Reacting to the intensified contradictions of the capitalist food system, many agrarian activists seek to revitalize family labor farms, to make agriculture ecologically sustainable, to renew the social and economic life of rural communities, and to create an unalienated labor process. While the agrarian movement is fragmented along lines of ideology, issue priorities and tactics, it is fundamentally in the populist tradition. This problematic of neo-populism, with its contradictory progressive and petty bourgeois tendencies, provides the context for an analysis of production relations on Maine's organic farms. The division of labor and decision-making authority on these farms is shown to conform closely to the age-old pattern of male dominance. Evidence from a survey of small commercial organic farms suggests that most women face a "double," and some a "triple burden" of farm, household and off-farm labor; that their work is more proletarian than that of males; and that their contributions to the family's means of subsistence and capital accumulation are not systematically correlated with participation in farm decisions. These preliminary findings are not sufficient to argue that small organic farms are patriarchal or that women (and children and wage workers) are exploited. But that thesis is consistent with the data, suggesting that farms in the new agrarian movement are not likely to be a force for transformation of the relations of dominance and subordination that characterize both capitalism and petty commodity production.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, Jerry
, et al., "Special Report: The Browning of America,"Newsweek (February 23, 1981), 26-37.
2.
Aronowitz, Stanley
, Food, Shelter and the American Dream, New York, Seabury Press, 1974.
3.
Barnes, Peter
, "The Great American Land Grab," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 137-141.
4.
Beale, Calvin
, "The Revival of Population Growth in Non-Metropolitan America," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 518-525.
5.
Belden, Joe
, et al., eds., New Directions in Farm, Land and Food Policies, Washington, D.C., Conference on Alternative State and Local Policies, 1981.
6.
Berry, Wendell
, "Where Cities and Farms Come Together," in Merrill, ed. (1976), 14-25.
7.
Boulding, Elise
, "The Labor of U.S. Farm Women: A Knowledge Gap,"Sociology of Work and Occupations, 7:3 (August, 1980), 261-290.
8.
Britt, C.
, T. Roberts, M. Rozyne, and D. Vail, The Past, Present and Future Competitiveness of Maine Agriculture, Richards Lane, Freeport, Maine, Maine Consortium for Food Self-Reliance, 1981.
9.
Brown, Lester
, By Bread Alone, New York, Praeger, 1974.
10.
Burawoy, Michael
, "Terrain of Contest: Factory and State Under Capitalism and Socialism,"Socialist Review, No. 58 (July-August, 1981), 82-124.
11.
Buttel, Frederick
, and Howard Newby, eds., The Rural Sociology of Advanced Societies, Montclair, Allanheld Osmun, 1980.
12.
Buttel, Frederick, "American Agriculture and Rural America: Challenges for Progressive Politics," unpublished manuscript, Department of Rural Sociology, Cornell University, 1981.
13.
Carlson, Elwood, "Comments on 'Sex Role Differentiation on Ten Maine Family Homesteads'," unpublished manuscript, Department of Sociology, Bowdoin College, 1979.
14.
Carnoy, Mai'n
and Derek Shearer, Economic Democracy, White Plains, M. E. Sharpe, 1980.
15.
Cochrane, Willard
, The Development of American Agriculture, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1979.
16.
Commoner, Barry
, "Can We Survive," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 98-105.
17.
Cordtz, Dan
, "Corporate Farming: A Tough Row to Hoe," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 144-151.
18.
de Janvry, Alain
, "Social Differentiation in Agriculture and the Ideology of Neopopulism," in Buttell and Newby, eds. (1980), 155-170.
19.
Donohue, George
, "Socio-Economic Characteristics of Full-Time and Part-Time Farmers," in Rodefeld, ed. (1978), 374-379.
20.
Eisenstein, Zillah
, "Relatwons of Capitalist Patriarchy," in Z. Eisenstein, ed., Capitalist Patriarchy and the Case for Socialist Feminism, Monthly Review Press (1979), 41-55.
21.
Folbre, Nancy, "Patriarchy and Capitalism in New England, 1620-1900," unpublished doctoral thesis, Amherst, Department of Economics, University of Massachusetts, 1979.
22.
Goldschmidt, Walter
, As You Sow, Montclair, Allanheld Osmun, 1978.
23.
Goodwyn, Lawrence
, "The Cooperative Commonwealth and Other Abstractions: In Search of a Democratic Premise,"Marxist Perspectives, no. 10 (Summer, 1980), 8-42.
24.
Goss, Kevin
, et al., "The Political Economy of Class Structure in U.S. Agriculture: A Theoretical Outline," in Buttell and Newby, eds. (1980), 83-132.
25.
Grant, Kenneth
, "Erosion in 1973-74: The Record and the Challenge,"Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 30:1January, 1975.
26.
Greene, Sheldon
, "Corporate Accountability and the Family Farm," in Merrill, ed. (1976), 52-63.
27.
Hamburger, Tom
, "New Type of Landowner May Speed Land Boom, Push Some Out," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 154-156.
28.
Hedley, Max
, "Structural Basis of the 'Family Farm,' and the Rural Community," paper presented at the 1981 Annual Meeting of the Rural Sociological Society, Guelph, Ontario (August, 1981).
29.
Hightower, Jim
, Eat Your Heart Out, New York, Crown Publishers, 1975; Hard Tomatoes, Hard Times, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Schenkman, 1973.
30.
Hill, Frances
, "American Farm Women: Challenge to Scholarship," paper presented at the 1981 Annual Meeting of the Rural Sociological Society, Guelph, Ontario (August, 1981).
31.
Joyce, Lynda
, and Sam Leadley, "An Assessment of Research Needs of Women in the Rural United States,"Agricultural Experiment Station, Pennsylvania State University, 1977.
32.
Kohl, Seena
, Working Together. Women and Family in Southwestern Saskatchewan, Toronto, Holt Rinehard, 1976.
33.
Kotz, Nick
, "Agribusiness," in Merrill, ed. (1976), 41-51.
34.
Lappe, Frances
, Diet for a Small Planet, New York, Ballantine Books, 1971.
35.
Lianos, T.
and Q. Paris, "American Agriculture and the Prophecy of Increasing Misery,"American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 54 (1972), 575-575.
36.
Marx, Karl
and Engels, Friedrich, "Preface" to the 1882 Russian Edition of the "Manifesto of the Communist Party," in R. Tucker, ed., The Marx Engels Reader (second edition), New York, Norton, 1978.
37.
Merrill, Richard
, ed., Radical Agriculture, New York, Harper Colophon, 1976.
38.
Mooney, P. R.
, Seeds of the Earth, Canadian Council for Development Action, Brandon (Manitoba), 1979.
39.
Oelhaf, Robert
, Organic Agriculture, Montclair, Allanheld Osmun, 1978.
40.
Perelman, Michael
, Farming for Profit in a Hungry World, Montclair, Allanheld Osmun, 1977.
Pimentel, David, et al., "Benefits and Costs of Pesticide Use in Food Production," unpublished manuscript, Department of Entomology, Cornell University, 1977.
43.
Pimentel, David
and Marcia Pimentel, Food, Energy and Society, New York, Halsted Press (Wiley), 1979.
44.
Raup, Philip
, "Corporate Farming in the United States,"Journal of Economic History, 33(1), (March, 1973), 274-290.
45.
Rhenish, Lynn
, "USDA Turns its Attention to Farm Women,"Rural America, 5:2 (March, 1980), 10-10.
46.
Robbins, William
, "300,000 Acre Plantation is Being Started in the Wilderness," in Rodefeld, et al., eds. (1978), 152-154.
47.
Rodefeld, Richard
, et al., eds., Change in Rural America, St. Louis, Mosby, 1978.
48.
Rozyne, Michael, and David Vail, "Aspects of the Social Relations of Production on Small Organic Farms in Maine," unpublished paper of the Maine Small Farm Management Project, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine, 1978.
49.
Strange, Marty
, "Who Will Control U.S. Agriculture?,"Small Farm Advocate, no. 9 (Summer, 1981). 6-11.
50.
Sweet, James
, "The Employment of Rural Farm Wives,"Rural Sociology, 37:4 (December, 1972), 553-577.
51.
Teal, Ptarmigan
, "Women in the Rural Economy: Employment and Self-Employment,"National Institute of Education, Vocational Education Study (209 Hamilton St., Cambridge, MA), 1980.
52.
Tessler, Lisa, "Sex-Role Differentiation on Ten Maine Homsteads," Bowdoin College, unpublished honors thesis, 1979.
53.
U.S. Department of Agriculture
, Entrepreneurial Control in Farming, ERS, No. 542 (Washington, D.C.), 1974.
54.
U.S. Department of Agriculture
, Report and Recommendations on Organic Farming (Washington, D.C.), 1980.
55.
U.S. Department of Agriculture
, A Time to Choose (Summary Report on the Structure of Agriculture), (Washington, D.C.), 1981.
56.
Vail, David, and Michael Rozyne, "Small Farm Marketing, the Experience of 31 Maine Farms"; "An Appropriate Technology for Small Farms: Lessons from 31 Organic Farms in Maine"; "Soil Fertility on 31 Small Organic Farms in Maine"; unpublished papers of the Maine Small Farm Management Project, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine, 1978.
57.
Vail, David, and Steven Amstutz, 'The Small Farm Apprenticeship in Maine: An Unequal Exchange?," unpublished paper of the Maine Small Farm Management Project, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine, 1979.
58.
Vail, David
and Michael Rozyne, "The Image and the Reality of Small Organic Farms," in D. Knorr, ed., Alterations in Food Production, Van Nostrand, forthcoming.
59.
Wilcox, Walter
, et al., Economics of American Agriculture, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall, 1974.
