Legacy has been invoked as a means for strengthening human attachments, continuing bonds, and ensuring that individuals will be remembered; however, little is known about the spectrum of approaches to, outcomes associated with, and best practices for legacy interventions.
Aim:
To systematically review research on legacy perceptions and interventions in pediatric and adult palliative care recipients.
Design:
A systematic mixed studies review synthesizing quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods study findings using PRISMA guidelines.
Data sources:
PubMed, PsycINFO, and CINAHL databases were searched on October 1, 2020. GRADE criteria were used to assess quality of quantitative reports, and the Johns Hopkins Evidence Level and Quality Guide was used to rate qualitative, mixed methods, and review articles. Data were synthesized using integrative thematic analysis.
Results:
The 67 studies reviewed describe a variety of legacy perceptions and interventions with adult and pediatric patients receiving palliative care. Statistically significant improvements in various dimensions of wellbeing are documented, with significant reduction in incidence and symptoms of depression in adults. Studies highlight the utility, feasibility, and perceived benefits of legacy interventions according to adult patients and their caregivers, and parents/caregivers of pediatric patients.
Conclusions:
Though future research with high-quality, experimental designs is needed, the positive outcomes associated with legacy interventions are documented in adult patient populations; additionally, the application of legacy interventions for children with serious illnesses receiving palliative care is reasonable based on the existing body of evidence. A consistent and operational concept of legacy is still needed for future research and practice.
HunterEG.The legacy of cancer: the importance of passing on beliefs, values, and positive health behaviors for women with cancer. J Psychosoc Oncol2007; 26(1): 101–121.
2.
HunterEG.Beyond death: inheriting the past and giving to the future, transmitting the legacy of one’s self. OMEGA2008; 56: 313–329.
3.
AllenRSHilgemanMMEgeMA, et al. Legacy activities as interventions approaching the end of life. J Palliat Med2008; 11: 1029–1038.
4.
*FosterTLDietrichMSFriedmanDL, et al. National survey of children’s hospitals on legacy-making activities. J Palliat Med2012; 15: 573–578.
5.
*AllenRSHarrisGMBurgioLD, et al. Can senior volunteers deliver reminiscence and creative activity interventions? Results of the legacy intervention family enactment randomized controlled trial. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 48: 590–601.
6.
BolesJC.Creating a legacy for and with hospitalized children. Pediatr Nurs2014; 40: 43–44.
7.
BolesJCJonesMDunbarJ, et al. Defining legacy: the perceptions of pediatric healthcare providers. Clin Pediatr2020; 59(11): 1004–1010.
8.
SiskCWalkerEGardnerC, et al. Building a legacy for children and adolescents with chronic disease. J Pediatr Nurs2012; 27(6): e71–e76.
9.
*ChochinovHCannBCullihallK, et al. Dignity therapy: a feasibility study of elders in long-term care. Palliat Support Care2012; 10(1): 3–15.
10.
MontrossLWintersKDIrwinSA.Dignity therapy implementation in a community-based hospice setting. J Palliat Med2011; 14: 729–734.
11.
ConstantiniMSleemanKPeruselliC, et al. Response and role of palliative care during the COVID-19 pandemic: a national telephone survey of hospices in Italy. Palliat Med2020; 34(7): 889–895.
12.
MitchellSBennettKMorrisA, et al. Achieving beneficial outcomes for children with life-limiting and life-threatening conditions receiving palliative care and their families: a realist review. Palliat Med2020; 34(3): 387–402.
13.
GhirottoLBusaniESalvatiM, et al. Researching children’s perspectives in pediatric palliative care: a systematic review and meta-summary of qualitative research. Palliat Support Care2019; 17(1): 107–118.
14.
VerberneLMKarsMCSchouten-van MeeterenAY, et al. Parental experiences and coping strategies when caring for a child receiving paediatric palliative care: a qualitative study. Eur J Pediatr2019; 178(7): 1075–1085.
15.
KabirMRiceJBushS, et al. A mixed-methods pilot study of ‘LIFEView’ audiovisual technology: virtual travel to support well-being and quality of life in palliative and end-of-life care patients. Palliat Med2020; 34(7): 954–965.
16.
RoikjaerSMisselMBergenholtzH, et al. The use of personal narratives in hospital-based palliative care interventions: an integrative literature review. Palliat Med2019; 33(10): 1255–1271.
17.
SandelowskiMVoilsCIBarrosoJ.Defining and designing mixed research synthesis studies. Res Sch2006; 13: 29–44.
18.
McConnellTScottDPorterS.Healthcare staff’s experience in providing end-of-life care to children: a mixed method review. Palliat Med2016; 30(10): 905–919.
19.
BrysonA.Integrating quantitative and qualitative research: how is it done?Qual Res2006; 1: 97–113.
20.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med2009; 6: e1000097.
21.
GuyattGOxmanADAklEA, et al. GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction—GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol2011; 64(4): 383–394.
22.
DangDDearholtS.Johns Hopkins nursing evidence-based practice: model and guidelines. 3rd ed.Indianapolis, IN: Sigma Theta Tau International, 2017.
23.
GreenfieldKHolleySSchothDE, et al. A mixed-methods systematic review and meta-analysis of barriers and facilitators to paediatric symptom management at end of life. Palliat Med2020; 34(6): 689–707.
24.
van DongenSIde NooijerKCrammJM, et al. Self-management of patients with advanced cancer. A systemtic review of experiences and attitudes. Palliat Med2020; 34(2): 160–178.
25.
PuchalskiCM.The FICA spiritual history tool #274. J Palliat Med2014; 17(1): 105–106.
26.
*PidermanKMEggintonJSIngramC, et al. I’m still me: inspiration and instruction from individuals with brain cancer. J Health Care Chaplain2017; 23(1): 15–33.
27.
*AdamsMRobertGMabenJ.Exploring the legacies of filmed patient narratives: the interpretation and appreciation of patient films by health care staff. Qual Health Res2015; 25(9): 1241–1250.
28.
*CollierA.Practice development using video-reflexive ethnography: promoting safe space (s) towards the end of life in hospital. Int Pract Devel J2016; 6(1): 1–16.
29.
*SchryerCMcDougallATaitGR, et al. Creating discursive order at the end of life: the role of genres in palliative care settings. Writ Commun2012; 29(2): 111–141.
30.
*KeallRMButowPNSteinhauserKE.Nurse-facilitated preparation and life completion interventions are acceptable and feasible in the Australian palliative care setting: results from a phase 2 trial. Cancer Nurs2013; 36(3): E39–E46.
31.
*JohnstonBNarayanasamyM.Exploring psychosocial interventions for people with dementia that enhance personhood and relate to legacy-an integrative review. BMC Geriatr2016; 16(1): 77.
32.
*BlixBHHamranTNormannHK.Indigenous life stories as narratives of health and resistance: a dialogical narrative analysis. Can J Nurs Res2012; 44(2): 64–85.
33.
*XiaoHKwongEPangS, et al. Perceptions of a life review programme among Chinese patients with advanced cancer. J Clin Nurs2012; 21(3–4): 564–572.
34.
*AndoMMoritaTMiyashitaM, et al. Effects of bereavement life review on spiritual well-being and depression. J Pain Symptom Manage2010; 40(3): 453–459.
35.
*LinYDaiYHwangS.The effect of reminiscence on the elderly population: a systematic review. Pub Health Nurs2003; 20(4): 297–306.
36.
*LiHRichardsonASpeckP, et al. Conceptualizations of dignity at the end of life: exploring theoretical and cultural congruence with dignity therapy. J Adv Nurs2014; 70(12): 2920–2931.
37.
*WangCWChowAYChanCL.The effects of life review interventions on spiritual well-being, psychological distress, and quality of life in patients with terminal or advanced cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Palliat Med2017; 31(10): 883–894.
38.
*TeoIKrishnanALeeGL.Psychosocial interventions for advanced cancer patients: a systematic review. Psycho-Oncology2019; 28(7): 1394–1407.
39.
*SchaeferMRSpencerSKBarnettM, et al. Legacy artwork in pediatric oncology: the impact on bereaved caregivers’ psychological functioning and grief. J Palliat Med2019; 22(9): 1124–1128.
40.
*SchaeferMRWagonerSTYoungME, et al. Healing the hearts of bereaved parents: impact of legacy artwork on grief in pediatric oncology. J Pain Symptom Manag2020; 60(4): 790–800.
41.
*FranklinFCCheungM.Legacy interventions with patients with co-occurring disorders: legacy definitions, life satisfaction, and self-efficacy. Subst Use Misuse2017; 52(14): 1840–1849.
42.
*KamrathHJOsterholmEStover-HaneyR, et al. Lasting legacy: maternal perspectives of perinatal palliative care. J Palliat Med2019; 22: 310–315.
43.
*LaneFJ.Looking ahead: planning for the first human intracortical visual prosthesis by using pilot data from focus groups of potential users. Disabil Rehabil: Assist Technol2011; 6(2): 139–147.
44.
*PidermanKMRadecki BreitkopfCJenkinsSM, et al. The feasibility and educational value of Hear My Voice, a chaplain-led spiritual life review process for patients with brain cancers and progressive neurologic conditions. J Cancer Educ2015; 30(2): 209–212.
45.
*PidermanKMRadecki BreitkopfCJenkinsSM, et al. The impact of a spiritual legacy intervention in patients with brain cancers and other neurologic illnesses and their support persons. Psycho-Oncol2017; 26(3): 346–353.
46.
*ChanMFNgSETienA, et al. A randomised controlled study to explore the effect of life story review on depression in older Chinese in Singapore. Health Soc Care Community2013; 21(5): 545–553.
47.
*DavisMC.Life review therapy as an intervention to manage depression and enhance life satisfaction in individuals with right hemisphere cerebral vascular accidents. Issues Ment Health Nurs2004; 25(5): 503–515.
48.
*Mastel-SmithBBinderBMalechaA, et al. Testing therapeutic life review offered by home care workers to decrease depression among home-dwelling older women. Issues Ment Health Nurs2006; 27(10): 1037–1049.
49.
*DoseAMMcCabePJKreckeCA, et al. Outcomes of a dignity therapy/life plan intervention for patients with advanced cancer undergoing chemotherapy. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2018; 20(4): 400–406.
50.
*DraperPHollowayMAdamsonS.A qualitative study of recently bereaved people’s beliefs about death: implications for bereavement care. J Clinl Nurs2014; 23(9–10): 1300–1308.
51.
*AndersonEWFrazerMSSchellingerSE.Expanding the palliative care domains to meet the needs of a community-based supportive care model. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2018; 35(2): 258–265.
52.
*AndersonEWWhiteKM.“This is what family does”: the family experience of caring for serious illness. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2018; 35(2): 348–354.
53.
*McTiernanKO’ConnellM.An interpretative phenomenological analysis exploring the lived experience of individuals dying from terminal cancer in Ireland. Palliat Support Care2015; 13(3): 641–651.
54.
*NaikADMartinLAMoyeJ, et al. Health values and treatment goals of older, multimorbid adults facing life-threatening illness. J Am Geriatr Soc2016; 64(3): 625–631.
55.
*SchellingerSEAndersonEWFrazerMS, et al. Patient self-defined goals: essentials of person-centered care for serious illness. Am J Hosp Palliat Med2018; 35(1): 159–165.
56.
*ScartonLJBoykenLLuceroRJ, et al. Effects of dignity therapy on family members: a systematic review. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2018; 20(6): 542–547.
57.
*AkardTFDuffyMHordA, et al. Bereaved mothers’ and fathers’ perceptions of a legacy intervention for parents of infants in the NICU. J Neonatal Perinatal Med2018; 11(1): 21–28.
58.
*AkardTFWraySFriedmanDL, et al. Transforming a face-to-face legacy intervention to a web-based legacy intervention for children with advanced cancer. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2020; 22(1): 49–60.
59.
*LaingCMMoulesNJSinclairS, et al. Digital storytelling as a psychosocial tool for adult cancer survivors. Oncol Nurs Forum2019; 46(2): 147–154.
60.
*DempseyLMurphyKCooneyA, et al. Reminiscence in dementia: a concept analysis. Dementia2014; 13(2): 176–192.
61.
*HesseMForstmeierSAtesG, et al. Patients’ priorities in a reminiscence and legacy intervention in palliative care. Palliat Care Soc Pract2019; 13: 1–8.
62.
*HeylandDKDodekPRockerG, et al. What matters most in end-of-life care: perceptions of seriously ill patients and their family members. Can Med Assoc J2006; 174(5): 627–633.
63.
*DennisMKWashingtonKT.“Just let me go”: end-of-life planning among Ojibwe elders. Gerontologist2018; 58(2): 300–307.
64.
*HelselDThaoKSWhitneyR.Their last breath: death and dying in a Hmong American community. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2020; 22(1): 68–74.
65.
*McDermottP.Patient dignity question: feasible, dignity-conserving intervention in a rural hospice. Can Fam Physician2019; 65(11): 812–819.
66.
*MaiSSGoebelSJentschkeE, et al. Feasibility, acceptability and adaption of dignity therapy: a mixed methods study achieving 360 feedback. BMC Palliat Care2018; 17(1): 73.
67.
*GreweF.The soul’s legacy: a program designed to help prepare senior adults cope with end-of-life existential distress. J Health Care Chaplain2017; 23(1): 1–14.
68.
*AkardTFHendricks-FergusonVLGilmerMJ.Pediatric palliative care nursing. Ann Palliat Med2018; 8(1): S39–S48.
69.
*BentleyBO’ConnorMKaneR, et al. Feasibility, acceptability, and potential effectiveness of dignity therapy for people with motor neurone disease. PLoS ONE2014; 9(5): e96888.
70.
*HallSGoddardCOpioD, et al. Feasibility, acceptability and potential effectiveness of dignity therapy for older people in care homes: a phase II randomized controlled trial of a brief palliative care psychotherapy. Palliat Med2011; 26(5): 703–712.
71.
*RudillaDGalianaLOliverA, et al. Comparing counseling and dignity therapies in home care patients: a pilot study. Palliat Support Care2016; 14(4): 321–329.
72.
*GuoQChochinovHMMcClementS, et al. Development and evaluation of the Dignity Talk question framework for palliative patients and their families: a mixed-methods study. Palliat Med2018; 32(1): 195–205.
73.
*BernatJKHelftPRWilhelmLR, et al. Piloting an abbreviated dignity therapy using a legacy-building web portal for adults with terminal cancer: a feasibility and acceptability study. Psycho-Oncol2015; 24(12): 1823.
74.
*LanXXiaoHChenY, et al. Effects of life review intervention on life satisfaction and personal meaning among older adults with frailty. J Psychosoc Nurs Ment Health Serv2018; 56(7): 30–36.
75.
ChochinovHMHackTHassardT, et al. Dignity therapy: a novel psychotherapeutic intervention for patients near the end of life. J Clin Oncol2005; 23(24): 5520–5525.
76.
*AspirasDDEmpeñoJMontross-ThomasL.To honor and bear witness: a clinician’s reflection on dignity therapy for people living with dementia. J Palliat Med2019; 22(8): 1007–1008.
77.
*ClabburnOKnightingKJackBA, et al. The use of digital legacies with people affected by motor neurone disease for continuing bonds: an interpretative phenomenological analysis study. Palliat Med2019; 33(7): 812–822.
78.
*DahleyLSandersG.Use of a structured life review and its impact on family interactions. Act Adapt Aging2016; 40(1): 53–66.
79.
*GarlandRAhmedSLoiselleCG.Taking control over our health: empowerment as perceived by young adults living with advanced cancer. Can Oncol Nurs J2020; 30(2): 93–102.
80.
*GiltinanJ.Using life review to facilitate self-actualization in elderly women. Gerontol Geriatr Educ1990; 10(4): 75–83.
81.
*HallSGoddardCSpeckP, et al. ‘It makes me feel that I’m still relevant’: a qualitative study of the views of nursing home residents on dignity therapy and taking part in a phase II randomised controlled trial of a palliative care psychotherapy. Palliat Med2013; 27(4): 358–366.
82.
*JonesEDBeck-LittleR.The use of reminiscence therapy for the treatment of depression in rural-dwelling older adults. Issues Ment Health Nurs2002; 23(3): 279–290.
83.
*KorteJDrossaertCHWesterhofGJ, et al. Life review in groups? An explorative analysis of social processes that facilitate or hinder the effectiveness of life review. Aging Ment Health2014; 18(3): 376–384.
84.
*McConnellTScottDPorterS.Healthcare staff ’s experience in providing end-of-life care to children: a mixed-method review. Palliat Med2016; 30(10): 905–919.
85.
*RodriguezASmithJMcDermidK.Dignity therapy interventions for young people in palliative care: a rapid structured evidence review. Int J Palliat Nurs2018; 24(7): 339–349.
86.
*SantosMWiegandDLSáN, et al. From hospitalization to grief: meanings parents assign to their relationships with pediatric oncology professional. Revista da Escola de Enfermagem da U S P2019; 53: e03521.
87.
*StevensDCamicPMSolwayR.Maintaining the self: meanings of material objects after a residential transition later in life. Educ Gerontol2019; 45(3): 214–226.
88.
*SubramaniamPWoodsB.The impact of individual reminiscence therapy for people with dementia: systematic review. Exp Rev Neuro2012; 12(5): 545–555.
89.
*WymanMFLiebzeitDVoilsCI, et al. “Hopes and wishes”: goals of high-need, high-cost older patients and their caregivers. Patient Educ Couns2020; 103(7): 1428–1434.
