The economic evidence for advance care planning: Systematic review of evidence

Abstract

Background:

Advance care planning is a process of discussion and review concerning future care in the event of losing capacity. Aimed at improving the appropriateness and quality of care, it is also often considered a means of making better use of healthcare resources at the end of life.

Aim:

To review and summarise economic evidence on advance care planning.

Design:

A systematic review of the academic literature.

Data sources:

We searched for English language, peer-reviewed journal articles, 1990–2014, using relevant research databases: PubMed, ProQuest, CINAHL Plus with Full Text; EconLit, PsycINFO, SocINDEX with Full Text and International Bibliography of the Social Sciences. Empirical studies using statistical methods in which advance care planning and costs are variables were included.

Results:

There are no published cost-effectiveness studies. Included studies focus on healthcare savings, usually associated with reduced demand for hospital care. Advance care planning appears to be associated with healthcare savings for some people in some circumstances, such as people living with dementia in the community, people in nursing homes or in areas with high end-of-life care spending. There is no evidence that advance care planning is likely to be more expensive.

Conclusion:

There is need for clearer articulation of the likely mechanisms by which advance care planning can lead to reduced care costs or improved cost-effectiveness, particularly for people who retain capacity. There is also a need to consider wider costs, including the costs of advance care planning facilitation or interventions and the costs of substitute health, social and informal care. Economic outcomes need to be considered in the context of quality benefits.

Keywords

Advance care planning end-of-life care cost-benefit analysis Health Care Economics and Organisations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Department of Health. End of Life Care Strategy: promoting high quality care for all adults at the end of life. Department of Health, London, July 2008.

Scottish Government. Living and dying well: a national plan for palliative and end of life care in Scotland. Report, Scottish Government, Edinburgh, September 2008.

Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety. Living matters, dying matters: a palliative and end of life care strategy for adults in Northern Ireland. Report, Department of Health, London, July 2010.

Brinkman-Stoppelenburg

Rietjens

Van Der Heide

. The effects of advance care planning on end of life care: a systematic review. Palliat Med 2014; 28: 1000–1025.

General Medical Council (GMC). Treatment and care towards the end of life: good practice in decision making. Report, General Medical Council, 2010, http://www.gmc-uk.org/end_of_life.pdf_32486688.pdf

Marckmann

in der Schmitten

. The economics of advance care planning: empirical data and ethical implications. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2013; 3: 241.

Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Systematic reviews: CRD’s guidance for undertaking systematic reviews in health care. York: University of York, 2009.

Maksoud

Jahnigen

Skibinski

. Do not resuscitate orders and the cost of death. Arch Intern Med 1993; 153: 1249–1253.

Fonk

Davidoff

Lutzow

. The effect of advance directives on end of life cost experience. J Health Care Poor Underserved 2012; 23: 1137–1156.

10.

Lisk

Nari

Yeong

. Geriatrician input into 12 care homes reduced emergency hospital admissions which was maintained with education & training of GPs and care home staff. Age Ageing 2014; 43(Suppl. 1): pi13.

11.

Gade

Venohr

Conner

. Impact of an inpatient palliative care team: a randomized control trial. J Palliat Med 2008; 11: 180–190.

12.

Baker

Leak

Ritchie

. Anticipatory care planning and integration: a primary care pilot study aimed at reducing unplanned hospitalization. Br J Gen Pract 2012; 62: e113–e120.

13.

Higginson

Finlay

Goodwin

. Do hospital-based palliative teams improve care for patients or families at the end of life? J Pain Symptom Manage 2002; 23: 96–106.

14.

Teo

Raj

Tan

. Economic impact analysis of an end of life programme for nursing home residents. Palliat Med 2014; 28: 430–437.

15.

Nicholas

Bynumm

Iwashynam

. Advance directives and nursing home stays associated with less aggressive end of life care for patients with severe dementia. Health Aff 2014; 33: 667–674.

16.

Abel

Pring

Rich

. The impact of advance care planning of place of death, a hospice retrospective cohort study. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2013; 3: 168–173.

17.

Lukas

Foltz

Paxton

. Hospital outcomes for a home-based palliative medicine consulting service. J Palliat Med 2013; 16: 179–184.

18.

Yoo

Nakagawa

Kim

. Integrative palliative care, advance directives, and hospital outcomes of critically ill older adults. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2012; 29: 655–662.

19.

Nicholas

Langa

Iwashyna

. Regional variation in the association between advance directives and end of life Medicare expenditures. JAMA 2011; 306: 1447–1453.

20.

Kelley

Ettner

Morrison

. Determinants of medical expenditures in the last 6 months of life. Ann Intern Med 2011; 154: 235–242.

21.

Tan

Jatoi

. End of life hospital costs in cancer patients: do advance directives or routes of hospital admission make a difference? Oncology 2011; 80: 118–122.

22.

Hamlet

Hobgood

Hamar

. Impact of predictive model-directed end of life counseling for Medicare beneficiaries. Am J Manag Care 2010; 16: 379–384.

23.

Engelhardt

McClive-Reed

Toseland

. Effects of a program for coordinated care of advanced illness on patients, surrogates, and healthcare costs: a randomized trial. Am J Manag Care 2006; 12: 93–100.

24.

Kessler

McClellan

. Advance directives and medical treatment at the end of life. J Health Econ 2004; 23: 111–127.

25.

Molloy

Guyatt

Russo

. Systematic implementation of an advance directive program in nursing homes: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2000; 283: 1437–1444.

26.

Teno

Lynn

Connors

Jr . The illusion of end of life resource savings with advance directives. J Am Geriatr Soc 1997; 45: 513–518.

27.

Weeks

Kofoed

Wallace

. Advance directives and the cost of terminal hospitalization. Arch Intern Med 1994; 154(18): 2077–2083.

28.

Chambers

Diamond

Perkel

. Relationship of advance directives to hospital charges in a Medicare population. Arch Intern Med 1994; 154: 541–547.

29.

Zhang

Wright

Huskamp

. Health care costs in the last week of life: associations with end of life conversations. Arch Intern Med 2009; 169: 480–488.

30.

Wholihan

Pace

. Community discussions: a vision for cutting the costs of end of life care. Nurs Econ 2012; 30: 170–175.

31.

Detering

Hancock

Reade

. The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2010; 340: c1345.

32.

Lorenz

Lynn

. Oregon’s lessons for improving advance care planning. J Am Geriatr Soc 2004; 52: 1574–1575.

33.

Chong

. Perceptions of benefits and barriers in conducting advance care planning: a cross-sectional survey of trained advance care planning facilitators. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2013; 3: 279.

34.

Finkler

. The distinction between cost and charges. Ann Intern Med 1982; 96: 102–109.

35.

Blunt

Bardsley

. Patient-level costing: can it yield efficiency savings? Report, Nuffield Trust, London, September 2012.

36.

Guerriere

Coyte

. Societal costs of home and hospital end-of-life care for palliative care patients in Ontario, Canada. Health Soc Care Community. Epub ahead of print 2 December 2014. DOI: 10.1111/hsc.12170.

37.

Kinley

Hockley

Stone

. The provision of care for residents dying in UK nursing care homes. Age Ageing 2014; 43: 375–379.

38.

Social Care Institute for Excellence. Dying well at home: the case for integrated working. Report, SCIE guide 48, May 2013. London: Social Care Institute for Excellence, http://www.scie.org.uk/publications/guides/guide48/files/guide48_researchevidence.pdf

39.

Emanuel

. The economics of dying: the illusion of cost savings at the end of life. N Engl J Med 1994; 330: 540–544.

40.

Newman

. Palliative Care Funding Review: implications for family carers. End Life J 2013; 3: 1–4.

41.

McCrone

. Capturing the costs of end-of-life care: comparisons of multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, and dementia. J Pain Symptom Manage 2009; 38(1): 62–67.

42.

Dumont

Jacobs

Fassbender

. Costs associated with resource utilization during the palliative phase of care: a Canadian perspective. Palliat Med 2009; 23: 708–717.

43.

Funk

Stajduhar

Toye

. Part 2: home-based family caregiving at the end of life: a comprehensive review of published qualitative research (1998–2008). Palliat Med 2010; 24(6): 594–607.

44.

Wright

Zhang

Ray

. Associations between end of life discussions, patient mental health, medical care near death, and caregiver bereavement adjustment. JAMA 2008; 300: 1665–1673.

45.

Bardsley

Georghiou

Davies

. Understanding patterns of health and social care at the end of life. Report, Nuffield Trust, London, October 2012.

46.

Georghiou

Bardsley

. Exploring the cost of care at the end of life. Report, Nuffield Trust, London, September 2014.

47.

Petrou

Gray

. Economic evaluation using decision analytical modelling: design, conduct, analysis, and reporting. BMJ 2011; 342: d1766.

48.

National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). Guide to the methods of technology appraisal. NICE, London, April 2013.

49.

Normand

. Measuring outcomes in palliative care: limitations of QALYs and the road to PalYs. J Pain Symptom Manage 2009; 38: 27–31.

50.

Round

. Is a QALY still a QALY at the end of life? J Health Econ 2012; 31: 521–527.

51.

Hughes

. Palliative care and the QALY problem. Health Care Anal 2005; 13: 289–301.

52.

Gomes

Harding

Foley

. Optimal approaches to the health economics of palliative care: report of an international think tank. J Pain Symptom Manage 2009; 38: 4–10.

53.

Higginson

Evans

Grande

. on behalf of MORECare. Evaluating complex interventions in End of Life Care: the MORECare Statement on good practice generated by a synthesis of transparent expert consultations and systematic reviews. BMC Med 2013; 11: 111.

54.

Evans

Stone

Manthorpe

. MRC guidance on developing and evaluating complex interventions: application to research on palliative and end of life care. Report, Methods review 15, 2013. London: National Institute for Health Research School for Social Care Research, http://sscr.nihr.ac.uk/PDF/MR/MR15.pdf

55.

Halpern

Emanuel

. Advance directives and cost savings: greater clarity and perpetual confusion. Arch Intern Med 2012; 172: 266–268.

56.

Pawson

Tilley

. Realist evaluation. London: SAGE, 1997.

57.

Lynn

De Vries

Arkes

. Ineffectiveness of the SUPPORT intervention: review of explanations. J Am Geriatr Soc 2000; 48(Suppl. 5): S206–S213.

58.

Goodman

Froggatt

Mathie

. End of life care. Report, Methods review 12, 2012. London: National Institute for Health Research School for Social Care Research, http://sscr.nihr.ac.uk/PDF/MR/MR12.pdf