Empowering Victims of Organized Crime: On the Concurrence of the Palermo Convention with the Un Declaration on Basic Principles of Justice for Victims

Abstract

In the year 2003 the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised Crime and its protocol against Trafficking in Persons will come into force and create new obligations for State Parties. Both legal instruments contain specific provisions on the rights of victims of organised crime and corruption and of trafficking in persons respectively. An analysis is made of the concurrence of these provisions with the United Nations Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power, adopted by the General Assembly in 1985.

Several of the main principles of justice for victims, such as the right to be protected against offenders, to claim compensation from the offender and to present views in court are honoured by the new legally binding instruments. The Convention and its protocol will give a new global impetus to criminal justice reform on behalf of victims. The right to claim compensation and express views are especially important for representatives of collective interests, such as NGO's supporting victims of trafficking. Such victim representation has become a regular feature of anti-Mafia trials in Italy.

In some other respects, however, these instruments fall short of the UN standards. The rights to be informed, to receive legal assistance, to privacy protection and to state compensation are all notably absent. The Conference of State Parties which will oversee the implementation of the Convention and its protocol should critically assess the practical impact of the victim provisions and make proposals for improvements where appropriate.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashworth

(2000). Victims' Rights, Defendants Rights and Criminal Procedure. In Integrating a Victim Perspective within Criminal Justice ( Crawford

Goodey

, eds) pp. 185–206. Ashgate/Dartmouth; Aldershot.

Brienen

M.E.I.

Hoegen

E.H.

(2000). Victims of Crime in 22 European Criminal Justice Systems: The implementation of Recommendation (85) II of the Council of Europe. Wolf Legal Production; Nijmegen.

Dijk

J.J.M.

(1986). Victims' Rights: A Right to Better Services or a Right of Active Participation? In Criminal Law in Action ( van Dijk

J.J.M.

, eds) pp. 351–375. Gouda Quint; Arnhem.

Dijk

J.J.M.

(1988). The United Nations Declaration on Crime Victims: Priorities for Policy Makers. In International Protection of Victims ( Bassiouni

M.C.

, ed.) pp. 117–126. Nouvelles Etudes Pénales; A.I.O.P. Erès.

Erez

(2000). Integrating a Victim Perspective through Victim Impact Statement. In Integrating a Victim Perspective within Criminal Justice ( Crawford

Goodey

, eds) pp. 165–184. Ashgate/Dartmouth; Aldershot.

Goodey

(2002a). Compensating Victims of Violent Crime in the European Union: The Case for State Restitution. In Reparation and Victim-Focussed Social Work ( Williams

, ed.) pp. 16–33. Jessica Kingsley Publishers; London.

Goodey

(2002b). Recognizing Organised Crime's Victims: The Case of Sex Trafficking in the EU. In Policy Responses to Transnational Organized Crime ( Edvands

Gill

, eds). Routledge; London.

Groenhuysen

(1999). Victims' Rights in the Criminal Justice System: A Call for More Comprehensive Implementation Theory. In Caring for Victims ( van Dijk

J.J.M.

, eds) pp. 85–115. Criminal Justice Press; Monsey, New York.

Jacobs

J.B.

(1999). Gotham Unbound: how New York City was liberated from the grip of Organised Crime. New York University Press; New York.

10.

Joutsen

(1991). Changing Victim Policy: International Dimensions. In: Victims and Criminal Justice ( Kaiser , eds) pp. 765–799. Max Planck Institute; Freiburg.

11.

Kangaspunta

(2001). Counter-trafficking: the Palermo Protocol against Trafficking in Persons and Beyond. Paper presented at the Conference on Orderly Migration, Visions and Challenges for 21st Century, The Hague, 5 Nov. 2001.

12.

Kartusch

(2001). Reference Guide For Anti-Trafficking Legislative Review (with particular emphasis on South Eastern Europe). Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of Human Rights; Vienna.

13.

Lucas

(1988). Commentary on the Main Principles of the Ottawa Draft Declaration. In International Protection of Victims ( Bassiouni

, ed.) pp. 353–369. A.I.O.P.; Erès.

14.

Orlando

(2001). Fighting the Mafia and Renewing Sicilian Culture. Encounter Books; San Francisco.

15.

Park

(1991). The False Claims Act, Qui Tam Relations, and the Government: Which is the Real Party to the Action? Stanford Law Review, 43, 1061–1080.

16.

Sebba

(1999). The Individualisation of the Victim: From Positivism to Postmodernism. In Integrating a Victim Perspective within Criminal Justice ( Crawford

Goodey

, eds) pp. 55–66. Ashgate/Dartmouth; Aldershot.

17.

Separovic

Z.P.

(2001). The Victim Declaration: AQ Substantial Moral Victory for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power. In Beyond Boundaries, Symposium Proceedings, Xth International Symposium on Victimology ( Gaudreault

Waller

, eds) pp. 277–283. Ass. Q. Plaidoyer-Victimes; Québec.

18.

Waller

(1988). International Standards, national trail blazing, and the next steps. In Victims of Crime: A new deal? ( Maguire

Pointing

, eds) pp. 195–204. Open University Press; Milton Keynes.

19.

United Nations Centre for International Crime Prevention (1999). Handbook on Justice for Victims (On the Use and Application of the Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power). United Nations; New York.

20.

United Nations Centre for International Crime Prevention (1999). Guide for Policy Makers (On the Implementation of the United Nations Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power). United Nations; New York.

21.

United Nations Office at Vienna/Centre for Social Development and Humanitarian Affairs (1993). Strategies for Confronting Domestic Violence: a resource manual. United Nations; New York.

22.

United Nations Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, eighth session (1999). Model strategies and practical measures on the elimination of violence against women in the field of crime prevention and criminal justice. United Nations/CICP; Vienna.

23.

Wemmers

J.M.

(1996). Victims in the Criminal Justice System. Kugler Publications; Amsterdam/New York.