A Method for Understanding Some Consequences of Bringing Patient-Generated Data into Health Care Delivery

Abstract

Objective. The consequences of personal health record (PHR) phenomena on the health care system are poorly understood. This research measures one aspect of the phenomena—the time-cost impact of patient-generated data (PGD) using discrete event model (DEM) simulation. Background/Significance. Little has been written about the temporal and cognitive burden associated with new workflows that include PGD. This pilot study reports the results for time-cost and resource utilization of a ‘‘typical’’ ambulatory clinic under varying conditions of PGD burden. Methods. PGD effects are modeled with DEM simulation reflecting the sequential relationships, temporal coupling, and impact assumptions within a virtual clinic. Three simulation scenarios of ever-increasing PGD impact are compared to a baseline case of no PGD use. Results. Introduction of PGD resulted in expected increases in cost and resource utilization along with a few key exceptions and unanticipated consequences. Direct and indirect impacts were observed with notable nonlinear, nonadditive, disproportionate, heterogeneous aspects and interactions among consequent labor cost, visit length, workday length, and resource utilization. The middle-impact simulations showed a 29% increase in daily labor costs and 28% shrinkage of the margin between revenues and labor costs. Lengths of both workday and patient visit were extended and less predictable with PGD use. Utilization rates of most staff positions rose. Nurse utilization rates showed greatest increases. Physicians’ utilization rates paradoxically stayed relatively unchanged. Conclusion. This analysis contributes to an understanding of the effects of PGD on time and cognitive burdens of physicians, staff, and physical resources. It illustrates the usefulness of DEM simulation for the purpose. Avoidable consequences are exposed quantifiably for both the patient and the clinic. More realistic ways to respond to PGD impact are needed.

Keywords

discrete event simulation computerized elicitation of preferences and judgments physician-patient communication resource allocation productivity loss health preference elicitation performance measures decision support techniques.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Tang PC , Ash JS , Bates DW , Overhage JM , Sands DZ Personal health records: definitions, benefits, and strategies for overcoming barriers to adoption. J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2006;13:121-6.

Mazze RS , Shamoon H. , Pasmantier R. , et al. Reliability of blood glucose monitoring by patients with diabetes mellitus. Am J Med. 1984;77:211-7.

Ziegler O. , Kolopp M. , Got I. , Genton P. , Debry G. , Drouin P. Reliability of self-monitoring of blood glucose by CSII-treated patients with type I diabetes. Diabetes Care. 1989;12:184-8.

American College of Physicians. E-Health and Its Impact on Medical Practice. Philadelphia: American College of Physicians; 2008.

Tai-Seale M. , McGuire TG , Zhang W. Time allocation in primary care office visits . Health Serv Res. 2007;42:1871-94.

Pritsker AAB , O’Reilly JJ Simulation with Visual SLAM and AweSim. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley; 1999.

Bergman M. Resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS): a useful tool for practice analysis . Rheumatology. 2003;9:325-7.

Medical Reimbursement Systems I. MRSI’s 2007 Emergency Medicine Reimbursement Update 2007. Available from: www.mrsiinc.com/Reimbursement%202007.pdf