C , Addington-Hall J , Barclay A , et al. How and why do GPs use specialist palliative care services?Palliat Med2002; 16: 241-246 .
61.
Breitbart W , Rosenfeld B , Passik SD.The network project: a multidisciplinary cancer education and training programme in pain management, rehabilitation, and psychosocial issues . J Pain Symptom Manage1998; 15: 18-26 .
62.
Thulesius H , Petersson Ch , Petersson K , Häkansson A.Learner-centred education in end-of-life care improved well being in home care staff: a prospective controlled study . Palliat Med2002; 16: 347-354 .
63.
Koffman J.Multiprofessional palliative care education: past challenges, future issues . J Palliat Care2001; 17: 86-92 .
64.
Shipman C , Addington-Hall J , Barclay S , et al. Educational opportunities in palliative care: what do general practitioners want?Palliat Med2001; 15: 191-196 .
65.
Esteva MC , Llobera JC , Miralles JX , Bauza MA.Management of terminal cancer patients: attitudes and training needs of primary health care doctors and nurses . Support Care Cancer2000; 8: 464-471 .
66.
Evans R , Stone D , Elwyn G.Organizing palliative care for rural populations: a systematic review of the evidence . Fam Pract2003; 20: 304-310 .
67.
Groot MM , Vernooij-Dassen MJ , Crul BJ , Grol R.General practitioners (GPs) and palliative care: perceived tasks and barriers in daily practice . Palliat Med2005; 19: 111-118 .
68.
Sloan PA , Donnelly MB , Vanderveer B , Delomas M , Schwartz RW , Sloan DA.Cancer pain education among family physicians . J Pain Symptom Manage1997; 14: 74-81 .
69.
Pérol D , Boissel JP , Broussolle Ch , Cetre Jch , Stagnara J , Chauvin F.A simple tool to evoke physicians' real training needs . Acad Med2002; 77: 407-410 .
70.
Brown CA , Belfield CR , Field SJ.Cost effectiveness of continuing professional development in health care: a critical review of the evidence . BMJ2002; 324: 652-655 .
