Tests of Preferential Independence in the QALY Model

Abstract

The author presents evidence for the descriptive adequacy of the quality-adjusted life years (QALY) model as applied to health profiles. One important assumption of the model is preferential independence: if two profiles have the same health state during year X, then preference between them does not switch if the level of health changes during year X. In experiment 1, 30-year health profiles were used to perform 27 em pirical tests of independence with 98 subjects. Independence was reliably satisfied in all 27 tests. In experiment 2, 15 additional tests were conducted. These tests had been specifically designed to be more sensitive to independence violations, but indepen dence was still mostly satisfied. In both experiments, the conclusions about indepen dence hold regardless of what discount rate is used. These results act as a "lower bound" on the validity of the QALY model for health profiles. Key words: quality-ad justed life years; QALY model; health profiles; preferential independence. (Med Decis Making 1998;18:418-428)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Weinstein MC , Siegel JE , Gold MR , Kamlet MS , Russell LB Recommendations of the Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. JAMA. 1996;276:1253-8.

Pliskin JS , Shepard DS , Weinstein MC Utility functions for life years and health status. Oper Res. 1980;28:206-24.

Krabbe Pfm , Bonsel GJ Sequence effects, health profiles, and the QALY model. Med Decis Making. 1998;18:178-86.

Gafni A. Time in health: can we measure individuals' "pure time preferences "? Med Decis Making. 1995;15:31-7.

Hall J. , Gerard K. , Salkeld G. , Richardson J. A cost utility analysis of mammography screening in Australia. Soc Sci Med. 1992; 34:993 -1004.

Mehrez A. , Gafni A. Quality-adjusted life years, utility theory, and healthy-years equivalents . Med Decis Making. 1989;9: 142-9. [Erratum. Med Decis Making. 1990;10:148-9].

Mehrez A. , Gafni A. The healthy-years equivalents how to measure them using the standard gamble approach. Med Decis Making. 1991;11:140-6.

Mehrez A. , Gafni A. Healthy-years equivalents versus quality-adjusted life years: in pursuit of progress. Med Decis Making. 1993;13:287-92.

Richardson J. , Hall J. , Salkeld G. The measurement of utility in multiphase health states. Int J Technol. Assess Health Care. 1996;12:151-62.

10.

Culyer AJ , Wagstaff A. QALYs versus HYEs. J Health Econ. 1993;11:311-23.

11.

Johannesson M. , Pliskin JS , Weinstein MC Are healthy-years equivalents an improvement over quality-adjusted life years? Med Decis Making. 1993:13 281-6.

12.

Johannesson M. QALYs, HYEs and individual preferences— a graphical illustration. Soc Sci Med. 1994 ;39:1623-32.

13.

Wakker P. A criticism of healthy-years equivalents. Med Decis Making. 1996;16:207-14.

14.

Loomes G. , McKenzie L. The use of QALYs in health care decision making. Soc Sci Med. 1989;28:299-308.

15.

Keeney RL , Raiffa H. Decisions with multiple objectives: preferences and value tradeoffs . New York: Wiley, 1976.

16.

Bleichrodt H. , Gafni A. Time preference, the discounted utility model and health. J Health Econ. 1996 ;15:49-66.

17.

Miyamoto JM , Lundell JW , Tu S. Sign matching tests for ordinal independence in paired comparison and rating data. Working paper. Department of Psychology, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington.

18.

Loewenstein GF , Prelec D. Preferences for sequences of outcomes . Psychol Rev. 1993;100:91-108.

19.

Naimark D. , Krahn M. , Naglie G. , Redelmeier D. , Detsky A. Primer on decision analysis: Part 5 -Working with Markov processes . Med Decis Making. 1997;17:152-9.

20.

Kuppermann M. , Shiboski S. , Feeny D. , Elkin EP , Washington AE Can preference scores for discrete states be used to derive preference scores for an entire path of events? An application to prenatal diagnosis. Med Decis Making. 1997 ;17: 42-55.