Managing fictitious capital: The legal geography of investment and political struggle in rental housing in New York City

Abstract

Since 2001 investors have purchased rent-regulated housing in New York City with heightened expectation for financial performance, placing pressure on tenants and communities through increasing rents, harassment, eviction, and when financial targets are not met, physical deterioration of buildings. At the heart of this investment strategy is fictitious capital, the extension of credit based on assumptions about future events. This paper shows that beyond assessments about the “truth” or rationality of the expectations underlying fictitious capital, the management of value as a problem is at stake. When the expectations underlying fictitious capital are not realized, a network of actors engage in a set of legal–financial practices to manage the value of rent-regulated multifamily buildings, including banking regulation and its exception, mortgage securitization and special servicing, distressed debt markets, rent stabilization, and foreclosure law. The breakdown of the assumptions of fictitious capital reveals new challenges and opportunities for tenant activism and policy to intervene in preserving rent-regulated housing. The paper focuses on how this financialization of housing not only serves as a moment for the increasing role of financial actors and imperatives, but also how it drives tenant activism and policy to engage legal–financial practices to redefine the tenant–landlord relationship and to tie financial expectations more closely to the material reality of tenants and communities.

Keywords

Financialization housing legal geography uneven development

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Appelbaum

Batt

(2014) Private Equity at Work: When Wall Street Manages Main Street, New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

Ashton

(2009) An appetite for yield: The anatomy of the subprime mortgage crisis. Environment and Planning A 41: 1420–1441.

Ashton P (2010) CRA's “blind spots”: Community reinvestment and concentrated subprime lending in Detroit. Journal of Urban Affairs 32(5): 579–608.

Ashton P (2011) The financial exception and the reconfiguration of credit risk in US mortgage markets. Environment and Planning A 43: 1796–1812.

Ashton P, Doussard M and Weber R (16 May 2014) Reconstituting the state: City powers and exposures in Chicago's infrastructure leases. Urban Studies. doi: 10.1177/0042098014532962.

Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development (ANHD) (2009) Predatory equity: Evolution of a crisis. Available at: http://www.anhd.org/resources/Predatory_Equity-Evolution_of_a_Crisis_Report.pdf (accessed 29 January 2015).

Balasubramanian V (2014) Jenner and Block wields RICO to reach landlord settlement. The American Lawyer, 23 July. Available at http://www.americanlawyer.com/id=1202664266519/Jenner–Block-Wields-RICO-to-Reach-Landlord-Settlement?slreturn=20150031104433 (accessed 31 January 2015).

Barbanel J (2010) City subpoenas data on 10 Bronx buildings. The Wall Street Journal, 14 December. Available at: http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703727804576017990083045426 (accessed 5 November 2014).

Blomley

(1997) The properties of space: History, geography, and gentrification. Urban Geography 18(4): 286–295.

10.

Blomley

(2005) Remember property? Progress in Human Geography 29(2): 125–127.

11.

Buckley C (2011) Deal would settle tenants’ harassment suit. The New York Times, 7 September, A26. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/08/nyregion/pinnacle-group-settles-ny-tenants-harassment-suit.html (accessed 5 November 2014).

12.

Buckley J and O’Leary C (2003) A real estate bubble in the Bronx? University Neighborhood Housing Project. Available at: http://unhp.org/pdf/bubble.pdf (accessed 6 May 2015).

13.

Callon

(1998) The Laws of Markets, Oxford: Blackwell.

14.

Christophers

(2010) On voodoo economics: Theorising relations of property, value and contemporary capitalism. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 35(1): 94–108.

15.

Christophers B (2015) For real: Land as capital and commodity. Paper presented at Land Fictions, 8th Annual MaGrann Conference, Rutgers University, 1–2 May.

16.

Citizens Housing and Planning Council (CHPC) (2009) Debt threat: Saving multifamily rental housing from zombie mortgages. Available at: http://chpcny.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/final-report-web-version-zombie-cover.pdf (accessed 17 August 2014).

17.

Clark

(1995) The rent gap re-examined. Urban Studies 32(9): 1489–1503.

18.

Coakley

(1994) The integration of property and financial markets. Environment and Planning A 26: 697–713.

19.

COMM 2012 CR2 Commercial Mortgage Backed Security Prospectus (2012) Available at: http://www.secinfo.com/d1evd6.pdj.htm#1stPage (accessed 5 November 2014).

20.

Comtois J (2010) Big residential landlord faces class-action suit. Crain's New York, 3 May. Available at: http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20100503/REAL_ESTATE/100509976/big-residential-landlord-faces-class-action-suit#article_tab (accessed 31 January 2015).

21.

Commons

(1924/2007) The Legal Foundations of Capitalism, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

22.

Day

(1999) Urban Castles: Tenement Housing and Landlord Activism in New York City, 1890–1943, New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

23.

De Soto

(1989) The Other Path, New York, NY: Basic Books.

24.

De Soto

(2000) The Mystery of Capital, New York, NY: Basic Books.

25.

Douvas J (2012) Twenty years of opportunistic real estate investing. Wharton Real Estate Review Spring. Available at: http://realestate.wharton.upenn.edu/review/index.php?article=238 (accessed 18 Janurary 2015).

26.

Elson

(1979) The value theory of labor. In: Elson

(ed.) Value: The Representation of Labor in Capitalism, London: CSE Books, pp. 115–180.

27.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) (1998) Managing the Crisis: The FDIC and RTC Experience, Washington, DC: FDIC.

28.

Fields D (2014) Contesting the financialization of urban space: Community organizations and the struggle to preserve affordable rental housing in New York City. Journal of Urban Affairs 37(2): 144–165.

29.

French

Leyshon

Wainwright

(2011) Financializing space, spacing financialization. Progress in Human Geography 35(6): 798–819.

30.

Froud

Williams

(2007) Private equity and the culture of value extraction. New Political Economy 12(3): 405–420.

31.

Gelinas N (2011) The mortgage hangover. City Journal. Available at: http://www.city-journal.org/2011/21_3_financial-crisis.html (accessed 29 January 2015).

32.

Gotham KF (2006) The secondary circuit of capital reconsidered: Globalization and the US real estate sector. American Journal of Sociology 112(1): 231–275.

33.

Groarke M (2002) Organizing against overfinancing: The northwest Bronx coalition campaign against Freddie Mac. Bronx County Historical Society Journal 39(Fall): 69–86.

34.

Hackworth

Smith

(2001) The changing state of gentrification. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 92(4): 464–477.

35.

Haila

(1988) Land as a financial asset: The theory of urban rent as a mirror of economic transformation. Antipode 20: 79–102.

36.

Hammel

(1999) Re-establishing the rent gap: An alternative view of capitalised land rent. Urban Studies 36(8): 1283–1293.

37.

Hardt M (2005) Immaterial labor and artistic production. Rethinking Marxism 17(2): 175–177.

38.

Harvey

(1982/2006) The Limits to Capital, London: Verso.

39.

Harvey D and Chatterjee L (1974) Absolute rent and the structuring of space by financial institutions. Antipode 6(1): 22–36.

40.

Hasty

(2011) Protecting tenants at foreclosure by funding needed repairs. Journal of Law and Policy 20: 581–640.

41.

Henderson

(2013) Value in Marx: The Persistence of Value in a More-than-capitalist World, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

42.

Immergluck D (2004) Credit to the Community: Community reinvestment and fair lending policy in the United States. Armonk, NY: ME Sharpe.

43.

Keating

(1998) Rent Control: Regulation and the Rental Housing Market, New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.

44.

Kennedy

Michelman

(1980) Are property and contract efficient? Hofstra Law Review 8(3): 711–770.

45.

Krinsky

(2006) The dialectics of privatization and advocacy in New York City's workfare state. Social Justice 33(3): 158–174.

46.

Krueckeberg

(1995) The difficult character of property: To whom do things belong? Journal of the American Planning Association 61(3): 301–309.

47.

Langley

(2008) Sub-prime mortgage lending: A cultural economy. Economy and Society 37: 469–494.

48.

Lazonick W and O'Sullivan M (2000) Maximizing shareholder value: A new ideology for corporate governance? Economy and Society 29: 13–35.

49.

Leavitt

Saegert

(1988) The community-household: Responding to housing abandonment in New York City. Journal of the American Planning Association 54(4): 489–500.

50.

Levitin

Twomey

(2011) Mortgage servicing. Yale Journal on Regulation 28(1): 1–90.

51.

Levitin AJ and Wachter SM (2013) The commercial real estate bubble. Harvard Business Law Review 3: 83–118.

52.

Leyshon

Thrift

(2007) The capitalization of almost everything: The future of finance and capitalism. Theory, Culture and Society 24: 97–115.

53.

Mann

(2010) Value after Lehman. Historical Materialism 18(4): 172–188.

54.

Marazzi

(2011) The Violence of Financial Capitalism, Cambridge: MIT Press Books.

55.

Mitchell T (2007) The properties of markets. In: MacKenzie D, Muniesa F and Siu L (eds) Do Economists Make Markets? Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 244–275.

56.

Mollencamp C and Wei L (2010) To fix sour property deals, lenders ‘extend and pretend’. The Wall Street Journal, 7 July, Available at: http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704764404575286882690834088 (accessed 4 February 2015).

57.

Moreno

(2014) The urban process under financialised capitalism. City: Analysis of Urban Trends, Culture, Theory, Policy, Action 18(3): 244–268.

58.

New York City Rent Guidelines Board (2011) Available at: http://www.nycrgb.org/html/resources/decontrol.html (accessed 2 September 2014).

59.

New York University, Furman Center for Real Estate and Urban Policy (2014) Profile of rent stabilized units and tenants in New York City. Available at: http://furmancenter.org/files/FurmanCenter_FactBrief_RentStabilization_June2014.pdf (accessed 23 July 2015).

60.

O'Neill P (2009) Infrastructure investment and the management of risk. In: Clark GL, Dixon AD and Monk AHB (eds) Managing Financial Risks: From Global to Local. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp. 165–190.

61.

Postone

(1995) Time, Labor, and Social Domination: A Reinterpretation of Marx's Critical Theory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

62.

Proactive Preservation Initiative (2011, August 9) Available at: http://council.nyc.gov/html/pr/080911buildings.shtml (accessed 5 November 2014).

63.

Page SN, Ankner D, Jones C and Fetterman R (2008) The risks and rewards of private equity in infrastructure. Public Works Management and Policy 13(2): 100–113.

64.

Riles

(2011) Collateral Knowledge: Legal Reasoning in the Global Financial Markets, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

65.

Schur

Sherry

(1977) The Neighborhood Housing Movement, New York, NY: Association of Neighborhood Housing Developers.

66.

SIGTARP (2015) The legacy of TARP's bank bailout program known as the capital purchase program. Retrieved from http://www.sigtarp.gov/Audit%20Reports/SIGTARP_CPP_Report.pdf (accessed 4 February 2015).

67.

Sidney MS (2003) Unfair Housing: How National Policy Shapes Community Action. Lawrence, Kansas: University Press of Kansas.

68.

Siemiatycki M and Farooqi N (2012) Value for money and risk in public–private partnerships: Evaluating the evidence. Journal of the American Planning Association 78(3): 286–299.

69.

Smith

(1979) Toward a theory of gentrification a back to the city movement by capital, not people. Journal of the American Planning Association 45(4): 538–548.

70.

Smith

(1982) Gentrification and uneven development. Economic Geography 58(2): 139–155.

71.

Squires GD (1992) Community reinvestment: An emerging social movement. In: Squires GD (ed.) From Redlining to Reinvestment: Community Responses to Urban Disinvestment. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, pp. 1–37.

72.

Stegman

(1972) Housing Investment in the Inner City: The Dynamics of Decline; A Study of Baltimore, Maryland, 1968–1970, Cambridge: MIT Press.

73.

Sternlieb

(1966) The Tenement Landlord, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers State University.

74.

Sternlieb

(1972) The Urban Housing Dilemma, New York, NY: New York Housing and Development Administration.

75.

Sternlieb

Burchell

(1973) Residential Abandonment: The Tenement Landlord Revisited, New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.

76.

Tabb

(1982) The Long Default: New York City and the Urban Fiscal Crisis, New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.

77.

University Neighborhood Housing Project (UNHP) (2011) New York City’s multifamily housing in distress. Available at: http://www.unhp.org/pdf/MultifamilyDistress.pdf (accessed 8 February 2014).