Construct Validity of the Bidding Game,Binary with Follow-up,and a Novel Structured Haggling Question Format in Determining Willingness to Pay for Insecticide-Treated Mosquito Nets

Abstract

This study examines Whether making question formats better fit the cultural context of markets Would improve the construct validity of estimates of Willingness to pay (WTP). WTP for insecticide-treated mosquito nets Was elicited using the bidding game, binary With follow-up (BWFU), and a novel structured haggling technique (SH) that mimicked price taking in market places in the study area. The results show that different question formats generated different distributions of WTP. Following a comparison of alternative models for each question format, construct validity Was compared using the most consistently appropriate model across question formats for the positive WTP values, in this case, ordinary least squares. Three criteria (the number of statistically significant explanatory variables that had the anticipated sign, the value of the adjusted R², and the proportion that Were statistically significant With the anticipated sign) used to assess the relative performance of each question format indicated that SH performed best and BWFU Worst. However, differences in the levels of income, education, and percentage of household heads responding to the different question formats across the samples complicate this conclusion. Hence, the results suggest that the SH technique is Worthy of further investigation and use.

Keywords

contingent valuation Willingness to pay construct validity theoretical validity question formats structured haggling technique

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Golan EH , Shechter M. Contingent valuation of supplemental health care in Israel. Med Decis Making. 1993;13(4):302—10.

O'Brien B. , Goeree R. , Gafni A. , et al. Assessing the value of a new pharmaceutical: a feasibility study of contingent valuation in managed care. Med Care. 1998;36(3):370—84.

Corso PS , Hammitt JK , Graaham JD , Dieker RC , Goldie SJ Assessing preferences for prevention versus treatment using willingness to pay. Med Decis Making. 2002;22(suppl):S92—101.

Foreit JR , Foreit KG The reliability and validity of willingness to pay surveys for reproductive health pricing decisions in developing countries. Health Policy . 2003;63(1):37—47.

Lenert LA Use of willingness to pay to study values for pharmacotherapies for migraine headache. Med Care. 2003;41(2):299—308.

Mitchell RC , Carson RT Using Surveys to Value Public Goods: The Contingent Valuation Method . Washington (DC): Resources for the Future; 1989.

Diamond P. , Hausman J.

Contingent valuation: is some number better than no number?

J Econ Perspect. 1994;8(4):45—64.

Stavem K. Association of willingness to pay with severity of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, health status and other preference measures. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2002;6(6):542—9.

Baron J. Biases in the quantitative measurement of values for public decisions . Psychol Bull. 1997;122:72—88.

10.

Currie GR , Donaldson C. , O'Brien BJ , Stoddart GL , Torrance GW , Drummond MF Willingness to pay for what? A note of alternate definitions of health care program benefits for contingent valuation studies. Med Decis Making. 2002;22(6):493—7.

11.

Shackley P. , Donaldson C. Should we use willingness to pay to elicit community preferences for health care? New evidence from using a ``marginal'' approach. J Health Econ. 2002 ;21(6):971—91.

12.

Klose T. The contingent valuation method in health care. Health Policy . 1999;47:97—123.

13.

Asgary A. , Willis KG Estimating the benefits of construction measures to mitigate earthquake risks in Iran. Environ Plann B Plann Des. 1997;24(4):613—24.

14.

S treiner DL , Norman GR Health Measurement Scales: Practical Guide to Their Development and Use. 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 1995.

15.

Carmines EG , Zeller RA Reliability and Validity Assessment. London: Sage; 1979.

16.

Luchini S. , Protiere C. , Moatti JP Eliciting several willingness to pay in a single contingent valuation survey: application to health care. Health Econ. 2003 ;12(1):51—64.

17.

Gyldmark M. , Morrison GC Demand for health care in Denmark: results of a national sample survey using contingent valuation. Soc Sci Med. 2001;53(8):1023—36.

18.

Dalmau-Matarrodona E. Alternative approaches to obtain optimal bid values in contingent valuation studies and to model protest zeros: estimating the determinants of individual's willingness to pay for home care services in day care surgery. Health Econ. 2001;10:101—18.

19.

Donaldson C. , Jones AM , Mapp TJ , Olson JA Limited dependent variables in willingness to pay studies: applications in health care. Appl Econ. 1998:30;667—77.

20.

Onwujekwe OE , Nwagbo DFE Investigating starting-point bias: a survey of willingness to pay for insecticide-treated nets. Soc Sci Med. 2002;55(12):2121—30.

21.

Onwujekwe OE , Chima R. , Shu E. , Nwagbo D. , Okonkwo P. Hypothetical and actual willingness to pay for insecticide-treated nets: a study in five Nigerian communities. Trop Med Int Health. 2001;6(7):545—53.

22.

Goodman CA , Mnzava AE , Dlamini SS , Sharp BL , Mthembu DJ , Gumede JK Comparison of the cost and cost-effectiveness of insecticide-treated bednets and residual house-spraying in Kwa-Zulu-Natal, South Africa. Trop Med Int Health. 2001;6(4):280—95.

23.

Johannesson M. , Jonsson B. , Borgquist L. Willingness to pay for anti-hypertensive therapy: results of a Swedish pilot study. J Health Econ. 1991;10(4):461—74.

24.

Hoddinott J. Modelling remittance flows in Kenya. J Afr Econ. 1992;1(2):207—32.

25.

Donaldson C. , Farrar S. , Mapp T. , Walker A. , McPhee S.

Assessing community values in health care: is the ``willingness to pay'' method feasible?

Health Care Anal. 1997;5:7—29.

26.

Guyatt HL , Ochola SA , Snow RW Too poor to pay: charging for insecticide-treated bednets in highland Kenya . Trop Med Int Health. 2002;7(10):846—50.

27.

Loomis J. , Brown T. , Lucero B. , Peterson G. Improving validity experiments of contingent valuation methods: results of efforts to reduce the disparity of hypothetical and actual WTP. Land Econ. 1996;72:450—61.

28.

Brieger WR , Ramakrishna J. , Adeniyi JD Community response to social marketing: filters for guinea worm control . Int Q Community Health Educ. 1989— 1990;19(1):3—17.