Delirium is a distressing neuropsychiatric disorder affecting patients in palliative care. Although many delirium screening tools exist, their utility, and validation within palliative care settings has not undergone systematic review.
Aim:
To systematically review studies that validate delirium screening tools conducted in palliative care settings.
Design:
Systematic review with narrative synthesis (PROSPERO ID: CRD42019125481). A risk of bias assessment via Quality Assessment Tool for Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 was performed.
Data sources:
Five electronic databases were systematically searched (January 1, 1982–May 3, 2020). Quantitative studies validating a screening tool in adult palliative care patient populations were included. Studies involving alcohol withdrawal, critical or perioperative care were excluded.
Results:
Dual-reviewer screening of 3749 unique titles and abstracts identified 95 studies for full-text review and of these, 17 studies of 14 screening tools were included (n = 3496 patients). Data analyses revealed substantial heterogeneity in patient demographics and variability in screening and diagnostic practices that limited generalizability between study populations and care settings. A risk of bias assessment revealed methodological and reporting deficits, with only 3/17 studies at low risk of bias.
Conclusions:
The processes of selecting a delirium screening tool and determining optimal screening practices in palliative care are complex. One tool is unlikely to fit the needs of the entire palliative care population across all palliative care settings. Further research should be directed at evaluating and/or adapting screening tools and practices to fit the needs of specific palliative care settings and populations.
WattCLMomoliFAnsariMT, et al. The incidence and prevalence of delirium across palliative care settings: a systematic review. Palliat Med2019; 33: 865−877.
2.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM-5. 5th ed.Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Association, 2013.
3.
LeonardMMAgarMSpillerJA, et al. Delirium diagnostic and classification challenges in palliative care: subsyndromal delirium, comorbid delirium-dementia, and psychomotor subtypes. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 48: 199−214.
4.
ZaalIJDevlinJWPeelenLM, et al. A systematic review of risk factors for delirium in the ICU. Crit Care Med2015; 43: 40−47.
5.
McCuskerJColeMGVoyerP, et al. Prevalence and incidence of delirium in long-term care. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2011; 26: 1152−1161.
6.
LeslieDLMarcantonioERZhangY, et al. One-year health care costs associated with delirium in the elderly population. Arch Intern Med2008; 168: 27−32.
7.
BreitbartWGibsonCTremblayA.The delirium experience: delirium recall and delirium-related distress in hospitalized patients with cancer, their spouses/caregivers, and their nurses. Psychosomatics2002; 43: 183−194.
8.
van den BoogaardMSchoonhovenLvan der HoevenJG, et al. Incidence and short-term consequences of delirium in critically ill patients: a prospective observational cohort study. Int J Nurs Stud2012; 49: 775−783.
9.
SalluhJIFWangHSchneiderEB, et al. Outcome of delirium in critically ill patients: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ2015; 350: h2538.
10.
LeonardMMNekolaichukCMeagherDJ, et al. Practical assessment of delirium in palliative care. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 48: 176−190.
11.
LawlorPGBushSH.Delirium diagnosis, screening and management. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care2014; 8: 286−295.
12.
ElsayemAFBrueraEValentineAD, et al. Delirium frequency among advanced cancer patients presenting to an emergency department: a prospective, randomized, observational study. Cancer2016; 122: 2918−2924.
13.
MarchingtonKLCarrierLLawlorPG.Delirium masquerading as depression. Palliat Support Care2012; 10: 59−62.
14.
SmithJAdcockL.The recognition of delirium in hospice inpatient units. Palliat Med2012; 26: 283−285.
15.
IrwinSARaoSBowerKA, et al. Psychiatric issues in palliative care: recognition of delirium in patients enrolled in hospice care. Palliat Support Care2008; 6: 159−164.
16.
MeagherDJLeonardMDonnellyS, et al. A longitudinal study of motor subtypes in delirium: frequency and stability during episodes. J Psychosom Res2012; 72: 236−241.
17.
FangC-KChenH-WLiuS-I, et al. Prevalence, detection and treatment of delirium in terminal cancer inpatients: a prospective survey. Jpn J Clin Oncol2008; 38: 56−63.
18.
NeufeldKJNelliotAInouyeSK, et al. Delirium diagnosis methodology used in research: a survey-based study. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry2014; 22: 1513−1521.
19.
World Health Organization. International classification of diseases and related health problems, 10th revision, https://icd.who.int/browse10/2019/en (2019, accessed August 1 2020).
20.
DeJWandAP.Delirium screening: a systematic review of delirium screening tools in hospitalized patients. Gerontologist2015; 55: 1079−1099.
21.
OhESFongTGHshiehTT, et al. Delirium in older persons: advances in diagnosis and treatment. JAMA2017; 318: 1161−1174.
22.
LawlorPG.Cancer patients with delirium in the emergency department: a frequent and distressing problem that calls for better assessment. Cancer2016; 122: 2783−2786.
23.
WoodhouseRSiddiqiNBolandJW, et al. Delirium screening practice in specialist palliative care units: a survey. BMJ Support Palliat Care. Epub ahead of print May 2020. DOI: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2020-002251.
24.
BolandJWKabirMBushSH, et al. Delirium management by palliative medicine specialists: a survey from the association for palliative medicine of Great Britain and Ireland. BMJ Support Palliat Care. Epub ahead of print March 2019. DOI: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2018-001586.
25.
LawlorPGDavisDHJAnsariM, et al. An analytical framework for delirium research in palliative care settings: integrated epidemiologic, clinician-researcher, and knowledge user perspectives. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 48: 159−175.
26.
BushSHLeonardMMAgarM, et al. End-of-life delirium: issues regarding recognition, optimal management, and the role of sedation in the dying phase. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 48: 215−230.
27.
LawlorPGRutkowskiNMacDonaldAR, et al. A scoping review to map empirical evidence regarding key domains and questions in the clinical pathway of delirium in palliative care. J Pain Symptom Manage2019; 57: 661−681, e612.
MoherDShamseerLClarkeM, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement. Syst Rev2015; 4: 1.
30.
National Institute for Health Research. PROSPERO: international prospective register of systematic reviews, https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero (2020, accessed August 1 2020).
31.
ScottMWebberCBushS, et al. Validated delirium screening tools in palliative care: a systematic review. PROSPERO: international prospective register of systematic reviews. Record ID CRD42019125481, https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?ID=CRD42019125481 (2019, accessed August 1 2020).
32.
LipowskiZ.Delirium updated. Psychosomatic medicine and liaison psychiatry. Boston, MA: Springer, 1980.
WhitingPFRutjesAWSWestwoodME, et al. QUADAS-2: a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies. Ann Intern Med2011; 155: 529−536.
35.
BreitbartWRosenfeldBRothA, et al. The memorial delirium assessment scale. J Pain Symptom Manage1997; 13: 128−137.
36.
CacchionePZ.Four acute confusion assessment instruments: reliability and validity for use in long-term care facilities. J Gerontol Nurs2002; 28: 12−19.
37.
StillmanMJRybickiLA.The Bedside Confusion Scale: development of a portable bedside test for confusion and its application to the palliative medicine population. J Palliat Med2000; 3: 449−456.
38.
de la CruzMNogueraASan Miguel-ArreguiMT, et al. Delirium, agitation, and symptom distress within the final seven days of life among cancer patients receiving hospice care. Palliat Support Care2015; 13: 211−216.
39.
JorgensenSMCarnahanRMWeckmannMT.Validity of the delirium observation screening scale in identifying delirium in home hospice patients. Am J Hosp Palliat Med2017; 34: 744−747.
40.
DetroyerEClementPMBaetenN, et al. Detection of delirium in palliative care unit patients: a prospective descriptive study of the delirium observation screening scale administered by bedside nurses. Palliat Med2014; 28: 79−86.
41.
KangBKimYJSuhSW, et al. Delirium and its consequences in the specialized palliative care unit: validation of the Korean version of memorial delirium assessment scale. Psychooncology2019; 28: 160−166.
42.
LawlorPGNekolaichukCGagnonB, et al. Clinical utility, factor analysis, and further validation of the memorial delirium assessment scale in patients with advanced cancer: assessing delirium in advanced cancer. Cancer2000; 88: 2859−2867.
43.
NeefjesECWvan der VorstMBoddaertMSA, et al. Accuracy of the delirium observational screening scale (DOS) as a screening tool for delirium in patients with advanced cancer. BMC Cancer2019; 19: 160.
44.
RyanKLeonardMGuerinS, et al. Validation of the confusion assessment method in the palliative care setting. Palliat Med2009; 23: 40−45.
45.
SandsMBDantocBPHartshornA, et al. Single question in delirium (SQiD): testing its efficacy against psychiatrist interview, the confusion assessment method and the memorial delirium assessment scale. Palliat Med2010; 24: 561−565.
46.
WilsonJEBoehmLSamuelsLR, et al. Use of the brief confusion assessment method in a veteran palliative care population: a pilot validation study. Palliat Support Care2019; 17: 569−573.
47.
AndrewMKBhatRClarkeB, et al. Inter-rater reliability of the DRS-R-98 in detecting delirium in frail elderly patients. Age Ageing2009; 38: 241−244.
48.
HamanoJMoritaTOzawaT, et al. Validation of the simplified palliative prognostic index using a single item from the communication capacity scale. J Pain Symptom Manage2015; 50: 542−547.
49.
BarahonaEPinhaoRGalindoV, et al. The diagnostic sensitivity of the memorial delirium assessment scale-Spanish version. J Pain Symptom Manage2018; 55: 968−972.
50.
KlankluangWPukrittayakameePAtsariyasingW, et al. Validity and reliability of the memorial delirium assessment scale-Thai version (MDAS-T) for assessment of delirium in palliative care patients. Oncologist2020; 25: e335−e340.
51.
GrassiLCaraceniABeltramiE, et al. Assessing delirium in cancer patients: the Italian versions of the delirium rating scale and the memorial delirium assessment scale. J Pain Symptom Manage2001; 21: 59−68.
52.
InouyeSKvan DyckCAlessiC, et al. Clarifying confusion: the confusion assessment method. A new method for detection of delirium. Ann Intern Med1990; 113: 941−948.
53.
ElyEWInouyeSKBernardGR, et al. Delirium in mechanically ventilated patients: validity and reliability of the confusion assessment method for the intensive care unit (CAM-ICU). JAMA2001; 286: 2703−2710.
54.
BrueraEHuiDDalalS, et al. Parenteral hydration in patients with advanced cancer: a multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled randomized trial. J Clin Oncol2013; 31: 111−118.
55.
van VelthuijsenELZwakhalenSMWarnierRM, et al. Psychometric properties and feasibility of instruments for the detection of delirium in older hospitalized patients: a systematic review. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2016; 31: 974−989.
56.
WongCLHolroyd-LeducJSimelDL, et al. Does this patient have delirium? Value of bedside instruments. JAMA2010; 304: 779−786.
57.
PorteousADewhurstFGrayWK, et al. Screening for delirium in specialist palliative care inpatient units: perceptions and outcomes. Int J Palliat Nurs2016; 22: 444−447.
58.
SpillerJAKeenJC.Hypoactive delirium: assessing the extent of the problem for inpatient specialist palliative care. Palliat Med2006; 20: 17−23.
59.
RaoSFerrisFDIrwinSA.Ease of screening for depression and delirium in patients enrolled in inpatient hospice care. J Palliat Med2011; 14: 275−279.
60.
HjermstadMJLogeJHKaasaS.Methods for assessment of cognitive failure and delirium in palliative care patients: implications for practice and research. Palliat Med2004; 18: 494−506.
61.
HosieADavidsonPMAgarM, et al. Delirium prevalence, incidence, and implications for screening in specialist palliative care inpatient settings: a systematic review. Palliat Med2013; 27: 486−498.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
