This study of the effects of three years of piano instruction is based on a sample of 117 fourth-grade children attending public schools in Montreal. The children had never participated in formal music instruction, did not have a piano at home, and their annual family income was below $40,000 Can. Children in the experimental group (n= 63) received individual piano lessons weekly for three years and were given an acoustic piano at no cost to their families. Children in the control group (n= 54) did not participate in formal music instruction. Participants were administered tests of self-esteem, academic achievement, cognitive abilities, musical abilities, and motor proficiency at the beginning of the project and throughout the three years of piano instruction. The results indicated that piano instruction had a positive effect on children’s self-esteem and school music marks but did not affect their academic achievement in math and language as measured by standardized tests and school report cards.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Amchin, R., Kopf, T. and Weaver, M. (1991) ‘Effects of Arts Education on High School Student Self-Concept’ , paper presented at the convention of the Ohio Music Educators Association, February, Cleveland, OH.
2.
Barnet, R.D. (1987) ‘Differential Validity and Prediction of Academic Success of Music Students’ , Dissertation Abstracts International47(7): 2472A–2472A .
3.
Chan, A.S., Ho, Y.C. and Cheung, M.C. (1998) ‘Music Training Improves Verbal Memory’ , Nature396: 128–128 .
4.
Clendenon-Wallen, J. (1991) ‘The Use of Music Therapy to Influence the Self-Confidence and Self-esteem of Adolescents who are Sexually Abused’ , Music Therapy Perspectives9: 73–81 .
5.
Cutietta, R. (1995) ‘Does Music Instruction Help a Child Learn to Read?’ , General Music Today9(1): 26–31 .
6.
Cutietta, R. (1996a) ‘Language and Music Programs’ , General Music Today9(1): 26–31 .
7.
Cutietta, R. (1996b) ‘Does Music Instruction Aid Mathematical Skills?’ , General Music Today9(3): 28–30 .
8.
Cutietta, R. (1996c) ‘Does Music Instruction Aid Academic Skills?’ , General Music Today10(1): 24–27 .
9.
DeGraffenreid, G. (1996) ‘A Comparison of the Music Scores of Fifth-Grade Students in Three Elementary Schools’ , paper presented at the Music Educators National Conference, Kansas City.
10.
Duke, B., Flowers, P. and Wolfe, D. (1997) ‘Children Who Study Piano with Excellent Teachers’ , Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education132: 51–85 .
11.
Frakes, L. (1985) ‘Differences in Music Achievement, Academic Achievement, and Attitude among Participants, Dropouts, and Nonparticipants in Secondary School Music’ , Dissertation Abstracts International46(2): 370A–370A . University Microfilms No. AAC8507938.
12.
Graziano, A.B., Peterson, M., and Shaw, G.L. (1999) ‘Enhanced Learning of Proportional Math through Music Training and Spatial Temporal Reasoning’ , Neurological Research21: 139–152 .
13.
Harding, J.A. (1990) ‘The Relationship between Music and Language Achievement in Early Childhood’ , Dissertation Abstracts International52(10): 3148A–3148A .
14.
Hetland, L. (2000) ‘Learning to Make Music Enhances Spatial Reasoning’ , Journal of Aesthetic Education34: 179–238 .
15.
Hietolahti-Ansten, M. and Kalliopuska, M. (1991) ‘Self-esteem and Empathy among Children Actively Involved in Music’ , Perceptual and Motor Skills72: 1364–1366 .
16.
Hurwitz, I., Wolff, P., Bortnick, B. and Kokas, K. (1975) ‘Nonmusical Effects of the Kodaly Music Curriculum in Primary Grade Children’ , Journal of Learning Disabilities8(3): 45–52 .
17.
Kivland, M. (1986) ‘The Use of Music to Increase Self-esteem in Conduct Disordered Adolescents’ , Journal of Music Therapy15(1): 136–144 .
18.
Kooyman, R.J. (1989) ‘An Investigation of the Effect of Music upon the Academic, Affective, and Attendance Profile of Selected Fourth Grade Students’ , Dissertation Abstracts International49(11): 3265A–3265A .
19.
Kvet, E.J. (1985) ‘Excusing Elementary Students from Regular Classroom Activities for the Study of Instrumental Music: The Effect on Sixth-Grade Reading, Language, and Mathematics Achievement’ , Journal of Research in Music Education26: 65–75 .
20.
Lamar, H.B. (1990) ‘An Examination of the Congruency of Music Aptitude Scores and Mathematics and Reading Achievement Scores of Elementary Children’ , Dissertation Abstracts International51(3): 778A–779A .
21.
Legette, R.M. (1994) ‘The Effect of a Selected Use of Music Instruction on the Self-Concept and Academic Achievement of Elementary Public School Students’ , Dissertation Abstracts International54(7): 2502A–2502A .
22.
Linch, S.A. (1994) ‘Differences in Academic Achievement and Level of Self-Esteem among High School Participants in Instrumental Music, Non-Participants, and Students Who Discontinue Instrumental Music Education’ , Dissertation Abstracts International54(9): 3362A–3362A .
23.
Lomen, D.O. (1970) ‘Changes in Self-Concept Factors: A Comparison of Fifth-Grade Instrumental Music Participants and Nonparticipants in Target and Nontarget Schools in Des Moines, Iowa’ , Dissertation Abstracts International31: 3962A–3962A .
24.
Michel, D.E. (1971) ‘Self-Esteem and Academic Achievement in Black Junior High School Students: Effects of Automated Guitar Instruction’ , Council for Research in Music Education24: 15–23 .
25.
Michel, D.E. and Farrell, D.M. (1973) ‘Music and Self-esteem: Disadvantaged Problem Boys in an All Black Elementary School’ , Journal of Research in Music Education21: 80–84 .
26.
Nolin, W. and Vander Ark, S. (1977) ‘A Pilot Study of Patterns of Attitudes toward School Music Experiences, Self-esteem and Socio-economic Status in Elementary and Junior High School Students’ , Contributions to Music Education5: 31–46 .
27.
Rauscher, R., Shaw, G. and Ky, N. (1995) ‘Listening to Mozart Enhances Spatial-Temporal Reasoning: Towards a Neurophysiological Basis’ , Neuroscience Letters185: 44–44 .
28.
Rauscher, R., Shaw, G., Levine, L., Wright, E., Dennis, W. and Newcomb, R. (1997) ‘Music Training Causes Long-term Enhancement of Preschool Children’s Spatialtemporal Reasoning’ , Neurological Research19: 2–2 .
29.
Schellenberg, E.G. (2001) ‘Music and Nonmusical Abilities’, in R. Zatorre and I. Peretz (eds) ‘The Biological Foundations of Music’, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 930: 355–371.
30.
Schreiber, E. H. (1988) ‘Influence of Music on College Students’ Achievement’ , Perceptual and Motor Skills66: 338–338 .
31.
Stancarone, M. (1992) ‘The Role of Music Aptitude, Fine Motor Skills, Coding, Ability, Behavioral and Academic Achievement in Predicting Achievement in Instrumental Music’ , Dissertation Abstracts International53(3): 1596B–1596B .
32.
Teaching Music (1995) ‘Study Music, Score High II’ , Teaching Music3(3): 47–47 .
33.
Teaching Music (2000) ‘Data Show a Positive Correlation between Music Education and Other Success Indicators’ , Teaching Music7(6): 54–55 .
34.
Teaching Music (2001) ‘SAT Scores and the Arts: Consistent Results’ , Teaching Music8(4): 62–63 .
35.
Thompson, W.F., Schellenberg, E.G., and Husain, G. (2002) ‘Decoding Speech Prosody: Do Music Lessons Help?’ , paper presented at The Neurosciences and Music conference, October, Venice.
36.
Trusty, J. and Oliva, G. (1994) ‘The Effect of Arts and Music Education on Students’ Self-concept’ , Update: Applications of Research in Music Education13(1): 23–28 .
37.
Turnipseed, J.P. (1978) ‘The Relationship between Participation in Structural Classical Music Education Programs and Academic Skills and Other School-Related Variables of Selected First-Grade Children’, in E. Asmus (ed.) Proceedings of the Research Symposium on the Psychology and Acoustics of Music, pp. 142–154. Kansas: University of Kansas Press .
38.
Vaughn, K. (2000) ‘Music and Mathematics: Modest Support for the Oft-claimed Relationship’ , Journal of Aesthetic Education34(3/4): 149–166 .
39.
Wagner, M.J. and Menzel, M.B. (1977) ‘The Effect of Music Listening and Attentiveness Training on the EEG’s of Musicians and Nonmusicians’ , Journal of Music Therapy14: 151–164 .
40.
Wamhoff, M.J. (1972) ‘A Comparison of Self-concept of Fourth Grade Students Enrolled and Not Enrolled in Instrumental Music in Selected Schools in the Barstow, California School District’ , Dissertation Abstracts International33: 626A–626A .
41.
Wig, J.A. and Boyle, J.D. (1982) ‘The Effect of Keyboard Learning Experiences on Middle School General Music Students’ Music Achievement and Attitudes’ , Journal of Research in Music Education30(3): 163–172 .
42.
Wood, A.L. (1973) ‘The Relationship of Selected Factors to Achievement Motivation and Self-esteem among Senior High School Band Members’ , Dissertation Abstracts International35: 1150A–1150A .
