Freedom,part-time pirates,and poo police: Regulating the heterotopic space of the recreational boat

Abstract

At all levels of governance from international convention to local policy, the regulation of pollution from boats and ships has been steeped in conflict and subject to resistance. Recreational boaters, in particular, are often highly resistant to attempts to regulate their boating activity, particularly on environmental grounds. Such ongoing resistance poses a significant policy compliance challenge. This paper seeks to shed light on this complex, ongoing and broader field of opposition to environmental management by way of a case study analysis of resistance to on-board sewage regulations on the part of recreational boaters in Queensland, Australia. This resistance on the part of ‘everyday’ citizens is examined through the lens of heterotopia. In consequence, the paper can contribute to understandings more broadly of problems beleaguering environmental policy while also attending to the deeply implicated social roles of recreational boating spaces; namely as heterotopias of compensation and/or illusion. It also highlights how these heterotopic positionings are intensified by the scatological orientation of the policy under study.

Keywords

Environmental policy freedom heterotopia marine pollution regulatory resistance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

(2002) From cesspool to sewer: Sanitary reform and the rhetoric of resistance, 1848–1880. Victorian Literature and Culture 30(2): 383–402.

Australian Maritime Safety Authority (2008) Annex IV of MARPOL: Commencement of Regulations for Existing Ships. Marine Notice 17/2008. Canberra: Australian Maritime Safety Authority.

Australian Maritime Safety Authority (2009) Marine Orders: Part 96 Marine Pollution Prevention – Sewage. Issue 2, Order No. 3 of 2009. Federal Register of Legislative Instruments F2009L03640. Canberra: Australian Maritime Safety Authority.

Baasel-Tillis

Tucker-Carver

(1998) Garbage and sewage disposal from recreational boats. Environmental Health 61(4): 8–18.

Bašić

(2001) Those vulgar tubes: External sanitary accommodations aboard European ships of the fifteenth through seventeenth centuries by Joe J. Simmons. Dubrovnik Annals 5: 134–137.

Bates N (2004) Hold that law, Lucas. What holding tanks? Fraser Coast Chronicle, 18 June 2004, 5.

Beder

(1991) Controversy and closure: Sydney’s beaches in crisis. Social Studies of Science 21: 223–256.

Bodansky

(1991) Protecting the marine environment from vessel-source pollution: UNCLOS III and beyond. Ecology Law Quarterly 18: 719–778.

Bray A (2007) Head-aches: Practicalities. Available at: www.mysailing.com.au/news/head-aches-practicalities-by-andrew-bray (accessed 4 August 2009).

10.

Choate

(1957) Recreational boating: The nation’s family sport. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 313(1): 109–112.

11.

Cottrell

Graefe

(1997) Testing a conceptual framework of responsible environmental behavior. The Journal of Environmental Education 29(1): 17–27.

12.

Crawford A (2004) Poo police patrol our passages. The Coastal Passage, 7. Available at: www.thecoastalpassage.com/poo_passages.html (accessed 3 April 2007).

13.

Dorey B (2004) Loo laws pull in. Capricorn Coast Mirror, 14 April 2004, 4.

14.

Fineman

(1998) Street-level bureaucrats and the social construction of environmental control. Organization Studies 19: 953–974.

15.

Foley C (2004) Queensland without notice: Marine effluent. Queensland Hansard 51st Parliament sitting 16 June 2004, Hansard extract, pp.1143–1444.

16.

Foucault

(1986) Of other spaces. Diacritics 22: 22–27.

17.

Gandy

(2004) Rethinking urban metabolism: Water, space and the modern city. City: Analysis of Urban Trends, Culture, Theory, Policy, Action 8(3): 363–379.

18.

Gandy

(2012) Queer ecology: Nature, sexuality, and heterotopic alliances. Environment and Planning D 30: 727–747.

19.

Ganser

(2012) The pirate ship as a Black Atlantic heterotopia: Michel Maxwell Philip’s Emmanuel Appadocca. In: Eckhard

Rieser

Schultermandl

(eds) Contact Spaces of American Culture: Globalizing Local Phenomena, Wein: Lit Verlag, pp. 51–76.

20.

Grant-Smith D (2011) Unspeakable: A Policy Story of Boaters, Floaters, Voters and Matter Out of Place. PhD Thesis, School of Environment, Griffith University.

21.

Grant-Smith D (2015) Implicating animals: The symbolic power of scapegoating animals in marine pollution debates. Australasian Journal of Environmental Management 22(3): 270–284.

22.

Grotius H (1608/1916) Mare Liberum: The Freedom of the Seas, or the Right Which Belongs to the Dutch to Take Part in the East Indian Trade. Translated by R. Van Deman Magoffin. New York: Oxford University Press.

23.

Hemingway

(1996) Emancipating leisure: The recovery of freedom in leisure. Journal of Leisure Research 28(1): 27–43.

24.

Hetherington

(1997) The Badlands of Modernity: Heterotopia and Social Ordering, London: Routledge.

25.

Heyd

(1999) Art and Foucauldian heterotopias. In: Darier

(ed.) Discourses of the Environment, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, pp. 152–162.

26.

Inglis

(2000) A Sociological History of Excretory Experience, Lewiston: Edwin Mellen.

27.

International Maritime Organisation (2016) Prevention of pollution by sewage from ships. Available at: www.imo.org/OurWork/Environment/PollutionPrevention/Sewage/Pages/Default.aspx (accessed 2 February 2017).

28.

Irons G (1986) Sewage pollution: Annex IV stumbles on the little ship. Ship and Boat International, March, 53–55.

29.

Jackson B (2000) Boaters are not impressed with New South Wales Waterways’ sewage disposal discussion paper. Marine Engineers Australia, June 2000, 56–58.

30.

Jennings

(2007) Sailing/cruising. In: Jennings

(ed.) Water-Based Tourism, Sport, Leisure and Recreation Experiences, London: Butterworth-Heinemann, pp. 23–45.

31.

Jewitt

(2011) Poo gurus? Researching the threats and opportunities presented by human waste. Applied Geography 31: 761–769.

32.

Johns

Clarke

(2001) Mythological analyses of boating tourism. Annals of Tourism Research 28(2): 334–359.

33.

Johnson

(2013) The geographies of heterotopia. Geography Compass 17(11): 790–803.

34.

Julian M (2000) MARPOL 73/78: The international convention for the prevention of pollution from ships. Maritime Studies 113: 16–23.

35.

Kearns

(1988) Private property and public health reform in England 1830–70. Social Science and Medicine 26(1): 187–199.

36.

Keith-Lucas

(1954) Some influences affecting the development of sanitary legislation in England. The Economic History Review 6(3): 290–296.

37.

Khator

Chan

(1992) Environmental management and street‐level regulators: A cultural trap? Public Administration and Development 12(4): 387–397.

38.

Klein

Mackenthun

(2004) Introduction: The sea is history. In: Klein

Mackenthun

(eds) Sea Changes: Historicizing the Ocean, New York: Routledge, pp. 1–12.

39.

Kramsch

Motzenbacker

(2004) On the “Pirate Frontier”: Re-conceptualizing the Space of Ocean Governance in Light of the Prestige Disaster. Governance and Place Working Paper Series, Nijmegen: University of Nijmegen.

40.

Laurier

(1999) That sinking feeling: Elitism, working leisure and yachting. In: Crouch

(ed.) Leisure/Tourism Geographies: Practices and Geographical Knowledge, London: Routledge, pp. 195–213.

41.

Leon

Warnken

(2008) Copper and sewage inputs from recreational vessels at popular anchor sites in a semi-enclosed bay (Qld, Australia). Marine Pollution Bulletin 57(6–12): 838–845.

42.

Lipsky

(2010) Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service, 30th anniversary expanded ed. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

43.

Lucas A (2004) Poolution solution. The Coastal Passage, 10. Available at: www.thecoastalpassage.com/poosolution.html (accessed 3 April 2007).

44.

MacNaughten

Urry

(2000) Bodies of nature: Introduction. Body and Society 6(3–4): 1–11.

45.

Maritime Safety Queensland (2003) Vessel-Sourced Sewage Regulatory Impact Statement, Brisbane: Queensland Government.

46.

Maritime Safety Queensland (2008) Changes to legislation on marine pollution. Seascape 5(4): 4.

47.

Mele

(1993) Polluting for Pleasure, New York, NY: WW Norton and Company.

48.

Moorhouse O (2005) The dreaded toilet police. Afloat, April 2005. Available at: www.afloat.com.au/www/79/1001224/displayarticle/1025379.html (accessed 3 April 2007).

49.

Morgan E and Grant-Smith D (2015) Tales of science and defiance: The case for co-learning and collaboration in bridging the science/emotion divide in water recycling debates. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 58(10): 1770–1778.

50.

Neal

Walters

(2007) ‘You can get away with loads because there’s no one here’: Discourses of regulation and non-regulation in English rural space. Geoforum 38: 252–263.

51.

Norson

(2004a) Why do I cruise?: They don’t belong here!. The Coastal Passage 8: 5.

52.

Norson B (2004b) The poo police of the Whitsundays. The Coastal Passage 8: 6.

53.

Nussbaum

(2003) Capabilities and fundamental entitlements: Sen and social justice. Feminist Economies 9(2–3): 33–59.

54.

Otsuki

(2012) Illegality in settlement heterotopias: A study of frontier governance in the Brazilian Amazon. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 30: 896–912.

55.

Patton

(2007) The Sea Can Wash Away All Evils: Modern Marine Pollution and the Ancient Cathartic Ocean, New York: Columbia University Press.

56.

Rose

(1999) Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

57.

Rousseau

(1767/2004) The Social Contract, London: Penguin Books.

58.

Royes L (2010) Waste ‘tossed from boat’ at Gardens Point. City News, 13 May 2010. Available at: http://city-news.whereilive.com.au/news/story/waste-tossed-from-boat-at-gardens-point/ (accessed 18 November 2010).

59.

Scott P (2004) Getting the goods on marine sewage. Go Boating, October/November 2004, 18–19.

60.

Selman

(2008) Pirate heterotopias. Deptford.Tv Diaries Volume II: Pirate Strategies, Greenwich: OWN.

61.

Simmons

III (1997) Those Vulgar Tubes: External Accommodations Aboard European Ships of the Fifteenth Through Seventeenth Centuries, College Station: Texas A&M Press.

62.

Stanley

(2002) And after the cross-dressed cabin boys and whaling wives? Possible futures for women’s maritime historiography. The Journal of Transport History 21(1): 9–22.

63.

Steinberg

(1999) The maritime mystique: Sustainable development, capital mobility, and nostalgia in the world ocean. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 17: 403–426.

64.

Steinberg

(2001) The Social Construction of the Ocean, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

65.

Strand

Gibson

(1990) The use of pump-out facilities by recreational boaters in Maryland. Estuaries 13(3): 282–286.

66.

The Coastal Passage (2004) The poo police are watching your passage. The Coastal Passage 8: 6.

67.

The Courier-Mail (2005) Letter to the editor, 23 July 2005, 26.

68.

The Motor Ship (1991) Sewage regulations increase equipment demand, January 1991, 20–25.

69.

Tyler B (2009) Wees and poos: The subject no one wants to talk about! Bow 2 Stern 5 2009: 23–28.

70.

Van Dyke

(1993) International governance and stewardship of the high seas. In: Van Dyke

Zaelke

Hewison

(eds) Freedom for the Seas in the 21^st Century: Ocean Governance and Environmental Harmony, Washington, DC: Island Press, pp. 13–22.

71.

Ward N (1996) Surfers, sewage and the new politics of pollution. Area 28(3): 331–338.

72.

Weinberg

Williams

(2005) Fecal matters. Social Problems 52(3): 315–336.

73.

West

(2004) Marine pollution from vessel sewage in Queensland. Maritime Law Association of Australia and New Zealand Journal 18: 216–151.

74.

White

(2002) Marine pollution from ships: International conventions and Australian laws. In: Lipman

Bates

(eds) Pollution Law in Australia, Chatswood: LexisNexis Butterworths.

75.

Wilkie

(2015) Performance, Transport and Mobility: Making Passage, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.