A prospective study comparing standardized non-bronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage (sNB-BAL) and nonspecific endotracheal aspirate (NsETA) in the microbiological diagnosis of pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients is described. One hundred episodes in 82 mechanically ventilated patients with or without radiological and clinical diagnostic criteria of pneumonia were studied. NsETA and sNB-BAL was performed on the day of study. Fifty-one patients had pneumonia (21 ventilator-associated, 12 hospital-acquired, 18 community-acquired) and 49 had no pneumonia as defined by widely accepted clinico-radiological criteria. The sNB-BAL was found to be significantly more specific (0.73) compared to NsETA (0.35) for the microbiological diagnosis of pneumonia. Colonization rates with NsETA were significantly higher compared to sNB-BAL (P value <0.0001). No patient had complications attributable to the sNB-BAL procedure. We conlude that sNB-BAL is a safe, effective, sensitive, specific and inexpensive procedure for the serial evaluation of pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients.
JohansonWrJr., PierceA.K., SabfordJ.P.Nosocomial respiratory infection with Gram-negative bacilli: the significance of colonization of the respiratory tract.Ann Intern Med1972; 77: 701–706.
CravenD.E., KunchesL.M., KilinskyV.Risk factors for pneumonia and fatality in patients receiving continuous mechanical ventilation.Am Rev Respir Dis1986; 133: 792–796.
8.
GrinerP.F., MayewskiR.J., MushlinA.I.Selection and interpretation of diagnostic tests and procedures—Principles and applications.Ann Intern Med1981; 94(Part 2): 553–592.
9.
TorresA., AznarR., GatellJ.M.Incidence, risk, and prognosis factors of nosocomial pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients.Am Rev Respir Dis1990; 142: 523–528.
10.
CelisR., TorresA., GatellJ.M.Nosocomial pneumonia: a multivariate analysis of risk and prognosis.Chest1988; 93: 318–324.
11.
PingletonS., FagonJ.Y., LeeperK.Patient selection for clinical investigation of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Criteria for evaluating diagnostic techniques.Chest1992; 102: 553S–556S.
12.
RodriquezJ.L., GibbonsK.J., BitzerL.G.Pneumonia: Incidence, risk factors, and outcome in injured patients.J Trauma1991; 31: 907–914.
13.
WeardenP.D., ChendrasekharA., TimberlakeG.A.Comparison of nonbronchoscopic techniques with bronchoscopic brushing in the diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia.J Trauma1996; 41: 703–707.
14.
ChastreJ., FagonJ., SolerP.Diagnosis of nosocomial bacterial pneumonia in intubated patients undergoing ventilation: comparison of the usefulness of bronchoalveolar lavage and the protected specimen brush.Am J Med1988; 85: 499–506.
15.
FagonJ.Y., ChastreJ., HanceA.J.Nosocomial pneumonia in ventilated patients: a cohort study evaluating attributable mortality and hospital stay.Am J Med1993; 94: 281–288.
16.
BaselskiV.S., Ei-TorkyM., CoalsonJ.J.The standardization of criteria for processing and interpreting laboratory specimens in patients with suspected ventilator-associated pneumonia.Chest1992; 102: 571S–579S.
17.
AndrewsC.P., CoalsonJ.J., SmithJ.D.Diagnosis of noso-comial pneumonia in acute, diffuse lung injury.Chest1981; 80: 254–258.
18.
ChastreJ., ViauF., BrunP.Prospective evaluation of the protected specimen brush for the diagnosis of pulmonary infections in ventilated patients.Am Rev Respir Dis1984; 130: 924–929.
19.
ChastreJ., FagonJ., Bornet-LescoM.Evaluation of bronchoscopic techniques for the diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia.Am J Respir Crit Care Med1995; 152: 231–240.
20.
CartierF.Strategy in immunocompromised patients with pulmonary infilterates.Intensive Care Med1987; 13: 87–88.
21.
CaugheyG., WongH., GamsuG.Nonbronchoscopic bron-choalveolar lavage for the diagnosis of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome.Chest1985; 88: 659–662.
22.
MannJ.M., AltusC.S., WebberC.A.Nonbronchoscopic lung lavage for diagnosis of opportunistic infection in AIDS.Chest1987; 91: 319–322.
23.
LevyH.Comparison of Ballard catheter brochoalveolar lavage with bronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage.Chest1994; 106: 1753–1756.
24.
BelloS., TejadaA., ChaconE.“Blind” protected specimen brushing versus bronchoscopic techniques in the aetiological diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia.Eur Respir J1996; 9: 1494–1499.
25.
MarikP.E., BrownW.J.A comparison of bronchoscopic vs blind protected specimen brush sampling in patients with suspected ventilator-associated pneumonia.Chest1995; 108: 203.
26.
KollefM.H., BockK.R., RichardsR.D.The safety and diagnostic accuracy of minibronchoalveolar lavage in patients with suspected ventilator-associated pneumonia.Ann Intern Med1995; 122: 743–748.
27.
PuginJ., AuckenthalerR., MiliN.Diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia by bacteriologic analysis of broncho-scopic and nonbronchoscopic “blind” bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.Am Rev Respir Dis1991; 143: 1121–1129.
28.
ZuckerA., PollackM., KatzR.Blind use of the double-lumen plugged catheter for diagnosis of respiratory tract infections in critically ill children.Crit Care Med1984; 12: 867–870.
29.
RoubyJ.J., Martin, de LasseleE.M.Nosocomial broncho-pneumonia in the critically ill.Am Rev Respir Dis1992; 146: 1059–1066.
30.
TorresA., PuigJ., Rodriguez-RoisinR.Diagnostic value of telescoping plugged catheters in mechanically ventilated patients with bacterial pneumonia using Metras catheter.Am Rev Respir Dis1988; 138: 117–120.
31.
Leal-NovalS.R., Alfaro-RodriguesE., Murillo-CabezaF.Diagnostic value of the blind brush in mechanically-ventilated patients by the blind protected telescoping catheter.Intensive Care Med1992; 18: 410–414.
32.
Ha-PhamL., Brun-BuissonC., LegrandP.Diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients: comparison of plugged telescopic catheter with the protected specimen brush.Am Rev Respir Dis1991; 143: 1055–1061.
33.
RoubyJ.J., RossignonM.D., NicolasM.H.A prospective study of protected bronchoalveolar lavage in the diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia.Anesthesiology1989; 71: 679–685.
34.
GaussorguesP., PipernoD., BachmannP.Comparison of non-bronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage to open lung biopsy for the bacteriologic diagnosis of pulmonary infection in mechanically ventilated patients.Intensive Care Medicine1989; 13: 259–264.
35.
MarquetteC.H., WalletF., NeriereR.Diagnostic value of direct examination of the protected specimen brush in ventilator-associated pneumonia.Eur Respir J1994; 7: 105–113.
36.
BaselskiV.S., WunderinkR.G.Practical Laboratory guidelines for performing respiratory cultures on patients with ventilator-associated pneumonia.Clinical Microbiology Newsletter1994; 16: 65–69.
37.
GraveveA.M., SawU.K., AklB.F.Role of different methods of lung biopsy in the diagnosis of lung lesions.Am J Surg1980; 140: 742.
38.
MeduriG.U., ChastreJ.The standardization of bronchoscopic techniques for ventilator-associated pneumonia.Chest1992; 102: 557S–564S.
39.
TorresA., El-EbiaryM., PadroL.Validation of different techniques for the diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia—comparison with immediate postmortem pulmonary biopsy.Am J Crit Care Med1994; 149: 324–331.
40.
TorresA., El-EbiaryM.Diagnostic approaches and hospital-acquired pneumonia.Sem Respir Crit Care Med1997; 18: 149–161.
41.
MarquetteC.H., CopinM.C., WalletF.Diagnostic tests for pneumonia in ventilated patients: Prospective evaluation of diagnostic accuracy using histology as a diagnostic gold standard.Am J Respir Crit Care Med1995; 151: 231–240.
42.
PapazianL., MartinC., AlbaneseJ., SauxP., CharrelJ., GouinF.Comparison of two methods of bacteriologic sampling of the lower respiratory tract: A study in ventilated patients with nosocomial brochopneumonia.Crit Care Med1989; 17: 461–464.
43.
FagonJ.Y., ChastreJ., HanceA.J.detection of nosocomial lung infection in ventilated patients: use of protected specimen brush and quantitative culture techniques in 147 patients.Am Rev Respir Dis1988; 138: 110–116.
44.
Brun-BuissonC.Microbiological diagnosis of ventilator associated pneumonia: to direct or not to direct sampling?Intensive Care Med1993; 19: 367–368.
45.
JohansonW.G.Jr., SeidenfieldJ.J., GomezP.Bacteriologic diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia following prolonged mechanical ventilation.Am Rev Respir Dis1988; 137: 259–64.
46.
GaussorguesP., PipernoD., BachmanP.Comparison of nonbronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage to open lung biopsy for the bacteriologic diagnosis of pulmonary infections in mechanically ventilated patients.Intensive Care Med1989; 15: 94–98.
47.
MiddletonR., BroughtonW.A., KirkpatrickM.B.Comparison of four methods for assessing airway bacteriology in intubated, mechanically-ventilated patients.Am J Med Sci1992; 304: 239–245.
48.
AlpertB.E., O'SullivanB.P., PanitchH.B.Nonbronchoscopic approach to bronchoalveolar lavage in children with artificial airways.Pediatr Pulmonol1992; 13: 38–41.
49.
JordaR., ParrasF., IbanezJ.Diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients by the blind protected telescoping catheter.Intensive Care Med1993; 19: 377–382.
50.
PipernoD., GaussorguesP., BachmannP.Diagnostic value of nonbronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage during mechanical ventilation.Chest1988; 93: 223.
51.
TorresA., BellacasaL.P., XaubetA.Diagnostic value of quantitative cultures of bronchoalveolar lavage and telescoping plugged catheters in mechanically-ventilated patients with bacterial pneumonia.Am Rev Respir Dis1989; 140: 306–310.
52.
WimberlyN., FalingL.J., BartlettJ.C.A fiberoptic technique to obtain uncontaminated lower airway secretion for bacterial culture.Am Rev Respir Dis1979; 119: 337.
MarquetteC.H., GeorgesH., WalletF.Diagnostic efficiency of endotracheal aspirates with quantitative bacterial cultures in intubated patients with suspected pneumonia: comparison with the protected specimen brush.Am Rev Respir Dis1993; 148: 138–144.
55.
ChevvetS., HemmerM., CarletJ.Incidence and risk factors of pneumonia acquired in intensive care units. Results from a multicentre prospective study on 996 patients.Intensive Care Med1993; 19: 256–264.
56.
BryanC.S., ReynoldsK.L.Bacteremic nosocomial pneumonia. Analysis of 172 episodes from a single metropolitan area.Am Rev Respir Dis1984; 129: 668–671.
57.
El-EbiaryM., TorresA., GonzalezJ.Quantitative cultures of endotracheal aspirates for the diagnosis of ventilator associated pneumonia.Am Rev Respir Dis1993; 148: 1552–1557.
58.
JourdainB., NovaraA., Joly-GuillouM.L.Role of quantitative cultures of endotracheal aspirates in the diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia.Am J Respir Crit Care Med1995; 152: 241.
59.
FabergasN., TorresA., El-EbiaryM.Histopathologic and microbiologic aspects of ventilator associated pneumonia.Anesthesiology1996; 84: 760–771.
60.
TorresA., MartosA., Puig de la BellacasaJ.Specificity of endotracheal aspiration, protected specimen brush and bronchoalveolar lavage in mechanically ventilated patients.Am Rev Respir Dis1993; 147: 952–957.
MarquetteC.H., HerengtF., SaulmierF.Protected specimen brush in the assessment of ventilator associated pneumonia: Selection of a certain segment for bronchoscopic sampling is unnecessary.Chest1993; 103: 243–247.
63.
FlanaganP.G.Diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia.J Hosp Inf1999; 41: 87–99.
