Vulnerability Reduction and Political Responsiveness: Explaining Executive Decisions in U.S. Disaster Policy during the Ford and Carter Administrations*
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online August, 2002
Vulnerability Reduction and Political Responsiveness: Explaining Executive Decisions in U.S. Disaster Policy during the Ford and Carter Administrations*
Decision-making by elected executives on disaster policy reflects comprehensive vulnerability management, political responsiveness to the media, political negotiation, and intergovernmental conflict. If vulnerability reduction is a significant influence, executive decisions should reflect political and social vulnerability and self-sufficiency. If political responsiveness influences disaster decisions, executive decisions should also reflect media coverage, proximity to elections, and decisions at other levels of government. The data set included 293 major disaster requests between 1974 and 1981. The analysis used multiple regression and logistic regression. Vulnerability reduction had an impact on aid decisions. Political responsiveness affected most decisions on disaster relief. The Ford administration was more sensitive to both responsiveness and vulnerability than the Carter administration. Overall, nationalization of disaster assistance has made the achievement of vulnerability management more difficult. The absence of minimum criteria has increased the discretion of executive choice.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaroneMichael, and UjifusaGrant. 1976. Almanac of American Politics.Boston: Gambit.
2.
BaroneMichael, and UjifusaGrant. 1978. Almanac of American Politics.Boston: Gambit
3.
BaroneMichael, and UjifusaGrant. 1980. Almanac of American Politics.Boston: Gambit.
4.
BirklandThomas A.1997. After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy, and Focusing Events.Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
5.
BucklesAndre. 1976. “F.D.A.A. National Disasters; Emergency Declarations.” 4 February. Gerald R. Ford Library. Domestic Council. Frederick Lynn May Files. Box 9. Folder: FDAA -Background (1).
6.
CannonJim. 1976. “Signing of the Teton Dam Relief Legislation.” 7 September. Gerald R. Ford Library. White House Central Files. Subject Files. DI. Box 4. Folder DI 2/ST 12.
7.
Congressional Quarterly, Inc.1974. America Votes. Vol. 11. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly, Elections Research Center.
8.
Congressional Quarterly, Inc.1976. America Votes. Vol. 12. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly, Elections Research Center.
9.
Congressional Quarterly, Inc.1978. America Votes. Vol. 13. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly, Elections Research Center.
DonahueAmy K., and JoycePhilip G.. 2001. “A Framework Tor Analyzing Emergency Management with an Application to Federal Budgeting.” Public Administration Review61: 728–740.
13.
DrabekThomas E.1991. “The Evolution of Emergency Management.” Pp. 3–29 in Emergency Management: Principles and Practice for Local Government, edited by DrabekThomas E., and HoetmerGerard J.. Washington, DC: International City Management Association.
14.
EdelmanMurray J.1988. Constructing the Political Spectacle.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
15.
EizenstatStu, and DaftLynn. 1978. “Recommended Approval for Major Disaster Declaration Due to Severe Storms, Flooding, and Mudslides - Montana and Wyoming.” 29 May 29 Jimmy Carter Presidential Library. White House Central Files. Subject Files. Box DI–11. Folder: DI-2/ ST 26 1/20/77–1/20/81 (Executive).
16.
EizenstatStu, and KirschenbaumBruce, and DaftLynn. 1980. “Recommendation for an Emergency Declaration for New Jersey Due to Drought.” 18 October. Jimmy Carter Presidential Library. White Mouse Central Files. Subject Files. Box DI–12. Folder DI–2/ ST 30. 2/1/78–1/20/81 (Executive).
17.
Federal Disaster Act.1950. Public Law 81–875.
18.
FEMA.2000. Partnership for a Safer Future: Federal Emergency Management Agency Strategic Plan FY 2000 through FY 2006.Washington, DC: Federal Emergency Management Agency.
19.
FEMA. n.d. Project Impact.Washington, DC: Federal Emergency Management Agency.
20.
FEMA. Office of Inspector General, Inspections Division. 1999. Review of Governors ‘Disaster Requests.Washington, DC: Federal Emergency Management Agency.
21.
GAO. August2001. Disaster Assistance: Improvement Needed in Disaster Declaration Criteria and Eligibility Assurance Procedures.Washington, DC: U. S. General Accounting Office.
22.
HyRonald John, and WaughWilliam L.Jr.1990. “The Function of Emergency Management.” Pp. 11–26 in Handbook of Emergency Management: Programs and Policies Dealing with Major Hazards and Disasters, edited by WaughWilliam L.Jr., and RonaldJohn Hy.Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
23.
KartezJack D., and LindellMichael K.. 1990. “Adaptive Planning for Community Disaster Response.” Pp. 5–31 in Cities and Disasters: North American Studies in Emergency Management, edited by SylvesRichard T., and WaughWilliam L.Jr.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
24.
KingdonJohn W.1995. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies.New York: HarperCollins.
25.
KulikBerke. 1999. Interview with the Associate Director of Disaster Assistance, Small Business Administration, 19 July.
26.
LowiTheodore. 1964. “American Business, Public Policy, Case Studies, and Political Theory” World Politics16: 677–715.
27.
MayF. Lynn. 1976. “Turndown of Major Disaster Declaration for Texas Due to Floods.” 9 June. Gerald R. Ford Library. While House Central Files. Subject Files. Box DI–8. Folder: DI 2/ ST 43 1/1/76—1/20/77 (Executive).
28.
McEntireDavid A., and FullerChristopher, and JohnsonChad W., and WeberRichard. 2002. “A Comparison of Disaster Paradigms: The Search for a Holistic Policy Guide.” Public Administration Review62: 267–281.
29.
MiletiDennis S.1999. Disasters by Design: A Reassessment of Natural Hazards in the United States.Washington, DC: Joseph Henry Press.
30.
NAPA.1993. Coping with Catastrophe: Building an Emergency Management System to Meet People's Needs in Natural and Manmade Disasters.Washington, DC: National Academy of Public Administration.
31.
National Governors Association.1979. 1979 Emergency Preparedness Project: Final Report.Washington, DC: National Governors Association Office of State Services.
32.
RossiPeter PL, and WrightJames D., and Weber-BurdinEleanor. 1982. Natural Hazards and Public Choice: The State and Local Politics of Hazard Mitigation.New York: Academic Press, Inc.
33.
SchneiderSaundra K.1995. Flirting with Disaster; Public Management in Crisis Situations.Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe, Inc.
34.
SettleAllen K.1990. “Disaster Assistance: Securing Presidential Declarations.” Pp. 33–56 in Cities and Disasters: North American Studies in Emergency Management, edited by SylvesRichard T., and WaughWilliam L.Jr.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
35.
Stafford Act.1988. Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act of 1988. P.L. 100–707. 102 Start. 4689.
36.
SylvesRichard T.1996. “The Politics and Budgeting of Federal Emergency Management.” Pp. 26–45 in Disaster Management in the U.S. and Canada: The Politics, Policymaking, Administration and Analysis of Emergency Management, edited by SylvesRichard T., and WaughWilliam L.Jr.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
37.
SylvesRichard T., and WaughWilliam L.Jr. (eds.). 1996. Disaster Management in the U.S. and Canada: The Politics, Policymaking, Administration and Analysis of Emergency Management.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
38.
U. S. Bureau of the Census.1977. County and City Data Book.Washington, DC: U. S. Government Printing Office.
39.
WamsleyGary L., and SchroederAaron D.. 1996. “Escalating in a Quagmire: The Changing Dynamics of the Emergency Management Policy Subsystem.” Public Administration Review56: 235–244.
40.
WaughWilliam L.Jr.1996. “Disaster Management for the New Millennium.” Pp. 344–359 in Disaster Management in the U.S. and Canada: The Politics, Policymaking, Administration and Analysis of Emergency Management, edited by SylvesRichard T., and WaughWilliam L.Jr.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
41.
WaughWilliam L.Jr., and RonaldJohn Hy.1990. “Introduction to Emergency Management.” Pp. 1–10 in Handbook of Emergency Management: Programs and Policies Dealing with Major Hazards and Disasters, edited by WaughWilliam L.Jr., and RonaldJohn Hy.Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
