The author examines the relationship between Marxism and critical realism. He problematises the suggestion that Marx implicitly utilised a critical realist theoretical framework. He does this by exploring three areas of inquiry: epistemology and ideology; the method of abstraction; causal powers and social form. By exploring these areas, the author demonstrates that critical realism in fact pursues a different theoretical project to that of Marxism. Moreover, by severing the link between theory and practice, critical realism commits fundamental theoretical problems and errors which it initially claimed to have surpassed. The author concludes by suggesting that these problems were inherent within the critical realist project from the outset.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albury, R., G. Payne and W. Suchting (1981) ‘Naturalism and the Human Sciences’ in Economy and Society10(3) August: 367–79.
2.
Arthur, Christopher J. (1997) ‘Against the Logical-Historical Method: Dialectical Derivation versus Linear Logic’ in Fred Mosely and Martha Campbell (eds.) Op.cit.: 9-37.
3.
Baert, Patrick (1996) ‘Realist Philosophy of the Social Sciences and Economics: A Critique’ in Cambridge Journal of Economics20: 513–522.
4.
Banaji, Jairus (1979) ‘From the Commodity to Capital: Hegel's Dialectic in Marx's “Capital”’ in Diane Elson (ed.) Value: The Representation of Labour in Capitalism.CSE Books, London: 14–45.
5.
Benton, Ted (1977) Philosophical Foundations of the Three Sociologies. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
6.
Benton, Ted (1981a) ‘Realism and Social Science: Some Comments on Roy Bhaskar's “The Possibility of Naturalism”’ in Radical Philosophy27: 13–21.
7.
Benton, Ted (1981b) ‘“Objective” Interests and the Sociology of Power’ in Sociology15 (2): 161–84.
8.
Benton, Ted (1993) Natural Relations: Ecology, Animal Rights and Social Justice. Verso, London.
9.
Benton, Ted (1997) ‘Response to Cecile Jackson’. Economy and Society26(1): 81–91.
10.
Bhaskar, Roy (1978) A Realist Theory of Science2nd edition, Verso, London.
11.
Bhaskar, Roy (1989) Reclaiming Reality. Verso, London.
12.
Bhaskar, Roy (1993) Dialectic: The Pulse of Freedom.Verso, London
13.
Bryant, G. A. (1995) Practical Sociology: Post-Empiricism and the Reconstruction of Theory and Application.Polity Press, Cambridge.
14.
Burkett, Paul (1998) ‘A Critique of Neo-Malthusian Marxism: Society, Nature and Population’ in Historical Materialism2, Summer: 118–142.
15.
Carchedi, Guglielmo (1983) ‘A Critical Note on Bhaskar and Systems Theory’ in Radical Philosophy33, Spring: 27–30.
16.
Clarke, Simon (1983) ‘State, Class Struggle and the Reproduction of Capital’ in Kapitalistate10-11: 113–130.
17.
Clarke, Simon (1991) Marx's Theory of Crisis. Macmillan, Basingstoke and London.
18.
Clarke, Simon (1994) ’The Value of Value: A Review of “Rereading Capital”’ in Simon Mohun (ed.) Debates in Value Theory.Macmillan, London: 129–48.
19.
Collier, Andrew (1979) ‘In Defence of Epistemology’ in John Mepham and David-Hillel Ruben (eds.) Issues in Marxist Philosophy, Vol.III: Epistemology, Science, Ideology.The Harvester Press: Sussex: 55–106.
20.
Collier, Andrew (1994) Critical Realism: An Introduction to Roy Bhaskar's Philosophy. Verso, London.
21.
Collier, Andrew (1996) ‘Engels: Revolutionary Realist?’ in Christopher J Arthur. (ed.) Engels Today: A Centenary Appreciation.Macmillan, London: 29–46.
22.
Dickens, Peter (1996) Reconstructing Nature: Alienation, Emancipation and the Division of Labour. Routledge, London.
23.
Elson, Diane (1979) ‘The Value Theory of Labour’ in Diane Elson (ed.) Value: The Representation of Labour in Capitalism.CSE Books, London: 115–180.
24.
Engels Frederick (1975) Anti-Dühring. Progress Publishers, Moscow.
25.
Fay, Brian (1990) ‘Critical Realism?’ in Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour20(1): 33–41.
26.
Gough, Jamie and Aram Eisenschitz (1997) ‘The Division of Labour, Capitalism and Socialism: An Alternative to Sayer’ in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research21(1): 23–37.
27.
Gunn, Richard (1989) ‘Marxism and Philosophy: A Critique of Critical Realism’, in Capital & Class37: 86–116.
28.
Hadden, Richard W. (1988) ‘Social Relations and the Content of Early Modern Science’ in The British Journal of Sociology39(2): 255–80.
29.
Harré, Rom and E.H. Madden (1975) Causal Powers. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
30.
Harris, Laurence (1979) ‘The Theory of Value and the Value of Theory: A Reply to Cutler et al.’ in Economy and Society8: 342–64.
31.
Hoffman, John (1975) Marxism and the Theory of Praxis.Lawrence & Wishart.
32.
Hoffman, John (1986) The Gramscian Challenge. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
33.
Holloway, John and Sol Picciotto (1978) ‘Introduction: Towards a Materialist Theory of the State’ in John Holloway and Sol Picciotto (eds.) State and Capital: A Marxist Debate.Edward Arnold, London: 1–31.
34.
Isaac, Jeffrey C. (1990) ‘Realism and Reality: Some Realistic Reconsiderations’ in Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour20(1): 1–31.
35.
Jackson, Cecile (1997) ‘Women in Critical Realist Environmentalism: Subaltern to the Species?’ in Economy and Society26(1): 62–80.
36.
Jessop, Bob (1982) The Capitalist State: Marxist Theories and Methods. New York University Press, New York.
37.
Jessop, Bob (1990) State Theory: Putting Capitalist States in their Place. Polity Press, Cambridge.
38.
Joseph, Jonathan (1998) ‘In Defence of Critical Realism’ in Capital&Class65 Summer: 73–106.
39.
Keat, Russell and John Urry (1982) Social Theory as Science2nd edition. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
40.
Larrain, Jorge (1979) The Concept of Ideology. Hutchinson, London.
41.
Larrain, Jorge (1983) Marxism and Ideology. Macmillan, London.
42.
Larrain, Jorge (1994) Ideology and Cultural Identity: Modernity and the Third World Presence, Polity Press, Cambridge.
43.
Lawson, Tony (1997) Economics and Reality. Routledge, London.
44.
Lenin, V.I. (1964) Materialism and Empirio-Criticism.Lawrence & Wishart.
Lewis, P.A. (1996) ‘Metaphor and Critical Realism’ in Review of Social EconomyLIV(4) Winter: 487–506.
47.
Lovering, John (1987) ‘Militarism, Capitalism and the Nation-State: Towards a Realist Synthesis’ in Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5: 283–302.
48.
Lovering, John (1990) ‘Neither Fundamentalism nor “New Realism”: A Critical Realist Perspective on Current Divisions in Socialist Theory’ in Capital & Class42, Winter: 30–54.
49.
Lukács, G. (1971) History and Class Consciousness. MIT Press, Cambridge.
50.
Manicas, Peter T. (1987) A History and Philosophy of the Social Sciences. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
51.
Marsden, Richard (1998) ‘The Unknown Masterpiece: Marx's Model of “Capital”’ in Cambridge Journal of Economics v: 297–324.
52.
Marx, Karl (1966) Capital III, Progress Publishers, Moscow.
53.
Marx, Karl (1970) Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts. Lawrence & Wishart, London.
54.
Marx, Karl (1972a) A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. International Publishers, New York.
55.
Marx, Karl (1972b) Theories of Surplus-Value II. Lawrence & Wishart, London.
56.
Marx, Karl (1973) The Grundrisse. Pelican, London.
57.
Marx, Karl (1988) Capital I. Penguin, Middlesex.
58.
Marx, Karl and Frederick Engels (1968) The German Ideology. Progress Publishers, Moscow.
59.
Mattick Jr., Paul (1997) ‘Theory as Critique: On the Argument in Capital’ in Fred Mosely and Martha Campbell (eds.), op cit.: 66-88.
60.
Medvedev, P.N.M.M. Bakhtin (1978) The Formal Method in Literary Scholarship, trans. by Albert J. Wehrle, John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
61.
Moseley, F., and Martha Campbell (eds) (1997) New Investigations of Marx's Method. Humanities Press International, New Jersey.
62.
O'Neill, J. (1996) ‘Engels Without: Dogmatism’ in C.J. Arthur (ed.) op cit: 47-66.
63.
Outhwaite, William (1987) New Philosophies of Social Science: Realism, Hermeneutics and Critical Theory. Macmillan, London.
64.
Outhwaite, William (1990) ‘Realism, Naturalism and Social Behaviour’ in Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour20(4): 365–377.
65.
Pashukanis, Evgeny B. (1989) Law and Marxism: A General Theory, trans. by Barbara Einhorn, ed. by Chris Arthur, Pluto Press, London.
66.
Postone, Moishe (1996) Time, Labor, and Social Domination. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
67.
Pratt, Andy C. (1995) ‘Putting Critical Realism to Work: the Practical Implications for Geographical Research’ in Progress in Human Geography19(1): 61–74.
68.
Rosenberg, Justin (1994) The Empire of Civil Society: A Critique of the Realist Theory of International Relations. Verso, London.
69.
Ruben, David-Hillel (1977) Marxism and Materialism: A Study in Marxist Theory of Knowledge. The Harvester Press, Sussex.
Sayer, Andrew (1981) ‘Abstraction: A Realist Interpretation’ in Radical Philosophy26, Summer: 6–15.
72.
Sayer, Andrew (1994) Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach2nd editionLondon: Routledge.
73.
Sayer, Andrew (1995) ‘Liberalism, Marxism and Urban Regional Studies’ in International Journal of Urban and Regional Studies, 19(1): 79–95.
74.
Sayer, Andrew (1997) ‘Essentialism, Social Constructionism, and beyond’ in The Sociological Review, 45(3): 453–487.
75.
Sayer, Derek (1987) The Violence of Abstraction: The Analytical Foundations of Historical Materialism. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
76.
Sayers, Sean (1983) ‘Materialism, Realism and the Reflection Theory’ in Radical Philosophy, Spring 33: 16–26.
77.
Sayers, Sean (1985) Reality and Reason. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
78.
Sayers, Sean (1996) ‘Engels and Materialism’ in Christopher J Arthur. (ed.) op cit.: 153-172.
79.
Smith, Tony (1997) ‘Marx's Theory of Social Forms and Lakatos's Methodology of Scientific Research Programs’ in Fred Mosely and Martha Campbell (eds.) op cit.: 176-197.
80.
Stockman, Norma (1983) Antipositivist Theories of the Sciences: Critical Rationalism, Critical Theory and Scientific Realism. Dordrecht (Netherlands), Reidal.
81.
Suchting, Wal (1992) ‘Reflections on Roy Bhaskar's “Critical Realism” ’ in Radical Philosophy61, Summer:23–31.
82.
Valera, Charles (1995) ‘Ethnogenic Theory and Psychoanalysis: The Unconscious as a Social Construction and as a Failed Explanatory Concept’ in Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour25(4): 363–385.
83.
Valera, Charles and Rom Harré (1996) ‘Conflicting Varieties of Realism: Causal Powers and the Problems of Social Structure’ in Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour26(3): 313–325.
84.
Weeks, John (1981) Capital and Exploitation. Edward Arnold, London.
85.
Weeks, John (1997) ‘The Law of Value and the Analysis of Underdevelopment’ in Historical Materialism I, Autumn: 91–112.
86.
Woodiwiss, Anthony (1990) Social Theory After Postmodernism: Rethinking Production, Law and Class. Pluto Press, London.
87.
Woolfson, Charles (1982) The Labour Theory of Culture. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
