This paper shows the importance of ownership, end markets and regionalism within the
global value chain and related conceptual frameworks. This is done through unpacking the
development trajectories of the major Sub Saharan African apparel export industries
against the backdrop of trade regime changes. Ownership characteristics of supplier firms
shape the ability to shift between different end markets and respond to lead firm
requirements; and the level of their local and regional embeddedness impacts on different
forms of upgrading. The emergence of new regionalism centred around investment and end
markets provides pathways for new trajectories of more sustainable value chains and local
industrialization. More locally and regionally embedded firms have been able to shift with
uneven success to new, and in particular regional, markets. In contrast, Asian-owned
transnational producers remain focused on the US market with limited market opportunities
and upgrading potential. Different types of ownership and embeddedness dynamics are
therefore important to explain the co-evolution of highly differentiated value chain
dynamics creating a variety of apparel industrialization trajectories in the apparel
export industry in Sub Saharan African.
Abdoolla RB-S (2013) Upgrading, learning opportunities and skill development in the textile and clothing
sector: Case study of Mauritius. Masters half dissertation, School of
Economics, University of Cape Town, Cape Town.
2.
Ancharaz VD and Kaseeah H (2012) Surviving
Chinese competition in a post-Multi-Fibre Agreement world: Experience of clothing
exports from Mauritius. In: Paper prepared for presentation at the
final workshop of the project “Adjusting to Chinese ascendency in the global clothing
industry,” African Clothing and Footwear Research Network (ACFRN), University
of Nairobi, Kenya.
3.
AppelbaumR
(2008) Giant transnational contractors in East Asia:
Emergent trends in global supply chains. Competition &
Change12(1):
69–87.
4.
AzmehS
(2014) Labour in global production networks: Workers in the
qualifying industrial zones (QIZs) of Egypt and Jordan. Global
Networks14(4):
495–513.
5.
AzmehSNadviK
(2013) “Greater Chinese” global production networks in the
Middle East: The rise of the Jordanian garment industry.
Development and Change44(6):
1317–1340.
6.
BairJ
(2005) Global capitalism and commodity chains: Looking back,
going forward. Competition & Change9(2):
153–180.
7.
BairJ
(2009) Global commodity chains: Genealogy and
review. In: BairJ (ed.)
Frontiers of Commodity Chain Research, Palo Alto,
CA: Stanford University Press, pp.
1–34.
8.
BarnesJMorrisM
(2010) Innovation challenges facing the Lesotho apparel industry:
An analysis of 10 firm-level case studies. Study for the World Bank’s Sector Unit for
finance and private sector development in the Africa Region,
Washington DC: World
Bank.
9.
CampbellJLHollingsworthJRLindbergLN
(1991) Governance of the American Economy,
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
10.
Chemengich M (2010) Impact of AGOA on the
textile and apparel industry of Kenya. Prepared for ACTIF African Country Reports,
Nairobi, Kenya.
11.
CoeNMDickenPHessM
(2008) Global production networks: Realizing the
potential. Journal of Economic Geography8(3):
271–295.
12.
DickenPHasslerM
(2000) Organizing the Indonesian clothing industry in the
global economy: The role of business networks. Environment and
Planning A32(2):
263–280.
13.
DunningJ
(2000) The eclectic paradigm as an envelope for economic and
business theories of MNE activity. International Business
Review9(2):
163–190.
14.
DunningJH
(1979) Explaining changing patterns of international
production: In defense of the Eclectic theory. Oxford Bulletin
of Economics and Statistics41(4):
269–295.
15.
FessehaieJMorrisM
(2013) Value chain dynamics of Chinese copper mining in
Zambia: Enclave or linkage development?European Journal of Development Research25(4):
537–556.
16.
Frederick S (2010) Development and application of a value chain research approach to understand and
evaluate internal and external factors and relationships affecting economic
competitiveness in the textile value chain. Doctoral dissertation, North
Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC.
17.
FrederickSStaritzC
(2011) Apparel industry developments after the MFA
phase-out. In: World Bank (ed.)
Sewing Success? Employment and Wage Effects of the End of the Multi-Fibre
Arrangement (MFA)Vol. I, Washington, DC:
World Bank, pp.
41–85.
18.
Gatimu C, McCormick D, Kamau P, et al.
(2012) Innovation and stabilization in Kenya’s clothing industry during the
liberalization and post-MFA period. In: Paper prepared for
presentation at the final workshop of the project “Adjusting to Chinese ascendency in
the global clothing industry,” African Clothing and Footwear Research Network
(ACFRN), University of Nairobi, Kenya.
19.
GereffiG
(1999) International trade and industrial upgrading in the
apparel commodity chain. Journal of International
Economics48(1):
37–70.
20.
GereffiGBairJ
(2010) Strengthening Nicaragua’s Position in the Textile-Apparel
Value Chain: Upgrading in the Context of the CAFTA-DR Region,
Durham, NC: Center on Globalization,
Governance & Competitiveness (CGGC).
21.
GereffiGHumphreyJKaplinskyR
(2001) Introduction: Globalisation, value chains and
development. IDS Bulletin32(3): 1–8.
22.
GereffiGHumphreyJSturgeonTJ
(2005) The governance of global value
chains. Review of International Political Economy12(1):
78–104.
23.
GibbonP
(2003) The African growth and opportunity act and the global
commodity chain for clothing. World Development31(11):
1809–1827.
24.
GibbonP
(2004) South Africa and the global commodity chain for
clothing: Export performance and constraints. In: McCormickDRogersonCM (eds)
Clothing and Footwear in African Industrialization,
Pretoria: Africa Institute of South
Africa, pp. 148–192.
25.
GibbonP
(2008a) Governance, entry barriers, upgrading: A
re-interpretation of some GVC concepts from the experience of African clothing
exports. Competition & Change12(1):
29–48.
26.
GibbonP
(2008b) Segmentation, governance and upgrading in global
clothing chains. A Mauritian case study. In: FoldNLarsenMN (eds)
Globalization and Restructuring of African Commodity Flows. 08
Tryck, Stockholm, pp. 184–209.
27.
GibbonPBairJPonteS
(2008) Governing global value chains: An
introduction. Economy and Society37(3):
315–338.
28.
GibbonPPonteS
(2005) Trading Down: Africa, Value Chains, and the Global
Economy, Philadelphia, PA:
Temple University Press.
29.
GranovetterM
(1985) Economic action and social structure: The problem of
embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology91(3):
481–510.
30.
HallPASoskiceD
(2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of
Comparative Advantage, Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
31.
HendersonJDickenPHessM
(2002) Global production networks and the analysis of
economic development. Review of International Political
Economy9(3):
436–464.
32.
HessM
(2004) Spatial’ relationships? Towards a reconceptualization
of embeddedness. Progress in Human Geography28(2):
165–186.
33.
HessM
(2009) Investigating the archipelago economy: Chains,
networks and the study of uneven development. Journal fuer
Entwicklungspolitik25(2):
20–37.
34.
HessMYeungHW-C
(2006) Whither global production networks in economic
geography: Past, present and future. Environment & Planning
A38(7):
1193–1204.
35.
HumphreyJSchmitzH
(2001) Governance in global value chains.
IDS Bulletin32(3):
19–29.
36.
HumphreyJSchmitzH
(2002) How does insertion in global value chains affect
upgrading in industrial clusters?Regional Studies36(9):
1017–1027.
37.
Kamau P (2009) Upgrading and technical efficiency in Kenyan garment firms: Does insertion in global
value chains matter? In: Thesis submitted to the Institute for Development
Studies, University of Nairobi, Nairobi, Kenya.
Kaplinsky R and Morris M (2006) Dangling by a Thread: How Sharp are the Chinese Scissors? Report
prepared for DFID. Brighton: IDS.
40.
LundvallB-Å
(1992) National Systems of Innovation: Towards a Theory of
Innovation and Interactive Learning, London:
Pinter Publishers.
41.
MorrisMKaplinskyRKaplanD
(2012) One thing leads to another – Commodities, linkages
and industrial development. In: MorrisMKaplinskyRKaplanD (eds)
Special issue of Resource Policy: Making the Most of Commodities: The
Determinants of Linkages in Africa. 37(4):
405–484.
42.
MorrisMReedL
(2009) Clothing and textiles. In:
KraakA (ed.)
Sectors and Skills – The Need for Policy Alignment,
London: HSRC Press, pp.
200–218.
43.
MorrisMStaritzC
(2014) Industrialization trajectories in Madagascar’s export
apparel industry: Ownership, embeddedness, markets, and upgrading.
World Development56: 243–257.
44.
MorrisMStaritzCBarnesJ
(2011) Value chain dynamics, local embeddedness, and
upgrading in the clothing sectors of Lesotho and Swaziland.
International Journal of Technological Learning, Innovation and
Development4(1/2/3):
96–119.
45.
NeilsonJPritchardB
(2009) Value Chain Struggles: Institutions and Governance in the
Plantation Districts of South India, Malden, MA:
Wiley-Blackwell.
46.
NelsonR
(1993) National Innovation Systems: A comparative
Analysis, New York: Oxford
University Press.
47.
PalpacuerF
(2008) Bringing the social context back in: Governance and
wealth distribution in global commodity chains. Economy and
Society37(3):
393–419.
48.
ParrilliMDNadviKYeungHW-C
(2013) Local and regional development in global value
chains, production networks and innovation networks: A comparative review and the
challenges for future research. European Planning
Studies21(7):
967–988.
49.
PerriAPeruffoE
(2014) Knowledge spillovers from FDI: A critical review from
the international business perspective. International Journal of
Management Reviews. DOI:
10.1111/ijmr.12054.
50.
PhelpsNAStillwellJWanjiruR
(2009) Broken chain: Foreign direct investment in the Kenyan
clothing and textile industry. World Development37(2):
314–325.
51.
PicklesJ
(1991) Industrial restructuring, peripheral
industrialization, and rural development in South Africa.
Antipode23(1):
68–91.
52.
PicklesJWoodsJ
(1989) Taiwanese investment in South Africa.
African Affairs: The Journal of the Royal African Society88(353):
507–528.
53.
Plank L and Staritz C (2015) Global
competition, institutional context, and regional production networks: Up- and
downgrading experiences in Romania’s apparel industry. Cambridge
Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 8(3):
421–438.
54.
PolanyiK
(1944) The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins
of Our Time, New York: Beacon
Press.
55.
ReedL
(2012) The changing dynamics of the South African clothing value
chain and the role for industrial policy: A case study of the China quotas.
PhD thesis, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South
Africa.
56.
SinkovicsRYaminMNadviK
(2014) Rising powers from emerging markets—The changing face
of international business. International Business
Review23(4):
675–848.
57.
SmithAPicklesJBučekM
(2014) The political economy of global production networks:
Regional industrial change and differential upgrading in the East European clothing
industry. Journal of Economic Geography14(6): 1023–1051.
.
58.
SmithASwainA
(2010) The global economic crisis, Eastern Europe, and the
Former Soviet Union: Models of development and the contradictions of
internationalization. Eurasian Geography and Economics51(1):
1–34.
59.
StaritzC
(2011) Making the Cut? Low-Income Countries and the Global Clothing
Value Chain in a Post-Quota and Post-Crisis World, Washington,
DC: World Bank.
60.
Staritz C (2012) Apparel exports – Still a
path for industrial development? Dynamics in apparel global value chains and
implications for low-income countries. ÖFSE Working Paper 34, Austrian Foundation for
Development Research, Vienna, Austria.
61.
StaritzCFrederickS
(2012) Apparel, for the project FDI and global value chains in
Sub-Saharan Africa: Understanding the factors that contribute to integration and
spillovers, Background Paper. Washington, DC:
World Bank.
UN COMTRADE (2014)
International Merchandise Trade Statistics (IMTS), New
York: United Nations Statistics
Division.
65.
WellerS
(2006) The embeddedness of global production networks: The
impact of crisis in Fiji’s garment export sector. Environment
and Planning A38(7):
1249–1267.
66.
WhitleyR
(1999) Divergent Capitalisms: The Social Structuring and Change of
Business Systems, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
67.
YeungHW-C
(2000) Embedding foreign affiliates in transnational
business networks: The case of Hong Kong firms in Southeast Asia.
Environment and Planning A32(2):
201–222.
68.
YeungHW-CCoeNM
(2015) Towards a dynamic theory of global production
networks. Economic Geography91(1):
29–58.
