Spatial governmentality and the rhetoric of scarce resources: ‘Scientific and reasonable’ points systems in Shenzhen (China)

Abstract

Since the early 2010s, all Chinese megacities have adopted points systems that allow ordinary people to apply for urban citizenship (hukou) in the city where they live. Although intended for applicants other than ‘talents’, points systems are highly selective. They are used to adjust urban population growth to economic development and to available resources. Based on research in Shenzhen, and combining Foucault and Gramsci, this article makes three arguments: first, points systems intensify the hukou system’s spatial governmentality, in that they set up a competition for scarce resources that shapes self-governing urban citizens; second, they are justified in ways that seek to produce consent, by giving them uncontestable grounding in science; and third, the gap between their proclaimed benefits and their actual, complex workings gives rise to critique, and even class-based critique.

Keywords

governmentality hegemony points systems citizenship urban economy population Foucault Gramsci critique scarcity resources carrying capacity public goods China

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anagnost

(2004). The Corporeal Politics of Quality ( Suzhi ). Public Culture 16(2), 189–208.

Arrow

Bolin

Costanza

, et al (1996) Economic growth, carrying capacity, and the environment. Ecological Applications 6(1): 13–15.

Baidu Baike Wiki Encyclopedia (2012) Shenzhen points-based household registration points table. Available at: https://baike.baidu.com/item/深圳积分入户分值表/18763901?fr=aladdin#2 (accessed 18 April 2018).

Bakken

(2000) The Exemplary Society: Human Improvement, Social Control, and the Dangers of Modernity in China. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Barnett

Clarke

Cloke

, et al (2008) The elusive subjects of neo-liberalism: Beyond the analytics of governmentality. Cultural Studies 22(5): 624–653.

Brown

(2021) Development and citizenship in the Chinese “Mayor’s Mailbox” system. Asian Survey 61(3): 443–472.

Chan

(2021) Internal Migration in China: Integration Migration with Urbanization Policies and Hukou Reform. Knomad Policy Note 16. https://www.knomad.org/publication/internal-migration-china-integrating-migration-urbanization-policies-and-hukou-reform (accessed 24 November 2021).

Chan

O’Brien

(2019) Phantom services: Deflecting migrant workers in China. The China Journal 81: 103–122.

Chen

Liang

, et al (2023) Responsive E-government in China: A way of gaining public support. Government Information Quarterly 40(3): 101809.

10.

China Daily (2010) Scientific outlook on development. Available at: xinhua/chinadaily.com.cn/people.com.cn.

11.

Creemers

(2018) China’s social credit system: An evolving practice of control. SSRN Scholarly Paper 3175792. Rochester, NY. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3175792.

12.

Crehan

KAF

(2002) Gramsci, Culture, and Anthropology. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

13.

Dean

(2015) The malthus effect: Population and the liberal government of life. Economy and Society 44(1): 18–39.

14.

Dong

Goodburn

(2020) Residence permits and points systems: New forms of educational and social stratification in urban China. Journal of Contemporary China 29(125): 647–666.

15.

(2020) The Shenzhen Experiment: The Story of China’s Instant City. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

16.

Ekers

Loftus

(2008) The power of water: Developing dialogues between Foucault and Gramsci. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 26(4): 698–718.

17.

Fairclough

(1996) Discourse and Social Change. Cambridge: Polity.

18.

Foucault

(1978) The History of Sexuality. Volume I: The Will to Knowledge. New York, NY: Random House, Inc.

19.

Foucault

(1980) Power/Knowledge. Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977. New York, NY: Pantheon.

20.

Foucault

(1991) “Governmentality.” In: Burchell

Gordon

Peter

Miller

(eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, pp.87–104.

21.

Göbel

(2021) From bulletin boards to big data: The origins and evolution of public complaint websites in China. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 50(1): 39–62.

22.

Graan

(2016) Introduction: Language and political economy, revisited. HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 6(3): 139–149.

23.

Gramsci

(1999) Selections from the Prison Notebooks. London: The Electric Book Co.

24.

Greenhalgh

(2003) Science, Modernity, and the Making of China’s One-Child Policy. Population and Development Review 29(2): 163–196.

25.

Greenhalgh

Winckler

(2005) Governing China’s Population: From Leninist to Neoliberal Biopolitics. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

26.

Greenhalgh

Zhang

(eds) (2020) Governing through science. The anthropology of science and technology in contemporary China. In: Can Science and Technology Save China? Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, pp.1–24.

27.

Guangdong Provincial Government (2010). Guiding opinions on carrying out the work of point-based systems for peasant workers' entrance into towns and cities. Available at: http://www.gd.gov.cn/gkmlpt/content/0/139/post_139081.html#7 (accessed 5 July 2010).

28.

Gueorguiev

(2021) Retrofitting Leninism: Participation without Democracy in China. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

29.

Guo

Liang

(2017) Differentiating citizenship in urban China: A case study of Dongguan city. Citizenship Studies 21(7): 773–791.

30.

Hart

(2014) Rethinking the South African Crisis: Nationalism, Populism, Hegemony. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press.

31.

Harvey

(1974) Population, resources and the ideology of science. Economic Geography 50, 256–77.

32.

Hukou Change Observation Blog (2018) Guide for entering Shenzhen household: Six hukou acquisition methods. Available at: http://hugaiguancha.blog.caixin.com/archives/185167 (accessed 1 August 2018).

33.

Jessop

(2004) Critical semiotic analysis and cultural political economy. Critical Discourse Studies 1(2): 159–174.

34.

Jessop

(2007) From micro-powers to governmentality: Foucault’s work on statehood, state formation, statecraft and state power. Political Geography 26(1): 34–40.

35.

Jessop

Sum

(2006) Beyond the Regulation Approach: Putting Capitalist Economies in Their Place. Cheltenham; Northampton: Edward Elgar.

36.

Jucheng Consulting (2024) The latest progress of Shenzhen points-based household registration. Available at: http://www.shenhus.com.cn/html/news/shenchouruhuzixun/83238.html (accessed 15 July 2024).

37.

Kipnis

(2007) Neoliberalism reified: Suzhi discourse and tropes of neoliberalism in the People’s Republic of China. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 13(2): 383–400.

38.

Lim

(2014) ‘Socialism with Chinese characteristics’: Uneven development, variegated neoliberalization and the dialectical differentiation of state spatiality. Progress in Human Geography 38(2): 221–247.

39.

(2008) Does Hukou Still Matter? The Household Registration System and Its Impact on Social Stratification and Mobility in China. Social Sciences in China, 1, 149–162.

40.

Merry

(2001) Spatial governmentality and the new social order. Controlling gender violence through law. American Anthropologist 103(1): 16–29.

41.

Message Board for Leaders (2020) Let me ask you, do people with low education have no social value? Available at: http://liuyan.people.com.cn/threads/content?tid=8667381 (accessed 26 November)

42.

Munro

(1971) The malleability of man in Chinese Marxism. The China Quarterly 48: 609–640.

43.

Perry

(2000) Governmentalities in city-scapes: Introduction to the symposium on city-spaces and arts of government. Polar: Political and Legal Anthropology Review 23(1): 65–73.

44.

Rodenbiker

(2021) Making ecology developmental: China’s environmental sciences and green modernization in global context. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 111(7): 1931–1948.

45.

Roseberry

(1994) Hegemony and the language of contention. In: Joseph

Nugent

(eds) Everyday forms of state formation: revolution and the negotiation of rule in modern Mexico. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, pp. 355–366.

46.

Sayre

(2008) The genesis, history, and limits of carrying capacity. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 98(1): 120–134.

47.

Shen

(2020) Policy coordination in the talent war to achieve economic upgrading: The case of four Chinese cities. Policy Studies (1): 1–21.

48.

Shenzhen MHRSSB, Municipal Human Resources and Social Security Bureau. (2010) Annual report on government information disclosure in 2009. Available at: http://hrss.sz.gov.cn/xxgk/xxgknb/content/post_2007852.html (accessed 16 November 2022).

49.

Shenzhen MHRSSB, Municipal Human Resources and Social Security Bureau (2021) Explanation of on the adoption of the “Shenzhen approved and point-based talent introduction and household implementation measures (draft for comment)”. Available at: http://hrss.sz.gov.cn/hdjlpt/yjzj/answer/12376 (accessed 16 November 2022).

50.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2010a) Notice on printing and distributing the trial method for migrant workers’ points-based access to hukou n°70. Available at: http://www.sz.gov.cn/zfgb/2010/gb711/content/post_4953653.html (accessed 10 April 2018).

51.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2010b) Shenzhen master plan. Available at: http://www.sz.gov.cn/attachment/0/684/684608/1344759.pdf (accessed 5 June 2023).

52.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2011) Notice on printing Shenzhen’s twelfth five-year plan n°86. Available at: http://www.sz.gov.cn/zfgb/2011/gb762/content/post_4948391.html (accessed 11 October 2022).

53.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2012), Interim measures for point-based household registration of migrant workers in Shenzhen. Available at: http://www.sz.gov.cn/cn/xxgk/zfxxgj/zcfg/szsfg/content/post_6582096.html# (accessed 11 October 2022).

54.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2017a) Answers from 7 Shenzhen municipal departments to 73 frequently asked questions. Available at: http://www.sz.gov.cn/cn/xxgk/zfxxgj/zcjd/content/post_1394169.html

55.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2017b) Trial regulations, Interim Measures for point-based hukou acquisition in Shenzhen, n°1. Available at: http://fgw.sz.gov.cn/attachment/0/297/297321/4591139.pdf (accessed 17 November 2022).

56.

Shenzhen Municipal Government (2021) Explanation on the adoption of several regulations on the relocation of household registration in Shenzhen (draft for comment), 18 June. http://hrss.sz.gov.cn/hdjlpt/yjzj/answer/12376 (accessed 16 November 2022).

57.

Shenzhen Statistics Bureau (2016) Shenzhen Statistical Yearbook 2015 http://tjj.sz.gov.cn/zwgk/zfxxgkml/tjsj/tjnj/content/post_3085977.html (accessed 10 October 2022).

58.

Shenzhen municipal planning and natural resources bureau (2021) Shenzhen Land and Space Master Plan 2020-2035. http://pnr.sz.gov.cn/xxgk/gggs/content/post_8858879.html (accessed 5 June 2023).

59.

Sigley

(2006) Chinese Governmentalities: Government, Governance and the Socialist Market Economy. Economy and Society 35(4): 487–508.

60.

Sklair

(1991) Problems of socialist development: The significance of Shenzhen special economic zone for China’s open door development strategy. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 15(2): 197–215.

61.

Smart

(2001) Local citizenship: Welfare reform urban/rural status, and exclusion in China. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 33(10): 1853–1869.

62.

Solinger

(1999) Contesting Citizenship in Urban China: Peasant Migrants, the State, and the Logic of the Market. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

63.

State Council (2006) Opinions about solving the issues of peasant migrant workers, no 5. Available at: http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2006/content_244909.htm (accessed 31 April 2018).

64.

State Council (2014a) National new urbanization plan (2014–2020). Available at: http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2014-03/16/content_2640075.htm (accessed 16 March 2022).

65.

State Council (2014b) Opinions on further promoting the reform of the household registration system no. 25. Available at: http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2014-07/30/content_8944.htm (accessed 24 July 2022).

66.

Stoddart

(2005) The Gramsci–Foucault nexus and environment sociology. Alternative Routes 21: 26–40.

67.

Sum

Jessop

(2013) Towards a cultural political economy: Putting culture in its place in political economy. Cheltenham, UK: Elgar.

68.

Thornton

(2011) Retrofitting the steel frame: From mobilizing the masses to surveying the public. In Heilmann

Perry

(eds) Mao’s Invisible Hand, The Political Foundations of Adaptive Governance in China. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, pp.237–258.

69.

Tomba

(2014) The Government Next Door: Neighborhood Politics in Urban China (1st ed.). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

70.

Trémon

(2023a) From Village Commons to Public Goods. Graduated Provision in Urbanizing China. Oxford/New York: Berghahn.

71.

Trémon

(2023b). Schools as drivers of capitalist accumulation conditional socialized reproduction in Shenzhen. Dialectical Anthropology 47: 253–273.

72.

Trémon

Chen

Liu

(2024) Citizenization or talent recruitment? The development of China’s points-based hukou channels. Journal of Contemporary China 1–17. DOI: 10.1080/10670564.2024.2360058

73.

Walsh

(2011) Quantifying citizens: Neoliberal restructuring and immigrant selection in Canada and Australia. Citizenship Studies 15(6–7): 861–879.

74.

Wan

Vickers

(2022) Towards meritocratic apartheid? Points systems and migrant access to China’s urban public schools. The China Quarterly 249: 210–238.

75.

Wang

Liu

(2018) Interpreting Chinese hukou system from a Foucauldian perspective. Urban Policy and Research 36(2): 153–167.

76.

Wang

(2020) Permits, points, and permanent household registration: Recalibrating hukou policy under “top-level design”. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 49(3): 269–290.

77.

Wang

Chan

Yang

(2021) Economic restructuring and migrant workers’ coping strategies in China’s Pearl River Delta. Third World Quarterly 42(4): 812–830.

78.

WeChat (2021a) Find out now! The latest news of Shenzhen point-based household registration is here! so many changes. Available at: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/_Y7XCKe1MGM5KxaZGjvOkQ (accessed 3 June2021).

79.

WeChat (2021b) Heavy News, Shenzhen intends to tighten the settlement policy!. Available at: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/saSPtJCkYpqR0Yf3MpzLZA (accessed 26 May 2021).

80.

Wong

Wai-Po

(1998) Reforming the household registration system: A preliminary glimpse of the blue chop household registration system in Shanghai and Shenzhen. International Migration Review 32(4): 974.

81.

Woodman

Guo

(2017) Introduction: Practicing citizenship in contemporary China. Citizenship Studies 21(7): 737–754.

82.

Yan

(2003) Neoliberal Governmentality and Neohumanism: Organizing Suzhi/Value Flow through Labor Recruitment Networks. Cultural Anthropology 18(4): 493–523.

83.

Zhang

(2018) Governing neoliberal authoritarian citizenship: Theorizing hukou and the changing mobility regime in China. Citizenship Studies 22(8): 855–881.

84.

Zhang

(2012) Economic migration and urban citizenship in China: The role of points systems. Population and Development Review 38(3): 503–533.

85.

Zhang

(2016) Local fiscal capability and liberalization of urban hukou. Journal of Contemporary China 25(102): 893–907.

86.

Zhang

Mol

APJ

Sonnenfeld

(2007) The interpretation of ecological modernisation in China. Environmental Politics 16(4): 659–668.