Supervision of Students May Protect Academic Physicians from Cognitive Bias: A Study of Decision Making and Multiple Treatment Alternatives in Medicine

Abstract

Objective. To determine how professional characteristics and practices of physicians alter the selection of medical treatments involving multiple alternatives. Situations involving multiple alternatives can increase the difficulty of making a decision, resulting in more choice deferral than when fewer alternatives are available. Design, Setting, Participants. A survey and scenario were mailed to a random sample of 314 primary and emergency care physicians affiliated with the Indiana University Medical Center. Using a scenario involving treatment decisions for a patient with osteoarthritis, the effects of multiple treatment alternatives on decision making were explored. Other physician factors included experience, workload, fatigue, continuing education, and supervision. Main Outcome Measures. Physicians’ treatment decisions. Results. Physician response was 61% (n = 192). In contrast to previous studies, physicians in the present study were equally likely to prescribe a new medication, regardless of whether they were deciding about 1 medication or between 2 similar medications (54.5% v. 56.0%, P = 0.841). However, physicians who supervise medical students were far less influenced by the cognitive bias associated with multiple choices than those who did not supervise medical students. Supervising physicians were more likely to defer making a decision when there was only 1 treatment option than when there were 2 (49.3% v. 37%, P = 0.143), whereas the opposite was true for nonsupervising physicians (33.3% v. 63%, P = 0.040). The number of hours spent supervising medical students and the number of years as a physician were also important factors in the decision-making process. Conclusions. Multiple treatment alternatives may result in a deferral of choice. However, this cognitive bias is attenuated by experience and supervision, thus enhancing decision making. Implicit and explicit learning gained through experience and the supervisory process appears to be a central mechanism by which the physicians are protected from this cognitive bias

Keywords

decision making multiple alternatives physician practices supervision learning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Reason J . Human Error. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1990.

Tversky A , Shafir E . Choice under conflict: the dynamics of deferred decision. Psychol Sci. 1992;3:358–361.

Redelmeier DA , Shafir E . Medical decision making in situations that offer multiple alternatives. JAMA. 1995;273:302–335.

Smith PJ , Galdes D , Fraser J , et al. Coping with the complexities of multiple-solution problems: a case study. Int J Man-Machine Stud. 1991;35:429–453.

Glavine MP , Chilingerian JA . Hospital care production and medical errors: organizational responses to improve care. In: Golembiewski RT , ed. Current Topics in Management: Vol. 1. Greenwich, CT: JAI; 1998:193–215.

Alan EL. Relationships among facility design variables and medication errors in a pharmacy [dissertation]. Auburn, AL: Auburn University; 1995.

Krueger GP . Fatigue, performance, and medical error. In: Bogner MS , ed. Human Error in Medicine. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1994:311–326.

Leape LL . Error in medicine. JAMA. 1994;272:1851–1857.

Kass F , Charles E , Eagle P , Yudofsky B . Assessing the impact of supervision on outpatient evaluations in psychiatry. Qual Rev Bull. 1984;10:3–5.

10.

Holliman CJ , Wuerz RC , Kimak MJ , et al. Attending supervision of nonemergency medicine residents in a university hospital ED. Am J Emerg Med. 1995;13:259–261.

11.

Sox CM , Burstin HR , Orav EJ , et al. The effect of supervision of residents on quality of care in five university-affiliated emergency departments. Acad Med. 1998;73:776–782.

12.

Cimino JJ . Development of expertise in medical practice. In: Sternberg RJ , Horvath JA , eds. Tacit Knowledge in Professional Practice: Researcher and Practitioner Perspectives. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1999:101–120.

13.

Olsen NJ . Tailoring arthritis therapy in the wake of the NSAID crisis. N Engl J Med. 2005;352:2578–2580.

14.

Ericsson KA , Krampe RT , Tesch-Römer C . The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychol Rev. 1993;100:363–406.

15.

Mechanic D , McAlpine DD , Rosenthal M . Are patients’ office visits with physicians getting shorter? N Engl J Med. 2001;344:198–204.

16.

Davis D , O’Brien MA , Freemantle N , Wolf FM , Mazmanian P , Taylor-Vaisey A . Impact of formal continuing medical education: do conferences, workshops, rounds, and other traditional continuing education activities change physician behavior or health care outcomes? JAMA. 1999;282:867–874.

17.

Kennedy JJ . Analyzing Qualitative Data: Log-Linear Analysis for Behavioral Research. 2nd ed. New York: Praeger; 1992.

18.

Orlander JD , Gupta M , Fincke BG , Manning ME , Hershman W . Co-teaching: A faculty development strategy. Med Educ. 2000;34:257–265.

19.

Klein G . Developing expertise in decision making. Thinking Reasoning. 1997;3:337–352.

20.

Patel VL , Arocha JF , Kaufman DR . Expertise and tacit knowledge in medicine. In: Sternberg RJ , Horvath JA , eds. Tacit Knowledge in Professional Practice: Researcher and Practitioner Perspectives. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1999:75–99.

21.

Mintz A . How do leaders make decisions? A poliheuristic perspective. J Conflict Resol. 2004;48:3–13.

22.

Dacey R , Carlson LJ . Traditional decision analysis and the poliheuristic theory of foreign policy decision making. J Conflict Resol. 2004;48:38–55.