Competition and International Equity Returns: Some Empirical Tests of “Turbulent Arbitrage”

Abstract

The idea that capital flows accelerate and decelerate in response to differential rates of return on real investment is common to virtually all of economic theory. This paper examines the nature of this process, especially the relationship between returns in the stock market and returns on real investment. Shaikh (1998) makes the case that the rate of return on new physical (real) investment is the “required” rate of return for the stock market and that competitive forces produce a rough equalization between these two rates of return, what he terms “turbulent arbitrage.” In contrast to neoclassical theories of perfect competition, with its notions of perfect information and convergence to a uniform rate of return, the notion of “turbulent arbitrage” is a dynamic process that requires a tendency toward convergence as well as the constant differentiation of profit rates (Botwinick 1993). Data on rates of return at the country, industry, and firm level for Japan, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States are analyzed and correlated with Shaikh’s “incremental rate of return on real investment” which, it is argued, is the target of the equalization process. Statistical and econometric tests based on time series methods and pooling techniques support the hypothesis that the rate of return on equity prices is linked to the incremental return on real investment. In addition, this association is examined for two industries—steel and retail trade—across these same four countries. Global and domestic equity markets are found to be significantly correlated with the incremental returns for the steel industry but not for the retail trade sector.

JEL classification: G15, F02, C33

Keywords

classical competition international equity returns incremental rate of return on real investment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ammer, J. , and J. Mei. 1996. Measuring international economic linkages with stock market data. Journal of Finance 51 (5): 1743-63.

Balvers, R. , Y. Wu , and E. Gilliland. 2000. Mean reversion across national stock markets and parametric contrarian investment strategies. Journal of Finance 55 (2): 745-72.

Blair, M.M. 1993. Industry-level indicators of free cash flow. In The deal decade: What takeovers and leveraged buyouts mean for corporate governance , ed. M. M. Blair , 99-203. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Botwinick, H. 1993. Persistent inequalities. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Brennan, M.J. , and H.H. Cao. 1997. International portfolio investment flows . Journal of Finance 52 (6): 1851-80.

Buffet, W. 1994. Berkshire Hathaway, Inc.: Annual report. Omaha, NE: Berkshire Hathaway, Inc.

Chen, N.F. , R. Roll , and S. Ross. 1986. Economic forces and the stock market . Journal of Business 59: 383-403.

Christodoulopolus, G. 1996. International competition and industrial rates of return. Unpublished PhD Dissertation, New School for Social Research .

Coval, J.D. , and T.J. Moskowitz. 1999. Home bias at home: Local equity preference in domestic portfolios. Journal of Finance 54 (6): 2045-73.

10.

Damodaran, A. 2001. Corporate finance, 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

11.

Enders, W. 1995. Applied econometric time series. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

12.

Fama, F. , and K.R. French. 2000. Forecasting profitability and earnings . Journal of Business 73 (2): 161-75.

13.

French, K.R. , and J.M. Poterba. 1991. Investor diversification and international equity markets. American Economic Review 81 (2): 222-6.

14.

Goetzmann, W.N. , and R.G. Ibbotson. 2006. The equity risk premium. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

15.

Gordon, M.J. 1962. The investment, financing, and valuation of the corporation . Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin .

16.

Greene, W. 1993. Econometric analysis. New York: Macmillan.

17.

Hausman, J.A. , and W.E. Taylor. 1981. Panel data and unobservable individual effects. Econometrica 49: 1377-97.

18.

Hecht, J. 1999. Modeling market shares of the leading personal automobile insurance companies. Journal of Economics and Business 51 (3): 279-96.

19.

Hirt, G. , and S. Block. 2003. Fundamentals of investment management , 7th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.

20.

Johansen, S. , and K. Juselius. 1990. Maximum likelihood estimation and inferences on cointegration-with applications to the demand for money. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 52: 169-210.

21.

Johnson, R. , and L. Soenen. 2002. Asian economic integration and stock market comovement. Journal of Financial Research 25 (2): 141-57.

22.

Kasa, K. 1992. Common stochastic trends in international stock markets . Journal of Monetary Economics 29: 95-124.

23.

Kim, M.J. , C. Nelson , and R. Startz. 1991. Mean reversion in stock prices? A reappraisal of the empirical evidence. Review of Economic Studies 58: 515-28.

24.

Kirzner, I. 1993. Entrepreneurial discovery and the competitive market process: An Austrian approach. Journal of Economic Perspectives 35 (1): 60-85.

25.

Malkiel, B.G. 1987. Efficient market hypothesis. In The New Palgrave-Finance, ed. J. Eatwell , M. Milgate , and P. Newman , 127-134. New York: W. W. Norton.

26.

Markowitz, H.M. 1952. Portfolio selection. Journal of Finance 7 (March): 77-91.

27.

Marx, K. 1847. The poverty of philosophy. Accessed at www.marxfaq.org/archive/marx/works/1847/povertyphilosophy/ch02c.htm

28.

Marx, K. [ 1867] 1967. Capital, vol. I. New York: International Publishers .

29.

Marx, K. [ 1885]1967. Capital, vol. II. New York: International Publishers .

30.

Marx, K. [ 1894]1967. Capital, vol. III. New York: International Publishers .

31.

Mishkin, F.S. 1984. Are real interest rates equal across countries? An empirical investigation of international parity conditions. Journal of Finance 39: 1345-57.

32.

Mueller, D.C. 1986. Profits in the long run. Cambridge , UK: Cambridge University Press.

33.

Mueller, D. C. , ed. 1990. The dynamics of company profits: An international comparison. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

34.

Mukherjee, T.K. , and A. Naka. 1995. Dynamic relations between macroeconomic variables and the Japanese stock market: An application of a vector error correction model. Journal of Financial Research 18: 223-37.

35.

Parsons, J.E. 1988. Bubble, bubble, how much trouble? Financial markets, capitalist development and capitalist crisis. Science & Society 52: 260-89.

36.

Ricardo, D. [ 1817]1971. Principles of political economy and taxation. London: Penguin Books .

37.

Richards, A.J. 1995. Comovements in national stock market returns: Evidence of predictability, but not cointegration. Journal of Monetary Economics 36: 631-54.

38.

Richards, A.J. 1997. Winner-loser reversals in national stock market indices: Can they be explained? Journal of Finance 52: 2129-44.

39.

Rosdolsky, R. 1977. The making of Marx’s Capital. London: Pluto Press.

40.

Ross, S.A. , R.W. Westerfield , and J. Jaffe. 2002. Corporate finance, 6th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.

41.

Ross, S.A. , R.W. Westerfield , and B.D. Jordan. 2003. Fundamentals of corporate finance, 6th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill .

42.

Shaikh, A. 1998. The stock market and the corporate sector: A profit-based approach. In Capital controversy, post-Keynesian economics and the history of economic thought: Essays in honor of Geoffrey Harcourt , ed. M. Sawyer , P. Arestis , and G. Palma. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, pp. 238-404.

43.

Shaikh, A. 1999. Real exchange rates and the international mobility of capital. Working Paper 265, Jerome Levy Economics Institute .

44.

Shefrin, H. 2002. Beyond greed and fear. New York: Oxford University Press.

45.

Shiller, R. 2000. Irrational exuberance. New York: Broadway Books.

46.

Shleifer, A. 2000. Inefficient markets: An introduction to behavioral finance. Clarendon Lectures in Economics. Oxford University Press .

47.

Smith, A. [ 1776]1937. The wealth of nations. New York: Random House.

48.

Sraffa, P. 1960. Production of commodities by means of commodities. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

49.

Stigler, G.J. 1963. Capital and rates of return in manufacturing industries . Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

50.

Zacharias, A. 2001. Testing profit rate equalization in the U.S. manufacturing sector, 1947-1998. Working Paper, Jerome Levy Economics Institute (January).

51.

Zellner, A. 1971. An introduction to Bayesian inference in econometrics . New York: John Wiley & Sons .