Murray Ryburn considers how the courts in England and Wales apply contrasting principles to achieve very different outcomes in the private law where there are disputed questions of contact in divorce and separation on the one hand, and on the other, in adoption. He challenges the extent to which such divergence can be justified when the similarities between the questions at issue could be expected more reasonably to lead to comparable approaches. Reasons for the existence of this judicial divide are considered, alongside the consequent harm that may thereby result in the lives of some children and their kin networks.
AyalonOFlasherA, Chain Reaction: Children and divorce, London: Jessica Kingsley, 1993
2.
BrodzinskyDSingerLBraffA, ‘Children's understanding of adoption‘, Child Development55, 1984, pp 869–78
3.
CicirelliV, ‘Sibling influence throughout the lifespan‘, in LambMSutton-SmithB (eds), Sibling Relationships: Their nature and significance across the lifespan, Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1982, pp 267–84
4.
CullenD, ‘Freeing for adoption: Whether court should hear from prospective adopters on question of contact‘, Adoption & Fostering17:4, 1993, pp 49–50
5.
CullenD, Adoption: A service for children - response to the draft adoption bill, London: BAAF, 1996, p 14
6.
Department of Health, Social Services Inspectorate, Contact Orders Study: A study of local authority decision-making around contact applications under section 34, London: DoH, 1994
7.
Department of Health, Social Services Inspectorate, Moving Goalposts: A study of post-adoption contact in the North of England, London: DoH, 1995
8.
Department of Health/Welsh Office, Adoption - A service for children: Adoption bill - A consultative document, London: DoH, 1996
9.
DominickC, Early Contact in Adoption: Contact between birth mothers and adoptive parents at the time of and after adoption, Research Series No 10, Wellington: Department of Social Welfare, 1989
10.
EtterJ, ‘Levels of co-operation and satisfaction in 56 open adoptions‘, Child Welfare72: 3, 1993, pp 257–267
11.
Family Rights Group, Promoting links: Keeping children and families in touch, London: FRG, 1986
12.
FieldJ, ‘Long-term outcomes for birth mothers before and after reunion‘, Adoption & Fostering14:3, 1990, pp 14–17
13.
FratterJRoweJSapsfordDThoburnJ, Permanent Family Placement: A decade of experience, London: BAAF, 1991
14.
FratterJ, Perspectives on Adoption with Contact: Implications for policy and practice, Cranfield University, Doctoral thesis, 1994
15.
GoldsteinJFreudASolnitA, Beyond the Best Interests of the Child, New York: Free Press, 1973
16.
GrotevantHMcRoyREldeCFravelD, ‘Adoptive Family Systems Dynamics: Variations by levels of openness‘, Family Process33:2, 1994, pp 125–146
17.
Hansard, Vol 461, 1948–49
18.
HetheringtonECoxMCoxR, ‘Long-term effects of divorce and remarriage on the adjustment of children‘, Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry24, 1985, pp 518–30
19.
HolmanR, ‘The place of fostering in social work‘, British Journal of Social Work5:1, 1975, pp 3–29
20.
Horsburgh Report, Report of the Departmental Committee on Adoption Societies and Agencies, London: British Parliamentary Papers, Cmnd 5499, 1937
21.
JollyS, ‘Cutting the ties - the termination of contact in care‘, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law3, 1994, pp 299–311
22.
KayeKWarrenS, ‘Discourse about adoption in adoptive families‘, Journal of Family Psychology4, 1988, pp 406–33
23.
KlienM, Western Systems of Juvenile Justice, USA: Sage, 1984
24.
KraftAPalomboJWoodsPMitchellDSchmidtA, ‘Some theoretical considerations on confidential adoptions, Part I: The birth mother‘, Child and Adolescent Social Work2, 1985, pp 13–22
25.
KraftAPalomboJMitchellDWoodsPTuckerN, ‘Some theoretical considerations on confidential adoptions, Part II: the adoptive parent', as above, pp 69–82
26.
KraftAPalomboJMitchellDWoodsPSchmidtATuckerN, ‘Some theoretical considerations on confidential adoption, Part III: the adopted child', as above, pp 139–153
27.
KraftAPalomboJMitchellDWoodsPSchmidtATuckerN, ‘Some theoretical considerations on confidential adoption, Part IV: Counter transference‘, Child and Adolescent Social Work4, 1986, pp 3–14
28.
LahtiJ, ‘A follow-up study of foster children in permanent placements‘, Social Service Review, December 1982, pp 556–71
29.
MainM, ‘Metacognitive knowledge, metacognitive monitoring, and singular (coherent) vs multiple (incoherent) model of attachment: Findings and directions for future research‘, in ParkesCStevenson-HindeJMarrisP (eds), Attachment across the Life Cycle, London: Routledge, 1995, pp 127–59
McWhinnieA, Adopted Children: How they grew up, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1967
32.
McWhinnieA, ‘The concept of “open adoption” - How valid is it?’, in McWhinnieASmithJ (eds), Current Human Dilemmas in Adoption: The challenge for parents, practitioners and policy makers, Dundee: University of Dundee, 1994, pp 7–32
33.
MillhamSBullockRHosieKHaakM, Children Lost in Care: The family contact of children in care, Aldershot: Gower, 1986
34.
MilnerJ, ‘A disappearing act: The differing career paths of fathers and mothers in child protection investigations‘, Critical Social Policy38, Autumn 1993
35.
PettitP, ‘Parental control and guardianship‘, in GravesonRCraneF (eds), A Century of Family Law, London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1957
36.
RaynorL, The Adopted Child Comes of Age, London: George Allen & Unwin, 1980
37.
RockelJRyburnM, Adoption Today: Change and choice in New Zealand, Auckland: Heinemann/Reed, 1988
38.
RoweJCainHHundlebyMKeaneA, Long-term Foster Care, London: Batsford/BAAF, 1984
39.
RyburnM, ‘Birth parents and contested adoption‘, in RyburnM (ed), Contested Adoptions: Research, law, policy and practice, Aldershot: Gower/Arena, 1994a, pp 159–74
40.
RyburnM, ‘The use of an adversarial process in contested adoptions', in RyburnM (ed), as above, 1994b, pp 187–202
41.
RyburnM, ‘Adoptive parents and contested adoptions', in RyburnM (ed), as above, 1994c, pp 139–58
42.
RyburnM, ‘Ideology and conflict: The place of adoption in English child welfare services‘, Children and Youth Services Review17: 5/6, 1995a, pp 707–24
43.
RyburnM, ‘Secrecy and openness in adoption: An historical perspective‘, Journal of Social Policy and Administration29:2, 1995b, pp 150–68
44.
RyburnM, ‘Adopted children's identity and information needs‘, Children and Society9:3, 1995c, pp 41–64
45.
RyburnM, ‘A study of post-adoption contact in compulsory adoptions‘, British Journal of Social Work26:5, 1996, pp 627–46
46.
SachdevP, ‘The triangle of fears, fallacies and facts‘, in HibbsE (ed), Adoption: International perspectives, Maddison CT: International Universities Press, 1991
47.
SchafferH, Making Decisions about Children: Psychological questions and answers, Oxford: Blackwell, 1990
48.
SelwynJ, ‘Ascertaining children's wishes and feelings in relation to adoption‘, Adoption & Fostering20:3, 1996, pp 14–20
49.
SilberKDornerP, Children of Open Adoption and their Families, San Antonio: Corona Publishing Company, 1990
50.
Tomlin Report, First Report of the Child Adoption Committee, London: British Parliamentary Papers, Cmnd 2401, 1925, p 9, para 28
51.
TrentJ, Homeward Bound, Ilford: Barnardo's, 1989
52.
WallersteinJKellyJ, Surviving the Breakup, New York: Grant MacIntyre, 1980
53.
WallersteinJCorbinSLewisJ, ‘Children of divorce: A ten-year study‘, in HetheringtonEArastehJ (eds), Impact of Divorce, Single Parenting, and Step Parenting on Children, Hillsdale NJ: Erlbaum, 1988
54.
WinklerRvan KeppelM, Relinquishing Mothers in Adoption, Melbourne: Institute for Family Studies, 1984
