A Psychoanalytic note on a Specific Delusion of time in Psychotic Depression *

Abstract

French

1) The specific delusion of the eternity of the depressed state presented by psychotic depressed patients in all aspects of their behaviour and thought during their illness, is described and discussed. It consists of the conviction that their depressed state will never end and will continue for an eternity.

2) The hopelessness and helplessness of such patients are directly linked with this delusion (cf. text).

3) The findings of the author, based on psychoanalytically-oriented psychotherapy and psychoanalysis differ from those presented in the existentialist literature (cf. text). Time is neither regularly ‘speeded up’ nor ‘slowed down’, ‘stagnant’ nor ‘dammed up’, nor is the ‘future blocked’ as reported by the existentialist phenomenologists. Rather, patients perceive their future in the deluded conviction that it is an unending depression that will continue unabated forever or for eternity.

4) The author considers the nature of this delusion. For him, the delusion of the permanence of the depressed state results from a marked regression to fixations in the earliest oral phase, in which the passage of time can only be measured by changes in the biological rhythms of the organ system denoting such change. Thus a state continues ‘forever’ until it is succeeded by a new organic state of function, e.g. sleep to wakefulness, feeding to satiation and very rapid sleep, etc. (cf. text). This regression explains the nature and form of the cathexis present in the patient's depressed state. Helplessness is felt to be a marked regression of aggressive cathexis to a late oral (pre-anal) stage—one prior to the development of sphincter control and mastery (cf. text).

5) The author also discusses some aspects of technique in using the above concepts in psychotherapy and psycho-analysis, of this aspect of their illness, of such patients (cf. text).

6) The patients' poor motivation to continue on-going psychotherapy once out of the depressed state, and the specific psychodynamic reasons for this, are discussed (cf. text).

References

Abraham

Karl

: a) 1911, Notes on the Psychoanalytic Investigation and Treatment of Manic-Depressive Insanity and Allied Conditions, p. 137–156; b) A Short Study of the Development of the Libido, Viewed in the Light of Mental Disorders, Part I, p. 418–480. Both in Selected Papers on Psychoanalysis. London, England, Hogarth Press, 1949.

Ellenberger

H. D.

: p. 104, in Existence. Ed. May

, Angel

, Ellenberger

H. F.

. New York, Basic Books, 1958.

du Nouy

Lecompte

: Le Temps et la Vie. Paris, Gallimard, 1936.

Freud

1917: Mourning and Melancholia in Coll. papers, Vol. IV, p. 152–170. London, Hogarth Press, 1949.

Grunberger

: Etude sur la Relation Objectale-Anale. Rev. franc. Psychanalyse, 24: 137 (March-April) 1960.

Jaspers

Karl

: General Psychopathology. (Eng. trans. of the German edition 1946) by Univ. of Manchester Press, England), Univ. of Chicago Press, 1964, p. 82.

Kloos

: Störungen des Zeiterlebens in der Endogenen Depresion (Disturbances in the Time-Feeling in Endogenous Depression). Nervenart, 11: 225–244, 1938.

Minkowski

: La Notion de trouble générateur et l'analyse structurale des troubles mentaux, in Le Temps Vécu. Paris, D'Artry, 1933, p. 207–254.

Minkowski

: Etude psychologique et analyse phénoménologique d'une cas de mélancolie schizophrénique. J. de Psychologie normale et pathologique, 20: 543–558, 1923. Also in Le Temps Vécu, ref cité no 8. (English version: Findings in a case of Schizophrenic Depression), p. 127–138 in Existence, opus cité ref. 2.

10.

Sarwer-Foner

: The Psychodynamics of Depression, read at Symposium on Depression. Wisconsin Med. Society, Eau Claire, Wis., 1964. To be published.

11.

Sarwer-Foner

: An Object-Relationship Classification of Depressive Illness — I: Patients Still Capable of Forming External Object Relationships, read at Amer. Coll. Neuropsychopharmacology Meeting, Washington, D. C., Jan. 1965. To be published.

12.

Sarwer-Foner

: An Object-Relationship Classification of Depressive Illness — II: Patients Who Can No Longer form External Object Relationships, read at Res. Seminar, Dept. of Psychiatry, Univ. of Illinois Med. School, Chicago, Ill., April 1965. To be published.

13.

Scott

C. W. M.

: A New Hypothesis Concerning the Relationship of Libidinal and Aggressive Instincts. Int. J. Psychoanal., Part II 35, 1954.

14.

Von Gebsattel

V. E.

: Zeitbezogenes Zwangsdenken in der melancholie, in Prolegomena Einer Medizinischen Anthropologie. Berlin, Springer, 1954, p. 1–18 and quoted in opus cité ref. no. 2, p. 100.