This article offers a reply to Werner Bonefeld’s recent contribution to the debate on value and abstract labour, in which he critically engages with our previous articles dealing with these questions. We argue that Bonefeld’s criticisms are not simply based on disagreements over these controversial issues, but also on a misunderstanding of our stance on abstract labour and value. In addition to clarifying our position, the article provides some brief critical remarks on Bonefeld’s own intervention in the debate and shows that his contribution fails to offer a solid analysis of the fundamental categories of the critique of political economy.
Bonefeld W. ( 1992) Social constitution and the form of the capitalist state . In Bonefeld W, Gunn R, Psychopedis K (eds.) Open Marxism. Volume I: Dialectics and History. London: Pluto Press .
2.
Bonefeld W. ( 2010) Abstract labour: Against its nature and on its time. Capital & Class34(2).
3.
Heinrich M. ( 2008) Critica De La Economia Politica: Una Introduccion A El Capital De Marx. Madrid: Escolar y Mayo.
4.
Hegel G. ( 1999) Science of Logic. Amherst, NY: Humanity Books.
5.
Iñigo Carrera J. ( 2007) Conocer el capital hoy. Usar críticamente El Capital . Buenos Aires: Imago Mundi.
6.
Iñigo Carrera J. (forthcoming) The Method, from the Grundrisse to Capital. In Bellofiore R, Starosta G, Thomas P (eds.) In Marx’s Laboratory. Critical Interpretations of the Grundrisse. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
7.
Kicillof A., Starosta G. ( 2007a) On materiality and social form: A political critique of Rubin’s value-form theory. Historical Materialism15(3).
8.
Kicillof A., Starosta G. ( 2007b) Value-form and class struggle: A critique of the autonomist theory of value. Capital & Class92.
9.
Marx K. ( 1975 [1881]) Notes on Adolf Wagner. In Carver T (ed.) Texts on Method. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
10.
Marx K. ( 1976a [1867]) Capital, Vol. I. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
11.
Marx K. ( 1976b [1867]) Results of the Immediate Process of Production. In Capital, Vol. 1. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
12.
Marx K. ( 1987 [1859]) Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. In MECW 29. London: Lawrence & Wishart.
13.
Marx K. ( 1993[1857]) Grundrisse. Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy. Harmondsworth: Penguin .
14.
Murray P. ( 2000) Marx’s ‘truly social’ labour theory of value: Part I, abstract labour in Marxian value theory. Historical Materialism6, Summer.
15.
Rubin I. ( 1973) Essays on Marx’s Theory of Value. Montreal: Black Rose Books.
16.
Starosta G. ( 2008) The commodity-form and the dialectical method. Science and Society, 72(3).
17.
Starosta G. ( 2011) Machinery, productive subjectivity and the limits to capitalism in Capital and the Grundrisse, Science and Society, 75(1).
