The whale multiple: Spatial formations of whale tourism in Jangsaengpo,South Korea

Abstract

Whale-watching tourism is widely regarded as a manifestation of the transition from whale hunting to whale protection. However, in Jangsaengpo, South Korea, watching whales and eating whale-meat occur side by side for tourism purposes. Here, the concurrence of the two seemingly conflicting practices is legitimated through the by-catch which enables eating without killing by using “accidentally” caught whales for meat. Bringing together ontological discussions of multinaturalism and the topological analysis of space, this paper examines the ways in which spatial relations are performed to produce multiple whale ontologies within Jangsaengpo's whale tourism. It specifically unfolds diverse geographical connections (from Japan to the US), and their interactions, which enact whales in Jangsaengpo as a multiplicity – what I call “the whale multiple”. This paper first traces Jangsaengpo's historical and contemporary whale-related geographical connections through which an array of actors and entities are enrolled into, and transformed, within the assemblage of whale tourism. It then considers the spatial politics exercised through the by-catch, which configures a concurrence of conflicting whale ontologies. The paper discusses the political implications of the whale multiple which suggests strategic living with different ontological worlds as a way of moving beyond the killing–protecting antagonism. By illustrating the spatial production and configuration of ontological multiplicity, this paper engages with the spatial dimension of the multinatural theorisation of nature.

Keywords

Ecotourism multinatural geography South Korea space whale

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

(2009) Green Development: Environment and Sustainability in a Developing World, Abingdon: Routledge.

Allen

(2011) Topological twists power's shifting geographies. Dialogues in Human Geography 1(3): 283–298.

Anderson

McFarlane

(2011) Assemblage and geography. Area 43(2): 124–127.

Baker

(2000) Predicted decline of protected whales based on molecular genetic monitoring of Japanese and Korean markets. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 267(1449): 1191–1199.

Baker

Steel

Choi

Y-Y

et al. (2010) Genetic evidence of illegal trade in protected whales' links Japan with the Us and South Korea. Biology Letters 6(5): 647–650.

Besio

Johnston

Longhurst

(2008) Sexy beasts and devoted mums: Narrating nature through dolphin tourism. Environment and Planning A 40(5): 1219–1234.

Bingham

Hinchliffe

(2008) Reconstituting natures: Articulating other modes of living together. Geoforum 39(1): 83–87.

Bissell

Fuller

(2009) The revenge of the still. M/C Journal 12(1): . Available at: http://journal.media-culture.org.au/index.php/mcjournal/article/view/136 (accessed 12 April 2017).

Blok

(2008) Contesting global norms: Politics of identity in Japanese pro-whaling counter mobilization. Global Environmental Politics 8(2): 39–66.

10.

Blok

(2011) War of the whales: Post-sovereign science and agonistic cosmopolitics in Japanese-global whaling assemblages. Science, Technology and Human Values 36(1): 55–81.

11.

Blok

(2013) Comparative globalities: Actor-network theory and the topologies of Japanese “research” whales. East Asian Science, Technology and Society 7(2): 185–204.

12.

Blok

(2014) Articulating social science in the wild of global natures? On economics and anthropology in transnational environmental politics. Environment and Planning A 46(9): 2125–2142.

13.

Brockington

(2002) Fortress Conservation: The Preservation of the Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania, Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

14.

Brockington

Duffy

(2011) Capitalism and Conservation, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.

15.

Brydon

(2006) The predicament of nature: Keiko the whale and the cultural politics of whaling in Iceland. Anthropological Quarterly 79(2): 225–260.

16.

Bulbeck

(2004) Facing the Wild: Ecotourism, Conservation and Animal Encounters, London: Earthscan.

17.

Bureau of Fisheries (1908) Fishery of Korea I. Report for the Department of Agriculture, Commerce and Manufacturing, The Japanese Korean Government. Seoul: Japan‐Korean Press Corporation (in Japanese).

18.

Büscher

Davidov

(2014) The Ecotourism-Extraction Nexus: Political Economies and Rural Realities of (Un)Comfortable Bedfellows, Oxford; New York: Routledge.

19.

Castells

(2010) The Rise of the Network Society, 2nd ed. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.

20.

Choi

Y-Y

(2007) New policy landscape for cetacean by-catch. In: KFEM conference on beyond whale by-catch to whale-watching, Pohang City, South Korea, 11 September. Seoul: KFEM Ocean Committee (in Korean).

21.

Choi M-A (2010) Whale-watching or whaling-watching? Contradictory perceptions of whale-watching tourism in Jangsaengpo, South Korea. MSc Thesis, King's College London, UK.

22.

Choi E-K (2016) 0.9 million visits to the ex-whaling port Jangsaengpo. Joongang Daily, 1 Nov. Available at: http://news.joins.com/article/20804625 - none (in Korean).

23.

Cloke

Perkins

(2005) Cetacean performance and tourism in Kaikoura, New Zealand. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 23(6): 903–924.

24.

Cunningham

Huijbens

Wearing

(2012) From whaling to whale watching: Examining sustainability and cultural rhetoric. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 20(1): 143–161.

25.

Dolin

(2008) Leviathan: The History of Whaling in America, New York: WW Norton and Company.

26.

Einarsson

(1993) All animals are equal but some are cetaceans. In: Milton

(ed.) Environmentalism: The View from Anthropology, London: Routledge, pp. 73–84.

27.

Einarsson

(2009) From good to eat to good to watch: Whale watching, adaptation and change in Icelandic fishing communities. Polar Research 28(1): 129–138.

28.

Epstein

(2008) The Power of Words in International Relations: Birth of an Anti-Whaling Discourse, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

29.

Fielding

(2014) The liminal coastline in the life of a whale: Transition, identity, and food-production in the Eastern Caribbean. Geoforum 54: 10–16.

30.

Gillespie

(2005) Whaling Diplomacy: Defining Issues in International Environmental Law, Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.

31.

Ginn

Biesel

Barua

(2014) Flourishing with awkward creatures: Togetherness, vulnerability, killing. Environmental Humanities 4: 113–123.

32.

Harrison

Anderson

(2012) Taking-Place: Non-Representational Theories and Geography, Surrey: Ashgate Publishing.

33.

Hathaway

(2013) Environmental Winds: Making the Global in Southwest China, Berkeley: University of California Press.

34.

Heazle

(2006) Scientific Uncertainty and the Politics of Whaling, Seattle: University of Washington Press.

35.

Hess

(2003) Gift of the Whale: The Inupiat Bowhead Hunt, a Sacred Tradition, Seattle: Sasquatch Books.

36.

Higham

Lusseau

(2008) Slaughtering the goose that lays the golden egg: Are whaling and whale-watching mutually exclusive?. Current Issues in Tourism 11(1): 63–74.

37.

Hinchliffe

(2007) Geographies of Nature: Societies, Environments, Ecologies, London: Sage.

38.

Hirata

(2005) Why Japan supports whaling. Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy 8(2–3): 129–149.

39.

Hobsbawm

Ranger

(2012) The Invention of Tradition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

40.

Hobson

(2007) Political animals? On animals as subjects in an enlarged political geography. Political Geography 26(3): 250–267.

41.

Hoyt

(2001) Whale Watching 2001: Worldwide Tourism Numbers, Expenditures, and Expanding Socioeconomic Benefits, Yarmouth Port, MA: IFAW.

42.

Hoyt

(2002) “Whale Watching”. In: Perrin

Wursig

Thewissen

JGM

(eds) Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, San Diego: Academic Press, pp. 1305–1310.

43.

Hur

Y-R

(2012) The Story of Jangsaengpo: People of the Whaling Port, Ulsan: Government of South District of Ulsan City (in Korean).

44.

IUCN (2016) The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2016-1. Cambridge: IUCN Global Species Programme Red List Unit. Available at: www.iucnredlist.org (accessed 30 June 2016).

45.

Kalland

(2009) Unveiling the Whale: Discourses on Whales and Whaling, Oxford; New York: Berghahn Books.

46.

Kalland

Moeran

(1990) Endangered Culture: Japanese Whaling in Cultural Perspective, Copenhagen: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies.

47.

Kang S and Phipps M (2000) A survey of whale meat markets along South Korea's coast. Report for the TRAFFIC East Asia, July. Hong Kong: TRAFFIC East Asia. Available at: www.trafficj.org/publication/00_a_survey_of_whale_meat.pdf.

48.

Kim D-K (2013) An investigation into Korean whale industry. PhD Thesis, University of Ulsan, South Korea (in Korean).

49.

Kim

Z-G

Choi

S-G

Ahn

Y-R

et al. (2007) An ecosystem based research of cetacean resources, Report for the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, South Korea. Ulsan: NFRDI (in Korean).

50.

Kim

Z-G

Choi

S-G

Ahn

Y-R

et al. (2009) Whales, Dolphins and Porpoises Off Korean Peninsula, Ulsan: National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (in Korean).

51.

Kitakado T, An Y-R, Choi S-G, et al. (2009) Integration of Abundance Estimates for Common Minke Whales in Sub-area 5, 6, and 10 Using Sighting Data from Japanese and Korean Surveys, A report submitted to the IWC scientific committee (SC/61/NPM6).

52.

Latour

(2004) Politics of Nature, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

53.

Latour

(2007) Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

54.

Law

(1999) After ANT: Complexity, naming and topology. In: Law

Hassard

(eds) Actor Network Theory and After, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 1–14.

55.

Law

(2004) And if the global were small and noncoherent? Method, complexity, and the baroque. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 22(1): 13–26.

56.

Law

Mol

(2001) Situating technoscience: An inquiry into spatialities. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 19(5): 609–621.

57.

Lee J-W (2012) Greenpeace says Korea did not submit the scientific whaling plan. Newsis, 5 December. Available at: http://article.joins.com/news/article/article.asp?total_id=10080090 (in Korean).

58.

Lee S-W, Hong J-W, Lee Y-J, et al. (2008) Juridical and institutional management for whale-watching tourism. Report for the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, South Korea (in Korean).

59.

Lee S-W, Hong J-W, Lee Y-J, et al. (2009) The masterplan for the whale tourism theme city. Report for the Ulsan Metropolitan Government, South Korea (in Korean).

60.

Lien

Law

(2011) ‘Emergent aliens’: On salmon, nature, and their enactment. Ethnos 76(1): 65–87.

61.

Lilly

(1961) Man and Dolphin, New York: Doubleday Garden City.

62.

Lorimer

(2010) Elephants as companion species: The lively biogeographies of Asian elephant conservation in Sri Lanka. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 35(4): 491–506. .

63.

Lorimer

(2012) Multinatural geographies for the Anthropocene. Progress in Human Geography 36(5): 593–612.

64.

Lorimer

(2015) Wildlife in the Anthropocene: Conservation after Nature, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

65.

Lorimer

Driessen

(2013) Bovine biopolitics and the promise of monsters in the rewilding of heck cattle. Geoforum 48: 249–259.

66.

Lukoschek

Funahashi

Lavery

et al. (2009) The rise of commercial ‘by-catch whaling’ in Japan and Korea. Animal Conservation 12(5): 398–399.

67.

MacMillan

Han

(2011) Cetacean by-catch in the Korean Peninsula – By chance or by design?. Human Ecology 39(6): 757–768.

68.

Marston

Jones

Woodward

(2005) Human geography without scale. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 30(4): 416–432.

69.

Massey

(1994) A global sense of place. In: Space, Place, and Gender, Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 146–156.

70.

Massey

(2005) For Space, London: Sage.

71.

Meletis

Campbell

(2007) Call it consumption! Re-conceptualizing ecotourism as consumption and consumptive. Geography Compass 1(4): 850–870.

72.

Miyashita T and An Y-R (2010) Sighting survey activities of Japan and Korea for the Western North Pacific common minke whales. Report for the IWC Scientific Committee (SC/62/NPM7). Available at: https://iwc.int/document_1441.

73.

Mol

(1999) Ontological politics: A word and some questions. The Sociological Review 47(S1): 74–89.

74.

Mol

(2002) The Body Multiple: Ontology in Medical Practice, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

75.

Mol A and Law J. (1994) Regions, networks and fluids: Anaemia and social topology Social Studies of Science 24(4): 641–671.

76.

Morikawa

(2009) Whaling in Japan: Power, Politics and Diplomacy, New York: Columbia University Press.

77.

Namgu (2013) Whale, Whaling and Whale Special Zone, Ulsan: Government of South District of Ulsan City (in Korean).

78.

Neves

(2010) Cashing in on cetourism: A critical ecological engagement with dominant e-NGO discourses on whaling, cetacean conservation, and whale watching. Antipode 42(3): 719–741.

79.

O'Connor

Campbell

Cortez

et al. (2009) Whale Watching Worldwide: Tourism Numbers, Expenditures and Economic Benefits, Yarmouth Port, MA: IFAW.

80.

Ong

Collier

(2008) Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems, Oxford; Malden, MA: John Wiley and Sons.

81.

Orams

(2001) From whale hunting to whale watching in Tonga: A sustainable future?. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 9(2): 128–146.

82.

Park

G-B

(1987) The History of Contemporary Korean Whaling, Busan: Taewha Publishing (in Korean).

83.

Park K-H and Jeung S-Y (2009) Reinforced management of by-catch and illegal whaling, Press release by the MAFF, 27 May (in Korean).

84.

Parsons

Rawles

(2003) The resumption of whaling by Iceland and the potential negative impact in the Icelandic whale-watching market. Current Issues in Tourism 6(5): 444–448.

85.

Payne

McVay

(1971) Songs of humpback whales. Science 173(3997): 585–597.

86.

Peace

(2005) Loving leviathan: The discourse of whale-watching in Australian ecotourism. In: Knight

(ed.) Animals in Person: Cultural Perspectives on Human-Animal Intimacies, Oxford; New York: Berg Publications, pp. 191–210.

87.

Segi

(2003) The coexistence of whaling and whale watching in a traditional whaling region: The case of Taiji, Wakayama Prefecture, Japan. Traditional Marine Resource Management and Knowledge Information Bulletin 15: 21–25.

88.

Singleton

(2016) Clumsiness and elegance in environmental management: Applying cultural theory to the history of whaling. Environmental Politics 25(3): 414–433.

89.

Srinivasan

(2014) Caring for the collective: Biopower and agential subjectification in wildlife conservation. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 32(3): 501–517.

90.

Tatar

Lee

(2012) The challenge of governance: Cultural barriers to enforcement of the IWC whaling moratorium in Korea. Korea Observer 43(4): 617–648.

91.

Thompson

(2002) When elephants stand for competing philosophies of nature: Amboseli National Park, Kenya. In: Law

Mol

Smith

et al. (eds) Complexities: Social Studies of Knowledge Practices, Durham, NC: Duke University Press, pp. 166–190.

92.

Tsing

(2005) Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

93.

Tsing

Satuka

(2008) Diverging understandings of forest management in Matsutake science. Economic Botany 62(3): 244–253.

94.

Watanabe

(2009) Japan's Whaling: The Politics of Culture in Historical Perspective, Melbourne: Trans Pacific Press (Translated by Clake H).

95.

Weller

(2006) Discovering Nature: Globalization and Environmental Culture in China and Taiwan, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

96.

Whatmore

(2002) Hybrid Geographies: Natures Cultures Spaces, London: Sage.

97.

Whatmore

Thorne

(1998) Wild(er)ness: Reconfiguring the geographies of wildlife. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 23(4): 435–454.

98.

White

(2008) In Defense of Dolphins: The New Moral Frontier, Malden, MA; Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

99.

WWF (World Wide Fund for Nature) (2004) Cetacean Bycatch and the IWC. Gland, Switzerland: WWF Species Programme and WWF International. Available at: http://awsassets.wwf.org.au/downloads/sp138_g_cetacean_bycatch_and_the_iwc_1jul04.pdf.