The Classification of Personality Disorder: I. The Choice of Category Concept *

Abstract

French

Some common clinical statements about patients with personality disorder are examined for their implications in the choice of category concepts for classifying personality. Clinicians seem to assume that personality categories are imprecise and that membership is probabilistic. These assumptions run counter to those of current classifications. The fact that most cases of personality disorder show features of more than condition creates difficulties for categorical systems. Dimensional systems are frequently proposed as a solution to this problem. Such an approach is rejected at the present time since there is no consensus regarding basic dimensions. Polythetic and prototype categories are examined as alternatives. It is suggested that prototype categorization provides an approach that is more in accord with clinical judgement. This approach, based upon Wittgenstein's concept of family resemblances, is better able to accommodate the imprecise or fuzzy nature of personality categories, although it does require some modification to the way categories are defined, and to the way diagnostic reliability is assessed.

References

Kendell

R.E.

The role of diagnosis in psychiatry. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1975.

Zadeh

L.A.

Fuzzy sets.

Information and Control 1965; 8: 338–353.

Black

Margins of precision: essays in logic and language. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 1970.

Cantor

, Mischel

Prototypes in person perception. In: Berkowitz

, ed. Advances in experimental social psychology, Vol. 12. New York: Academic Press, 1979.

Zadeh

L.A.

Outline of a new approach to the analysis of complex systems and decision processes. In: Cochrane

J.L.

, Zeleny

, eds. Multiple criteria decision making. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1973.

Eysenck

H.J.

A dimensional system of psychodiagnostics. In: Mahrer

A.R.

, ed. New approaches to personality classification. New York: Columbia University Press, 1970.

Eysenck

H.J.

, Wakefield

J.A.

Diagnosis and clinical assessment: the DSM-III.

Ann Rev Psychol 1983; 34: 167–193.

Presly

A.S.

, Walton

H.J.

Dimensions of abnormal personality.

Br J Psychiatry 1973; 122: 269–276.

Frances

The DSM-III personality disorders section: a commentary.

Am J Psychiatry 1980; 137: 1050–1054.

10.

Frances

Categorical and dimensional systems of personality diagnosis.

Compr Psychiatry 1982; 23: 516–527.

11.

Stone

The borderline syndromes: constitution, personality and adaptation. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1980.

12.

Millon

Disorders of personality: DSM-III axis II. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1981.

13.

McLemore

C.W.

, Benjamin

L.S.

What ever happened to interpersonal diagnosis? A psychosocial alternative to DSM-III.

Am Psychol 1979; 34: 17–34.

14.

Benjamin

L.S.

Structural analysis of social behavior.

Psychol Rev 1974; 81: 392–425.

15.

Cattell

R.B.

The scientific analysis of personality. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 1965.

16.

Leary

Interpersonal diagnosis of personality: a functional theory and methodology for personality evaluation. New York: Ronald Press, 1957.

17.

Hempel

C.G.

Aspects of scientific explanation. New York: Free Press, 1965.

18.

Wittgenstein

Philosophical investigations. New York: Macmillan, 1953.

19.

Beckner

The biological way of thought. New York: Columbia University Press, 1959.

20.

Rosch

Principles of categorization. In: Rosch

, Lloyd

D.B.

, eds. Cognition and categorization. Hillsdale, NJ.: Lawrence Erlbaum Assocs, 1978.

21.

Guze

S.B.

Nature of psychiatric illness: why psychiatry is a branch of medicine.

Compr Psychiatry 1978; 19: 295–307.

22.

Feighner

J.P.

, Robins

, Guze

S.B.

. Diagnostic criteria for use in psychiatric research. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1972; 26: 57–63.

23.

Needham

Polythetic classification: convergence and consequences.

Man 1975; 10: 349–369.

24.

Rosch

, Mervis

C.B.

Family resemblances: studies in the internal structure of categories.

Cognitive Psychology 1975; 7: 573–605.

25.

Sokal

R.R.

Classification: purposes, principles, progress, prospects.

Science 1974; 185: 1115–1123.

26.

Rosch

Linguistic relativity. In: Silverstein

, ed. Human communication: theoretical perspectives. New York: Halstead Press, 1974.

27.

Rosch

Cognitive representations of semantic categories.

J Exper Psychol: General 1975; 104: 192–233.

28.

Rosch

, Mervis

C.B.

, Gray

W.D.

. Basic objects in natural categories. Cognitive Psychology 1976; 8: 382–439.

29.

Cantor

, Smith

E.E.

, French

. Psychiatric diagnosis as prototype categorization. J Abnorm Psychol 1980; 89: 181–193.

30.

Horowitz

L.M.

, Post

D.L.

, French

. The prototype as a construct in abnormal psychology: 2. Clarifying disagreement in psychiatric judgements. J Abnorm Psychol 1981; 90: 575–585.

31.

Spitzer

, Forman

, Nee

DSM-III field trials: I. Initial inter-rater diagnostic reliability.

Am J Psychiatry 1979; 136: 815–817.

32.

Standage

K.F.

The use of Schneider's typology for the diagnosis of personality disorders.

Br J Psychiatry 1979; 135: 238–268.