In January 2006 the Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois (CHUV), a large university hospital in Lausanne, Switzerland, became the first hospital in Switzerland to allow assisted suicide (AS) in exceptional cases within its walls. However, euthanasia is illegal. This decision has posed several ethical and practical dilemmas for the hospital’s palliative care consult service. To address these, the team embarked on a formal process of open dialogue amongst its members with the goal of identifying a collective response and position. This process involved meetings every 4 to 6 weeks over the course of 10 months. An iterative process unfolded. One of the principal dilemmas relates to finding a balance between the team’s position against AS and the patient’s autonomy and the institution’s directive. Although all team members expressed opposition to AS, there were mixed opinions as to whether or not the team members should be present during the act if requested so by patients. Some thought this could be misinterpreted as complicity in the act and could send out mixed messages to the public and other health professionals about palliative care. Others felt that the team’s commitment to nonabandonment obliged them to be present even if they did not provide the drug or give any advice or assistance. The implications of nonabandonment are explored, as are several other questions such as whether or not the teams are obliged to provide detailed information on AS when requested by patients.
1 van der Heide A Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD Rurup ML Buiting HM van Delden JJM Hanssen-de Wolf JE . End-of-Life Practices in the Netherlands under the Euthanasia Act . N Engl J Med2007; 356: 1957 – 1965 .
2.
2 Deliens L van der Wal G . The euthanasia law in Belgium and the Netherlands . Lancet2003; 362: 1239 – 1240 .
3.
3 Ganzini L Nelson HD Schmidt TA Kraemer DF Delorit MA Lee MA . Physicians’ experiences with the Oregon Death with Dignity Act . N Engl J Med2000; 342: 557 – 563 .
4.
4 Kissane DW Street A Nitschke P . Seven deaths in Darwin: case studies under the Rights of Terminally Ill Act, Northern Territory, Australia . Lancet1998; 352: 1097 – 1102 .
5.
5 Bosshard G Fischer S Bär W . Open regulation and practice in assisted dying. How Switzerland compares with the Netherlands and Oregon . Swiss Med Wkly2002; 132: 527 – 534 .
6.
6 Ganzini L Harvath TA Jackson A Goy ER Miller LL Delorit MA . Experiences of Oregon nurses and social workers with hospice patients who requested assistance with suicide . N Engl J Med2002; 347: 582 – 588 .
7.
7 Harvath TA Miller LL Smith K Clark L Jackson A Ganzini L . Dilemmas encountered by hospice workers when patients wish to hasten death . J Hosp Palliat Nursing2006; 8: 200 – 209 .
8.
8 Volker DL . Oncology nurses' experiences with requests for assisted dying from terminally ill patients with cancer . Oncol Nurs Forum2001; 28: 39 – 49 .
9.
9 Wasserfallen JB Chioléro R Stiefel F . Assisted suicide in an acute care hospital: a 18-Month experience . Swiss Med Wkly. (In Press).
11 Hurst SA Mauron A . Assisted suicide and euthanasia in Switzerland: allowing a role for non-physicians . Br Med J2003; 326: 271 – 273 .
12.
12 Swiss penal code of the twenty-first of December 1937, Book Second–Special dispositions–First Title: Infraction against life and body integrity.
13.
13 Kapp C . Swiss financial capital attracts suicide tourists . Lancet2003; 361: 846 .
14.
14 Bosshard G Ulrich E Bär W . 748 cases of suicide assisted by a Swiss Right-To-Die organisation . Swiss Med Wkly2003; 133: 310 – 317 .
15.
15 Bosshard G Jermini D Eisenhart D Bär W . Assisted suicide bordering on active euthanasia . Int J Legal Med2003; 117: 106 – 108 .
16.
16 Fischer S Bosshard G Faisst K . Swiss doctors’ attitudes towards end-of-life decisions and their determinants.A comparison of three language regions . Swiss Med Wkly2005; 135: 370 – 376 .
17.
17 Miccinesi G Fischer S Paci E Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD Cartwright C van der Heide A . Physicians’ attitudes towards end-of-life decisions: a comparison between seven countries . Soc Sci Med2005; 60: 1961 – 1974 .
18.
18 Fischer S Miccinesi G Hornung R . Responders and non-responders in a study on medical end-of-life decisions in Denmark, the Netherlands, Sweden and Switzerland . Soc Prev Med2006; 51: 24 – 33 .
19.
19 Personal communication. Unpublished results of recent survey of curricula by Swiss Palliative Care Society’s Education Working Group.
20.
20 Wasserfallen JB . Respecter la liberté du patient et du soignant . Schweiz Arzteztg2006; 87: 20 .
21.
21 Waeber G Odier C Foppa C Wasserfallen JB Vannotti M Mazzocato C . Assistance au suicide en hôpital de soins aigus : sommes-nous prêts?Rev Med Suisse2007; 3: 2454 – 2460 .
22.
22 Wilkes L White K Tolley N . Euthanasia: a comparison of the lived experience of Chinese and Australian palliative care nurses . J Adv Nurs1993; 18: 95 – 102 .
23.
23 Bittel N Neuenschwander H Stiefel F . Euthanasia: a survey by the Swiss Association for Palliative Care . Support Care Cancer2002; 10: 265 – 271 .
24.
24 Müller-Busch HC Oduncu FC Woskanjan S Klaschik E . Attitudes on euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide and terminal sedation: A survey of the members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine . Med Health Care Philos2005; 7: 333 – 339 .
25.
25 Finlay IG Wheatley VJ Izdebski C . The House of Lords Select Committee on the Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill Bill: implications for specialist palliative care . Palliat Med2005; 19: 444 – 453 .
26.
26 Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland . Submission from the Ethics Committee to the Select Committee of the House of Lords on the Assisted Dying Bill.Southampton : Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland , 2004.
27.
27 Sepulveda C Marlin A Yoshida T Ullrich A . Palliative care: the World Health Organization’s global perspective . J Pain Symptom Manage2002; 24: 91 – 96 .
28.
29.
29 Matersvedt LJ Clark D Ellershaw K Forde R Gravgaard AMB Muller-Busch HC . Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: a view from an EAPC Ethics Task Force . Palliat Med2003; 17: 97 – 101 .
30.
30 Foley K Hendin H . Introduction: A medical, ethical, legal and psychosocial perpective. In: K FoleyH Hendin , (eds), The case against assisted suicide: for the right to end-of-life care.Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press ; 2002.
31.
31 Wilson KG Chochinov HM McPherson CJ . Desire for Euthanasia or Physician-Assisted Suicide in Palliative Cancer Care . Health Psychol2007; 26: 314 – 323 .
32.
32 Sobel J . Point de vue sur l'assistance au décès . Rev Med Suisse2001; 121: 163 – 164 .
33.
33 Humphrey D Clement M . Freedom to die: People, politics, and the right-to-die movement.New York : St.Martin's ; 1998.
34.
34 Battin MP . Is a physician ever obligated to help a patient die? In: LL Emanuel , (ed), Regulating how we die: The ethical, medical and legal issues surrounding physician-assisted suicide.Cambridge, Massachusetts : Harvard University Press ; 1998. p. 21–47.
35.
35 Quill TE Battin MP . Excellent palliative care as the standard, physician-assisted dying as a last resort. In: TE QuillMP Battin , (eds), Physician assisted suicide: The case for palliative care and patient choice.Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press ; 2004. p. 323–333.
36.
36 Brody H . Assisted death-a compassionate response to a medical failure . N Engl J Med1992; 327: 1384 – 1388 .
37.
37 Chochinov HM Tataryn D Clinch JJ Dudgeon D . Will to live in the terminally ill . Lancet1999; 354: 816 – 819 .
38.
38 Kelly BD McLoughlin DM . Euthanasia, assisted suicide and psychiatry: A Pandora’s box . Br J Psychiatry2002; 181: 278 – 279 .
39.
39 Suarez-Almazor ME Newman C Hanson J Bruera E . Attitudes of Terminally Ill Cancer Patients About Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide: Predominance of Psychosocial Determinants and Beliefs Over Symptom Distress and Subsequent Survival . J Clin Oncol2002; 20: 2134 – 2141 .
40.
40 Shah N Warner J Blizard B King N . National survey of UK psychiatrists' attitudes to euthanasia . Lancet1998; 352: 1360 .
41.
41 Quill TE Cassel CK . Nonabandonment: A central obligation for physicians. In: TE QuillMP Battin , (eds), Physician assisted suicide: The case for palliative care and patient choice.Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press ; 2004. p. 24–38.
42.
42 Claxton-Oldfield S Claxton-Oldfield J Rishchynski G . Understanding of the term "palliative care": A Canadian survey . Am J Hosp Palliat Med2004; 21: 105 – 110 .
43.
44.
45.
45 Hudson PL Schofield P Kelly B Hudson R Street A O’Connor M . Responding to desire to die statements from patients with advanced disease: recommendations for health professionals . Palliat Med2006; 20: 703 – 710 .
46.
46 Zylicz Z . Palliative care and euthanasia in the Netherlands: Observations of a Dutch physician. In: K FoleyH Hendin , (eds), The case against assisted suicide: for the right to end-of-life care.Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press ; 2002. p. 122–143.
47.
47 Emanuel EJ Fairclough DL Emanuel LL . Attitudes and Desires Related to Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide Among Terminally Ill Patients and Their Caregivers . JAMA2000; 284: 2460 – 2468 .
48.
48 Stevens KR . Emotional and psychological effects of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia on participating physicians . Issues Law Med2006; 21: 187 – 200 .
49.
49 Van Marwiijk H Haverkate I van Royen P The AM . Impact of euthanasia on primary care physicians in the Netherlands . Palliat Med2007; 21: 609 – 614 .
50.
50 Koffman K Burke G Raval B Byrne J Gonzales J Daniels C . Demographic factors and awareness of palliative care and related services . Palliat Med2007; 21: 145 – 153 .
51.
51 Zaré M Palmiere C Sobel J La Harpe R Burkhardt S . L’assistance au suicide en Suisse dans le contexte de polypathologie invalidante irréversible . Rev Med Suisse2007; 3: 2303 – 2305 .
