Global value chain and global production network analyses have largely focused on
dominance of Northern retailers over suppliers in the global South. The expansion of
retailers within the global South sourcing from and supplying consumer end-markets within
their own geographic regions is reconfiguring value chain dynamics. This paper draws on
GVC and GPN approaches and the concepts of multi-polar governance to analyse changing
dynamics of global and regional retail supply networks. Drawing on a case study of
supermarket expansion within South and East Africa, it analyses how ‘waves of diffusion’
by global and regional supermarkets provide new opportunities for ‘strategic
diversification’ by some horticultural producers and workers. It examines the implications
for economic and social upgrading and downgrading, finding mixed outcomes. Strategic
diversification provides opportunities for economic and social upgrading by more capable
suppliers and skilled workers, but economic downgrading pressures persist and some are
excluded from both global and regional value chains.
BairJ
(2005) Global capitalism and commodity chains: Looking back,
going forward. Competition and Change9: 153–180.
2.
BairJ
(2008) Frontiers of Commodity Chain Research,
Stanford California: Stanford University
Press.
3.
BarrientosS
(2013) Labour chains’ analysing the role of labour
contractors in global production networks. Journal of
Development Studies49: 1058–1071.
4.
BarrientosS
(2014) Gendered global production networks: Analysis of
cocoa–chocolate sourcing. Regional Studies48: 791–803.
5.
BarrientosSGereffiGRossiA
(2011) Economic and social upgrading in global production
networks – challenges and opportunities. International Labour
Review150: 319–340.
6.
BarrientosSKritzingerA
(2004) Squaring the circle – global production and the
informalisation of work in South African fruit exports. Journal
of International Development16: 81–92.
7.
Barrientos S and Visser M (2012) South
African horticulture value chains: Opportunities and challenges for economic and social
upgrading. Capturing the Gains Working Paper, No. 12, University of Manchester.
Available at: www.capturingthegains.org (accessed June 2013).
8.
Bernhardt T and Milberg W (2011) Does
economic upgrading generate social upgrading? Insights from the horticulture, apparel,
mobile phones and tourism sectors. Capturing the Gains Working Paper, University of
Manchester. 2011/7.
9.
CattaneoO
(2013) Aid for Trade and Value Chains in Agrifood,
Geneva: World Trade
Organization.
10.
CattaneoOGereffiGStaritzC
(2010) Global Value Chains in a Postcrisis World: A Development
Perspective, Washington DC: The
World Bank.
11.
CoeNDickenPHessM
(2008) Global production networks: Realising the
potential. Journal of Economic Geography8: 271–295.
12.
CoeNJordhus-LierD
(2010) Constrained agency? Re-evaluating the geographies of
labour. Progress in Human Geography.
April. 1–23.
13.
CoeNWrigleyN
(2007) Host economy impacts of transnational retail: The
research agenda. Journal of Economic Geography7: 341–371.
14.
CoeNWrigleyN
(2009) The Globalization of Retailing,
London: Edward
Elgar.
15.
Deloitte (2011) Leaving home: global
powers of retailing 2011: global retail perspectives, Deloitte
LLP.
16.
DickenPKellyPFOldsK
(2001) Chains and networks, territories and scales: Towards
a relationional framework for analyzing the global economy.
Global Networks1: 89–112.
17.
DihelN
(2011) Beyond the Nakumatt Generation: Distribution Services in
East Africa. Africa Trade Policy Notes No. 26. Washington DC: World
Bank.
18.
DolanC
(2004) On farm and packhouse: Employment at the bottom of a
global value chain. Rural Sociology69: 99–126.
19.
DolanCHumphreyJ
(2000) Governance and trade in fresh vegetables: Impact of
UK supermarkets on the African horticulture industry. The
Journal of Development Studies37: 147–176.
20.
EmongorRKirstenJ
(2009) The impact of South African supermarkets on
agricultural development in the SADC: A case study in Zambia, Namibia and
Botswana. Agrekon48: 60–84.
21.
Evers B, Opondo M, Barrientos S, et al.
(2014) Global and regional supermarkets: Implications for producers and workers in
Kenyan and Ugandan horticulture. Capturing the Gains Working Paper No. 39. Available at:
www.capturingthegains.org (accessed May 2014).
22.
Fernandez-StarkKBamberPGereffiG
(2011) The Fruit and Vegetables Global Value Chain: Economic
Upgrading and Workforce Development, Durham:
Duke University Center on Globalization, Governance and
Competitiveness.
23.
GereffiG
(1994) The organization of buyer-driven global commodity
chains: How U.S. retailers shape overseas production networks. In:
GereffiGKorzeniewiczM
(eds) Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism,
Westport: Prager, pp.
95–122.
24.
GereffiGChristianM
(2009) The impacts of Wal-mart: The rise and consequences of
the world's dominant retailer. Annual Review of
Sociology35: 573–591.
25.
GereffiGHumphreyJKaplinskyR
(2001) Globalization, value chains and
development. IDS Bulletin32.
26.
GereffiGHumphreyJSturgeonT
(2005) The governance of global value
chains. Review of International Political Economy12: 78–104.
27.
GibbonPPonteS
(2005) Trading Down: Africa, Value Chains and the Global
Economy, Philadelphia: Temple
University Press.
28.
GuarinAKnorringaP
(2014) New middle-class consumers in rising powers:
Responsible consumption and private standards. Oxford
Development Studies42: 151–171.
29.
HamiltonGGSenauerBPetrovicM
(2011) The Market Makers: How Retailers are Reshaping the Global
Economy, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
30.
Hatch G, Becker P and van Zyl M (2011) The
dynamic African consumer market: Exploring growth opportunities in Sub-Saharan Africa,
Accenture. Available at: www.accenture.com (accessed June 2012).
31.
HendersonJDickenPHessM
(2002) Global production networks and the analysis of
economic development. Review of International Political
Economy9: 436–464.
32.
HensonSHumphreyJ
(2010) Understanding the complexities of private standards
in global agri-food chains as they impact developing countries.
Journal of Development Studies46: 1628–1646.
33.
HessM
(2004) ‘Spatial’ relationships? Towards a
reconceptualization of embeddedness. Progress in Human
Geography28: 165–186.
34.
HumphreyJ
(2007) The supermarket revolution in developing countries:
Tidal wave or tough competitive struggle?Journal of Economic Geography7: 433–450.
35.
HumphreyJSchmitzH
(2002) How does insertion in global value chains affect
upgrading in industrial clusters?Regional Studies36: 1017–1027.
36.
Kaplinsky R and Morris M (2002) A Handbook
for Value Chain Research, International Development Research Centre (IDRC)/Institute of
Development Studies (IDS). Available at: http://www.ids.ac.uk/globalvaluechains/tools/index.html.
37.
KnorringaPPeglerL
(2006) Globalisation, firm upgrading and impacts on
labour. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale
Geografie97: 470–479.
38.
MaertensMSwinnenJ
(2009) Trade, standards and poverty: Evidence from
Senegal. World Development37: 161–178.
39.
NathanDKalpanaV
(2007) Issues in the Analysis of Global Value Chains and their
Impact on Employment and Incomes in India,
Geneva: International Institute for
Labour Studies, ILO.
40.
NeilsonJPritchardBYeungHW-C
(2014) Global value chains and global production networks in
the changing international political economy: An introduction.
Review of International Political Economy21: 1–8.
41.
NevenDOderaMMReardonTWangH
(2009) Kenyan supermarkets, emerging middle-class
horticultural farmers, and employment impacts on the rural poor.
World Development37: 1802–1811.
42.
OumaS
(2010) Agrifood governance and the restructuring of the
Kenyan horticulture industry. Economic Geography86: 197–222.
43.
PhillipsN
(2013) Unfree labour and adverse incorporation in the global
economy: Comparative perspectives on Brazil and India. Economy
and Society42: 171–196.
44.
PicklesJSmithABucěkM
(2006) Upgrading, changing competitive pressures, and
diverse practices in the East and Central European apparel industry.
Environment and Planning A38: 2305–2324.
45.
PonteSEwertJ
(2009) Which way is “Up” in upgrading? Trajectories of
change in the value chain for South African wine. World
Development37: 1637–1650.
46.
PonteSSturgeonT
(2014) Explaining governance in global value chains: A
modular theory-building effort. Review of International
Political Economy21: 195–223.
47.
RaoJOQaimM
(2013) Supermarkets and agricultural labor demand in Kenya:
A gendered perspective. Food Policy38: 165–176.
48.
RaworthKKidderT
(2009) Mimicking ‘lean’ in global value chains: Its the
workers who get leaned on. In: BairJ (ed.)
Frontiers of Commodity Chain Research,
Stanford: Stanford University
Press, pp. 165–189.
49.
ReardonTHensonSBerdegueJA
(2007) ‘Proactive fast-tracking’ diffusion of supermarkets
in developing countries: Implications for market institutions and trade.
Journal of Economic Geography7: 399–431.
50.
ReardonTTimmer
BarretCPBerdegueJA
(2003) The rise of supermarkets in Africa, Asia and Latin
America. American Journal of Agricultural Economics85: 1140–1146.
51.
RiisgaardLHammerN
(2011) Prospects for labour in global value chains: Labour
standards in the cut flower and banana industries. British
Journal of Industrial Relations49: 168–190.
52.
SelwynB
(2013) Social upgrading and labour in global production
networks: A critique and an alternative conception. Competition
and Change17: 75–90.
53.
SmithSAuretDBarrientosS
(2004) Ethical Trade in African Horticulture: Gender, Rights and
Participation. IDS Working Paper 223. Brighton: Institute of
Development Studies.
54.
Tschirley D (2010) Opportunities and
Constraints to increased fresh produce trade in East and Southern Africa. In: 4th video conference under AAACP-funded series of high value agriculture
seminars, Mimeo.
55.
VorleyBFearneARayD
(2007) Regoverning Markets: A Place for Small-Scale Producers in
Modern Agri-Food Chains?, London:
Gower Publishing.
