Using the ‘Social Marketing Mix Framework’ to explore recruitment barriers and facilitators in palliative care randomised controlled trials? A narrative synthesis review

Abstract

Background:

Effective recruitment to randomised controlled trials is critically important for a robust, trustworthy evidence base in palliative care. Many trials fail to achieve recruitment targets, but the reasons for this are poorly understood. Understanding barriers and facilitators is a critical step in designing optimal recruitment strategies.

Aim:

To identify, explore and synthesise knowledge about recruitment barriers and facilitators in palliative care trials using the ‘6 Ps’ of the ‘Social Marketing Mix Framework’.

Design:

A systematic review with narrative synthesis.

Data sources:

Medline, CINAHL, PsycINFO and Embase databases (from January 1990 to early October 2016) were searched. Papers included the following: interventional and qualitative studies addressing recruitment, palliative care randomised controlled trial papers or reports containing narrative observations about the barriers, facilitators or strategies to increase recruitment.

Results:

A total of 48 papers met the inclusion criteria. Uninterested participants (Product), burden of illness (Price) and ‘identifying eligible participants’ were barriers. Careful messaging and the use of scripts/role play (Promotion) were recommended. The need for intensive resources and gatekeeping by professionals were barriers while having research staff on-site and lead clinician support (Working with Partners) was advocated. Most evidence is based on researchers’ own reports of experiences of recruiting to trials rather than independent evaluation.

Conclusion:

The ‘Social Marketing Mix Framework’ can help guide researchers when planning and implementing their recruitment strategy but suggested strategies need to be tested within embedded clinical trials. The findings of this review are applicable to all palliative care research and not just randomised controlled trials.

Keywords

Palliative care palliative medicine terminal care randomised controlled trial

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ross

Grant

Counsell

et al . Barriers to participation in randomised controlled trials: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol 1999; 52: 1143–1156.

Mills

Seely

Rachlis

et al . Barriers to participation in clinical trials of cancer: a meta-analysis and systematic review of patient-reported factors. Lancet Oncol 2006; 7: 141–148.

Donovan

de Salis

Toerien

et al . The intellectual challenges and emotional consequences of equipoise contributed to the fragility of recruitment in six randomized controlled trials. J Clin Epidemiol 2014; 67: 912–920.

McDonald

Knight

Campbell

et al . What influences recruitment to randomised controlled trials? A review of trials funded by two UK funding agencies. Trials 2006; 7: 9.

Sully

BGO

Julious

Nicholl

. A reinvestigation of recruitment to randomised, controlled, multicenter trials: a review of trials funded by two UK funding agencies. Trials 2013; 14: 166.

Grande

Todd

. Why are trials in palliative care so difficult? Palliat Med 2000; 14: 69–74.

Bouça-Machado

Rosário

Alarcão

et al . Clinical trials in palliative care: a systematic review of their methodological characteristics and of the quality of their reporting. BMC Palliat Care 2017; 16: 10.

Haun

Estel

Rücker

et al . Early palliative care for adults with advanced cancer. Cochrane DB Syst Rev. Epub ahead of print 12 July 2017. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD011129.pub2.

Kavalieratos

Corbelli

Zhang

et al . Association between palliative care and patient and caregiver outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA 2016; 316: 2104–2114.

10.

Agar

Lawlor

Quinn

et al . Efficacy of oral risperidone, haloperidol, or placebo for symptoms of delirium among patients in palliative care: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Intern Med 2017; 177: 34–42.

11.

Boland

Currow

Wilcock

et al . A systematic review of strategies used to increase recruitment of people with cancer or organ failure into clinical trials: implications for palliative care research. J Pain Symptom Manage 2015; 49: 762–772e5.

12.

Preston

Farquhar

Walshe

et al . Strategies designed to help healthcare professionals to recruit participants to research studies. Cochrane DB Syst Rev. Epub ahead of print 29 February 2016. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.MR000036.pub2.

13.

Kars

van Thiel

van der Graaf

et al . A systematic review of reasons for gatekeeping in palliative care research. Palliat Med 2016; 30: 533–548.

14.

Nichols

Martindale-Adams

Burns

et al . Social marketing as a framework for recruitment: illustrations from the REACH study. J Aging Health 2004; 16: 157S–176S.

15.

Galli

Knight

Robertson

et al . Using marketing theory to inform strategies for recruitment: a recruitment optimisation model and the txt2stop experience. Trials 2014; 15: 182.

16.

Etkin

Farran

Barnes

et al . Recruitment and enrollment of caregivers for a lifestyle physical activity clinical trial. Res Nurs Health 2012; 35: 70–81.

17.

LeBlanc

Lodato

Currow

et al . Overcoming recruitment challenges in palliative care clinical trials. J Oncol Pract 2013; 9: 277–282.

18.

Popay

Roberts

Sowden

et al . Guidance on the conduct of narrative symthesis in systematic reviews: a product from the ESRC methods programme. Lancaster: Lancaster University, 2006.

19.

Sladek

Tieman

Fazekas

et al . Development of a subject search filter to find information relevant to palliative care in the general medical literature. J Med Libr Assoc 2006; 94: 394–401.

20.

Tieman

Sladek

Currow

. Changes in the quantity and level of evidence of palliative and hospice care literature: the last century. J Clin Oncol 2008; 26: 5679–5683.

21.

Sigurdardottir

Oldervoll

Hjermstad

et al . How are palliative care cancer populations characterized in randomized controlled trials? A literature review. J Pain Symptom Manage 2014; 47: 906–914.e17.

22.

Radbruch

. Mastering breathlessness in patients with advanced respiratory disease. Lancet Respir Med 2014; 2: 944–945.

23.

Gale

Heath

Cameron

et al . Using the framework method for the analysis of qualitative data in multi-disciplinary health research. BMC Med Res Methodol 2013; 13: 117.

24.

Eager

Owen

Williams

et al . Effective caring: a synthesis of the international evidence on carer needs and interventions. Report, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, NSW, Australia, December 2007.

25.

Aveyard

Payne

Preston

. A post-graduate’s guide to doing a literature review in health and social care. Maidenhead: Open University Press, 2016, p. 113.

26.

Abernethy

Currow

Wurzelmann

et al . Enhancing enrollment in palliative care trials: key insights from a randomized, placebo-controlled study. J Support Oncol 2010; 8: 139–144.

27.

Ammari

ABH

Hendriksen

Rydahl-Hansen

. Recruitment and reasons for non-participation in a family-coping-orientated palliative home care trial (FamCope). J Psychosoc Oncol 2015; 33: 655–674.

28.

Bakitas

Lyons

Dixon

et al . Palliative care program effectiveness research: developing rigor in sampling design, conduct, and reporting. J Pain Symptom Manage 2006; 31: 270–284.

29.

Bakitas

Lyons

Hegel

et al . The project ENABLE II randomized controlled trial to improve palliative care for rural patients with advanced cancer: baseline findings, methodological challenges, and solutions. Palliat Support Care 2009; 7: 75–86.

30.

Baskin

Morris

Ahronheim

et al . Barriers to obtaining consent in dementia research: implications for surrogate decision-making. J Am Geriatr Soc 1998; 46: 287–290.

31.

Bausewein

Booth

Gysels

et al . Effectiveness of a hand-held fan for breathlessness: a randomised phase II trial. BMC Palliat Care 2010; 9: 22.

32.

Buss

Arnold

. Challenges in palliative care research: one experience. J Palliat Med 2004; 7: 405–407.

33.

Buss

DuBenske

Dinauer

et al . Patient/caregiver influences for declining participation in supportive oncology trials. J Support Oncol 2008; 6: 168–174.

34.

Clark

Currow

Agar

et al . A pilot phase II randomized, cross-over, double-blinded, controlled efficacy study of octreotide versus hyoscine hydrobromide for control of noisy breathing at the end-of-life. J Pain Palliat Care Pharmacother 2008; 22: 131–138.

35.

Cook

Finlay

Butler-Keating

. Recruiting into palliative care trials: lessons learnt from a feasibility study. Palliat Med 2002; 16: 163–165.

36.

Currow

Abernethy

Shelby-James

et al . The impact of conducting a regional palliative care clinical study. Palliat Med 2006; 20: 735–743.

37.

Mitchell

Abernethy

. A comparison of methodologies from two longitudinal community-based randomized controlled trials of similar interventions in palliative care: what worked and what did not? J Palliat Med 2005; 8: 1226–1237.

38.

Daniels

Exley

. Preparation, information and liaison: conducting successful research in palliative care. Int J Palliat Nurs 2001; 7: 192–197.

39.

Farquhar

Higginson

Fagan

et al . The feasibility of a single-blinded fast-track pragmatic randomised controlled trial of a complex intervention for breathlessness in advanced disease. BMC Palliat Care 2009; 8: 9.

40.

Farquhar

Brafman-Kennedy

Higginson

et al . Recruiting patients with advanced malignant and non-malignant disease: lessons learned from a palliative care RCT. Trials 2011; 12: A119.

41.

Fischer

Cervantes

Fink

et al . Apoyo con Cariño: a pilot randomized controlled trial of a patient navigator intervention to improve palliative care outcomes for Latinos with serious illness. J Pain Symptom Manage 2015; 49: 657–665.

42.

Fowell

Johnstone

Finlay

et al . Design of trials with dying patients: a feasibility study of cluster randomisation versus randomised consent. Palliat Med 2006; 20: 799–804.

43.

Goldstein

Kalman

Kutner

et al . A study to improve communication between clinicians and patients with advanced heart failure: methods and challenges behind the working to improve discussions about defibrillator management trial. J Pain Symptom Manage 2014; 48: 1236–1246.

44.

Goodwin

Leszcz

Quirt

et al . Lessons learned from enrollment in the BEST study: a multicenter, randomized trial of group psychosocial support in metastatic breast cancer. J Clin Epidemiol 2000; 53: 47–55.

45.

Gorman

Forest

Stapleton

et al . Massage for cancer pain: a study with university and hospice collaboration. J Hosp Palliat Nurs 2008; 10: 191–197.

46.

Hanson

Bull

Wessell

et al . Strategies to support recruitment of patients with life-limiting illness for research: the palliative care research cooperative group. J Pain Symptom Manage 2014; 48: 1021–1030.

47.

Hardy

Ling

Mansi

et al . Pitfalls in placebo-controlled trials in palliative care: dexamethasone for the palliation of malignant bowel obstruction. Palliat Med 1998; 12: 437–442.

48.

Higginson

Hart

Burman

et al . Randomised controlled trial of a new palliative care service: compliance, recruitment and completeness of follow-up. BMC Palliat Care 2008; 7(1): 7.

49.

Hudson

Aranda

McMurray

. Randomized controlled trials in palliative care: overcoming the obstacles. Int J Palliat Nurs 2001; 7: 427–434.

50.

Hussainy

Marriott

. Recruitment strategies for palliative cancer care patients and carers. Int J Pharm Pract 2009; 17: 369–371.

51.

Jones

Harrington

Barlow

et al . Advance care planning in advanced cancer: can it be achieved? An exploratory randomized patient preference trial of a care planning discussion. Palliat Support Care 2011; 9: 3–13.

52.

Jones

FitzGerald

Leurent

et al . Rehabilitation in advanced, progressive, recurrent cancer: a randomized controlled trial. J Pain Symptom Manage 2013; 46: 315–325.

53.

Jordhøy

Kaasa

Fayers

et al . Challenges in palliative care research; recruitment, attrition and compliance: experience from a randomized controlled trial. Palliat Med 1999; 13: 299–310.

54.

Kruse

Parker Oliver

Wittenberg-Lyles

et al . Conducting the ACTIVE randomized trial in hospice care: keys to success. Clin Trials 2013; 10: 160–169.

55.

Kutner

Smith

Mellis

et al . Methodological challenges in conducting a multi-site randomized clinical trial of massage therapy in hospice. J Palliat Med 2010; 13: 739–744.

56.

Latimer

Crabb

Roberts

et al . The patient care travelling record in palliative care: effectiveness and efficiency. J Pain Symptom Manage 1998; 16: 41–51.

57.

Lee

Vather

O’Callaghan

et al . Validation of the phase II feasibility study in a palliative care setting: gastrografin in malignant bowel obstruction. Am J Hosp Palliat Med 2013; 30: 752–758.

58.

McMillan

Weitzner

. Methodologic issues in collecting data from debilitated patients with cancer near the end of life. Oncol Nurs Forum 2003; 30: 123–129.

59.

McWhinney

Bass

Donner

. Evaluation of a palliative care service: problems and pitfalls. Br Med J 1994; 309: 1340–1342.

60.

Miller

Chibnall

. Strategies for recruiting patients into randomized trials of palliative care. Palliat Med 2003; 17: 556–557.

61.

Miller

Chibnall

Videen

et al . Supportive-affective group experience for persons with life-threatening illness: reducing spiritual, psychological, and death-related distress in dying patients. J Palliat Med 2005; 8: 333–343.

62.

Noble

Nelson

Fitzmaurice

et al . A feasibility study to inform the design of a randomised controlled trial to identify the most clinically effective and cost-effective length of anticoagulation with low-molecular-weight heparin in the treatment of cancer-associated thrombosis (ALICAT). Health Technol Assess 2015; 19: vii–xxiii, 1–93.

63.

Philip

Gold

Milner

et al . A randomized, double-blind, crossover trial of the effect of oxygen on dyspnea in patients with advanced cancer. J Pain Symptom Manage 2006; 32: 541–550.

64.

Prentice

Roth

Kelly

. Topical benzydamine cream and the relief of pressure pain. Palliat Med 2004; 18: 520–524.

65.

Rees

Hardy

. Novel consent process for research in dying patients unable to give consent. Br Med J 2003; 327: 198–200.

66.

Riopelle

Wagner

Steckart

et al . Evaluating a palliative care intervention for veterans: challenges and lessons learned in a longitudinal study of patients with serious illness. J Pain Symptom Manage 2011; 41: 1003–1014.

67.

Sampson

Jones

Thune-Boyle

et al . Palliative assessment and advance care planning in severe dementia: an exploratory randomized controlled trial of a complex intervention. Palliat Med 2011; 25: 197–209.

68.

Shelby-James

Hardy

Agar

et al . Designing and conducting randomized controlled trials in palliative care: a summary of discussions from the 2010 clinical research forum of the Australian palliative care clinical studies collaborative. Palliat Med 2012; 26: 1042–1047.

69.

Storey

. Trying trials. J Palliat Med 2004; 7: 393–394.

70.

Vermandere

Warmenhoven

Van Severen

et al . Spiritual history taking in palliative home care: a cluster randomized controlled trial. Palliat Med 2016; 30: 338–350.

71.

Westcombe

Gambles

Wilkinson

et al . Learning the hard way! Setting up an RCT of aromatherapy massage for patients with advanced cancer. Palliat Med 2003; 17: 300–307.

72.

Zambroski

Buck

Garrison

et al . Lessons from the field: challenges in accruing hospice heart failure patients to intervention research. J Cardiovasc Nurs 2014; 29: 91–97.

73.

Lee

Kristjanson

. Human research ethics committees: issues in palliative care research. Int J Palliat Nurs 2003; 9: 13–18.

74.

Noble

Buckle

Gadd

. Service user and patient and public involvement in palliative and supportive care research. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2015; 5: 459–460.

75.

Donovan

Paramasivan

de Salis

et al . Clear obstacles and hidden challenges: understanding recruiter perspectives in six pragmatic randomised controlled trials. Trials 2014; 15: 5.

76.

Audrey

. Qualitative research in evidence-based medicine: improving decision-making and participation in randomized controlled trials of cancer treatments. Palliat Med 2011; 25: 758–765.

77.

Johnson

Booth

Currow

et al . A mixed-methods, randomized, controlled feasibility trial to inform the design of a phase III trial to test the effect of the handheld fan on physical activity and carer anxiety in patients with refractory breathlessness. J Pain Symptom Manage 2016; 51: 807–815.

78.

Rick

Graffy

Knapp

et al . Systematic techniques for assisting recruitment to trials (START): study protocol for embedded, randomized controlled trials. Trials 2014; 15: 407.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.03 MB