An Evaluation of the AirCare Program Based on Cost-Benefit and Cost-Effectiveness Analyses

Abstract

A cost-benefit analysis of the AirCare program in the province of British Columbia on the basis of emissions cost factors from the literature showed a benefit outweighing the cost. Furthermore, a cost-effectiveness analysis comparing the AirCare program with a hybrid-car rebate program revealed that the AirCare program is more effective in reducing emissions of major air pollutants such as NO_x, hydrocarbons, and CO. However, the hybrid-car rebate program contributes significantly to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions because of much greater fuel efficiency, although its contribution to reducing emissions of major air pollutants is small compared with that of the AirCare program. Both the AirCare program and the hybrid-car program are therefore essential to addressing both local air quality improvement and global warming issues, and the programs complement each other.

Keywords

AirCare program cost-benefit analysis cost-effectiveness analysis life-cycle analysis greenhouse gas emissions reduction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Azar, C. , & Sterner, T. (1996). Discounting and distributional considerations in the context of global warming. Ecological Economics, 19, 169-184.

Baram, M. (1980). Cost-benefit analysis: An inadequate basis for health, safety and environmental regulatory decision making. Ecological Law Quarterly, 8, 473-531.

Contadini, J. F. (2005). Social cost comparison among fuel cell vehicle alternatives. Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.methanol.org/fuelcell/special/contadini_pg1.cfm

Delucchi, M. A. , Murphy, J. J. , & McCubbin, D. R. (2002). The health and visibility cost of air pollution: A comparison of estimation methods. Journal of Environmental Management, 64, 139-152.

Gourley, D. I. , Stewart, S. J. , Wong, J. , Buholzer, G. , & Loo, S. (2005). AirCare—Results and observations in 2003 and 2004 (abridged version). Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.aircare.ca/pdfs/2003-2004-Report-Abridged.pdf

Gourley, D. I. , Stewart, S. J. , Wong, J. , & Loo, S. (2003). AirCare—Results and observations in 2001 and 2002 (abridged version). Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.aircare.ca/pdfs/2003Report-AbridgedFinalVersion.pdf

Hartman, R. S. , Wheeler, D. , & Singh, M. (1994). The cost of air pollution abatement (Policy Research Department Working Paper 1398). Washington, DC: World Bank.

IBI Group . (2001). Richmond/Airport-Vancouver Rapid Transit Project: Multiple account evaluation: Final report. Retrieved November 14, 2005, from http://www.city.vancouver.bc.ca/engsvcs/transport/rto/pdf/multiple_account_evaluatio.pdf

Johansson, B. (1999). The economy of alternative fuels when including the cost of air pollution. Transportation Research, D4, 91-108.

10.

Jones, L. , & Coninx, P. (1998). AirCare program just blows smoke—Public spends $63 million a year for less than a $500,000 environmental benefit. Retrieved November 14, 2005, from http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/shared/readmore.asp?sNav=pb&id=210

11.

Nordhaus, W. (1993). Rolling the DICE: An optimal transition path for controlling greenhouse gases. Resource and Energy Economics, 15, 27-50.

12.

Sagoff, M. (1981). At the shrine of our lady of Fatima, or why political questions are not all economic. Arizona Law Review, 23, 1283-1298.

13.

Stewart, S. J. , Gourley, D. I. , & Wong, J. (2001). AirCare—Results and observations relating to the first eight years of operation. Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.aircare.ca/pdfs/AirCare_8yrs.pdf

14.

VanDeVeer, D. , & Pierce, C. (1998). The environmental ethics & policy book: Philosophy, ecology and economics (2nd ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

15.

Victoria Transport Policy Institute . 2005. Transportation cost and benefit analysis—Air pollution costs. Retrieved November 13, 2005, from http://www.vtpi.org/tca/tca0510.pdf

16.

Walsh, M. P. (1999). Existing in use vehicles; the key to short term reductions in mobile source emissions. Retrieved November 14, 2005, from http://www.walshcarlines.com/inspection.html

17.

Wang, M. Q. , Santini, D. J. , & Warinner, S. A. (1995). Monetary values of air pollutants in various U.S. regions. Transportation Research Record, 1475, 33-41.