To evaluate the quality of life (QOL) in patients with early stage invasive carcinoma of the breast treated with conservative surgery and postoperative irradiation.
Methods
A mailed survey to examine QOL was conducted in 227 subjects with breast cancer treated in 1990 and 1994 with conservation surgery plus definitive irradiation. The self-compiled questionnaire was developed based on a series of 38 items assessing six core areas of QOL. Furthermore, the patients were requested to evaluate the degree of information provided by the medical staff concerning the disease, the treatment and related side effects and to evaluate the effects of the treatment on their social, overall QOL, and health status.
Results
The questionnaire was completed by 156 patients (68.7%) who had a median age of 56 years (range, 28–75 years) at the time of treatment and 59 years (range, 31–82 years) at the time of the study. The physical condition was reported to be good. Data relating to sexual life were provided by more than 90% of the patients. Some limitations in sexuality, some interference with sexual desire, and some modifications during intercourse were reported by 11, 11, and 10 patients, respectively. The subjective evaluations of the cosmetic results of the therapies were judged good-excellent by 56% of the patients, 12 (8%) only had a negative perception of their body image. Twenty-five percent of the sample declared that they felt tense, 19% nervous, 18% lonely, 27% anxious and 16% depressed. Only six patients (4%) declared that the treatment had had a bad on their social life, and 18 (11%) thought that their health status has been affected by the treatment. A worsening of QOL due to the disease or the treatment was reported by 8% of the responders. The amount of information received concerning the treatment and its side effects was considered sufficient by most of the patients.
Conclusions
The results of the study revealed a satisfactory health-related QOL in patients treated with breast conservation and postoperative irradiation. A preserved favorable body image and lack of a negative impact on sexuality was observed, even though about half of the patients reported a negative judgement on esthetic outcome. Some patients had persistent psychosocial concerns. No significant additional problems attributable to radiation therapy capable of affecting QOL outcomes were reported.
BeaconH.J.ThompsonS.G.: Multi-level models for repeated measurements data: application to quality of life data in clinical trials.Stat Med, 15: 2717–2732, 1996.
2.
BradyM.J.CellaD.F.MoF.BonomiA.E.TulskyD.S.LloydS.R.DeasyS.CobleighM.ShiomotoG.: Reliability and validity of the functional assessment of cancer therapy - breast quality of life instrument.J Clin Oncol, 15, 974–986, 1997.
3.
KatzS.: The science of quality of life.J Chron Dis, 6: 459–463, 1987.
4.
LevineM.N.GuyattG.H.GentM.De PauwS.GoodyearM.D.HryniukW.M.ArnoldA.FindlayB.SkillingJ.R.BramwellV.H.: Quality of life in stage II breast cancer: an instrument for clinical trials.J Clin Oncol, 6: 1798–1810, 1988.
5.
MercierM.SchraubS.BransfieldD.D.BarthodL.: Measurement of quality of life. Application to the screening of psychological distress in cancer patients.Bull Cancer, 79: 193–204, 1992.
6.
SpilkerB.MolinekF.JohnstonK.SimpsonR.L.Jr., TilsonH.H.: Quality of life bibliography and indexes.Med Care, 28 Suppl, DS1–77, 1990.
7.
WilkinD.HallamL.DoggettM.: Measures of need and outcome for primary care.Oxford University Press, Oxford1992.
8.
AaproM.CullA.: Depression in breast cancer patients: the need for treatment.Ann Oncol, 10: 627–636, 1999.
9.
GanzP.A.Coscarelli-SchagA.LeeJ.PolinskyM.L.TanS.: Breast conservation versus mastectomy. Is there a difference in psychological adjustment or quality of life in the year after surgery?Cancer, 68: 1729–1738, 1992.
10.
LevyS.M.HaynesL.T.HerbermanR.B.LeeJ.McFeeleyS.KirkwoodJ.: Mastectomy versus breast conservation surgery: mental health effects at long-term follow-up.Health Psychol, 11: 349–354, 1992.
11.
NIH Consensus Conference.Treatment of early-stage breast cancer.JAMA, 265: 391–395, 1991.
12.
MeyerowitzB.E.: Psychological correlates of breast cancer and its treatment.Psychol Bull, 87: 108–131, 1980.
13.
DunnJ.StegingaS.K.OcchipintiS.WilsonK.McCaffeyJ.: Profiles of distress in women following treatment for primary breast cancer.Breast, 7: 251–254, 1998.
14.
SchoverL.R.: The impact of breast cancer on sexuality, body image, and intimate relationships.CA-A Cancer J, 41: 112–121, 1991.
15.
ScottC.B.: Issues in quality of life assessment during cancer therapy.Semin Radiat Oncol, 8(suppl. 1): 5–9, 1998.
16.
AmichettiM.CaffoO.ArcicasaM.RoncadinM.LoraO.RigonA.ZiniG.ArmaroliL.CoghettoF.ZoratP.NeriS.TeodoraniN.: Quality of life in patients with ductal carcinoma in situ of the breast treated with conservative surgery and postoperative irradiation.Breast Cancer Res Treat, 54: 109–115, 1999.
17.
CaffoO.AmbrosiniG.AgugiaroS.EccherC.MalutaS.: The influence of both surgery and adjuvant chemotherapy on breast cancer women quality of life. In: Cancer treatment update, BanzetP, HollandJF, KhayatD, WeilM (Eds), pp 677–680, Springer-Verlag, Paris, 1994.
18.
ArmitageP.BerryG.: Statistical methods in medical research.Blackwell, Oxford, 1987.
19.
FallowfieldL.J.: Assessment of quality of life in breast cancer.Acta Oncol, 34: 689–694, 1995.
20.
StefanekM.E.: Quality of life and other psychosocial issues in breast cancer.Curr Opin Oncol, 6: 583–586, 1994.
21.
CataliottiL.CostaA.DalyP.A.FallowfieldL.FreilichG.HolmbergL.PiccartM.van de VeldeC.J.H.VeronesiU.: Florence statement on breast cancer, 1998, forging the way ahead for more research on and better care in breast cancer.Eur J Cancer, 35: 14–15, 1999.
22.
JamesonK.R.WellischD.K.PasnauR.O.: Psychosocial aspects of mastectomy: I. The woman's perspective.Am J Psychol, 135: 432–436, 1978.
23.
MaguireG.P.LeeE.G.BevingtonD.J.KuchemannC.S.CrabtreeR.J.CornellC.E.: Psychiatric problems in the first year after mastectomy.Br Med J, 1: 963–965, 1978.
24.
MorrisT.GreerH.S.WhiteP.: Psychological and social adjustment to mastectomy.Cancer, 40: 2381–2387, 1977.
25.
WellischD.K.JamesonK.R.PasnauR.O.: Psychosocial aspects of mastectomy: II. The man's perspective.Am J Psychol, 135: 543–546, 1978.
26.
GraydonE.J.: Women with breast cancer: their quality of life following a course of radiation therapy.J Adv Nurs, 19: 617–622, 1994.
27.
FallowfieldL.J.HallA.MaguireG.P.BaumM.: Psychological outcome of different treatment policies in women with breast cancer outside a clinical trial.Br Med J, 301: 575–580, 1990.
28.
KiebertG.M.deHaesJ.C.van de VeldeC.J.: The impact of breast conserving treatment and mastectomy on the quality of life of early-stage breast cancer patients: a review.J Clin Oncol, 9: 1059–1070, 1991.
29.
MaunsellE.BrissonJ.DeschenesL.: Psychological distress after initial treatment for breast cancer: a comparison of partial and total mastectomy.J Clin Epidemiol, 42: 765–771, 1989.
30.
McArdleJ.M.HughsonA.V.M.McArdleC.S.: Reduced psychological morbidity after breast conservation.Br J Surg, 77: 1221–1223, 1990.
31.
SteimbergM.D.JulianoM.A.WiseL.: Psychological outcome of lumpectomy versus mastectomy in the treatment of breast cancer.Am J Psychiatry, 142: 34–39, 1985.
32.
PoulsenB.GraversenH.P.BeckmannJ.Blichert-ToftM.: A comparative study of post-operative psychosocial function in women with primary operable breast cancer randomized to breast conservation therapy or mastectomy.Eur J Surg Oncol, 23: 327–334, 1997.
33.
PeckA.BolandI.: Emotional reactions to radiation treatment.Cancer, 40: 180–184, 1977.
34.
NorhouseL.L.: Psychological impact of the diagnosis of breast cancer on the patient and her family.J Am Med Womens Assoc, 47: 161–164, 1992.
35.
IrvineR.N.BrownB.CrooksD.RobertsJ.BrowneG.: Psychosocial adjustment in women with breast cancer.Cancer, 67: 1097–1117, 1991.
36.
MargolisG.J.GoodmanR.L.: Psychological factors in women choosing radiation therapy for adjuvant radiotherapy.Psychosomatics, 25: 464–469, 1984.
37.
PozoC.CarverC.S.NoriegaV.HarrisS.D.RobinsonD.S.KetchamA.S.LegaspiA.MoffatF.L.Jr., ClarkK.L.: Effects of mastectomy versus lumpectomy on emotional adjustment to breast cancer: a prospective study of the first year postsurgery.J Clin Oncol, 10: 1292–1298, 1992.
38.
StefanekM.E.: Psychosocial aspects of breast cancer.Curr Opin Oncol, 5: 996–1000, 1993.
39.
TaylorS.E.LichtmanR.R.WoodJ.V.BlumingA.Z.DosikG.M.LeibowitzR.L.: Illness-related and treatment-related factors in psychological adjustment to breast cancer.Cancer, 55: 2506–2513, 1985.
40.
WainstockJ.: Breast cancer: psychosocial consequences for the patients.Semin Oncol Nurs, 7: 207–215, 1991.
41.
KemenyM.WellischD.K.SchainW.F.: Psychosocial outcome in a randomized surgical trial for treatment of primary breast cancer.Cancer, 62: 1231–1237, 1988.
42.
NoguchiM.SaitoY.NishijimaH.KoyanagiM.NomomuraA.MizukamiY.NakamuraS.MichihishiT.OhtaN.KitagawaH.: The psychological and cosmetic aspects of breast conserving therapy compared with radical mastectomy.Surg Today, 23: 598–602, 1993.
43.
GanzP.A.DesmondK.A.BelinT.R.MeyerowitzB.E.RowlandJ.H.: Predictors of sexual health in women after a breast cancer diagnosis.J Clin Oncol, 17: 2371–2380, 1999.
44.
MorV.MalinM.AllenS.: Age differences in the psychosocial problem encountered by breast cancer patients.Monogr Natl Cancer Inst, 16: 191–197, 1994.
45.
VinokurA.D.ThreattB.A.Vinokur-KaplanD.SatarianoD.A.: The process of recovery from breast cancer for younger and older patients.Cancer, 65: 1242–1254, 1998.
46.
WenzelL.B.FaircloughD.L.BradyM.J.CellaB.GarrettK.M.KlushmanB.C.CranelA.MarcusA.C.: Age-related difference in the quality of life of breast cancer patients after cancer.Cancer, 86: 1768–1774, 1999.
47.
SilvermanD.C.EdbrilS.GartrellN.WiseN.BotnickL, Liao-RosemblattE.HuntleyB.: A pilot study of women's attitude towards breast-conserving surgery with primary, radiation therapy for breast cancer.Int J Psychiatry Med, 15: 381–391, 1985.
48.
van HeeringenC.van MoffaertM.de CupypereG.: Depression after surgery for breast cancer.Psychother Psychosomatics, 51: 175–179, 1989.
49.
HaydenK.MoinpourC.MetchB.FeiglP.: Pitfalls in quality of life assessment: lessons from a Southwest Oncology Group breast cancer trial.Oncol Nurs Forum, 20: 1415–1419, 1993.
50.
HammickM.TuttA.TaitD.M.: Knowledge and perception regarding radiotherapy and radiation in patients receiving radiotherapy: a qualitative study.Eur J Cancer Care, 7: 102–112, 1998.
51.
HollandJ.C.RowlandJ.LebovitsA.: Reactions to cancer treatments: assessment of emotional response to adjuvant radiotherapy as a guide to planned intervention.Psychiatr Clin North Am, 2: 347–358, 1979.
52.
MarasteR.BrandtL.OlssonH.Ryde BrandtB.: Anxiety and depression in breast cancer patients at start of adjuvant radiotherapy.Acta Oncol, 31: 641–643, 1992.
53.
MargolisG.GoodmanR.RubinA.: Psychological effects of breast conserving cancer treatment and mastectomy.Psychosomatics, 31: 33–39, 1990.
54.
RowlandJ.MassieM.J.: Psychologic reactions to breast cancer diagnosis, treatment, and survival.In: Diseases of the breast, HarrisJ.R.LippmanL.M.E.MorrowM.HellmanS. (Eds), pp 919–938, Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia, 1996.
55.
WalkerL.G.EreminO.: Psychological assessment and intervention: future prospects for women with breast cancer.Semin Surg Oncol, 12: 76–81, 1996.
56.
CaffoO.FellinG.GrafferU.LucianiL.: Assessment of quality of life after radical radiotherapy for prostate cancer.Br J Urol, 78: 557–563, 1996.
57.
AnnunziataM.A.FoladoreS.MagriM.D.CrivellariD.FeltrinA.BidoliE.VeronesiA.: Does the information level of cancer patients correlate with quality of life?A prospective study. Tumori, 84: 619–623, 1998.
58.
WatsonM.GreerS.RowdenL.GormanC.RobertsonB.BlissJ.M.TunmoreR.: Relationship between emotional control, adjustment to cancer and depression and anxiety in breast cancer patients.Psychol Med, 21: 51–57, 1991.
