A Randomized Clinical Trial Comparing Open to Arthroscopic Acromioplasty with Mini-Open Rotator Cuff Repair for Full-Thickness Rotator Cuff Tears

Abstract

Background:

Rotator cuff tears affect patients' quality of life. The evolution toward less invasive operative techniques for rotator cuff repair requires appropriate comparisons with the standard open procedure, using validated outcomes in a randomized fashion.

Hypothesis:

There is no difference in disease-specific quality of life outcomes at 2 years between an open surgical repair (open) versus an arthroscopic acromioplasty with mini-open (scope mini-open) repair for patients with full-thickness rotator cuff tears.

Study Design:

Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 1.

Methods:

Patients with unremitting pain, failed nonoperative treatment, and imaging indicating full-thickness rotator cuff tears were included in the study. Massive irreparable cuff tears were excluded. Patients were assessed using the disease-specific Rotator Cuff-Quality of Life index, which produces a maximum score of 100, representing a high quality of life. Secondary shoulder-specific outcomes (American Shoulder and Elbow Society, Shoulder Rating Questionnaire, and Functional Shoulder Elevation Test) were also measured at baseline, 3 and 6 months, and 1 and 2 years.

Results:

The mean Rotator Cuff-Quality of Life scores at an average follow-up of 28 months were not statistically different: open, 86.9 (95% confidence interval: 81.8–92.0); and scope mini-open, 87.2 (95% confidence interval: 80.6–93.8). At 3 months, the patients who underwent scope mini-open showed statistically significantly better outcomes (55.6 vs 71.3; P = .005). The baseline to 3-month difference in Rotator Cuff-Quality of Life scores between the scope mini-open and open groups was also statistically significant.

Conclusion:

Patient outcomes improved from baseline to all postoperative measurement intervals. There was no difference in outcome at 1 and 2 years after surgery between the scope mini-open and open procedures. The quality of life of patients undergoing the arthroscopic acromioplasty with mini-open rotator cuff repair improved statistically significantly and clinically at 3 months compared with the open group.

Keywords

rotator cuff open acromioplasty arthroscopic mini-open quality of life

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andersen

Sojbjerg

Johannsen

Sneppen

. Self-training versus physiotherapist-supervised rehabilitation of the shoulder in patients treated with arthroscopic subacromial decompression: A clinical randomized study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1999;8(2):99–101.

Baysal

Balyk

Otto

Luciak-Corea

Beaupre

. Functional outcome and health-related quality of life after surgical repair of full-thickness rotator cuff tear using a mini-open technique. Am J Sports Med. 2005;33(9):1346–1355.

Bishop

Klepps

Bird

Gladstone

Flatow

. Cuff integrity after arthroscopic versus open rotator cuff repair: A prospective study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2006;15(3):290–299.

Blevins

Warren

Cavo

. Arthroscopic assisted rotator cuff repair: Results using a mini-open deltoid-splitting approach. Arthroscopy. 1996;12(1):50–59.

Boileau

Brassart

Watkinson

Carles

Hatzidakis

Krishnan

. Arthroscopic repair of full-thickness tears of the supraspinatus: Does the tendon really heal? J Bone Joint Surg Am 2005;87(6):1229–1240.

Brox

Gjengedal

Uppheim

. Arthroscopic surgery versus supervised exercises in patients with rotator cuff disease (stage II impingement syndrome): A prospective, randomized, controlled study in 125 patients with a 2 1/2-year follow-up. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 1999;8(2):102–111.

Burkhart

Danaceau

Pearce

Jr . Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair: Analysis of results by tear size and by repair technique-margin convergence versus direct tendon-to-bone repair. Arthroscopy 2001;17(9):905–912.

Codman

. The Shoulder: Rupture of the Supraspinatus Tendon and Other Lesions In or About the Subacromial Bursa. Amory

, ed. Boston, Mass: Thomas Todd; 1934.

Ellman

. Arthroscopic subacromial decompression: Analysis of 1- to 3-year results. Arthroscopy. 1987;3(3):173–181.

10.

Galatz

Ball

Teefey

Middleton

Yamaguchi

. The outcome and repair integrity of completely arthroscopically repaired large and massive rotator cuff tears. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004; 86(2):219–224.

11.

Gartsman

. Combined arthroscopic and open treatment of tears of the rotator cuff. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1997;79:776–783.

12.

Gartsman

Brinker

Khan

Karahan

. Self-assessment of general health status in patients with 5 common shoulder conditions. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1998;7(3):228–237.

13.

Gartsman

O'Connor

. Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair with and without arthroscopic subacromial decompression: A prospective, randomized study of 1-year outcomes. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2004; 13(4):424–426.

14.

Haahr

Ostergaard

Dalsgaard

. Exercises versus arthroscopic decompression in patients with subacromial impingement: A randomized, controlled study in 90 cases with a 1-year follow-up. Ann Rheum Dis. 2005;64(5):760–764.

15.

Hata

Saitoh

Murakami

Seki

Nakatsuchi

Takaoka

. A less invasive surgery for rotator cuff tear: Mini-open repair. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2001;10(1):11–16.

16.

Hawkins

Kennedy

. Nonoperative treatment of rotator cuff tears. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1995;321:178–188.

17.

Hayes

Ginn

Walton

Szomor

Murrell

. A randomized clinical trial evaluating the efficacy of physiotherapy after rotator cuff repair. Aust J Physiother. 2004;50(2):77–83.

18.

Herrera

Bauer

Reynolds

Wilk

Bigliani

Levine

. Infection after mini-open rotator cuff repair. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2002;11(6):605–608.

19.

Hersch

Sgaglione

. Arthroscopically assisted mini-open rotator cuff repairs. Functional outcome at 2- to 7-year follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2000;28(3):301–311.

20.

Hollinshead

Mohtadi

Vande Guchte

Wadey

. Two 6-year follow-up studies of large and massive rotator cuff tears: Comparison of outcome measures. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2000;9(5): 373–381.

21.

Huber

Hofstaetter

Hanslik-Schnabel

Posch

Wurnig

. Translation and psychometric testing of the Rotator Cuff Quality-of-Life Measure (RC-QOL) for use in German-speaking regions [in German]. Z Rheumatol. 2005;64(3): 188–197.

22.

Hunt

Moore

Krishnan

. The fate of the coracoacromial ligament in arthroscopic acromioplasty: An anatomical study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2000;9(6):491–494.

23.

Husby

Haugstvedt

Brandt

Holm

Steen

. Open versus arthroscopic subacromial decompression: A prospective, randomized study of 34 patients followed for 8 years. Acta Orthop Scand. 2003; 74(4):408–414.

24.

Ide

Maeda

Takagi

. Arthroscopic transtendon repair of partial-thickness articular-side tears of the rotator cuff: Anatomical and clinical study. Am J Sports Med. 2005;33(11):1672–1679.

25.

Ide

Maeda

Takagi

. A comparison of arthroscopic and open rotator cuff repair. Arthroscopy. 2005;21(9):1090–1098.

26.

Kim

Park

Kang

. Arthroscopic versus mini-open salvage repair of the rotator cuff tear: Outcome analysis at 2 to 6 years' follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2003;19(7):746–754.

27.

Kirkley

Griffin

Dainty

. Scoring systems for the functional assessment of the shoulder. Arthroscopy. 2003;19(10):1109–1120.

28.

L'Insalata

Warren

Cohen

Altchek

Peterson

. A self-administered questionnaire for assessment of symptoms and function of the shoulder. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1997;79(5):738–748.

29.

Levy

Uribe

Deianey

. Arthroscopic assisted rotator cuff repair: Preliminary results. Arthroscopy. 1990;6(1):55–60.

30.

Lindh

Norlin

. Arthroscopic subacromial decompression versus open acromioplasty. A 2-year follow-up study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993;290:174–176.

31.

Liu

. Arthroscopically assisted rotator cuff repair. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1994;76(4):592–595.

32.

MacDermid

Holtby

Razmjou

Bryant

. All-arthroscopic versus mini-open repair of small or moderate-sized rotator cuff tears: A protocol for a randomized trial [NCT00128076]. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2006;7:25.

33.

McKee

Yoo

. The effect of surgery for rotator cuff disease on general health status. Results of a prospective trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82(7):970–979.

34.

Medical Research Council (Great Britain). Aids to the Examination of the Peripheral Nervous System. London, Great Britain: Her Majesty's Stationary Office; 1976:1.

35.

Misamore

Ziegler

Rushton

. Repair of the rotator cuff. A comparison of results in 2 populations of patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1995;77(9):1335–1339.

36.

Mohtadi

Hawkins

. Rotator cuff problems in athletes. In: Orthopedic Sports Medicine. DeLee

Drez

, eds. Philadelphia, Pa: WB Saunders; 1994:623–656.

37.

Murray

Jr Lajtai

Mileski

Snyder

. Arthroscopic repair of medium to large full-thickness rotator cuff tears: Outcome at 2- to 6-year follow-up. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2002;11(1):19–24.

38.

Neer

2nd . Anterior acromioplasty for the chronic impingement syndrome in the shoulder: A preliminary report. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1972;54(1):41–50.

39.

Norberg

Field

Savoie

3rd . Repair of the rotator cuff. Mini-open and arthroscopic repairs. Clin Sports Med. 2000; 19(1)77–99.

40.

Norlin

. Arthroscopic subacromial decompression versus open acromioplasty. Arthroscopy. 1989;5(4):321–323.

41.

Nutton

McBirnie

Phillips

. Treatment of chronic rotator cuff impingement by arthroscopic subacromial decompression. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1997;79(1):73–76.

42.

Paulos

Kody

. Arthroscopically enhanced mini approach to rotator cuff repair. Am J Sports Med. 1994;22:19–25.

43.

Pollock

Flatow

. The rotator cuff. Full-thickness tears: Mini-open repair. Orthop Clin North Am. 1997;28(2):169–177.

44.

Post

Silver

Singh

. Rotator cuff tear. Diagnosis and treatment. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1983;173:78–91.

45.

Razmjou

Bean

van Osnabrugge

MacDermid

Holtby

. Cross-sectional and longitudinal construct validity of 2 rotator cuff disease-specific outcome measures. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2006;7:26.

46.

Richards

Bigliani

. A standardized method for the assessment of shoulder function. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1994;3:347–352.

47.

Rosner

. Fundamentals of Biostatistics. Belmont, Calif: Duxbury Press, Wadsworth Publishing Company; 1995.

48.

Sachs

Stone

Devine

. Open vs arthroscopic acromioplasty: A prospective, randomized study. Arthroscopy. 1994;10(3):248–254.

49.

Sauerbrey

Getz

Piancastelli

Lannotti

Ramsey

Williams

Jr . Arthroscopic versus mini-open rotator cuff repair a comparison of clinical outcome. Arthroscopy. 2005;21(12):1415–1420.

50.

Severud

Ruotalo

Abbott

Nottage

. All-arthroscopic versus mini-open rotator cuff repair: A long-term retrospective outcome comparison. Arthroscopy. 2003;19(3):234–238.

51.

Spangehl

Hawkins

McCormack

Loomer

. Arthroscopic versus open acromioplasty: A prospective, randomized, blinded study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2002;11(2):101–107.

52.

Torpey

Ikeda

Weng

van der Heeden

Chao

McFarland

. The deltoid muscle origin. Histologic characteristics and effects of subacromial decompression. Am J Sports Med. 1998;26(3):379–383.

53.

Verma

Dunn

Adler

. All-arthroscopic versus mini-open rotator cuff repair: A retrospective review with minimum 2-year follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2006;22(6):587–594.

54.

Warner

Goitz

Irrgang

Graff

. Arthroscopic-assisted rotator cuff repair: Patient selection and treatment outcome. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1997;6(5):463–472.

55.

Wilson

Hinov

Adams

. Arthroscopic repair of full-thickness tears of the rotator cuff: 2- to 14-year follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2002;18(2):136–144.

56.

Youm

Murray

Kubiak

Rokito

Zuckerman

. Arthroscopic versus mini-open rotator cuff repair a comparison of clinical outcomes and patient satisfaction. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2005;14(5):455–459.