Application of a Hurdle Model with Random Effects to Explore the Relationship between Operational Characteristics and Safety Performance

Abstract

This study used the bus incident data in Victoria, Australia to establish the relationship between operational characteristics and the safety performance of bus operators. A series of count models were investigated to account for methodological challenges, including excess zeros and panel data structure. The empirical results highlighted the different effects operational characteristics had on the risk and prevalence of bus incidents. Operators of smaller size, providing non-route services and operating in regional areas had a lower risk of having any reported incidents compared with larger route operators and operators in areas of higher accessibility. In cases where at least one incident had been reported, incident frequency was higher for operators with higher fleet total travel distance, older fleets and better roadworthy performance (this factor being counterintuitive). Findings from this study provide safety regulators with evidence-driven opportunities to enhance bus safety, including improving incident reporting practices, the establishment of a comprehensive database for heavy vehicle operators, and specific efforts targeted at older fleets.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cohen, H., and S. Silkunas. The Relationship Between Transit Asset Condition and Service Quality, Report No. 0309474884, The National Academies Press, 2018.

Goh

K. C. K.

Currie

Sarvi

Logan

.. Bus Accident Analysis of Routes With/Without Bus Priority. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 65, 2014, pp. 18–27.

Huting

Reid

Nwoke

Bacarella

K. E

. Identifying Factors That Increase Bus Accident Risk by using Random Forests and Trip-Level Data. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2016, 2539: 149–158.

Yoon

Kho

S.-Y.

Kim

D.-K

. Effect of Regional Characteristics on Injury Severity in Local Bus Crashes: Use of Hierarchical Ordered Model. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2017. 2647: 1–8.

Chang

H.-L.

Yeh

C.-C

. Factors Affecting the Safety Performance of Bus Companies: The Experience of Taiwan Bus Deregulation. Safety Science, Vol. 43, No. 5–6, 2005, pp. 323–344.

Davey

Wishart

Frereeman

Watson

. An Application of the Driver Behaviour Questionnaire in an Australian Organisational Fleet Setting. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2007, pp. 11–21.

Mitchell

Friswell

Mooren

. Initial Development of a Practical Safety Audit Tool to Assess Fleet Safety Management Practices. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 47, 2012, pp. 102–118.

Cantor

D. E.

Osborn

Singh

. A Firm Size and Safety Performance Profile of the US Motor Carrier Industry, Iowa State University, Institute for Transportation, 2014.

Qiu

Logan

D. B.

Oxley

Lowe

. Exploring the Effects of Vehicular and Operational Characteristics on Bus Roadworthiness: An Application of the Multilevel Modeling Approach. Transportation Research Record, Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2019, 2673(4): 811–822.

10.

Moses

L.N.

Savage

. The Effect of Firm Characteristics on Truck Accidents. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 26, No. 2, 1994, pp. 173–179.

11.

Monaco

Redmon

. Does Contracting with Owner Operators Lead to Worse Safety Outcomes for US Motor Carriers? Evidence from the Motor Carrier Management Information System. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 45, 2012, pp. 654–659.

12.

Chen

G. X

. Impact of Federal Compliance Reviews of Trucking Companies in Reducing Highway Truck Crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 40, No. 1, 2008, pp. 238–245.

13.

Hwang

Boyle

L. N.

Banerjee

A. G

. Identifying Characteristics that Impact Motor Carrier Safety using Bayesian Networks. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 128, 2019, pp. 40-45.

14.

Mooren

Williamson

Friswell

Olivie

Grzebieta

Magableh

. What are the Differences in Management Characteristics of Heavy Vehicle Operators with High Insurance Claims Versus Low Insurance Claims? Safety Science, Vol. 70, 2014, pp. 327-338

15.

Friswell

Williamson

. Comparison of the Fatigue Experiences of Short Haul Light and Long Distance Heavy Vehicle Drivers. Safety Science, Vol. 57, 2013, pp. 203–213.

16.

Corsi

T. M.

Grimm

C. M.

Cantor

D. E.

Sienicki

. Safety Performance Differences between Unionized and Non-Union Motor Carriers. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, Vol. 48, No. 4, 2012, pp. 807–816.

17.

Naveh

Marcus

. Financial Performance, ISO 9000 Standard and Safe Driving Practices Effects on Accident Rate in the U.S. Motor Carrier Industry. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 39, No. 4, 2007, pp. 731–742.

18.

Victorian Legislation and Parliamentary Documents PoV. Bus Safety Act 2009 (updated 1 Jan, 2011). http://www.legislation.vic.gov.au/Domino/Web_Notes/LDMS/LTObject_Store/LTObjSt5.nsf/DDE300B846EED9C7CA257616000A3571/E12FFB466D68536FCA25780D0082074D/$FILE/09-13aa010%20authorised.pdf.

19.

Hugo Centre for Migration and Population Research. Accessibility/Remoteness Index of Australia Plus (ARIA+ 2016) 2018. https://www.adelaide.edu.au/hugo-centre/news/list/2018/11/21/accessibilityremoteness-index-of-australia-plus-aria-2016.

20.

Naznin

Currie

Logan

Sarvi

. Application of a Random Effects Negative Binomial Model to Examine Tram-Involved Crash Frequency on Route Sections in Melbourne, Australia. Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 92, 2016, pp. 15–21.

21.

Lord

Mannering

. The Statistical Analysis of Crash-Frequency Data: A Review and Assessment of Methodological Alternatives. Transportation Research Part A, Vol. 44, No. 5, 2010, pp. 291–305.

22.

Chin

H.C.

Quddus

M. A

. Applying the Random Effect Negative Binomial Model to Examine Traffic Accident Occurrence at Signalized Intersections. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 35, No. 2, 2003, pp. 253–259.

23.

Hou

Meng

Leng

. Application of a Random Effects Negative Binomial Model to Examine Crash Frequency for Freeways in China. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, Vol. 509, 2018, pp. 937–944.

24.

Cai

Lee

Eluru

Abdel-Aty

. Macro-Level Pedestrian and Bicycle Crash Analysis: Incorporating Spatial Spillover Effects in Dual State Count Models. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 93, 2016, pp. 14–22.

25.

Hosseinpour

Yahaya

A. S.

Sadullah

A. F

. Exploring the Effects of Roadway Characteristics on the Frequency and Severity of Head-On Crashes: Case Studies from Malaysian Federal Roads. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 62, 2014, pp. 209–222.

26.

M.-C.

Pavlicova

Nunes

E. V

. Zero-Inflated and Hurdle Models of Count Data with Extra Zeros: Examples from an HIV-Risk Reduction Intervention Trial. The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, Vol. 37, No. 5, 2011, pp. 367–375.

27.

Atkins

D. C.

Baldwin

S. A.

Zheng

Gallop

R. J.

Neighbors

. A Tutorial on Count Regression and Zero-Altered Count Models for Longitudinal Substance Use Data. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors: Journal of the Society of Psychologists in Addictive Behaviors, Vol. 27, No. 1, 2013, pp. 166–177.

28.

Hilbe

J. M.

Negative Binomial Regression, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2011.

29.

Min

Agresti

. Random Effect Models for Repeated Measures of Zero-Inflated Count Data. Statistical Modelling, Vol. 5, No. 1, 2005, pp. 1–19.

30.

Raihan

M. A.

Alluri

Gan

. Estimation of Bicycle Crash Modification Factors (CMFs) on Urban Facilities using Zero Inflated Negative Binomial Models. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 123, 2019, pp. 303–313.

31.

Shankar

Milton

Mannering

. Modeling Accident Frequencies as Zero-Altered Probability Processes: An Empirical Inquiry. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 29, No. 6, 1997, pp. 829–837.

32.

Lord

Washington

S. P.

Ivan

J. N

. Poisson, Poisson-Gamma and Zero-Inflated Regression Models of Motor Vehicle Crashes: Balancing Statistical Fit and Theory. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 37, No. 1, 2005, pp. 35–46.

33.

King

Song

J. J

. A Bayesian Two-Part Quantile Regression Model for Count Data with Excess Zeros. Statistical Modelling, 2018: 1471082X18799919.

34.

Cragg

J.G.

Some Statistical Models for Limited Dependent Variables with Application to the Demand for Durable Goods. Econometrica (pre-1986), Vol. 39, No. 5, 1971, pp. 829.

35.

Zhen

Shao

Zhang

. Spatial Hurdle Models for Predicting the Number of Children with Lead Poisoning. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 15, No. 9, 2018, pp. 1792.

36.

Neelon

Chang

H. H.

Ling

Hastings

N. S

. Spatiotemporal Hurdle Models for Zero-Inflated Count Data: Exploring Trends in Emergency Department Visits. Statistical Methods in Medical Research, Vol. 25, No. 6, 2014, pp. 2558–2576.

37.

Zhang

Chien

S. I. J.

Wang

J Dong

. Predicting Expressway Crash Frequency using a Random Effect Negative Binomial Model: A Case Study in China. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 98, 2017, pp. 214–222.

38.

Aguero-Valverde

Full Bayes Poisson Gamma, Poisson Lognormal, And Zero Inflated Random Effects Models: Comparing the Precision of Crash Frequency Estimates. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 50, 2013, pp. 289–297.

39.

pFang

Wagner

B. D.

Harris

J. K.

Fillon

S. A

. Zero-Inflated Negative Binomial Mixed Model: An Application to Two Microbial Organisms Important in Oesophagitis. Epidemiology and Infection, Vol. 144, No. 11, 2016, pp. 2447–2455.

40.

Son

H. D.

Kweon

Y.-J.

Park

B. B

. Development of Crash Prediction Models with Individual Vehicular Data. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, Vol. 19, No. 6, 2011, pp. 1353–1363.

41.

Lord

Washington

Ivan

J. N

. Further Notes on the Application Of Zero-Inflated Models in Highway Safety. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 39, No. 1, 2007, pp. 53–57.

42.

Hauer. E. (ed.). Safety in Highway Design Standards. Proc., 2nd International Symposium of Highway Geometric Design, 1999.

43.

Paterson

A. D.

Turpin

. Assessment and Selection of Competing Models for Zero-Inflated Microbiome Data. PLOS ONE, Vol. 10, No. 7, 2015, pp. e0129606.

44.

Lewis

Butler

Gilbert

. A Unified Approach to Model Selection using the Likelihood Ratio Test. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 2, No. 2, 2011, pp. 155–162.

45.

Burnham

K. P.

Anderson

D. R

. Multimodel Inference: Understanding AIC and BIC in Model Selection. Sociological Methods and Research, Vol. 33, No. 2, 2004, pp. 261–304.

46.

Vrieze

S. I

. Model Selection and Psychological Theory: A Discussion of the Differences between the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) and the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC). Psychological Methods, Vol. 17, No. 2, 2012, pp. 228.

47.

Burnham

K. P.

Anderson

D. R.

Huyvaert

K. P

. AIC Model Selection and Multimodel Inference in Behavioral Ecology: Some Background, Observations, and Comparisons. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, Vol. 65, No. 1, 2011, pp. 23–35.

48.

Dziak, J. J., D. L. Coffman, S. T. Lanza, R. Li, and L. S. Jermiin. Sensitivity and Specificity of Information Criteria. bioRxiv, Vol. 21, No. 2, 2019, pp. 553–565.

49.

Chipeta

M. G.

Ngwira

B. M.

Simoonga

Kazembe

L. N

. Zero Adjusted Models with Applications to Analysing Helminths Count Data. BMC Research Notes, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2014, pp. 856.

50.

Tüzen

M. F.

Erbaş

. A Comparison of Count Data Models with an Application to Daily Cigarette Consumption of Young Persons. Communications in Statistics: Theory and Methods, Vol. 47, No. 23, 2018, pp. 5825–5844.

51.

Brooks, M. E., K. Kristensen, K. J. van Benthem, A. Magnusson, C. W. Berg, A. Nielsen, H. J. Skaug, M. Machler, and B. M. Bolker. glmmTMB Balances Speed and Flexibility among Packages for Zero-Inflated Generalized Linear Mixed Modeling. The R Journal, Vol. 9, No. 2, 2017, pp. 378–400.

52.

Survey of Motor Vehicle Use, Australia, 12 months ended 30 June 2018, 2019. https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/9208.012%20months%20ended%2030%20June%202018?OpenDocument. Accessed Jun. 19, 2019.

53.

Bus Industry Confederation. Bus Industry Confederation Response to Vehicle Emissions Standards for Cleaner Air Draft Regulation Impact Statement 2017. Accessed Jul. 24, 2019. https://www.infrastructure.gov.au/vehicles/environment/forum/files/RIS_Bus_Industry_Confederation_Euro6.pdf.

54.

Transport for NSW. Calculating Bus Age and Fleet Age for SMBSC and OSMBSC Contracts 2017. Accessed Jul. 7, 2019, https://www.transport.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/media/documents/2017/basis-for-calculating-bus-age.pdf.

55.

af Wåhlberg

A. E.

Characteristics of Low Speed Accidents with Buses in Public Transport. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 34, No. 5, 2002, pp. 637–647.

56.

Kumara

S. S. P.

Chin

H. C

. Application of Poisson Underreporting Model to Examine Crash Frequencies at Signalized Three-Legged Intersections. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Record, 2005. 1908: 46–50.

57.

Victorian Bus Operators. Focus Group Discussion with Victorian Bus Operators on Issues Regarding Bus Inspections and Incidents, 2019.

58.

Besharati

M. M.

Tavakoli Kashani

. Factors Contributing to Intercity Commercial Bus Drivers’ Crash Involvement Risk. Archives of Environmental and Occupational Health, Vol. 73, No. 4, 2018, pp. 243–250.

59.

Bus Safety Victoria. Safety Culture Guidance, 2016.

60.

Blower, D. Estimating Motor Carrier Management Information System Crash File Underreporting from Carrier Records. United States. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. Office of Analysis, Research, and Technology, 2017.

61.

Bus Safety Victoria. Reportable Incidents of Victorian Bus Operators. 2018.

62.

Warmerdam

Newnam

Sheppard

Griffin

Stevenson

. Workplace Road Safety Risk Management: An Investigation into Australian Practices. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 98, 2017, pp. 64–73.

63.

Park

H.-C.

Kim

D.-K.

Kho

S.-Y.

Park

P. Y

. Cross-Classified Multilevel Models for Severity of Commercial Motor Vehicle Crashes Considering Heterogeneity among Companies and Regions. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 106, 2017, pp. 305–314.

64.

Liu

Boyle

L. N.

Banerjee

A. G

. Predicting Interstate Motor Carrier Crash Rate Level using Classification Models. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 120, 2018, pp. 211–218.

65.

Chimba

Sando

Kwigizile

. Effect of Bus Size and Operation to Crash Occurrences. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 42, No. 6, 2010, pp. 2063–2067.

66.

Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. MCMIS (Motor Carrier Management Information System), 2015.

67.

Geedipally

S. R.

Lord

Dhavala

S. S

. The Negative Binomial-Lindley Generalized Linear Model: Characteristics and Application using Crash Data. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 45, 2012, pp. 258–265.

68.

Lord

Geedipally

S. R

. The Negative Binomial–Lindley Distribution as a Tool for Analyzing Crash Data Characterized by a Large Amount of Zeros. Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 43, No. 5, 2011, pp. 1738–1742.

69.

Shaon

M. R. R.

Qin

Shirazi

Lord

Geedipally

S. R

. Developing a Random Parameters Negative Binomial-Lindley Model to Analyze Highly Over-Dispersed Crash Count Data. Analytic Methods in Accident Research, Vol. 18, 2018, pp. 33–44.

70.

Miaou

S.-P.

Lord

. Modeling Traffic Crash-Flow Relationships for Intersections: Dispersion Parameter, Functional Form, and Bayes versus Empirical Bayes Methods. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2003. 1840: 31–40.

71.

Shirazi

Dhavala

S. S.

Lord

Geedipally

S. R

. A Methodology to Design Heuristics for Model Selection Based on the Characteristics of Data: Application to Investigate When the Negative Binomial Lindley (NB-L) is Preferred over the Negative Binomial (NB). Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 107, 2017, pp. 186–194.

72.

Shirazi

Lord

. Characteristics-Based Heuristics to Select a Logical Distribution between the Poisson-Gamma and the Poisson-Lognormal for Crash Data Modelling. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science, Vol. 15, No. 2, 2019, pp. 1791–1803.