Object Concept and Object Relations in Childhood Psychosis: A Pilot Study

Abstract

French

The two master theories of human development, the Freudian and Piagetan, have evolved in parallel fashion without ever meeting. The advent of ‘ego metapsychology’ brought the two systems closer together, to be finally correlated by Anthony, Wolff, et al.

The role of the mother is primordial in both cognitive and psychoanalytic systems. As already shown experimentally by Gouin-Décarie the two systems are interconnected in that a failure or fixation in the libidinal development is accompanied by an ‘adherence’ in the cognitive sphere.

The aim of this pilot study was to verify the hypothesis that any condition accompanied or caused by a severe disturbance in the mother-child relationship will result in severe mental retardation or arrest in cognitive development within the sensorio-motor stage. The sample was composed of twenty randomly selected children (age range: 3 to 9 years), divided into a psychotic sub-group and a non-psychotic one, the latter serving as control. These children were attending the Pride of Judea Day School in New York City. All had a complete psychiatric and psychological evaluation, plus a detailed developmental history, carried out independently of this research. The Piagetan Test of Sensorio-Motor development elaborated by Gouin-Décarie was administered to both groups.

The results showed that an ‘adherence’ of cognitive development to the sensorio motor stage was positively correlated with Early Infantile Autism and Mental Retardation. In order to further clarify this correlation the subjects' early development in their first two years of life was scrutinized using a check list of autistic signs. A statistically highly significant correlation could then be established between the arrest of cognitive development in the sensorio motor stage and an autistic type of development within the first two years of life, irrespective of diagnosis.

In view of these findings it seems pointless to apply interpretative psychotherapies to these children or to submit them to standard kindergarten techniques when they lack the very rudiments for abstract thinking.

References

Anthony

: (1956a) The significance of Jean Piaget for child psychiatry. Brit. J. Med. Psychol., XXIX, 20–34.

Anthony

: (1958) An experimental approach to the psychopathology of childhood: Autism. Brit. J. Med. Psychol., XXXI, Parts 3 and 4, 221–225.

Bender

(1953) Childhood schizophrenia. Psychiat. Quart., 27, 663.

Bergman

, and Escalona

S. K.

: (1949) “Unusual Sensitivities in Very Young Children”. The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, III/IV, 333–352, New York, International Universities Press.

Bettelheim

: (1967) The Empty Fortress, 443–475. New York, The Free Press, 1967.

Décarie

T. Gouin-

: (1965) Intelligence and Affectivity in Early Childhood, Transl. Brandt & Brandt. New York, International Universities Press, 1965.

Fisher , and Yates : (1957) Statistical Tables for Biological, Agricultural and Medical Research, Oliver and Boyd, 1957.

Freud

: (1922) Beyond the Pleasure Principle. London, The Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis.

Gesell

, and Amatruda

C. S.

: (1947) Developmental Diagnosis, Paul B. Hoeber, Second Edition, 1964.

10.

Gratton

, and Rizzo

: (1969) Group therapy with young psychotic children, Int. J. Group Psychother., XIX, 63–71.

11.

Kanner

: (1944) Early infantile autism. J. Pediat., 25, 211.

12.

Knobel

: (1962) Psychopharmacology for the hyperkinetic child. Arch. Gen. Psychiat., 6, 198.

13.

Piaget

: (1937) La construction du réel chez l'enfant, Actualités Pédagogiques et Psychologiques, Suisse, Delachaux & Niestle, 1967.

14.

Rizzo

, and Gratton

: (1964) Group Psychotherapy with Autistic Children. Film edited by Rizzo

, M.D., Washington University, St. Louis, Mo.

15.

Spitz

: (1945) Hospitalism, The Psychoanalytic Study of The Child, 1, 53–74, New York, International Universities Press.

16.

Spitz

: (1946) Anaclytic depression, The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, II, 313–342, New York, International Universities Press.

17.

Stanley

: (1963) The Essence of Biometry, Montreal, McGill University Press, 1963.

18.

Wolff

P. H.

: (1960) “The Developmental Psychologies of Jean Piaget and Psychoanalysis”. Psychological Issues, Monograph 5, New York, International Universities Press.