The Effect of Perceptual Mode Preferences and Other Selected Variables on Upper Elementary School Students' Responses to Conservation-Type Rhythmic and Melodic Tasks
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online April, 1992
The Effect of Perceptual Mode Preferences and Other Selected Variables on Upper Elementary School Students' Responses to Conservation-Type Rhythmic and Melodic Tasks
This study examined eight through 12-year-olds' (grades three through six) ability to perform the conservation-type tasks in music developed by Webster and Zimmerman (1983). The learning styles of the students, specifically their perceptual mode preferences, were determined by the Dunn, Dunn and Price Learning Style Inventory (1986). Students with visual, tactile, and kinesthetic preferences were chosen for the study. Specific reinforcement (graphic notation; clapping rhythm and shaping melodies) was given to the experimental groups during the musical testing. The dependent variables of rhythmic conservation and melodic conservation were analysed separately using a 4x3x2 ANOVA design. Conservation scores were evaluated with preference group (control tactile-kinesthetic, control visual, experimental tactile-kinesthetic, and experimental visual), grade (3-4, 5 and 6) and gender as independent variables. Significant effects were found for group but not for grade level or gender when melodic conservation scores were analysed. The rhythmic conservation analysis revealed significant main effects for group and grade level, as well as a significant three-way interaction.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Apfelstadt, H.
(1986). Learning modality: A potential clue in the search for vocal accuracy. Update, 4(3), 4-6.
2.
Barbe, B.
and Milone, N. Jr. (1981, February). What we know about modality strengths. Educational Leadership, 378-380.
3.
Bartholomew, D.
(1987). Problems with Piagetian conservation and musical objects. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 93, 27-40.
4.
Bebeau, M. J.
(1982). Effects of traditional and simplified methods of rhythm-reading instruc- tion. Journal of Research in Music Education, 30, 107-119.
5.
Bennett, C.
(1979). Individual differences and how teachers perceive them. Social Studies, 70(2), 56-61.
6.
Botvin, G. J.
(1974). Acquiring conservation of melody and cross-modal transfer through successive approximation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 22, 226-233.
7.
Carbo, M. (1980). An analysis of the relationship between the modality preferences of kindergartners and selected reading treatments as they affect the learning of a basic sight-word vocabulary. Dissertation Abstracts International,41, 1389A.
8.
Crowther, R.
, Durkin, K., Shire, B. and Hargreaves, D. (1985). Influences on the development of children's conservation-type responses to music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 85, 26-37.
9.
Dunn, R.
(1983, May). Can students identify their own learning styles?Educational Leadership, 60-62.
10.
Dunn, R.
and Carbo, M. (1981, February). Modalities: An open letter to Walter Barbe, Michael Milone, and Raymond Swassing. Educational Leadership, 381-382.
11.
Dunn, R.
and Dunn, K. (1978). Teaching Students through their Individual Learning Styles: A Practical Approach. Reston, VA: Reston.
12.
Dunn, R.
, Dunn, K. and Price, G. (1986). Learning Style Inventory. Lawrence, KS: Price Systems.
13.
Dunn, R.
, Dunn, K. and Price, G. (1987). Learning Style Inventory Manual. Lawrence, KS: Price Systems.
14.
Ellis, M. C.
and McCoy, C. W. (1990). Field dependence/independence in college non-music majors and their ability to discern form in music. Journal of Research in Music Education, 38, 302-310.
15.
Fizzell, R.
(1984, Spring). The status of learning styles. The Educational Forum, 303-312.
16.
Forsythe, J. L.
and Kelly, M. M. (1989). Effects of visual-spatial added cues on fourth-graders' melodic discrimination. Journal of Research in Music Education, 37, 272-277.
17.
Friedman, P.
and Alley, R. (1984). Learning/teaching styles: Applying the principles. Theory into Practice, 23, 77-81.
18.
Gordon, E. E.
(1979). Primary Measures of Music Audiation. Chicago, IL: G.I.A. Publications.
19.
Hargreaves, D. J.
(1986). Developmental psychology and music education. Psychology of Music, 14(2), 83-96.
20.
Heitland, K. W. (1982). Cognitive styles and musical aptitudes: An exploratory study. (Doctoral Dissertation, Indiana University.) Dissertation Abstracts International, 43, 2534A.
21.
Krietner, K. (1981). Modality strengths and learning styles of musically talented high school students. Unpublished M.S. dissertation, the Ohio State University.
22.
Larsen, R.
and Boody, C. (1971). Some implications for music education in the work of Jean Piaget. Journal of Research in Music Education, 18, 35-50.
23.
Matson, D. (1978). Field dependence-independence in children and their response to musical tasks embodying Piaget's principle of conservation. (Doctoral Dissertation, the Ohio State University.) Dissertation Abstracts International, 39, 4798A.
24.
Moore, B. (1986). Music composition and learning style: The relationship between curriculum and learner. (Doctoral Dissertation, University of Madison-Wisconsin, 1986.) Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 2071A.
25.
Moore, R. S.
and Staum, M. (1987). Effects of age and nationality on auditory/visual sequential memory of English and American children. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 91, 126-131.
26.
Nelson, D.
(1984). The conservation of rhythm in Suzuki violin students: A task validation study. Journal of Research in Music Education, 32, 25-34.
27.
Nocera, S.
(1979). Reaching the Special Learner Through Music. Morristown, NJ: Silver Burdett.
28.
Norton, D.
(1980), Interrelationships among music aptitude, IQ, and auditory conservation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 20, 207-217.
29.
Olson, G. B.
(1978). Intersensory and intrasensory transfer of melodic contour perception of children. Journal of Research in Music Education, 26, 41-47.
30.
Olson, G. B.
(1981). Perception of melodic contour through intrasensory matching and intrasensory transfer by elementary students. Journal of Educational Research, 74, 358-362.
31.
Olson, I.
(1988). Perceptual field-dependencelindependence correlates of listening skills and attitude set. Paper presented at the National Biennial In-Service Conference of the Music Educators National Conference, Indianapolis, IN.
32.
Perney, J.
(1977). Musical tasks realted to the development of he conservation of metrical time. Journal of Research in Music Education, 24, 159-168.
33.
Pflederer, M.
(1964). The responses of children to musical tasks embodying Piaget's principle of conservation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 12, 251-268.
34.
Pflederer, M.
(1967). Conservation laws applied to the development of musical intelligence. Journal of Research in Music Education, 15, 215-233.
35.
Pflederer, M.
and Sechrest, L. (1968). Conservation-type responses of children to musical stimuli. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 13, 19-36.
36.
Raemsich, J.
(1981). Learning styles in general education. The Wisconsin School Musician, 51, 28-34.
37.
Schmidt, C. P.
(1984). The relationship among aspects of cognitive style and language- bound/language-optional perception to musicians' performance in aural dicrimination tasks. Journal of Research in Music Education, 32, 159-168.
38.
Schmidt, C. P.
and Lewis, B. E. (1987). Field dependence/independence, movement-based instruction and fourth grader's achievement in selected musical tasks. Psychology of Music, 15, 117-127.
39.
Schmidt, L.
(1976). Music as a learning model. Music Educators Journal, 63(1), 94-97.
40.
Serafine, M.
(1979). Meter conservation in music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 59, 94-97.
41.
Serafine, M.
(1980). Piagetian research in music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 62, 1-21.
42.
Smith, E.
(1953). The value of notated examples in learning to recognise musical themes aurally. Journal for Research in Music Education, 1, 97-104.
43.
Walker, R.
(1981). Presence of internalised images of musical sounds and their relevance to music education. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 66, 107-111.
44.
Webster, P.
and Schlentrick, K. (1982). Discrimination of pitch direction by preschool children with verbal and non-verbal tasks. Journal of Research in Music Education, 30, 155-162.
45.
Webster, P.
and Zimmerman, M. (1983). Conservation of rhythmic and tonal patterns of second through sixth grade children. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 73, 28-49.
46.
Willet, B. E.
and Netusil, A. J. (1989). Music computer drill and learning styles at the fourth- grade level. Journal of Research in Music Education, 37, 219-229.
47.
Zimmerman, M.
(1981). Child development and music education. Documentary Report of the Ann Arbor Symposium (pp. 49-55). Reston, VA: Music Educators National Conference.
